Download

Wealth Migration Has a New Variable: Insurance

Rising insurance costs are reshaping where wealthy Americans relocate, turning coverage availability into a dealbreaker alongside taxes and climate.

Interview

For years, high-net-worth (HNW) individuals made decisions about where to live based on a familiar checklist: taxes, climate, cost of housing, quality of life. Insurance was mostly an afterthought… something to sort out after the deal closed.

More than 160,000 millionaires have relocated out of California and New York since 2018, drawn to states like Florida and Texas for tax advantages and warmer climates. For the first time, though, insurance costs are factoring into HNW individuals' choices about where to relocate. Over the past nine months, clients have started asking questions that rarely used to come up before purchasing another property: What does coverage cost here?

Buying insurance wasn't always a difficult question for this client segment, but it's now a key consideration. Even when coverage is available, costs can reach $20,000 to $40,000 or more per month for a single property, depending on location and risk profile.

These shifts present both an opening and a responsibility for advisors to make insurance part of the conversation before a client falls in love with a property and the options narrow.

WHAT ATTRACTS CLIENTS IS OFTEN WHAT PUTS THEM AT RISK

There's a pattern worth naming: the same conditions that draw HNW individuals to a location frequently create the exposures that make it difficult to insure. Florida offers warmth, tax advantages and coastal living––along with some of the most volatile homeowners insurance costs in the country. Texas provides economic opportunity and lifestyle appeal, in addition to hail events that total the luxury vehicles parked in open driveways.

One client purchased a property in the North Carolina mountains specifically to get away from Florida's storm exposure. Three weeks after moving in, a hurricane hit his new home. The assumption of safety, based on geography alone, turned out to be wrong.

During the pandemic, Montana and Wyoming attracted HNW individuals due to the wide open space and lack of density. Some discovered too late that their property had no reliable water source nearby, leaving them either uninsurable or facing significant mitigation costs just to secure coverage.

The pattern holds across U.S. markets. A location that may check every box on taxes, climate and lifestyle almost always has something else going on that drives up the cost of living. Increasingly, that something is insurance.

5 WAYS ADVISORS CAN RESPOND

Advisors can help HNW clients navigate this landscape by initiating the insurance conversation early — before a property is chosen, before an offer is made and before emotional attachment makes difficult news harder to deliver. Here are five ways advisors can get ahead of the conversation and help clients make more informed purchase decisions:

  1. Know the insurance picture before your client buys. Two properties can sit side by side in Florida but carry insurance costs that differ by a factor of three. The difference usually has nothing to do with size or location. One roof may be reinforced, the other not. One home may be better protected against wind. Those mitigation details may be invisible to a buyer focused on the property but are exactly what underwriters see when they price the risk.
  2. Factor in lifetime cost, not just price of admission. HNW clients are accustomed to evaluating what something costs to acquire, but many underestimate what an asset really costs to maintain. An expensive boat, for example, can carry maintenance and insurance costs that run over $100,000 a month. A coastal property or home in a hail corridor are no different. Helping clients see the full cost of a location –– including premiums, mitigation investments and exposure to weather events –– before they commit is where advisors add the most value.
  3. Build a risk mitigation plan. For existing properties, there is almost always something a client can do to improve their risk profile. A client who invested $150,000 in a new roof, for instance, saw his annual premium drop from $72,000 to $18,000. The right improvements can protect clients' property, strengthen insurability and significantly reduce what they pay to maintain coverage.
  4. Involve insurers early on new construction. For clients building, involve carriers from day one. Water suppression systems, fire retardants and construction standards that underwriters look for at placement are decisions made during the build. Trying to retrofit coverage requirements into a finished home can turn into a far more expensive conversation.
  5. Understand what drives costs by location. Tort environments, weather patterns and local economics all influence what insurance costs in each market, and none of them stay static. Louisiana remains one of the most expensive states in the country to insure, due to a combination of severe weather patterns and its litigious environment. Florida is a useful case study in volatility: litigation reform is driving premiums down in some segments, but carriers remain one significant storm away from reversing course. Advisors who understand these dynamics can warn clients about potential cost shifts before they commit to a property.
THE ADVISOR'S ROLE IS CHANGING

As wealth continues to migrate into new and complex risk territory, the most valuable thing an advisor can offer is early involvement — getting into the conversation before a client commits to a location. HNW individuals with a strategic partner who goes beyond placing coverage are much more likely to avoid the situations that are becoming increasingly common: a property that turns out to be uninsurable, premiums that make ownership financially unworkable or a renewal that arrives with costs no one anticipated.

AI's Conundrum for Underwriting

Underwriting AI systems are designed to assist rather than replace human judgment, but this efficiency trade-off may eliminate how juniors become experts.

AI Underwriting

I sell software that encodes expert decisions, so hold that against everything below.

We ran an opinion-drafting model on real renewal files before connecting it to anything. It writes the underwriting opinion the way the senior underwriter does, off claims history and portfolio context. This is health cover outside the US, about 2,500 renewals, where per-condition exclusions still get written into the policy, so the medical exceptions are the job.

Two things came back in the same run. The AI overgeneralized, taking an exception written for one condition and applying it to a whole disease category. It also caught diagnoses the human-written opinions had missed.

Everyone wants to talk about the catch. Both findings landed in the same place, though. A draft, on a human's desk, under somebody else's signature. Nothing we built moved an inch of authority, and that was the design.

Everything ships below the authority line

A great deal of personal lines business quotes and binds without an underwriter looking at it, under filed rates and rules, with authority in an approved rule set instead of a person. That predates all of this by decades. So the real line runs between decisions you can specify in advance and decisions you can't, and what you can't write down stays with the person holding the pen.

The pattern almost everyone has converged on, including us, follows from that. Keep the system decision-negative. Triage, enrich, summarize, score referrals, draft the opinion. The output lands under an existing authority threshold, a human signs, and nobody reopens a governance document. That's why this version gets built, and the ambitious one doesn't. It's an engineering choice made to dodge a governance cost, and we should name it that way instead of calling it a safety feature.

It fails in one specific way. Our reviewers caught the overgeneralization because they could see which prior opinions the draft had reasoned from. Take that away and approvals start to look like review. A reviewer who can't reconstruct why the system said what it said signs because the queue is long, one of the best-replicated results in the human factors work on decision aids.

The line could move

The usual defense of that design is that the alternative is impossible, because the veteran's reasoning lives only in the veteran. I believed that for years. Mostly it isn't true.

Texas requires personal auto, residential property, and workers' compensation insurers to file their underwriting guidelines with the state within 10 days of use, and defines a guideline to include a practice whether written, oral, or electronic. The auto and property filings are public records.

But a filed guideline records the rule, not the reasoning. Nothing in a filing tells you when to depart from it, and the departures are the job. I opened by saying the medical exceptions are where the work sits. So codification retires a smaller claim than it looks. The policy is written down. The judgment isn't.

Noise cuts the other way

There's a finding anyone selling expertise capture should have to answer, and it's a decade old.

In 2015 Daniel Kahneman ran identical cases past 48 underwriters at one large carrier. Executives guessed two underwriters would differ by about 10%. The median difference between any two was 55%. One priced a risk at $9,500 where another said $16,700.

I used to read that as damaging. It runs the other way. Goldberg showed in 1970 that a model built from a judge's own past calls often beats the judge, because the model never drifts. It outperformed 79% of the clinicians it was built from. Noise is the argument for encoding, not against it. What it kills is the premise that there's one veteran in there worth copying whole.

Our own two results are that finding in miniature. The model won on consistency and lost on the rare structured exception.

Reading decisions out of files instead of asking about them is policy capturing, and it predates everyone in this argument. It shows spread that one interview at a time can't. It also flatters the file, which holds the justification rather than the reasoning.

What none of it fixes is the label. The label you have is what the underwriter decided; the label you want is whether the account ran profitably. Seasoning fixes the lag, not the hole, because declined accounts never produce a loss ratio and the only book you can test on is the one he agreed to write. Test on it anyway. Almost nobody in my category does, and I'm not the exception. Everything I've reported here is an agreement measure or a stopwatch, not a loss ratio.

Where the efficiency goes

Suppose you get all of that decision right. The gain still may not land where the business case said.

Carl Van has been in claims since 1980 and runs International Insurance Institute, which sells adjuster training, so read him with that in mind. He was talking about adjusters. The mechanism carries because it doesn't live in the job title. It lives with the executive who signed for the system. By email in August:

"Some companies themselves drive the empathy and humanity out of the adjuster position without realizing it... usually to justify the expense of an improved system, someone invariably promised higher production in some executive meeting.

"Therefore, if you improve the system, the adjuster WILL NOT spend more time being empathetic or human. They will spend the extra time trying to accomplish the higher workload standards imposed by the company."

The capitals are his. Van says the characteristics in his book can be trained, and his firm has trained them for 28 years, but they "won't happen just because the adjusters have more time on their hands." The version that works funds the training next to the system. That line item is the first one cut, because the business case is where somebody already promised the production number.

The part I can't resolve

Our renewal team went from eight people to three. Before anyone else does the arithmetic, I'll do it. Those 2,500 renewals at six minutes each come to roughly 250 hours a year, and taking the review to one minute saves about 208 of those hours. That's a tenth of a person. The rest came from the definition and follow-up work around the review, not from the review. The headline number and the stopwatch number are not the same number, and people in my line of work print both and hope you won't multiply.

What went away was routine renewal review. That's also where a junior underwriter turns into a senior one. You sit with hundreds of ordinary files until an unusual one announces itself.

The obvious fix is to route a share of straight-through-eligible files to a junior anyway and book it as training, the way a teaching hospital protects cases. Teaching hospitals tried it. Matt Beane spent two years inside robotic surgery programs and found residents getting 10 to 20 times less hands-on practice, with the ones who stayed competent managing it by breaking protocol. The fix already failed where I borrowed the metaphor.

So the trade is real and I don't have a way around it. I haven't met anyone who does.

Managing Litigation Risk in Nuclear Verdict Era

Auto and trucking litigation now drives 33% of carrier spending as nuclear verdicts climb, demanding proactive management over reactive response.

Managing Litigation Risk in Nuclear Verdict Era

Litigation is one of the most volatile and least standardized components of indemnity leakage. Venue outcomes vary widely, plaintiff bar strategy has grown more sophisticated, and jury behavior remains inherently unpredictable. This is exactly why litigation is often the hardest leakage driver for claims organizations to bring under control in day-to-day operations.

According to a 2026 CLM Litigation Management Study, auto and trucking has overtaken general liability as carriers' single largest litigation spending driver. It now accounts for 33% of total litigation spending, up from 24% in 2023. At the same time, data from Marathon Strategies' May 2025 analysis puts the median nuclear verdict against corporate defendants at $51 million, up from a $44 million median. Even mid-severity claims now carry thermonuclear tail risk in adverse venues.

Claims organizations at P&C insurers are stretched thin. However, when done well, claims litigation management is one of the most effective methods for controlling severity and protecting loss ratio performance.

A Three-Layer Approach to Claims Litigation Management

The CLM 2026 data also show that settlement — not trial — remains the dominant path to resolution. A mean of 87% of non-workers' comp litigated claims settle, against a verdict rate of just 2.9%, indicating that settlement quality, not just avoiding trial, is the true performance lever.

Yet many legacy claims processes were not built for the circumstances insurers face today. Litigation propensity is assessed too late to change outcomes. Panel counsel is retained based on legacy relationships rather than performance. And even once a case is flagged, panel counsel selection and case strategy tend to move independently of one another, with reserves catching up only after the fact.

Closing that gap requires more than incremental fixes. It calls for an end-to-end approach built on three integrated layers, each tied to a distinct point of loss ratio impact.

1. Analytics and AI

The foundation of a modern litigation management approach is intelligence applied at the earliest possible point in the claims life cycle. Machine learning models embedded at first notice of loss (FNOL) score litigation likelihood using injury type, claimant history, adjuster notes, and jurisdiction, giving claims teams a head start on cases most likely to become contested. The earlier that signal arrives, the more severity is still avoidable.

Attorney selection benefits from that same discipline. Panel counsel are scored on cost per claim, resolution time, and win rate, then matched to cases based on demonstrated performance rather than tenure or familiarity. Later in a case's life cycle, predictive models take on a different task, comparing the likely cost and outcome of settling now against continuing to litigate so adjusters can weigh that decision with data instead of instinct.

A Litigation Risk Index ties these capabilities together: a composite score built from plaintiff attorney specialization, reptile-theory signals, and jurisdiction severity. In practice, the score is used to trigger escalation thresholds, reserve reviews, and counsel reassignment, giving claims organizations a consistent way to gauge venue risk across an entire portfolio.

2. Claims Management Platform

Where analytics identify risk, the claims management platform puts that intelligence to work inside the daily workflow, rather than leaving it in a separate tool an adjuster has to remember to check.

Preferred counsel assignment is automated first. Panel tiers are enforced by default, and any deviation is flagged for supervisor approval so that attorney selection is strategic, not based on firm availability or convenience. Each file carries a real-time litigation risk score inside the platform, visible to the adjuster the moment a case is assigned.

From there, oversight becomes continuous instead of periodic: a centralized case tracking dashboard, automated diary management, and billing review keep reserve alignment current as a file moves through each stage. The Litigation Risk Index recalculates at key case events, automatically escalating a file to the litigation management track the moment its risk profile changes. The result is fewer files drifting off-process, and less variance in how similar cases get handled.

3. Advisory and Governance

Analytics and platform automation are only as effective as the human judgment guiding them, which is where advisory and governance close the loop. Quarterly venue heat map updates, paired with judicial behavior analysis (plaintiff-friendly tendencies, historical award patterns, and jurisdiction-specific trends) give litigation leadership an continuing view of exposure and reserve guidance that shifts as jurisdictions evolve, rather than a static assessment revisited only after a bad outcome.

That intelligence feeds directly into panel strategy. Rather than reviewing counsel performance on an ad hoc basis, this layer calls for a structured panel redesign process: identifying underperforming firms, restructuring fee arrangements, and setting outcome targets tied to results. A regular litigation strategy review cadence carries that discipline into individual files, with adjusters and defense counsel working from file-level guidance and early resolution playbooks, particularly for cases trending toward nuclear venues, well before a verdict is at risk.

This layer also defines what happens when risk scores change. Intervention protocols tied to low, medium, and high score bands establish clear escalation paths, agreed upon with carrier leadership in advance, so no file's rising risk profile goes unaddressed for lack of an owner.

When these three layers operate together rather than in isolation, litigation shifts from a cost absorbed after the fact into a severity lever that is actively managed from FNOL forward.

Turn Litigation Insight Into Action

Litigation is not going away, and neither is the pressure it places on loss ratios. Exposure risk will likely continue climbing, and nuclear verdicts show little sign of slowing down.

No approach eliminates litigation risk entirely. But carriers that manage it proactively through integrated analytics, embedded workflows, and disciplined governance can meaningfully influence the trajectory of a case rather than simply reacting to it after exposure has already escalated.

To learn more about navigating the changing environment around litigation management, read ValueMomentum's whitepaper "Combating Social Inflation: Strategies for Claims Organizations to Reduce Leakage."

Generic AI Stops Where Insurance Decisions Begin

Generic AI can summarize and extract data, but vertical AI is needed to provide the context and governance required by high-stakes decisions.

Generic AI stops Where Insurance Decisions Begin

Generic AI is reaching its limit in insurance. It can summarize a submission, draft a customer response or extract information from a claims file. What it cannot do independently is make the high-stakes decisions that determine insurance performance.

Those decisions require more than a plausible answer. They depend on an insurer's data, pricing and underwriting rules, risk appetite, regulatory obligations, portfolio position and operational context. Without that grounding, AI may produce an answer that sounds credible but cannot be trusted, explained or acted upon.

According to Grant Thornton's 2026 AI Impact Survey, 44% of insurance executives said governance or compliance challenges had caused AI projects to fail or underperform, while 56% identified regulatory uncertainty as a leading barrier to scaling AI.

This is driving the industry toward vertical AI built specifically for insurance. Unlike general-purpose tools, vertical AI can apply intelligence within the context, controls and accountability that real insurance decisions demand.

The Danger of Faster Silos

Most insurers already have vast amounts of data, but rarely a complete view at the moment a decision must be made. Policy data may sit in one system, claims history in another and customer interactions somewhere else. Portfolio information and external risk signals may also arrive on different cycles.

Each source tells part of the story, but none necessarily reflects the full business context.

When insurers place AI on top of that partial view, they may produce an answer more quickly without producing a better decision. In high-stakes decision making, speed cannot compensate for missing context.

Insurance has traditionally been organized around separate disciplines, including pricing, underwriting, claims, customer engagement and portfolio management, even though the outcomes of those functions are closely connected. A pricing decision affects conversion and retention. An underwriting decision changes portfolio quality. A claims experience can influence renewal, customer value and future risk.

The business understands these relationships, but its systems do not always reflect them.

The risk is that insurers layer AI onto the same fragmented operating model. Pricing, claims, underwriting and service may each gain tools, while the organization still lacks a shared understanding of the decision being made. Individual tasks become faster, but the underlying disconnect remains.

That is the limit of horizontal AI. It can improve an activity without improving the enterprise decision surrounding it.

Insurance AI Should Follow the Decision

Policy administration, billing, claims and CRM platforms remain essential to insurance operations. They preserve records, process transactions and provide the stability insurers rely on. AI should strengthen the work performed within and across those systems, rather than attempt to replace them.

These platforms are highly effective at recording what has happened. The greater opportunity lies in helping insurers determine what should happen next.

A renewal decision, for example, may require policy history, recent claims, customer value, portfolio concentration, emerging risk signals, a pricing model, underwriting appetite and current regulatory requirements. No single platform owns all of that context.

The architecture must therefore be decision-centered rather than core-centered. Insurers need to identify the intelligence, rules, workflows and human expertise that must come together around each decision, then orchestrate those elements across the systems they already use.

Vertical AI extends far beyond adding insurance terminology to a general-purpose model. It is designed around how insurance work is performed, how decisions are governed and how their consequences are managed.

A rate change, for example, affects more than the price presented to a customer. It can influence portfolio composition, retention, profitability, fairness and regulatory filings. The AI supporting that decision must understand those connections.

Bringing the necessary context into the workflow may require predictive AI for risk and pricing, generative AI for explanation and guidance, and agentic AI for bounded, multistep execution. The type of model matters less than the insurer's ability to orchestrate the right intelligence around the decision.

The decision must come first.

Governance Must Travel With The Action

Insurance has always delegated authority within defined boundaries. Controls throughout the process allow insurers to distribute decision-making without losing accountability.

Agentic AI changes the risk profile because it can take action rather than simply provide advice. When an AI system can initiate or execute steps in real time, reviewing its activity after the fact may be too late.

Governance must therefore be embedded within the decision itself. It should define which data can be used, which models and rules may be applied, when human review is required and how the complete decision path can be reconstructed.

Not every AI component will be deterministic, but the route from input to action must be controlled wherever the decision demands it. Probabilistic intelligence requires deterministic guardrails, including defined permissions, monitoring, escalation paths, and the ability for a person to intervene.

The regulatory direction is already clear. The NAIC's model bulletin calls on insurers to establish governance, documentation, testing, validation and third-party oversight for AI systems supporting decisions that affect consumers. It also reinforces that insurers remain accountable for those decisions, regardless of the technology used to support them.

Human oversight must be designed into the operating model. This does not mean asking someone to rubber-stamp every AI-generated output. It means defining what can be automated, what must be reviewed, when escalation is required, and who ultimately carries responsibility.

Done well, this approach also gives experienced underwriters, actuaries and claims professionals greater leverage. Their hard-won expertise can become reusable decision logic, business rules and escalation paths, rather than remaining trapped in documents, manual processes or the knowledge of a small number of individuals.

Measure Decisions, Not Deployments

The insurance industry has invested heavily in data, analytics, predictive models, cloud platforms and core modernization. The remaining gap lies between those assets and the decisions that run the business.

A vertical approach allows insurers to advance AI without waiting for a multiyear core replacement. It can draw on the systems, data, and models insurers already trust, then orchestrate them around the decisions that need to improve today.

This makes existing investments more valuable while giving the business greater flexibility to adapt, without destabilizing the systems that keep operations running.

Success should therefore be measured by the quality and business impact of the decisions being improved, not by the number of AI tools deployed. That may include stronger pricing performance, more consistent underwriting, faster product changes, improved customer outcomes, or better portfolio management.

Insurance is an industry of connected consequences. AI built for isolated tasks will miss those connections, regardless of how capable the underlying model may be.

Insurance-native, vertical AI begins with the decision. It brings together domain context, predictive and generative intelligence, business rules, workflows, governance, and human judgment at the point where action occurs.

That is how insurers can move beyond isolated AI use cases and turn AI into a trusted, scalable capability for the decisions that matter most.

How to Automate Insurance Endorsements

Automating endorsement processing eliminates manual data entry bottlenecks, freeing account managers to focus on strategic client relationships and risk management.

Automating Insurance Endorsements to Enhance Client Service

Have you ever calculated the true cost of a manual policy update?

Mid-term policy modifications carry heavy administrative overhead across insurance operations.

  • Adding a vehicle to a commercial fleet requires significant data entry.
  • Adjusting coverage limits involves pulling up multiple internal systems.
  • Updating a mortgagee address demands careful attention to detail.

These routine tasks pull account managers away from meaningful client interactions.

High-touch service relies on speed, accuracy, and clear communication. Automating endorsement processing preserves human energy for relationship management. Account managers were hired for their expertise in risk management and their ability to build client trust. Every hour spent manually keying data is an hour taken away from proactive client service. Insurance leaders should look at back-office workflow automation as a primary strategy for protecting client relationships.

Operational Friction Points in Endorsement Management

Endorsement requests often arrive through unstructured emails containing the insured's instructions. Account managers spend their valuable time manually extracting information and re-keying data into the AMS and carrier portals. This repetitive administrative overhead creates operational bottlenecks.

When routine endorsements take days to process due to back-office backlogs, client trust begins to erode. Insureds expect quick turnarounds for mid-term changes. Delayed processing affects the client relationship right when individuals and business owners need confirmation that their assets are protected.

What Intelligent Endorsement Automation Looks Like

Agencies can modernize these workflows without losing operational control. Purpose-built insurance automation handles repetitive data entry while keeping licensed staff in control of key decisions.

Request Intake and Data Extraction

Intelligent tools can continuously monitor shared email inboxes and carrier portals for incoming endorsement notifications and direct change requests. Using advanced data extraction techniques, these systems read unstructured emails and attached PDFs. The software automatically identifies key field data, pulling policy numbers, effective dates, coverage adjustments, and premium changes directly from the source material.

Policy Validation and System Matching

Extracting data requires accuracy before any record changes take place. Automation cross-references extracted request data against active policy records in your core AMS. The system verifies endorsement details, checks for missing information early in the workflow, and confirms that requested coverage limits or deductibles fall within allowed ranges. Early validation eliminates time-consuming back-and-forth communication with clients.

Automated System Updating

Once validated, automated tools apply verified changes directly to the correct policy record in the AMS. Automation updates coverage limits, adjusts premium amounts, and modifies effective dates without requiring manual data entry from staff. Detailed audit trails capture every modification automatically, logging timestamps and specific changes to maintain complete compliance.

Exception Handling and Human Oversight

Automation functions best alongside human judgment. When a complex request comes in, such as a major shift in coverage boundaries or missing documentation, a good insurance automation solution flags the file for manual review. An assigned account manager receives an immediate notification to evaluate the exception, ensuring complete oversight over non-standard adjustments.

Turning Back-Office Efficiency into Better Client Experience

Streamlining back-office workflows through automation translates directly into a better client experience. Shifting staff focus away from manual data entry reclaims capacity for high-value client engagement. Account managers gain the time needed to review coverage needs proactively, discuss risk management strategies, and prepare for upcoming renewals in advance.

Automated extraction and validation also eliminate human error. Re-keying information manually can lead to typos, which sometimes cause coverage gaps or billing discrepancies down the line. Consistent logic across workflows reduces variance and ensures records remain accurate across all systems.

With endorsement processing automation, clients receive quick confirmations and updated policy documents. Rapid service builds confidence. Processing policy change requests swiftly and accurately reinforces the client's confidence in your agency's capabilities.

Elevating the Client Experience Through Automation

Insurance agencies should view automation as an enhancement to human potential. By removing repetitive administrative tasks, account managers can return to the relationship-focused work that drives client retention. Modern solutions layer directly onto existing agency management systems and carrier portals, driving efficiency without disrupting core operations.

The Case for Specialty Insurance in Restaurants

In a risky and fast-changing environment, restaurants face issues that standard commercial policies were never designed to address.

Specialty Insurance Addresses Emerging Restaurant Risks Quickly

Few industries carry as much daily risk as restaurants do, and few have watched risks change as quickly. Food safety incidents, allergen risk, perishable inventory loss, kitchen fires, and equipment failure have long shaped the industry's insurance needs. What's different now is how fast entirely new categories of risk are landing on top of them -- from larger, more complex supply chains and increasingly connected operations to reputational threats driven by social media.

Couple this with the fact that traditional commercial policies are built on historical loss data, where pricing and underwriting is based on what has happened before, and a clear gap can be seen immediately, with many of the risks affecting restaurants today emerging faster than conventional insurance product development cycles are responding.

These changing risks have been widely discussed in the market. The challenge is developing and delivering coverage quickly enough to address them. And this is where the argument for more targeted specialty products that can address new exposures while they are still emerging lands.

Where specialty insurance fills the gap

Specialty insurance is designed differently than traditional commercial products. Rather than expecting broad commercial policies to expand gradually over time and attempt to accommodate every possible exposure within them, specialty products can be developed around specific operational risks as they emerge.

Specialty insurance works alongside traditional commercial insurance, providing more targeted protection where broader policies may not be designed to address, without waiting for years of historical claims data to reshape a standard policy.

That flexibility is particularly important for risks that are structurally different from those insurers have modelled in the past. In the restaurant sector specifically, examples of risks include:

  • Supplier contamination networks becoming more complex and more fragile: The global food supply chain has become increasingly connected, a shift from the more local, slow-moving contamination events that traditional insurers historically built their products to address. The speed and scale at which a single contamination event can cascade has changed significantly. The multistate outbreak of Cyclospora infections being investigated by the CDC, FDA, and public health officials is a prime example.
  • Social media is creating a category of adverse publicity risk that didn't exist 15 years ago: Adverse publicity would have been a relatively narrow risk in 2005: a bad review in a local paper or a segment on a local news channel would have been manageable, containable, slow-moving, even. But today things are very different: one TikTok video of unsanitary conditions, an X thread about a foodborne illness experience, or a Reddit post about a foreign object in a meal can reach millions within hours or even minutes. The speed at which this can then reduce bookings, drive away customers, both new and old, and create lasting damage is huge.
  • Malicious tampering and product extortion are growing with the rise of brand-driven restaurant culture: The growth of celebrity chefs, food influencers, and social media has also changed the value of a restaurant. For many businesses, their brand is now one of their most valuable assets, which in turn can increase their exposure to bad actors seeking to exploit or damage that reputation through false claims, online misinformation or deliberate tampering. This remains rare, though it's taken seriously enough today that both the FDA and USDA have dedicated food defense programs and guidance designed to help food businesses prevent and respond to intentional contamination.

Each of these risks follows the same pattern: they emerged faster than traditional underwriting cycles could respond, they were categorically different from the historical data that standard policies were built on, and by the time a major carrier had modeled and priced the exposure, restaurants had already been living with it unprotected for years.

That challenge can be addressed by the speed of specialty product development. Reducing the time between identifying a new risk, designing appropriate coverage, and bringing it to market is essential if coverage is to keep pace with changing business needs.

Modern technology is making this increasingly achievable, allowing insurers to develop and distribute specialty products more efficiently than has historically been possible. For brokers, it also means being able to access and place niche products within the same conversations and workflows they already use to advise clients.

A broader opportunity for the insurance industry

The restaurant sector is dealing with a unique set of emerging risks, but it offers a useful illustration of a much wider trend across commercial insurance.

Businesses in many industries outside of the food services sector are also facing new forms of risk that sit outside the classic assumptions underpinning traditional insurance products. Climate volatility, cyber threats, supply chain disruption and reputational exposure are all evolving so quickly that they're creating protection gaps that broad, standardized policies weren't designed to address.

As is the case with restaurants, closing those gaps will take more than developing new products. It will also call for an insurance market capable of identifying emerging exposures, designing appropriate coverage, and bringing specialized products to businesses at speed.


Mike Gulla

Profile picture for user MikeGulla

Mike Gulla

Mike Gulla is chief executive officer and cofounder of Adaptive.

He has more than 20 years of experience, including at Hippo Insurance, Allstate, Esurance, Nationwide, and Verisk.

As part of his time at Hippo, he spearheaded the smart home IoT insurance program to help mitigate losses. While at Esurance, he led the underwriting development needed for the company’s first direct-to-consumer online bindable home insurance quote.

Why Multifamily Risk Isn't About Storm Count

Storm count doesn't predict multifamily risk, yet owners still treat a quiet forecast as permission to ease enforcement.

Why Multifamily Risk Isn't About Storm Count

The insurance industry has spent the summer treating storm count as a proxy for risk. With NOAA's 2026 Atlantic outlook pointing to a below-normal season, the prevailing read across multifamily ownership has been one of relief after several punishing years.

But that read conflates two things that are not, in fact, the same variable.

The industry's own reinsurance modeling doesn't support the equivalence, and neither does the loss pattern showing up in ordinary, non-catastrophic claims that have nothing to do with named storms at all.

Start with what a "quiet" season actually means statistically rather than what it implies emotionally. A below-normal story count reduces the probability of a major landfall, but it does nothing to reduce the severity of one if it happens. And, it also says nothing at all about the far more frequent, far less dramatic losses, from fires and burst pipes to structural failures, which drive claims in any given month regardless of what the Atlantic is doing.

That second category is where the coverage gap actually lives, and it's been on display twice recently. In Henrico County, Va., a fire at the Darby House senior apartments displaced dozens of residents, prompting the Virginia Apartment Management Association to remind tenants publicly that a landlord's policy stops at the building's walls; it doesn't cover what's inside a resident's unit. Days later, a roof collapse at North Union Apartments in Midvale, Utah, left residents uncertain whether their losses were covered at all, with coverage varying from resident to resident depending on who had signed up and who hadn't.

Neither event involved a storm, and that's precisely why they're instructive. They show the coverage gap operating at full strength in the absence of the peril everyone's currently watching.

If a below-normal hurricane season lulls owners into treating resident-level insurance enforcement as a lower priority this year, the Henrico and Midvale losses are what that complacency looks like even in a quiet season's ordinary months, before a single storm enters the equation.

"Quiet" is a statistical average, not a guarantee

NOAA's outlook has pointed toward below-normal activity all summer, with only four named storms recorded so far. Colorado State's forecasting team, meanwhile, has revised its numbers downward since spring.

On paper, this is good news for a market that's spent the last several years absorbing catastrophic losses. Swiss Re's own data complicates that reading, however.

The reinsurer's institute found that 2025's global insured catastrophe losses of $107 billion came in below the long-term trend almost entirely because no major U.S. hurricane made landfall that year. This was characterized explicitly as favorable variability, not a reduction in underlying risk.

If 2026 tracks the long-run 5-7% annual growth trend that's held since 1996, the same report projects insured losses climbing to roughly $148 billion; in a peak-loss scenario driven by a single major hurricane or earthquake, that figure rises to $320 billion.

That's the crucial detail a headline storm count doesn't capture. The industry's own reinsurance modeling treats "quiet so far" as noise sitting on top of a rising baseline, not as a trend in its own right.

Coverage of this year's season has made the same point more bluntly, noting that a below-normal forecast produced the exact conditions when Hurricane Andrew struck in 1992, remembered as one of the costliest storms in U.S. history. The industry as a whole must be reminded, therefore, that storm count and loss severity aren't the same variable. They never have been.

For multifamily owners, the practical takeaway isn't that this season will necessarily be bad. It's that a favorable forecast is not a reason to relax the parts of the risk picture within an owner's control. Because the parts that aren't, including where a storm tracks and how intense it becomes on approach, remain exactly as unpredictable.

The gap sits below master policy

While the macro conversation stays fixed on named storms, a far more mundane and fixable problem recurs every month. Most residents simply aren't required to carry coverage for the fire, burst pipe, and structural failure losses that actually drive claims, the kind that hit Henrico and Midvale last month.

A CNBC Select analysis of a RentRedi study, for one, found that only about 47% of U.S. landlords required renters insurance in 2025, leaving a majority of leases nationwide with coverage effectively optional, at an average cost of $14.25 a month, according to the Insurance Information Institute.

This is a strikingly low enforcement rate for a policy this inexpensive, and this directly tied to an owner's own liability exposure.

That gap also compounds a cost problem operators are already living with on the master-policy side. The NAA's Premium Pulse analysis, drawing on Federal Reserve data, found that real, inflation-adjusted multifamily property insurance costs per unit rose about $465 in 2019 to $821 in 2024, representing a 77% increase in five years. Insurance, in fact, now represents 4.8% of multifamily revenue nationally, up from under 2% in 2000.

The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis reached a similar conclusion when surveying operators directly, documenting firsthand accounts of premiums rising sharply even as coverage itself shrinks.

Owners are absorbing that cost increase on the building side while leaving an inexpensive, liability-reducing tool underused on the resident side, and that mismatch gets harder to justify the more premiums climb.

Some operators have tried to solve this the other way, by folding tenant-caused damage into a landlord-side Tenant Legal Liability program instead of relying on individual renters' policies. Subrogation counsel, however, has flagged a structural cost to that shortcut.

Because TLL coverage is written to protect the landlord's own insured interest rather than the tenant's, it can limit or bar the landlord's insurer from pursuing subrogation against a negligent tenant once a claim is paid.

A program built to simplify risk management can therefore end up narrowing the very recovery rights that keep loss from landing entirely on the portfolio. Individual, verified renters insurance, carried at adequate liability limits rather than the token minimums many leases still specify, preserves that recovery path in a way blanket landlord-side products generally don't.

Waiting to see the season

The fix here isn't a data availability problem in the way it might sound. Running an effective renters insurance program requires knowing who's covered, at what limits, verified against which unit, and that information exists in principle at every property.

What's missing in most portfolios is a consistent, centralized way to confirm it at scale and catch the gap before a claim exposes it, rather than after. Enforcement, in other words, isn't a question of building new infrastructure from scratch, but one of actually verifying what leases already claim to require, instead of accepting a self-attestation and moving on.

That's a lever owners control entirely on their own timeline, independent of carrier appetite, reinsurance pricing, or how the rest of this hurricane season unfolds.

If the season stays quiet, tighter enforcement still reduces claims exposure and preserves subrogation rights against the ordinary losses that happen in any given month, storm or not.

On the other hand, if the update doesn't hold, the operators who tightened enforcement now won't be the ones relearning this lesson in October.

Commercial Insurance Has an Identity Crisis

When a steel column buckled in a Manhattan tower conversion, it exposed a deeper problem: Buildings lack persistent identity across their lifecycle.

Missing Link

When two steel columns buckled on the 21st floor of the former Pfizer headquarters in Manhattan this July, the building safety industry watched a familiar sequence unfold, and commercial property insurers should have watched just as closely. 

Reporting noted that engineers were cautioned against assuming the visible damage marked the full extent of the problem at the 37-story tower, then mid-conversion into more than 1,600 apartments. Structural elements are connected, and a failure in one area often signals stress elsewhere. Early accounts pointed toward a missing steel reinforcement plate, a detail that should have appeared in the project's engineering plans but was never installed, according to engineers cited by The Real Deal.

For a carrier underwriting that asset, or an adjuster assigned to the claim, it would be easy to call this a documentation failure. That framing undersells the problem. The tower did not lose its documentation. It lost records continuity. Every renovation, code cycle, and material change was tied to whatever system or individual happened to be tracking it at the time. When those links broke, so did the file's ability to describe the true risk on the books.

The missing layer is not another document repository. It is a persistent identity connecting every record, inspection, permit, renovation, owner, engineer, and platform to the same physical asset across its lifecycle and every policy period it will ever carry.

Documentation Answers the Wrong Question

Even carriers with disciplined underwriting files run into this. A document repository answers what records exist. It cannot answer what actually happened to a specific asset across its operating life, the question a claims examiner is really asking.

A recent industry analysis of facility continuity found that as veteran facility managers retire, decades of undocumented building knowledge often leave with them, since it lives in someone's head rather than in a system. The analysis cited IFMA projections that more than 45% of facility management professionals worldwide will retire within a decade, removing much of the institutional memory insurers have quietly relied on when pricing risk.

That is the same failure described two ways: a retiring manager who carried undocumented knowledge out the door, or a file that cannot say what a structure can support after decades of alterations. The cause is identical. The record lives with the software, the vendor, or the employee, never with the infrastructure itself.

What Claims and Underwriting Actually Require

In a post-failure scenario, structural engineers, investigators, and claims teams are not simply looking for a folder of drawings. They need a reliable, continuous chain of custody for every material change, traceable to who made it, when, and under what code cycle. A binder handed off at turnover cannot provide what's needed.

The same need extends well beyond a single claim. Fire departments, FEMA, adjusters, building officials, and search and rescue teams all depend on the same continuous history of what a building is, what it can support, and what has changed. So does every actuary modeling portfolio exposure, and every reinsurer pricing a treaty against it.

What claims and underwriting actually require is closer to a VIN for physical infrastructure, a persistent identifier every contractor, engineer, permitting office, carrier, and platform can reference over decades, regardless of who owns the data or which system created it. Imagine underwriting an aircraft fleet if every maintenance record moved to a new numbering system each time ownership changed. That is unacceptable in aviation. It remains normal for buildings.

A Survey That Is Measuring Something Deeper

Viewed this way, recent survey findings from ARC Facilities on facility leader confidence are not really measuring documentation quality. They are measuring identity fragmentation, the same fragmentation showing up as inconsistent exposure data across a book of business. The survey found many facility leaders describe only partial confidence in accessing critical building information when it matters most, one noting their organization lacks a reliable system.

Low confidence in complete records is what a carrier's risk engineers should expect in an industry where every renovation, ownership change, and software migration creates another chance for the thread between an asset and its history to snap, often just before a claim tests it.

The Layer the Industry Never Standardized

Over recent decades, the built environment has standardized layer after layer of how infrastructure gets built and managed. CAD standardized design. BIM standardized information. GIS standardized location. IFC standardized interoperability. Digital twins standardized representation.

None of those layers standardized identity, a persistent, portable reference that follows infrastructure across every system, every underwriting cycle, and every claim, throughout its lifecycle. Each platform generation has improved how information about an asset is captured, but none has solved for what happens once the platform, vendor, or risk manager who understood it moves on.

A digital twin cannot remain continuous if the identity of the asset it represents is not continuous. Neither can a book of business.

Interoperability tells systems how to exchange information. Identity tells systems what they are exchanging information about. The industry has spent 50 years perfecting the first problem while leaving the second unaddressed, and insurers have been pricing risk on top of that gap.

A Different Question for Risk and Insurance Leaders

The Pfizer conversion is useful not because documentation failed at a single point, but because continuity failed across an entire history of changes, and continuity depends on identity. That is a claims story and an underwriting story at once.

The more productive question for the insurance and risk industry isn't how thoroughly infrastructure gets documented. It's why so little of it carries a persistent identity across ownership changes, renovations, and software migrations, including changes in carrier, broker, and policy. Every industry exchanges data about buildings without a shared way to identify what it describes.

The built world has standardized nearly every way information is created, exchanged, and analyzed. The next standard will not be another data format. It will be persistent identity, and the carriers who adopt it first will be the ones who can actually price the risk they are holding.

Workers’ Comp Cost Savings: Fact or Fiction

Many workers' compensation programs rely on fee reduction alone, missing the critical early intervention that truly controls costs.

Workers' Compensation Cost Savings

I was once hired by a major insurance company to review the operation of their workers’ compensation managed care program administered by their third-party administrator (TPA). My analysis was over in less than three minutes. Their version of managed care was date stamps and rubber bands.

Medical bills from providers came to their mailroom and were date-stamped, wrapped in rubber bands and mailed to an outside vendor to reduce the medical fees to be paid. There was no management of anything. There was no intake of injuries, no direction to network providers, no contact with injured workers, no follow-up with medical providers, no contact with supervisors and no return-to-work program in place, to name a few problems.

I noted that reducing a bill to a state fee schedule is simply an administrative function of a claim administrator. The administrator kept a third of the “savings,” making millions of dollars while their clients’ workers’ compensation costs were out of control.

While conducting claim audits on behalf of large, self-insured entities in both the private and public sector, I typically found claims examiners with 200 case files to manage,with little or no nurse case management involved. On the other hand, I also found just the opposite. I was a consultant to a large city in Texas whose TPA had nurse case managers billing excessive time on every claim, resulting in costs skyrocketing.

During a site visit at a manufacturing facility, I once asked the plant manager, “Do you explain to your employees how to report a work-related accident?” He stated, “We don’t want our employees to know about workers’ comp.” I replied, “It has been around for a hundred years, and word is starting to leak out.”

True cost-effective workers’ compensation managed care must begin from the moment of injury. It is estimated that 50% of the future costs of a new injury will be determined in the first 24 hours. True cost containment can be achieved, but it must involve a well-thought-out program administered from day one by industry experts, including pre-planned intake and four-point contact (the injured worker, medical provider, supervisor, and the claims adjuster) within 24 to 48 hours of injury.

Today, 25% of a workers’ compensation claims adjuster’s day is spent on hold, trying to coordinate medical appointments. Unfortunately, many workers’ compensation managed care programs result in financially rewarding overtreatment.

Early intervention is essential to control claim costs while ensuring injured employees receive the right care at the right time. The injured worker should be contacted immediately by a nurse case manager to direct them to the appropriate medical provider based on the nature of the injury. Many employers I worked with initially directed all care to the local emergency room. Unless the injury is a true emergency, this is typically a total waste of time and money. Now, with the growth of urgent care centers, they may be a better option than the ER. However, the best option would be to direct care to the nearest appropriate medical specialists already trained and certified in a pre-planned network, with contracted fees already in place.

The employer/supervisor then needs to be contacted to review the accident, identify any witnesses, obtain a written job description and specific job duties such as lifting X amount, standing for X hours a day, etc.

Next, the nurse case manager should be following up with the designated medical provider to obtain objective medical findings and the need for any additional diagnostic testing or services such as physical therapy, etc.

The nurse case manager then needs to be in constant contact with the claims adjuster about the treatment plan and return-to-work status and any pre-authorization requirements.

It is imperative that all these pre-planned steps are in place before an accident or injury takes place and that injured workers, if they are going to require time off work, are informed regarding state waiting periods for potential benefits retroactive to the day of injury. When injured employees receive prompt, high-quality care, clear communication about their treatment and benefits, and reassurance that appropriate return-to-work accommodation is available, they are significantly less likely to seek legal representation. Attorney involvement can dramatically increase claim costs, making early intervention and effective communications critical.

It is well documented that by having a pre-planned program in place, employers can save enormous amounts of indirect costs involved with work-related injuries and accidents such as overtime, replacement workers, and lost productivity.

Real direct and indirect savings can be documented in well-run programs, but be aware of smoke and mirrors and date stamps and rubber bands.

AI Can Help Fill Key Gap for Life Insurers

Life insurers carry decades-long risk locked in contracts they can't revise, yet lack systems to continuously test the assumptions beneath them.

Life Insurers

In 2012, someone showed me a life insurance policy still in force. Issued in 1928. I'd come to the sector after a long run in credit cards, where you know what you're carrying within six to 18 months. I did the math without meaning to: that policy predated Social Security.

Insurance carries risk differently, and the difference isn't just duration — it's what either side can do about it once the ink is dry. A lender can act on an individual account: reduce a line, renegotiate, price it differently, charge it off. A life insurer cannot unilaterally touch a policy already in force; that right belongs to the policyholder, not the carrier. The industry doesn't just carry decades-long risk. It carries it locked, one contract at a time, with no lever to revisit terms even after the assumptions underneath them have quietly stopped matching reality.

That's an issue the industry's own machinery was never built to answer. Reserving, asset adequacy testing, hedging, reinsurance, the sale of legacy blocks to run-off specialists — all of it real, all of it sophisticated, all of it built to answer whether the aggregate is still solvent. None of it answers a narrower, harder question: does this one assumption, buried in a block that's still passing in aggregate, still hold? The standards touching assumption review ask for judgment, triggered by whatever surfaces the need — not a date on a calendar. The tests that do run on a schedule check the aggregate, not the assumption underneath it.

Here's the tell that this gap stopped being theoretical

In March 2026, the NAIC began piloting a structured AI Systems Evaluation Tool across 12 states. It isn't a general AI-governance gesture. Examiners using it can ask insurers to detail the oversight of AI systems used by actuarial service providers specifically, and to walk through the testing, verification, frequency, and methodology behind them. For actuaries who build or validate predictive models — which increasingly means experience studies and assumption-setting, not just pricing or claims — that means model documentation and assumption justifications becoming subject to regulatory examination, not just internal actuarial standards of practice. That's not an analogy to a proactive posture. It's regulators reaching directly into how AI-touched assumptions get tested and justified — a first, concrete step toward exactly the granular scrutiny this piece is arguing the industry doesn't otherwise have.

(A brief aside: the industry has pushed back hard on this pilot, and not merely over workload. Trade groups' formal comments call it "voluntary for regulators while compulsory for companies," note it has no defined end date, and flag that findings from what's explicitly an exploratory phase could be held against a carrier before the tool itself is finalized. Those are fair governance objections. They're also, in a way, evidence for this piece's own argument: regulators are building this proactive posture iteratively, through judgment and a pilot, before hardening it into a fixed rule — which is closer to the muscle insurers themselves need than a reason to dismiss it.)

That same year — 2012 — I watched a version of this exposure play out in real time, from inside a different seat, in an industry-wide effort that was already well underway. The 2008 crisis had left insurers holding large in-force books of annuities carrying guaranteed crediting or withdrawal rates set in a much higher-rate era. When rates fell and stayed down for years, those guarantees didn't just look generous — they became a standing liability the original pricing had never been stress-tested against. And because nobody can unilaterally rewrite a policy already in force, the fix was never going to be a model update. It was years of patient, unglamorous, one-by-one work: building offers attractive enough that policyholders would voluntarily give up guarantees the industry could no longer comfortably afford to keep. Carrier by carrier, contract by contract, across the sector — not because anyone lacked talent, but because nobody had a standing practice of asking, before the rate environment turned, whether that guarantee still made sense.

That's the exposure insurance carries now, in its own way, with its own kind of contract. It isn't new, and it was never really about AI — the gap between "the aggregate is fine" and "the individual assumption still holds" predates any model running against an underwriting file. What's changing is the cost of not knowing. Checking assumptions individually, continuously, used to be a resourcing decision nobody could justify for a block that was passing anyway. That constraint is loosening — not because the risk changed, but because the tools that make granular, continuing review economically realistic now exist. "We check the aggregate and trust judgment to catch the rest" isn't gone as an answer. It's weaker than it was five years ago. And that industry-wide effort is a preview of something worth sitting with: the fix that took years of manual, one-by-one work only got built because the rate environment forced it. It's a much better position to build that habit before something forces it than during.

What this actually asks of insurance executives

I'm not offering a view on hedging strategy or reserve methodology — that's not my lane. What is squarely in my lane: whether the organizational conditions exist for the people who already own assumption review to work well with AI — not defer to it, not ignore it, but genuinely partner with it.

  • The regulator's own posture is worth studying less for compliance value and more as a design pattern — and it's only become buildable as standing practice, rather than crisis response, recently. Assumption review has always had owners. What it hasn't had is a way to run continuously rather than annually or on trigger. That's what AI now makes affordable — not a replacement for an actuary's judgment, but a way to test a guarantee, a lapse assumption, a legacy block, far more often than a person could manage alone.
  • The harder question is whether the talent is being built for that partnership. Treating an AI system's output as the answer is one failure mode. Dismissing what it surfaces because it doesn't match what the model has always said is the other. The judgment in between — knowing when to challenge an AI finding, when to trust it, when to go dig further — isn't automatic. It has to be cultivated, the same way any other analytical judgment is.

Picture your next executive meeting on NAIC's AI Systems Evaluation Tool — whenever the Fall National Meeting takes it up, this becomes an agenda item somewhere. The easy question in that room will be whether you're ready for the exam. The harder, better question is whether the people who own your assumption reviews are equipped to work alongside AI — able to use what it surfaces, and just as able to push back on it when something doesn't add up.

The guaranteed-rate annuity problem wasn't solved by finding more talent — the industry had no shortage of it. It was solved reactively, once a crisis forced the question, and it took years longer than it should have because nobody was set up to ask it before the crisis made it unavoidable. That's the real choice in front of insurance leadership now: build the organizational conditions and the talent to ask that question all the time, with AI doing part of the looking and people doing the judging — or wait for the next rate environment, or the next examiner, to force the question again.


Amy Radin

Profile picture for user AmyRadin

Amy Radin

Amy Radin is a strategic advisor, keynote speaker, and Columbia University lecturer focused on why transformation succeeds or stalls in large, complex organizations. 

Drawing on senior leadership roles at Citi, American Express, and AXA, including one of the world’s first corporate chief innovation officer roles, she helps leaders build the capabilities required to absorb, scale, and sustain change.

Learn more at amyradin.com.