Download

AI Lets Insurers Avoid Reserve Surprises

AI-enabled decision intelligence helps insurers integrate fragmented enterprise data before reserve surprises become $500 million problems.

AI Changed a $500 Million Reserve Development Story
The Call

At 6:42 a.m. on a Tuesday morning in early February, Michael Grant's phone rang.

He was already awake. Public company CEOs rarely sleep well during earnings week.

The caller ID displayed David Ellis, Meridian Commercial Insurance's chief financial officer. David never called before seven unless something had gone wrong.

Michael answered immediately.

"We have a reserve problem."

The independent actuarial review had concluded the previous evening. After weeks of analysis and challenge sessions, the conclusion was unavoidable. Meridian would need to strengthen its commercial casualty reserves by approximately $500 million.

The financial implications were immediate.

Before the markets opened, the board would need to be informed. Rating agencies would request meetings. Investors would expect explanations. The earnings call scheduled later that week would no longer focus on operating performance. It would focus on credibility.

Michael listened quietly before asking a single question.

"How did we not see this coming?"

It was the question every executive, director, analyst, regulator, and shareholder would eventually ask.

It was also the wrong question.

The better question was this:

How did a long sequence of individually reasonable executive decisions become a $500 million reserve development?

The answer did not lie in a single actuarial assumption or one poor management decision.

It began nearly three years earlier.

Three Years Earlier

Three years before the reserve strengthening, Meridian looked exactly like the kind of carrier executives aspire to build.

The regional P&C insurer had earned a reputation for disciplined underwriting, conservative reserving, and consistent financial performance. Reserve development was generally predictable. Analysts viewed the company as steady. Rating agencies considered it well managed. Internally, executives regarded reserve discipline as one of Meridian's competitive strengths.

The quarterly reserve committee reflected that culture.

Led by the chief financial officer, the committee brought together senior leaders from actuarial, claims, underwriting, finance, and risk. Each function contributed a different perspective before management selected the company's carried reserve position.

The chief actuary presented reserve indications based on established actuarial methods and independent reserve reviews.

Claims executives discussed emerging litigation trends, settlement behavior, and developments within the largest claims.

Underwriting reviewed changes in portfolio composition, policy limits, pricing discipline, and business mix.

Finance evaluated the implications for earnings, capital adequacy, and external financial reporting.

The discussions were disciplined.

Assumptions were challenged.

Alternative interpretations were debated.

No one rushed to conclusions.

Looking back, there was remarkably little to criticize.

The organization had experienced executives.

It had sound governance.

It had reliable data.

It had established actuarial methods.

It had exactly the reserve process most well-managed carriers would expect to have.

And yet, within three years, those same executives would be explaining a $500 million reserve strengthening to the board and to the market.

The explanation would not be weak governance.

Nor would it be poor judgment.

It would be something far more subtle.

The organization possessed the information it needed.

It simply possessed it in pieces.

The First Signals

The first indications that something was changing did not arrive dramatically.

They appeared as routine operational observations.

During one quarterly reserve committee meeting, the chief claims officer noted that commercial auto bodily injury claims in several jurisdictions were remaining open longer than historical experience suggested. Settlement negotiations appeared less predictable. Litigation was becoming more complex in certain venues.

The observation attracted discussion but not concern.

Claims professionals encounter fluctuations like these regularly. Individual developments often reflect temporary operational factors rather than lasting changes in the underlying claims environment.

The committee agreed that the trend deserved continued monitoring.

Nothing suggested it justified changing reserves.

The underwriting discussion followed.

The chief underwriting officer described gradual changes in the portfolio. Larger commercial accounts represented a growing share of written premium. Higher liability limits had become increasingly common in several business segments. Competitive market conditions were influencing coverage structures in selected areas.

None of those developments appeared unusual.

Each reflected deliberate business decisions that management had already approved.

The business remained profitable.

Pricing discipline remained intact.

The portfolio continued performing within expectations.

The chief actuary then presented the quarterly reserve indications.

Historical development remained broadly consistent with prior analyses. Multiple actuarial methods continued supporting management's reserve position. Independent actuarial review identified no material reserve deficiency.

Viewed independently, each conclusion was entirely reasonable.

Claims observed subtle operational changes.

Underwriting observed gradual portfolio evolution.

Actuarial observed reserve adequacy supported by historical experience.

No individual observation justified changing the company's reserve position.

The committee approved another quarterly reserve selection.

It was a disciplined decision supported by the evidence available at that time.

What no one yet understood was that the organization was beginning to observe different parts of the same emerging story.

The Institutional Blind Spot

Nothing about Meridian's organizational structure was unusual.

Like most successful P&C insurers, it was organized around specialized functions.

Claims focused on claims.

Underwriting focused on risk selection and portfolio quality.

Actuarial focused on reserve adequacy.

Finance focused on earnings and capital.

Each function was exceptionally good at answering its own questions.

That specialization represented a strength.

It also created an unintended limitation.

Reserve adequacy is not fundamentally a claims question.

Nor an underwriting question.

Nor solely an actuarial question.

It is an institutional judgment that depends upon integrating evidence originating across the enterprise.

During periods of stability, that distinction rarely matters.

Historical experience aligns closely with current operations.

Independent functions naturally reinforce one another.

But when the operating environment begins changing faster than historical experience can reveal, something important happens.

Claims professionals may observe changing litigation behavior months before those developments become statistically visible.

Underwriters may recognize shifts in portfolio characteristics before those changes influence reserve development.

Finance may begin asking different questions about capital while actuarial analyses remain appropriately anchored in historical data.

Each observation is valid.

Each reflects disciplined professional judgment.

Each remains incomplete.

The reserve committee brought those perspectives together.

It integrated professional opinions.

It did not necessarily integrate the underlying evidence.

That distinction explains how well-governed institutions can still reach consequential decisions with an incomplete understanding of emerging enterprise risk.

Meridian was not suffering from a lack of information.

The organization knew many important things.

It simply did not yet know what those things meant when viewed together.

Rewinding the Story

Now rewind the story.

The portfolio is the same.

The claims are the same.

The executives are the same.

The reserve committee is the same.

The governance process is unchanged.

No authority has been delegated to AI.

No actuarial methods have been replaced.

No reserve decisions have been automated.

Only one thing changes.

The institution begins making reserve decisions with a more complete understanding of the evidence already available across the enterprise.

Instead of reviewing information that has been organized independently by claims, underwriting, actuarial, finance, and risk, the reserve committee begins with an integrated view of the emerging risk environment.

That distinction may appear subtle.

It is anything but.

In the original timeline, each function accurately described what it was observing.

Claims reported longer settlement cycles.

Underwriting described a gradually changing portfolio.

Actuarial presented reserve indications that remained within established ranges.

Finance evaluated capital and earnings implications.

Every presentation was accurate.

Every conclusion was professionally sound.

What the committee never saw was how those observations were beginning to reinforce one another.

Now imagine the same meeting supported by an AI-enabled decision intelligence capability.

Before the committee convenes, the system continuously evaluates information flowing across the enterprise—not to make reserve recommendations, but to identify relationships that deserve executive attention.

It examines claim notes, case reserve movements, settlement duration, litigation activity, jurisdictional trends, changes in policy limits, shifts in portfolio composition, external legal developments, and traditional actuarial analyses.

Its purpose is not to predict ultimate losses.

Its purpose is to answer a different question:

Are independently observed developments beginning to describe the same emerging enterprise risk?

Rather than producing another dashboard, the system highlights combinations of evidence that would otherwise remain separated by organizational boundaries.

Claims managers have independently observed increasing settlement duration within several commercial auto segments.

Underwriting has independently documented continued growth in higher-limit policies within many of those same segments.

External litigation data suggests increasing plaintiff success in overlapping jurisdictions.

Traditional actuarial indications remain within acceptable ranges, but recent development is gradually migrating toward the upper end of those ranges.

None of these observations is individually conclusive.

Together, however, they justify asking different questions before the next reserve decision.

Notice what has not changed.

The chief actuary still owns the actuarial analysis.

Claims leadership still evaluates claim behavior.

Underwriting still assesses the portfolio.

Finance still considers capital implications.

The reserve committee still debates.

Management still decides.

The board still exercises oversight.

AI has not replaced professional judgment.

It has strengthened the evidence supporting professional judgment.

Instead of asking,

"Do today's reserve indications remain reasonable?"

the committee begins asking,

"Does our historical development fully reflect what the rest of the organization is already beginning to observe?"

That is a fundamentally different conversation.

The committee is no longer evaluating isolated evidence. It is evaluating the emerging enterprise narrative that evidence collectively describes.

The Decision Changes Before the Outcome Does

The first visible change at Meridian is not a reserve adjustment.

It is the discussion preceding the reserve decision.

During the next quarterly review, actuarial indications continue supporting management's reserve position.

Historically, that would likely have concluded the discussion.

Instead, it becomes the starting point.

Claims leadership is asked whether the changing settlement patterns represent temporary operational variation or an emerging shift in litigation behavior.

Underwriting reviews whether the evolving portfolio characteristics are concentrated within specific industries, geographies, or coverage structures.

Actuarial evaluates additional scenarios while continuing to rely upon established reserving methods.

No one proposes a $500 million reserve increase.

Nor should they.

The available evidence still supports management's selected reserve position.

What changes is the institution's understanding of uncertainty.

Over subsequent quarters, as additional claim development enters the actuarial analyses, the findings no longer appear unexpected.

Management has already been investigating the underlying drivers.

Reserve strengthening still occurs.

Long-tail casualty business remains uncertain.

No analytical capability eliminates that uncertainty.

The difference is that reserve adjustments occur progressively as the organization's understanding evolves rather than emerging as a single material financial event.

Capital planning becomes more measured.

Investor communication becomes more predictable.

Management discussions become more forward-looking.

The financial impact remains. The surprise does not.

Beyond Reserving

Reserve development illustrates a broader principle that applies throughout P&C insurance.

Every consequential decision is made before uncertainty has been eliminated.

Underwriting decisions commit capital before future losses are known.

Claims decisions resolve complex situations before every fact has emerged.

Reinsurance decisions reshape retained risk before the next catastrophe occurs.

Reserve decisions recognize liabilities before ultimate claim outcomes become fully visible.

The common challenge is not technology.

It is decision making under uncertainty.

That is why the executive conversation around AI should begin to change.

Today's discussion often centers on models, copilots, agents, orchestration platforms, and automation.

Those capabilities matter.

They improve productivity.

They streamline workflows.

They reduce operating expense.

But those are implementation capabilities.

Enterprise value is created somewhere else.

It is created when institutions consistently make better consequential decisions.

That distinction changes how executives evaluate AI investments.

Instead of asking,

"How many AI capabilities have we deployed?"

they begin asking,

"Which consequential decisions have become measurably better because of them?"

That is ultimately the only business question that matters.

The Decision Before the Decision

Meridian's story is not fundamentally about reserving.

It is about institutional decision making.

The company did not experience a $500 million reserve strengthening because it lacked capable executives, disciplined actuarial methods, or sound governance.

It experienced one because individually reasonable observations remained institutionally disconnected until history had already confirmed what operations had begun to signal.

That distinction reaches well beyond reserving.

Every consequential underwriting decision reflects the institution's understanding of risk at a particular moment.

Every significant claims decision reflects its understanding of liability, customer impact, and financial exposure.

Every reinsurance decision reflects management's understanding of the portfolio before uncertainty has been resolved.

In each case, executives must commit capital before perfect information exists.

The quality of those decisions depends upon the quality of the evidence available before the commitment is made.

That is where AI has the opportunity to reshape P&C insurance.

Not by replacing executive judgment.

Not by automating accountability.

Not by predicting the future with perfect accuracy.

Its greatest contribution is enabling institutions to assemble, interpret, and challenge evidence earlier, allowing experienced executives to make better-informed consequential decisions while they still have the opportunity to influence the outcome.

For decades, reserve committees have begun with a familiar question:

"Based on the evidence before us today, what reserve should we establish?"

The AI era introduces an earlier and arguably more important question:

"Have we assembled every meaningful piece of evidence the institution already possesses before making one of its most consequential financial decisions?"

The institutions that outperform in the AI era will not necessarily be those that deploy the most AI.

They will be the ones that consistently assemble better evidence before making consequential decisions.

In the AI era, competitive advantage will belong less to the institutions that possess the most information than to those that assemble the best evidence before making consequential decisions.


Upendra Belhe

Profile picture for user UpendraBelhe

Upendra Belhe

Dr. Upendra Belhe is president of Belhe Analytics Advisory.

With over 30 years of experience in the P&C insurance sector, Dr. Belhe has held senior leadership roles in global insurance organizations. Dr. Belhe now collaborates with insurers, insurtech firms, and investors to develop and implement analytics strategies.

A Scandal the Insurance Industry Must Sidestep

The illegal use of cameras that read license plates is a scandal that won't go away any time soon — and could smear insurance, if we aren't careful.

Image
Traffic Cameras

As soon as I heard about Flock, the now-huge network of cameras that can automatically read license plates and instantly report their location to authorities, I wondered how long it would take before we read about police officers using the network to track girlfriends, wives and exes. 

It actually took longer than I thought, but here we are: The Washington Post reported a week ago that at least 50 officers throughout the U.S. have been accused of stalking by using Flock and similar systems. All sorts of national media have now followed the Post story, and we're in an environment of heightened sensibilities about surveillance and about how scary AI might turn out to be, so this story isn't going away any time soon. 

In the swamp that is today's social media, some conspiracy theorists are trying to drag in the insurance industry, saying it uses Flock cameras in nefarious ways. As the scandal unfolds, we need to not only make sure we avoid any unethical uses of camera networks but can respond quickly and convincingly to any online trolls alleging abuse.

Let's have a look. 

A nephew of mine had his car stolen off the street in Washington, DC, about a year and a half ago. The four young thieves then had the temerity to drive it right past him as he stood on the sidewalk reporting the theft to a police officer. Had Flock cameras been in place in the neighborhood, they could have let police track the car and quickly recover it. 

Instead, the car wound up being used in a crime that left the car riddled with bullets and involved a wounded girl being transported in the trunk. Even though the thieves then abandoned the car, the insurance process dragged on for weeks because the adjuster couldn't get access to the car. After all, it was in police custody as a crime scene. 

In theory, Flock will gradually prevent more and more thefts, because thieves will either be caught and incarcerated or will simply realize that car theft is a losing proposition. But the backlash to the Washington Post story shows that progress won't be simple or straightforward. 

Insurers, rightly, want to lean in on technology that will reduce thefts and, as a result, lower premiums for policyholders. But we all need to be careful. Surveillance cameras, whether those employed by Flock or those increasingly deployed on cars' dashboards, will be toxic for some time.

Cheers,

Paul

   

AI Can Transform Agency Financial Operations

AI-powered reconciliation transforms month-end closing from a periodic fire drill into continuous real-time financial visibility for agencies.

AI-Powered Reconciliation Transforms Agency Financial Operations

Somewhere in your agency right now, someone is probably matching carrier statements by hand, and by the time they finish, the numbers they're checking are already out of date.

That's direct bill reconciliation, one of the most manual, error-prone jobs in an agency's back office. Someone matches carrier statements against your management system line by line, hunting for the discrepancies that always show up: a payment posted to the wrong policy, a commission rate that doesn't match the schedule, a premium finance installment that's out of sync, a chargeback nobody flagged. It's tedious work, and for years it's simply been accepted as the cost of getting paid what you're owed. The book grows, the statement volume grows with it, and reconciliation stays exactly as manual as when the agency was half the size.

Here's the argument I'd make to any operations leader reading this: reconciliation isn't a back office chore anymore. It's one of the highest leverage places in your entire financial operation to put AI to work, and the shift isn't incremental. It's closer to what personal computing did to batch processing: things that used to be periodic events, the month end close, the quarterly true up, are starting to happen continuously instead. And when that happens, the knowledge of where the agency actually stands stops living in one person's spreadsheet and starts belonging to the agency itself, in real time.

What manual review actually misses

Ask anyone who's done reconciliation by hand what keeps them up at night, and it's rarely the errors they catch. It's the ones they don't. A commission underpayment on a single policy is a rounding error. The same pattern running quietly across a book of business for two quarters is a real number, and by the time someone notices, it's already happened.

AI-powered reconciliation catches a different category of error than manual review, not because it's more careful, but because it's built to look for patterns rather than line items. It flags a commission rate that's drifted from the schedule across dozens of policies at once, not just the one a reviewer happened to pull. It catches a payment landed against the wrong policy before it compounds into a billing dispute. And increasingly, it catches the kind of discrepancy that turns into an E&O claim: a missed cancellation, earned premium never reconciled, a client charged for coverage that had already lapsed. Manual review finds what someone thinks to look for. Automated reconciliation finds what's actually there.

Why this is the highest leverage place to automate

Agencies have no shortage of processes worth improving, and it's tempting to assume the highest value automation lives somewhere flashier, in underwriting or the sales motion. Reconciliation rarely makes that list, and that's exactly why it's underrated.

1. It touches every transaction, not just the exceptions. Automating a workflow that only runs when something goes wrong helps at the margins. Reconciliation runs on every payment, every commission, every policy in the book, so improving it once compounds across the entire book every month.

2. It's where money and data are supposed to agree, and usually don't. Every other financial operations problem, delayed close, unclear profitability, cash flow surprises, traces back to a reconciliation gap somewhere upstream. Fix the reconciliation and a lot of the downstream noise quiets down on its own. It also means the agency, not one person's manual process, becomes the one holding the accurate picture.

3. It's measurable in a way a lot of operational improvements aren't. You can point to the hours recovered, the discrepancies caught before they became client issues, the days shaved off the close. The close either happens faster and cleaner or it doesn't, and everyone in the agency can see which, making it one of the easier automation investments to justify.

What the recovered time actually looks like

The honest answer is that most agencies underestimate how much staff time direct bill reconciliation consumes until they see it recovered. It's not unusual for a single person to spend a meaningful share of every month matching statements by hand, time an agency pays for that produces no new business and serves no client directly. It just keeps the lights on.

The operations leaders getting this right aren't redeploying that time into more reconciliation, done faster. They're redeploying it into the work reconciliation was always supposed to make room for: catching a renewal about to lapse, following up on an account that looks profitable on paper but isn't, having the conversation with a producer about which accounts are actually worth the effort. The close stops being a monthly fire drill and starts being a byproduct of work already happening in real time.

The month end close was never the point

The month end close exists because reconciling by hand takes time, and batching the work into a monthly cycle was the only way to make it manageable. Take away the reason for the batch, and the batch stops making sense. That's the real shift underway: not that reconciliation gets faster, but that a monthly close as a distinct event starts to look like an artifact of how the work used to get done.

Agencies that treat this as a technology upgrade will get a faster close. Agencies that treat it as a chance to see their own numbers continuously, rather than waiting for someone to hand them a reconciled report two weeks after the fact, will get something more valuable: the agency itself, not whoever happens to be doing the matching that week, becomes the one who actually knows where things stand. That's worth more than the hours it saves.


Dave Stevens

Profile picture for user DaveStevens

Dave Stevens

David Stevens is the vice president of growth and CX for Financial Management Solutions at Applied Systems.

He spent four years at Google as a senior strategy and insights manager for the financial services sector. His prior payments experience also includes four years at Boston Consulting Group and three years at Goldman Sachs. 

Stevens holds an MBA from INSEAD.

Insurers' Real Barrier to Operational Efficiency

Insurers are discovering that outdated workflows, not legacy systems, are the real barrier to operational efficiency and sustainable growth.

Insurance Companies Rethink Operations Through Workflow Standardization

The insurance industry is facing a hard question: Is the way we work actually working? 

For many, the answer is no.

Disconnected workflows remain one of the biggest pain points across insurance operations. Quotes bounce between departments. Claims pile up in inboxes. Approvals disappear into email threads. Every manual handoff creates friction, slows resolution times, and chips away at customer and broker relationships. 

Guidewire, Duck Creek, and other core systems have made real strides, but the deeper issue is that integrations fall apart because the underlying workflows are outdated, inefficient, poorly documented, and full of exceptions that no one has mapped out.

The fix is not simply adding new people or platforms; it's streamlining and standardizing workflows first and then using that enhanced foundation as the platform for making informed workforce and technology decisions.

The Standardization Gap No One Talks About

Before any technology conversation can happen, carriers have to confront the problem at a more fundamental level by addressing inconsistent processes across their own organizations.

Most insurance organizations have established ways of doing things, and many of them work passably well. But having a "working" process and one that's optimized are two different matters. Seemingly, there's always room to tighten handoffs, eliminate process redundancies, and create consistency across teams without overhauling what already works. Nevertheless, even rock-solid workflows benefit from a fresh look–because what worked five years ago is not ready for today's work volume and complexity, or available technology options.

The Capgemini World Property and Casualty Insurance Report 2026 confirmed that even carriers that are heavily invested in AI are dependent on workflows built for human execution. For these businesses, the remaining challenge slowing process redesign for them lies in solving gaps in collaboration and data readiness. In plain terms: technology cannot fix a process. It can only accelerate it, for better or worse.

Standardization means thoroughly understanding and documenting how work actually moves through the organization, from submission intake to policy issuance to claims resolution, and then deciding how it should move. This is tedious, time-consuming work, but doing it pays huge dividends in the long run – and carriers that skip it and jump straight to automation consistently struggle to connect their technology investments to measurable returns.

Complexity Runs Far Deeper Than Most Carriers Admit

Handling non-standard or specialty risks exponentially increases the problem and raises the stakes.

For example, in 2024, excess and surplus lines markets surpassed $81 billion in written policies, a 12% jump over the previous year, and the continuation of a five-year trend of double-digit growth. This expansion brings volume, and with it, further exposure of manual processing's inherent vulnerabilities.

The compliance burden alone illustrates the problem clearly. According to the Wholesale and Specialty Insurance Association's 2025 Compliance Benchmarking Report, the most common data filing error – incorrectly applying tax rates – accounts for 38% of all rejections, followed by missed deadlines at 29%.

These numbers aren't the result of technology failures but instead stem from undocumented processes performed manually and varying from person to person – call it "vibe underwriting," if you will. Fixing the first problem, incorrect application of prevailing tax rates, does not require purchasing a workflow automation platform. It requires deliberately mapping and documenting every step of the process and eliminating or correcting the inconsistencies that have built up over time.

Undocumented workarounds and informal "tribal knowledge" are among the most common causes of errors in compliance-heavy workflows, and no software or LLM can solve this until the process itself is defined and accountability for consistency is assigned.

Standardization in specialty lines does not mean stripping out flexibility. It means building structured, auditable workflows wherever possible, so underwriters and brokers spend their time on judgment calls that actually require expertise, not on chasing paperwork or correcting errors that could have easily been avoided in the first place.

Where Technology Fits In

Artificial intelligence and automation are already delivering real results in production. According to McKinsey, leading P&C insurers are seeing 40% reductions in underwriting costs through automation and predictive analytics. In specialty lines, around 52% of insurers have deployed AI tools for faster underwriting, and 47% have improved processing accuracy and turnaround times using AI in their claims workflows.

In claims specifically, straight-through processing is becoming the standard outcome for routine losses, reducing cycle time and manual touchpoints across the lifecycle. With AI-automated data extraction, document review, compliance checks, and routing, adjusters are able to focus on complex, potentially costly losses needing human evaluation.

Low-code automation platforms are emerging as the practical path forward for managing high-variability submissions. These tools let business users build and update workflows without waiting on development resources, even as appetite, rating logic, and product lines constantly shift to meet dynamic markets. Cloud-native, API-connected platforms add another layer of flexibility, providing scalability to grow capacity during CAT events and other demand surges, and scale back during quieter periods without adjusting permanent headcount.

Standardized Processes Produce Better Staffing Decisions

This is the critical juncture for workflow efficiency and workforce strategy. You cannot right-size a team around a broken or inconsistent process.

If a claims department runs on manual data entry, inconsistent documentation standards, and siloed systems, staffing levels will reflect that dysfunction. Bring more hires into a fragmented workflow and you get a bigger, but still fragmented workflow. Standardize the process first, then determine how many people you need and what skills those roles actually require.

Successful automation implementations in insurance have shown up to a 50% reduction in employee workload alongside a 25% to 35% increase in team productivity. To yield maximum value from these gains requires an additional step of redeploying human experts, rather than simply reducing headcount. After all, AI is a tool, and you wouldn't replace a skilled plumber with a wrench.

When repetitive, high-volume tasks are automated, underwriters underwrite. Adjusters focus on complex losses. And every role across the insurance value chain is empowered to focus on building broker and agent relationships instead of spending time on tasks that can be automated with human oversight.

A growing number of carriers are also rethinking their workforce structure entirely, blending lean internal leadership teams with technology and specialized vendor partners. This model lets organizations scale up during peak periods without carrying excess fixed overhead year-round.

A Practical Starting Point

The path forward does not require transforming every process at once.

Start with a workflow audit to isolate the areas generating the most operational friction. That typically means FNOL intake, renewal workflows, compliance reporting, and submission intake.

Map what actually happens today, not the idealized version your business may have documented sometime in the past. And do not just talk to the people doing the work. Engage them fully in the mapping process itself. They are the subject matter experts, and this is an opportunity to recognize and create a competitive advantage from their contributions. The people closest to the work know where the friction is, where the workarounds live, and precisely where the process breaks down under pressure. Bringing them into the solution builds ownership, surfaces insights no audit tool will catch, and signals that you value your team for their expertise, and not just their output.

From there, define the standard. Map what the process should look like, step by step, with ownership at each stage clearly defined. Only then are you prepared to evaluate technology platforms, choose the tools that best integrate with existing systems and give managers real-time visibility into where work stands.

Perhaps most important: train your people on the new workflows in their entirety, and not the new software. Track results with concrete metrics (from set baselines): processing times, error rates, submission-to-bind cycle times, and compliance rejection rates. Adjust the new workflows as these data direct.

The Bottom Line

Process efficiency is not an IT initiative. It is a discipline combining business workforce strategy. Insurers that audit their workflows, standardize their operations, and then layer in the right technology will hire smarter, retain better, and serve clients and brokers faster.

The carriers gaining ground right now are not just doing more. They are doing more with less friction. That starts with knowing exactly where friction lives, and having the discipline to fix it before committing to your next platform.

Sources: Capgemini World Property and Casualty Insurance Report 2026; McKinsey and Company; Wholesale and Specialty Insurance Association 2025 Compliance Benchmarking Report; Datagrid Workflow Automation Analysis; Patra 2025 AI and Insurtech Trends Report


James Ballot

Profile picture for user JamesBallot

James Ballot

James P. Ballot is an insurance research, thought leadership, and content strategy leader with more than a decade of experience helping industry, regulatory, business, consumer, and higher education audiences understand and navigate complex industry transitions.

Agency Growth Numbers May Be Misleading You

Revenue growth masks a retention crisis costing agencies millions in enterprise value and leaving half their book vulnerable to churn.

Agency Growth Numbers May Be Misleading You

I spend a lot of time with agency principals at very different stages of growth. Some are running lean operations in a single market. Others are managing multi-state books across several product lines. One thing I hear consistently, almost regardless of scale, is some version of this sentence: "We had our best enrollment year ever." My next question is always the same: What did that actually do for the health of your business?

The insurance distribution industry has spent years treating enrollment volume as the definitive signal of agency health. For most of the last decade, the underlying economics cooperated. A prolonged hard market in property and casualty, combined with rising premiums across many health and medical product lines, created an environment where agency revenue continued to grow, even when relatively few leaders stopped to examine what was actually driving it.

Most agencies have not had a reason to look too closely at those numbers, and the market has not forced the question. That is starting to change.

The Hidden Math Behind the Headlines

The 2025 Best Practices Study found top-performing agencies posted organic growth rates consistently between 10.3% and 10.7%. Those are historic numbers. On the surface, they make a compelling case that chasing enrollment is the right strategy.

The problem is what sits underneath. Financial benchmarking data shows that for the average insurance brokerage, roughly seven percentage points of that double-digit growth figure are attributable to premium rate increases and exposure base expansion rather than new accounts or deeper relationships with existing clients. Strip out the inflationary tailwinds, and actual organic growth for the average firm lands somewhere between 2.7% and 3.2%.

That is a very different business than the one most agencies believe they are running. The industry has benefited from macroeconomic tailwinds that made revenue growth look like strategic growth; premium inflation was confused with operational excellence. When the market softens and premium inflation cools, the distance between those two numbers will become impossible to ignore.

The Retention Gap Nobody Talks About

Industry data puts the average retention rate for a single-policy client at roughly 77%. An agency whose book is built primarily on single-policy households is losing close to a quarter of those clients every year. The agency is operating an expensive treadmill, constantly spending on client acquisition just to hold revenue flat.

When an agency deepens the relationship to five or more policies per client, that retention rate climbs to approximately 85%. That increase in retention sounds modest, but the compounding math over a five-year horizon is anything but. A multi-policy client is nearly twice as likely to still be in the book five years from now, representing roughly a 60% improvement in long-term customer value driven entirely by product depth rather than acquisition.

What makes this even more striking is how pervasive the single-policy problem is. Research indicates that approximately half of the average firm's customer base holds only one policy. That means half of the average independent agency's book of business is both an untapped revenue opportunity and a serious flight risk, simultaneously.

Why the Industry Stays Stuck

In most agencies, the barrier to deeper product relationships is operational, not strategic. The independent distribution ecosystem was designed to maximize transactions, not deepened relationships. Every new product can introduce another appointment, enrollment workflow, commission schedule, and other points of friction. Eventually, the economics favor moving on to the next prospect rather than deepening the relationship with the current one.

Consider what it takes to build a comprehensive household relationship spanning a major medical plan, a hospital indemnity policy, and a term life product. An agent navigates three separate carrier portals, re-enters the same client data three times, manages three different quoting engines with three different underwriting workflows, and then attempts to reconcile three fundamentally incompatible commission structures on the back end. That extra 30 to 45 minutes per client, multiplied across an open enrollment season, is simply not compatible with high-volume production targets.

The compliance landscape compounds the challenge, particularly in the senior market. CMS Marketing and Communications Guidelines generally prohibit agents from using a Medicare sales appointment to cross-sell non-health products without a documented Scope of Appointment secured at least 48 hours in advance. As a result, an agent who identifies a legitimate cross-selling opportunity often cannot pursue it in that moment. Instead, the opportunity requires a separate appointment, additional documentation, and another workflow. Each additional step introduces friction, reducing the likelihood that a valuable client need is ultimately addressed.

None of these barriers are insurmountable. They are real, though, and they explain why agencies that understand the economics of product depth still struggle to execute against it. The gap between what agencies know they should do and what their infrastructure allows them to do is where retention gets lost.

What Capital Actually Sees When It Looks at Your Book

The insurance brokerage M&A market is as active as it has ever been, driven by private equity consolidators, national aggregators, and large brokers competing for quality books. In an M&A context, the word "quality" has a very specific meaning that has nothing to do with enrollment volume.

Institutional buyers are not purchasing a snapshot of today's revenue—they are purchasing the predictability and durability of tomorrow's cash flows. A client retention rate at or above 90% is considered the standard for premium, platform-grade valuations. Agencies that consistently hit that threshold command meaningfully higher multiples, often one to two turns of EBITDA above lower-retention books. When a buyer identifies a book built primarily on single-policy clients with historical churn running below 80% to 85%, the response is earnout structures that shift up to 40% of the total purchase price into contingent payments tied to retention benchmarks the selling agency is unlikely to meet.

This is the moment that tends to surprise founders who have spent years optimizing for enrollment. They assumed the number of clients in the book was what they were selling. Buyers see it differently. They are buying the quality of those relationships, and a book full of single-policy households is a book full of clients who are one price comparison away from leaving.

The Market is Moving Anyway

The argument for product depth has always been sound, but several structural shifts are making it urgent in a way it was not five years ago.

The traditional employer-sponsored group health model is fracturing. ICHRA adoption grew by 34% among large employers and up to 49% among mid-sized employers between 2024 and 2025, as businesses shifted from selecting group plans to providing employees with tax-free dollars to shop the individual market themselves. The expiration of enhanced ACA premium subsidies pushed average deductibles to nearly $3,800 in 2026, sending millions of individuals into the market with complex coverage needs and no institutional support to navigate them.

The senior market is moving in parallel. By 2030, all Baby Boomers will be age 65 or older, with roughly 10,000 Americans turning 65 every day. Original Medicare's well-documented gaps in dental, vision, hearing, and extended hospital stays create natural openings for the agent who takes the time to build a full household picture. Multi-product senior households are among the stickiest in the book. The relationship has real financial consequences for the client, which translates directly into retention.

Carriers are responding to these same market dynamics. The era of rewarding volume alone is steadily giving way to compensation structures that reward persistence and quality of business submitted. As acquisition costs rise and profitability comes under greater pressure, carriers are placing increasing value on agencies that consistently deliver durable books of business rather than simply higher application counts.

A Different Way to Measure Agency Health

The agencies I see creating the greatest long-term value are not necessarily the ones with the largest enrollment numbers. They are the ones that can answer two questions with confidence: how many of their clients hold more than one product and what their 12-month and 24-month retention rates look like by product line. Those metrics don't just describe yesterday's performance; they predict tomorrow's enterprise value.

The agencies leading this transition have recognized that relationship growth is an operational capability, not simply a sales initiative. They routinely identify single-policy households with unmet needs, but more importantly, they've invested in systems that make acting on those opportunities almost effortless. Quoting across product lines, managing compliance requirements, and reconciling commissions are integrated into a single workflow rather than a series of disconnected administrative tasks. When the operational friction is removed, producers stop abandoning cross-sells and the book composition changes.

The valuation gap between those two categories of agency will only widen as the hard market continues to ease and rate-driven premium inflation recedes. When that happens, growth has to come from somewhere real. The agencies that figured that out before they needed to will be in a fundamentally different position than the ones that did not.

Enrollment is no longer the end goal. It is the invitation, the beginning of the relationship. Agencies treating enrolled clients as a relationship will deepen those bonds rather than finish as a transaction. Years from now, they won't simply look back on this market as a period of strong enrollment. They'll recognize it as the period in which they built businesses that compound.

How to Reduce Residential Water Risk

Water damage severity depends less on what failed and more on where it occurred, how long it flowed undetected and how far it spread.

Managing Residential Water Risk Beyond Component Failure

A $12 supply line in an upstairs bathroom failed while the homeowner was away, causing more than $150,000 in damage. Water flowed unchecked for a couple of days, cascading down the stairs, damaging multiple levels of the home and ultimately flooding the basement. The homeowner returned from the trip days later and discovered the leak, but by then, the damage was done. It was far too late to prevent extensive damage and a costly restoration. What makes residential water claims so different from each other and why is understanding these distinctions so critical?

There are three factors that largely determine how severe a home water loss becomes: where the failure occurred, how long the water continued to flow and how much of the home was affected. The first question is usually straightforward: What failed? Was it a washing machine supply line, a toilet connection, a water heater, a leaking pipe joint or something else? Identifying the source is essential. It explains how the claim began and what needs to be repaired. It does not always explain why one loss is relatively contained while another results in extensive structural damage, months of restoration and significantly higher costs.

The second question is how long the water continued to flow. Every hour a leak goes undetected gives water more opportunity to spread through the home, increasing the amount of demolition, drying, reconstruction and replacement required. As labor, material and restoration costs rise, the difference between discovering a leak within minutes and discovering it days later becomes much more significant.

A real-world example helps demonstrate these dynamics. An insurance agent recommended that his client, who traveled often, install an automatic water shutoff valve. When the homeowner went to Italy on vacation, the ice maker in his freezer failed. Water flowed from the freezer onto the floor and throughout the home. After four days, the landscaper noticed water coming from the garage. Turns out, water flooded 70% of the first floor, and even worse, the leak was still flowing.

The final question is how much of the home was affected. When water is confined to a single room, it can often be contained relatively quickly. Water that travels through multiple levels of a home can damage drywall, flooring, cabinetry, insulation and personal belongings, turning a localized plumbing failure into a much larger restoration project.

One of the most consistent patterns in residential water losses is that some of the costliest claims begin on an upper floor. Second-story laundry rooms and upstairs plumbing fixture supply lines, particularly toilet supply lines, can produce severe losses because water rarely remains where the leak begins. It can travel through ceilings, walls and multiple levels of the home before the source is discovered and the flow is stopped. A supply line beneath a first-floor bathroom sink typically presents a very different exposure.

The opportunity to reduce claim severity remains significant. According to research from Parks Associates and Johnson Controls, 26% of U.S. households have experienced water leak damage, yet only 5% of single-family homeowners use a smart leak detection solution. The gap suggests many homeowners still discover leaks only after damage has occurred, rather than identifying problems early.

For carriers, this creates an opportunity to evaluate residential water risk through a broader lens. The type and age of a plumbing component remain relevant, but so do the location of the fixture, the layout of the home and the length of time a leak could continue before it's discovered. Those factors can help carriers identify where early detection and mitigation efforts may have the greatest effect on claim severity.

For agents, the opportunity to provide value extends beyond explaining coverage. Clients often think about water risk in terms of whether a loss will be covered. They spend far less time considering which parts of their home have the greatest potential to produce a severe loss and the broader disruption to their lives if a serious leak occurs.

Agents can help homeowners better understand water risk by looking beyond the plumbing component itself and focusing on the conditions that can turn a small leak into a major claim. Conversations with clients should include:

  • Identifying upper-floor plumbing fixtures, particularly second-story laundry rooms, bathrooms and refrigerators with ice makers, where leaks have the greatest potential to affect multiple levels of the home.
  • Discussing how long a home is left unoccupied and whether a leak could continue unnoticed for hours or days.
  • Encouraging homeowners to replace aging supply lines and other plumbing components before they fail.
  • Evaluating whether leak detection, automatic water shutoff technology and continuing monitoring may be appropriate, particularly for homes that are frequently unoccupied, vacation properties or homes with significant upstairs plumbing.

Carriers and agents play different roles, but they share the same objective: reducing avoidable losses. Helping homeowners understand where their greatest water exposures exist before a loss occurs can reduce claim severity and minimize disruption when a leak happens. Understanding what failed will always be an important part of evaluating a water claim. Understanding where it failed, how long it went unnoticed and how much of the home was affected provides a clearer picture of the exposure before a loss occurs. The plumbing component explains how a claim begins, but location and time often determine how expensive it becomes.

'Non-AI' Is the New Solution for Compliance

As insurers race to deploy AI, the real competitive edge lies in building non-AI governance systems that ensure accountability and regulatory defensibility.

Insurance Industry Needs Non-AI Compliance Infrastructure

The insurance industry has spent the last three years asking one question: where can we apply AI?

It's time to start asking the harder one: where shouldn't we?

We've seen what AI can do in underwriting, claims triage, fraud detection, and customer servicing. The efficiency gains are real. The speed is real. But as we embed AI deeper into consequential decisions — decisions that determine whether a claim gets paid, whether a risk gets written, whether a customer gets flagged — we're walking into a compliance gap that most organizations haven't fully reckoned with yet.

The definition of compliance is changing underneath us.

Traditionally, compliance in insurance was about people and processes following rules. Regulators asked: did you follow the procedure? Was the policy applied correctly? Can you show me the file?

Those questions still exist. But they're being joined by a new set:

  • Why did the AI make this decision?
  • What data trained it, and was that data appropriate?
  • Can the decision be explained to the customer who was denied?
  • Can it be audited three years from now when a regulator comes asking?
  • When something goes wrong, who is accountable — the model, the vendor, or the carrier?

These aren't hypothetical questions. They're already landing on legal and compliance desks across the industry. And most AI systems aren't built to answer them cleanly.

Here's the tension nobody talks about openly.

The more we automate decisions with AI, the more we need infrastructure that is not AI to govern those decisions.

Compliance requires consistency, predictability, and an evidence trail that holds up under scrutiny. In many cases, the right tool for that job is deterministic — rules engines, governance frameworks, workflow controls, immutable audit logs, human checkpoints at defined thresholds. These aren't legacy artifacts to be replaced. They're the architecture of accountability that AI, by its probabilistic nature, cannot fully provide on its own.

This isn't a limitation to be embarrassed about. It's an architectural reality to be designed around.

The Auditor Cannot Be the Accused.

You cannot use AI to audit AI.

Yet most organizations today are doing exactly that — monitoring AI models with more AI. If the original model has a flaw, the auditing model likely carries the same one. That's not oversight. That's a mirror.

We've already seen AI fabricate citations — confidently, cleanly, and completely wrong. Now imagine that happening in a claims denial or an underwriting decision, where the AI made the call and wrote the audit trail.

Regulators will ask for explainability reports that were produced independently — not one AI explaining another. That documentation needs to be deterministic, traceable, and human-readable. Built without AI. Full stop.

The next wave of RegTech won't be smarter AI. It will be AI governance.

While carriers and insurtechs race to deploy more models, there's an equally significant — and arguably less crowded — opportunity in building the layer that sits above those models. The technology that ensures every AI-driven decision is transparent, explainable, documented, and defensible. The systems that answer the regulator's question before the regulator asks it.

Some of this already exists in nascent form. Model risk management frameworks borrowed from banking are making their way into insurance. Explainability requirements are starting to appear in state regulations around algorithmic underwriting.

The organizations that get ahead of this won't be the ones with the most AI. They'll be the ones who built the governance layer early — and can demonstrate it when it matters.

A word to operators.

If you're running an insurance business and you've deployed AI in any customer-facing or claims-facing capacity, ask your team this week: if a regulator asked us to explain the last 1,000 decisions this model made, could we do it? And could we prove that explanation wasn't itself generated by another AI?

If the answer to either question is uncertain, that's your compliance gap — and it's growing faster than most people realize.

The competitive advantage in this next phase won't come from adding more AI. It will come from making the AI you already have trustworthy enough to defend.


Manjunath Krishna

Profile picture for user ManjunathKrishna

Manjunath Krishna

Manjunath Krishna is a property and casualty underwriting consultant at Accenture.

He has nearly a decade of experience supporting global underwriters and carriers. He holds CPCU, AU, AINS, and AIS designations.

The Private Equity Revolution in Insurance

Private equity is systematically acquiring the unregulated, fee-generating operations around insurance carriers, with broad implications.

 Private Equity Targets Insurance Operations Beyond Regulation

Insurance enjoys the protection of a regulatory moat. Capital requirements, reserve rules, licensing, and market oversight protect policyholders—and, by extension, legacy carriers' market positions.

But the moat is built around the balance sheet, not the operating model. It was never designed to protect expense ratios, organizational layers, underwriting workflows, claims operations, or administrative overhead.

Private equity is finding the seams—the fee-generating, capital-light nodes adjacent to the regulated core—and systematically buying them, then using AI to compress cost inside while the actual risk gets parked elsewhere. Here's where the action is happening.

1. MGA and program administration

MGAs underwrite and distribute without carrying capital—and, in excess and surplus lines, without the rate-filing straitjacket that binds admitted business. In the E&S market, no state Department of Insurance reviews an actuarial memo before an MGA changes pricing. That's not a technicality; it's the ballgame.

Roll-up money has been pouring into program administration at a pace that should alarm anyone who thought "we're regulated, we're safe." AI-driven underwriting here doesn't need to win a fight with a state commissioner—it just needs to be better and faster than the human it's replacing.

2. Claims, fraud, and subrogation

Loss costs and loss adjustment expense consume roughly 60–70 cents of every premium dollar. That's the single largest pool of spending in the industry, and it's almost entirely a process problem—not a regulatory one. A state insurance commissioner has opinions about your rate filing, not about whether your computer vision model estimates hail damage better than an adjuster with a clipboard, or whether an natural language processing (NLP) model flags subrogation opportunities your staff missed while chasing cycle-time bonuses.

This is the cleanest PE trade there is: buy or build the platform, automate the workflow, collect the toll. No rate filing required, no market conduct exam in the way. Claims processing today is like bank credit card processing 30 years ago—bespoke and fragmented. Look for rapid consolidation. Think: Visa and Mastercard. Blackstone, Apollo, and KKR certainly are.

3. Fronting

Fronting carriers exist so an MGA or insurtech can write business without holding a balance sheet. They rent a fronting carrier's paper and lay the risk off to a reinsurer (often also private capital). It's elegant financial engineering, and it's grown explosively because it lets everyone upstream of the actual risk-bearing get paid without ever touching the risk. Though regulators have started naming fronting arrangements specifically in their review of PE ownership structures, real action may be years away.

4. Agency roll-ups

This isn't new, and it isn't really disruption any more so much as consolidation. Acrisure, Hub, BroadStreet, AssuredPartners—PE has been buying up the independent agency channel for 15 years, riding a demographic wave of retirement-age owners with no succession plan and no appetite to fight for a better multiple. It works. It will keep working.

AI helps at the margins—better cross-sell, better retention scoring—but the trade was never about the tech. It was about the math, and the math has gotten more expensive as everyone's figured it out.

5. Data and risk analytics

Everybody wants to be Verisk. Almost nobody gets to be, because Verisk, CoreLogic, and LexisNexis Risk Solutions already occupy the high ground, and moats in data businesses are real. The greenfield here is narrower than the hype suggests—you'll see PE money chasing climate-risk modeling and computer-vision property inspection at the edges, not a wholesale takeover of the analytics layer.

Note: If your strategy deck has a slide about "becoming the data platform for the industry," ask whether you're actually building a moat or just donating R&D spending to a market that's already been won.

6. Reinsurance and alternative capital

Cat bonds, ILS, sidecars—genuinely useful capital efficiency tools, and genuinely attractive to institutional and PE money looking for returns uncorrelated to public markets. But this is also the layer drawing the most direct regulatory heat right now, because it's structurally identical to the arrangement that has state regulators and the NAIC nervous about affiliated reinsurance in the life and annuity world: related-party transactions, opaque asset-liability matching, risk-based capital that may not be pricing the actual risk. These are known trades, under active review.

7. The balance sheet itself

And here, finally, is the piece PE mostly leaves alone: the actual risk-bearing carrier. Full statutory capital requirements, rate filings, market conduct exams, risk-based capital rules that don't care whose name is on the equity. This is the one link where regulatory protection still functions as advertised, and it's not an accident that PE has mostly declined to fight it head-on. Instead, private capital rents access to this layer—through fronting, through reinsurance, through MGA fee arrangements—rather than trying to own and run it directly. The fortress holds. Under siege are the lands that sustain it.


Riv Arthur

Profile picture for user RivArthur

Riv Arthur

Riv Arthur is a business leader and technologist working in insurance, healthcare, and private equity.

The Missing Layer in Insurance AI: Why General-Purpose Models Fall Short

Generic AI can't handle insurance's complexity. Learn what separates data from intelligence and why it matters for compliance, accuracy, and trust.

Zywave

Eighty-four percent of large brokers with over $100 million in revenue now use generative AI. Claude, ChatGPT, and Copilot save producers hours every week on prospecting and reporting. But these tools are trained on public internet data, not insurance data.

That gap matters more in insurance than in almost any other industry. Regulation changes state by state. One wrong sentence in a submission or coverage recommendation can trigger an E&O event. And one in two agency records is missing critical fields, so generic AI often builds a confident answer on an incomplete picture.

The agencies pulling ahead are not the ones using AI first. They are the ones grounding AI in insurance-specific data. This whitepaper shows you what that gap costs and what to look for in a platform built to close it.

Come visit Zywave's website to learn:

  • Why Insurance Needs Specialized AI Context
  • The Hidden Cost of Incomplete Records
  • What Generic AI Gets Wrong About Insurance
  • The Difference Between Data and Intelligence
  • Four Questions to Ask Before You Trust an AI Platform

See the difference>>

 

Sponsored by Zywave


ITL Partner: Zywave

Profile picture for user Zywave

ITL Partner: Zywave

Zywave delivers AI-powered growth engines for the insurance industry, enabling carriers, MGAs, agencies, and brokers to grow profitably, strengthen risk assessment, enhance client relationships, and streamline operations. Its intelligent, AI-driven platform acts as a performance multiplier for more than 160,000 insurance professionals worldwide, across all major segments. By combining automation, data insights, and best practices, Zywave helps organizations stay competitive and efficient in today’s fast-changing risk environment—empowering them to adapt quickly, scale effectively, and achieve sustainable growth.

For more information, visit zywave.com.

Additional Resources

Zywave recognized as a Leader in The Forrester Wave™: Insurance Agency Management Systems, Q4 2025 

Access Report

Could You Handle Weeks Without Electricity?

A new study raises the prospect that a Carrington Event — a series of gigantic solar flare that would devastate the electric grid — could be even worse that previously feared. 

Image
Electricity

In 2012, the world avoided catastrophe by nine days. 

A solar storm emitted a plasma cloud of gigantic proportions that summer. Had it hit the Earth, it would have done trillions of dollars in damage, wiping out communications and GPS satellites while causing so many transformers to explode that it would have taken down much of the electric grid for weeks, months or even a year. But the plasma cloud passed through the spot in the Earth's orbit where it had been nine days earlier and did almost no damage. Nine days....

The Earth wasn't so fortunate in 1859, when what's now known as a Carrington Event — named after one of the astronomers who saw the solar eruption — wiped out the world's telegraph system. And scientists say such a massive flare will surely hit the Earth again, with its now exponentially more wired and, thus, vulnerable electrical and electronic infrastructure. The only questions are: when, and how devastating will the flare be?

Models suggest that the likelihood of a Carrington Event is only about 1% in any given year, but the effects would be so devastating that we need to at least be running scenarios to see how we can help clients be more resilient while also making sure insurers would survive such a catastrophe.

Let's have a look.

The Carrington Event itself isn't what a reporter would call new news. While the near miss in 2012 received remarkably little coverage, we ran an article in 2014 on the potential danger that holds up quite well, and have been periodically raising the issue since then. This article in 2021 goes deep into the implications for insurers, partly by looking at a solar storm in 1989 that, while far less severe than a Carrington Event, showed in miniature the sort of damage one might cause. A solar storm in 2024 — again, far less severe than a Carrington Event — prompted me to revisit the issue, and, for those looking for a truly deep dive into the history of solar storms and their implications, our colleagues at the International Insurance Society published this piece that same year. As a solar cycle peaked last year, making intense storms more likely, we ran another piece on the potential implications.

What is new is a recent study that found, according to the subhead of a Wired article: "Scientists have long assumed that there’s an upper limit to the intensity of the solar winds that reach Earth. New research suggests there’s not—and the implications are alarming."

The article says:

"For years, scientists have believed that there is a natural limit to the intensity with which Earth responds to the most extreme solar storms. According to that idea, when the solar wind reaches very high values, Earth's magnetic field stops reacting proportionally, and its response enters a kind of 'saturation.' However, this new study suggests that perhaps that limit never existed. What appeared to be a physical phenomenon could, in reality, be an illusion caused by the way the measurements are analyzed."

In other words, our magnetic field may not offer the protection we long thought it did. 

A Carrington Event is still seen as a truly rare occurrence — some models say one will hit Earth every 100 to 250 years, while I've seen models that say such an event is even rarer, coming just once a millennium. But the threat can't be dismissed as a black swan. When one hits, it won't be a total surprise. We know another Carrington Event — or even worse — will occur. So the threat is more of a grey swan, and there's no excuse for not planning at least at some level for when it hits. 

The effects of a massive solar event would be beyond anything we've seen in the modern day. This wouldn't just be an extended blackout. The shutdown of the grid could be so total that we'd lose access to the financial system, meaning no ATMs or credit cards. We would lose much of our communication network because of damage to satellites as well as to the cell towers and WiFi that need electricity. Water purification systems would be down. Farmers would lose access to many needed supplies, endangering our food supply. 

So insurers must help clients map out how they would keep their businesses operating or at least recover quickly — in the U.S., parts of the Atlantic Coast and upper Midwest seem to be most vulnerable, so backup capabilities located elsewhere might be wise. Generators, batteries (though many will be overwhelmed by a Carrington Event's electric surge), water supplies and so on should also be part of a plan, keeping in mind that something that may be routinely available now will be in excruciating demand if the electric grid goes down even for weeks, let alone months.

I think there are technology opportunities here, too. Solar power and batteries are improving so fast and dropping in price so quickly that they are providing unprecedented, decentralized power sources that could allow for considerable resilience even with the grid down for an extended stretch. I don't know just what would be involved in hardening them enough to withstand a massive electric shock, but doing so would greatly diminish the length of the damage from a Carrington-level event. The good news about such a solar storm is that we get about 18 hours of warning — the time between when astronomers spot a solar flare and when the storm hits the Earth — so there is time to switch power sources into bunker mode. 

Insurers obviously also have to protect themselves so they can reliably pay claims and help the world get back on its feet. Insurers should cover as much risk as possible but have to stay in business. So they need to be careful as they underwrite risks that could be beyond measure when the next Carrington Event hits.

I'd suggest also working with government to develop a recovery plan, though I'm not optimistic. I suspect that even a White House that believed in FEMA, as the current administration clearly does not, would be vague and noncommittal. So I suspect that coordination between insurers and governments will largely have to be arranged after the fact — and that the finger-pointing and legal action will be mind-bending.

I hope I don't come across as a boy crying "wolf," having repeatedly raised an alarm for a dozen years that has yet to be borne out. But remember: The fable ends with a wolf appearing and eating all the sheep.

Cheers,

Paul