Download

Is There a Silver Bullet on Reserving?

Advancements in technology today provide the tools and resources necessary for the step change in reserving capabilities that were not previously possible.

featured
Robot learning from data

The principal reserving challenge today is the opportunity cost of inefficiencies, primarily caused by the ineffectual use of human capital. This inefficiency makes it hard to redeploy more resources for continuous development and drains talent from reserving teams. The reporting process itself and supporting activities are far too onerous and consume too much human capital resource.

Given this strain on resources and the continuous compromises made due to deficiencies, why has there been so little innovation to date? And why do we think things are going to change?

Uniquely complex

The reporting process is uniquely challenging due to its very different objectives, constraints and timescales compared with typical modeling processes. The governance controls and audit requirements are much more onerous. This adds significantly to the difficulty of maintaining the process - let alone considering innovative techniques and new approaches.

For example, in some markets there is a requirement to print out information on the model parameters and the models used with enough detail for someone to independently recreate the results, which then becomes even more challenging when you start to add complexity to the models involved.

The reserving process itself is an optimization exercise. We recognize that there are a range of reasonable best estimates at any given valuation date; the challenge is in optimizing the selection of our best estimates to meet reserving objectives over time. This is a non-trivial process control problem, and real progress can only be made with a step change in how we think about and perform reserving.

There is, of course, more to reserving than the reporting process. But until we address the fundamental issues here, there is little opportunity for growth. There has been a common perception that reserving is a statutory requirement and nothing more, but reserving is a critical part of business intelligence.

What has changed

The difference now is that advancements in technology provide the tools and resources necessary for a step change in capabilities. For example, workflow management solutions enable the production of much more decision support material in a shorter time, while maintaining and improving governance and controls. And the leaders in this space reduce the need for ad hoc analysis, have more data-driven analysis to support decision making and free up time to embed further capabilities.

Tools provide a powerful solution for integrating software and systems in an end-to-end process, supporting a best-in-class approach to the architecture. This allows much more flexibility to use the best tool for a particular job in an end-to-end process.

The availability of cheap computing power is opening up possibilities to leverage data assets. For example: Robotic process automation is being used to produce more for less with increasing granularity; interpretation techniques are helping decision makers identify the pertinent information and prevent this being lost in large volumes of analytical output; and machine learning is being leveraged to unlock value from unstructured data.

The architecture possibilities enabled by the capability to integrate a diverse range of systems and applications into a coherent process has really expanded the possibilities, not just within reserving but across the organization. For this reason, real change in reserving practices appears feasible in the near future.

See also: How Machine Learning Halts Data Breaches

Impact of machine learning

The role of machine learning should be limited primarily as an enabler for targeted elements of the reserving solution, rather than as a one-stop remedy. Further, machine learning needs to be considered in the context of a wider road map to a future target operating model. Investing in the right development at the wrong time is probably the biggest pitfall when it comes to machine learning and reserving.

Besides operational efficiency and process control, the main benefit of machine learning for reserving is improved insights, and at its core it is designed to tackle the problem of optimization. We are effectively running an optimization to hit a moving target, with the objective of considering the cost of being wrong to provide meaningful outputs. This is very different from machine learning techniques where supervised learning methods are typically used with a well-defined response to simply minimize the error in fitting to historic data.

In pricing and risk modeling, for example, an insurer can assume that the risk differentials in their recent historic policy and claims data are representative of experience in the near future. This is a reasonable assumption in practice.

The difficulty in reserving is three-fold. First, the information necessary to inform the answer far in the future may not be in the historic data. So, building a predictive model of historic data is not going to provide the answer. Second, the estimates will change over time as the insurer generates more information on what the outcome will be. Finally, the reserving process and the way the insurer communicates results are going to be very different from today. This will require many more visualizations. Back testing diagnostics, for example, will be essential. This is why the road map is so important for placing developments in the right order to get where they need to be.

In terms of a single machine learning method that is going to magically solve all the problems in reserving, there is no silver bullet. Indeed, some developments will simply exacerbate existing problems if the right parts of the wider solution are not in place beforehand.

We are seeing a gradual move toward the use of machine learning in projection of ultimate losses. In considering the end goal for machine learning in reserving processes, there is a useful analogy in process control applications in robotics. Consider an exercise of programming a quadcopter to fly through a hoop that is thrown through the air at random. The quadcopter needs to monitor the data feed from sensors tracking the position of the quadcopter and the hoop to determine adjustments to the speed and direction the quadcopter should make.

How the hoop is thrown, how the wind blows during flight and numerous other variables mean that the quadcopter cannot know where that hoop will be when it eventually flies through it. The algorithms optimize a decision, given all information available at the time, to minimize the probability of missing the target at that point in time, and repeat this at regular intervals until the target is reached. In reserving, we cannot know what the ultimate loss for any given cohort will be, any more than the quadcopter can know where the hoop will be. But we can optimize the output from our reserving processes to acknowledge that we're on a journey and minimize the cost of being wrong at any given time.

See also: The Risks of AI and Machine Learning

Road map to unlock reserving capabilities

Insurers that have had the greatest success so far in improving their reserving capabilities are those that have made the most progress on the journey toward their defined future operating model. Strategic planning on developments and clear objectives for these exercises up front is a key differentiator for market leaders. There is a lot that can be done to realize the benefits of operational efficiency and process control before resorting to machine learning. It has its place, but it's not the complete solution.

Embedding a workflow management solution in the reserving processes, such as WTW’s Unify technology, is a critical enabler for the journey. The step change in automation capabilities will enable insurers to produce significantly more decision support material, while mitigating the problems of maintaining the governance, controls and audit, in addition to freeing resources for development activities. This tooling is essential to have in place to enable any real growth in data-driven analytics as well as supporting reserving without expenses spiraling out of control. Insurers will have the capabilities to readily integrate new tooling into the environment, with improvements in governance, control and audit. Robotic process automation will then complement these capabilities by producing increasingly sophisticated data-driven analysis and output in a timely manner for the same headcount.


Lewis Maddock

Profile picture for user LewisMaddock

Lewis Maddock

Lewis Maddock leads the nordic insurance consulting and technology business and global future of reserving intellectual property development at WTW.

How Smart COIs Can Revolutionize Insurance

Smart certificates of insurance eliminate risk, ensure compliance and reduce costs for every stakeholder in the process.

Person typing on a laptop

While commercial insurance is still a very paper-based industry, the issuance and tracking of certificates of insurance (COI) is ripe for innovation. A COI is a document that provides proof of a business's insurance coverage and can be shared with clients and vendors.

COIs are often shared as paper documents or email attachments, which means they can quickly become outdated. They must be checked, re-checked and verified constantly to make sure the information is still valid. This is a time-consuming and inefficient process.

That's where smart COIs come into play. A smart COI is a living, breathing document that contains policies available for real-time monitoring. It uses dynamic data to ensure businesses always have continuous, compliant insurance coverage. Smart COIs are created by agents and remain current as a result of direct connections, via application programming interface (API), with agency management systems. This connection allows for seamless, real-time data sharing.

Thus, COIs move from being static, paper documents, providing a number of benefits for both businesses and insurance agents.

Businesses know their suppliers' current coverage at all times via continuous feeds from their agents' systems, thus reducing risk. This provides several crucial new benefits. For example, businesses can trigger action when suppliers are non-compliant by denying access to systems or buildings, stopping a payment or canceling an order. Businesses can receive notifications when suppliers' insurance coverage lapses, is canceled or is reduced below required limits.

Businesses using smart COIs to share coverage with clients makes them more attractive to do business with. Their clients know that the organization is up to date in its coverage and can check on any particulars in the policy at any time. There is also less manual, paper-based work for internal employees, which leads to greater operational efficiency.

For an insurance agent or broker, smart COIs make their lives much easier and allow them to work more efficiently. Agents know that, if any situation arises, they have the most accurate data available on the COI. They don't have to spend time digging through paperwork or checking and double checking policy information. They can quickly respond to requests and do so digitally, without any cumbersome paperwork. Smart COIs also provide agents with real-time alerts that let them know when their clients may need more insurance coverage and how much.

From a risk management perspective, the current COI process without a smart COI is flawed at the foundation. Time and money go into the review of static COIs, and they are only accurate for 24 hours at most. Is one day of compliance even worth all the headache? The process needs to be transformed, and smart COIs have proven to be the answer.

See also: COI Is a 4-Letter Word; Tech Is the Solution

We often compare smart COIs to smart home security systems. The traditional COI simply renders point-in-time information, like taking a photo of your front porch. It tells you if in that exact moment there was someone at your door. Within seconds, that photo is out of date. Smart COIs, like smart home security systems, can use monitoring to show you who was at the door and when they were there and can track their history and alert you or a third party.

McKinsey says, "For a long time, the traditional insurance business model has proved to be remarkably resilient. But it too is beginning to feel the digital effect. It is changing how products and services are delivered, and increasingly it will change the nature of those products and services and even the business model itself. We firmly believe that opportunities abound for incumbent insurance companies in this new world."

Insurance is not often thought of as an overly innovative industry. Every aspect of the insurance process can't be transformed overnight, but there are areas where digital innovation can immediately begin to provide value. Smart COIs are one such area. They eliminate risk, ensure compliance and reduce costs for every stakeholder in the COI process.


Peter Teresi

Profile picture for user PeterTeresi

Peter Teresi

Peter Teresi is the co-founder and CEO of Certificial.

Prior to founding Certificial, Teresi served as the CEO of ACORD Solutions Group. He shaped the overall strategy of ASG and oversaw the design of new solutions to operationalize ACORD standards and enable a digital marketplace. During his nearly 20 years with ACORD, he held several other positions, including senior vice president of solutions, chief technology officer and vice president of standards and technology.

Teresi's entire career has been dedicated to bringing innovative technology to the insurance industry.

Cost-of-Living Crisis and Civil Unrest

Social unrest won't abate any time soon, given the after-shocks of COVID, the looming cost-of-living crisis and the ideological rifts that divide societies around the world.

Woman wearing a mask sitting on a train and looking out the window

During the COVID pandemic, demonstrations against restrictions and mandates have taken place regularly across the world. While they may have been in response to a series of unprecedented events, the protests played out in a context of growing civil unrest globally. Political polarization increased in the years following the global financial crisis of 2008, and according to the Global Peace Index, demonstrations, strikes and riots surged by 244% between 2011 and 2019. 

The results are inevitably disruptive. Earlier this year, unrest in Paris and in Wellington, New Zealand, saw convoys of vehicles create disruption in protest at government coronavirus restrictions. The protests were inspired by events in Canada, where a "freedom convoy" had brought the capital, Ottawa, to a standstill.

Economic and insured losses from previous protests have been significant. In 2018, the "yellow vest" movement in France rallied to protest fuel prices and economic inequality, with French retailers losing $1.1 billion in revenue in just a few weeks. A year later in Chile, large-scale demonstrations were sparked by an increase in subway fares, leading to insured losses of $3 billion. In the U.S., the 2020 protests over the death of George Floyd in police custody are estimated to have resulted in over $2 billion insured losses, while the South African riots of July 2021 caused damage totaling $1.7 billion.

Protests set to increase around the world

According to the Verisk Civil Unrest Index Projections, 75 countries will likely see an increase in protests by late 2022. The unifying and galvanizing effect of social media on such protests is not a particularly recent phenomenon, but during the COVID crisis it combined with other potentially inflammatory factors to create a perfect storm of discontent.

The largely unregulated nature of social media allowed misinformation to spread unchecked, providing a platform for conspiracy theorists and an outlet for resentments. These grievances were centered on three main areas: anti-vaccination sentiment and civil liberties; mistrust in government and concern about government overreach; and economic hardship.

Although the political right were most likely to resent restrictions, the protests blurred traditional allegiances and united people across the economic and political spectrum behind specific topics. Geography was less of a barrier, too. Those with like-minded views were able to share views more easily and mobilize in greater numbers more quickly and effectively. In a world where trust in both government and media has fallen sharply, misinformation could take hold and partisan grievances be intensified and exploited.

See also: COVID-19 Trio Tops Global Business Risks

Platforms could be used with impunity

The 2022 Edelman Trust Barometer found concern over fake news being used as a weapon had risen to 76% among its global respondents. With confidence in traditional sources of information and leadership so undermined, social media gave a platform to powerful individuals who could use it with impunity and without legal consequences. When political leaders such as Donald Trump in the U.S. or Jair Bolsonaro of Brazil appeared to downplay the severity of the pandemic, social media warriors were emboldened. If they could attract the right audience, almost anyone with a social media account could become a politician, journalist or opinion leader. The pandemic disproportionately hit certain industries and ethnic groups harder than others, so where there already existed a sense of injustice, there also opened up the possibility for radicalization.

The COVID crisis shone a light on divided societies and increased the gulfs that already existed in some populations. A lack of social-media regulation in stable democracies led to misinformation that threatened to destabilize social norms and cohesion, while hostile states arguably used the lack of regulation in these democracies to gain ground with their own destabilizing messages.

Risk management and insurance

The circumstances surrounding the COVID crisis may have been unique, but social media’s influence is likely to play a role in fueling civil unrest for the foreseeable future. Unrest carries a risk of material damage to buildings and assets, business interruption, denial of access or loss of attraction. Targets or casualties could include government buildings, transport infrastructure, supply chains, retail premises, foreign-owned enterprises, petrol stations, distribution centers for critical goods and tourism or hospitality businesses.

Companies should review their insurance policies in the event of increasing local activity and update their business contingency plans if necessary, taking into account their supply chain vulnerabilities. Property policies may cover political claims in some cases, but insurers offer specialist coverage to mitigate the impact of strikes, riots and civil commotion (SRCC).

Civil unrest increasingly represents a more critical exposure for companies than terrorism. The nature of the threat is evolving, as some democracies become unstable and certain autocracies crack down on dissenters. Unrest can occur simultaneously in multiple locations, as social media now facilitates the rapid mobilization of protestors. This means large retail chains, for example, could suffer multiple losses in one event.

Where we currently stand, I do not expect incidences of social unrest to abate any time soon, given the after-shocks of COVID-19, the looming cost-of-living crisis and the ideological rifts that continue to divide societies around the world. At AGCS, we’re seeing rising interest from risk managers in specialist cover for political violence, as some traditional property and casualty insurers have stepped back from the exposures associated with SRCC insurance. The standalone market is also having a rethink on war-like perils, as well as the coverage extensions that were offered freely only a few months ago.

Life Insurance’s Awkward Necessity – Death

Discomfort with the certainty of death leaves life insurers questioning where they can meet customers. The answer lies where almost all other industries have ventured – online.

Two men sitting a table with papers in front of them

Let’s get it out of the way early. Everyone will die. It is not an “if”; it is a when. And because it is a guarantee that no one likes to entertain, consumers shy away from even thinking about the topic of life insurance, let alone going through the process that puts them face-to-face with statistics and data surrounding their own mortality. 

Longstanding Hurdles

That resistance is actually deeply intertwined in who we are as people. In a study from Bar Ilan University in Israel, Yair Dor-Ziderman found that “the brain does not accept that death is related to us.” Humans have a primal mechanism that tells us the information is not reliable when it links oneself to death, so the brain doesn’t believe it to be real. Because the process of purchasing life insurance is linked to the realization that a consumer will in fact die for the policy to be enacted, it’s human nature to want to avoid it. 

Even if consumers can get over the mortality hurdle, they have traditionally been met with an intermediated, agent-assisted, purchase journey that can last up to two months. If they are using an agent, they are left to disclose personal health information to either someone they have known a long time and consider a family friend or a stranger; both instances can cause great discomfort. This leaves life insurers questioning where they can meet these customers. The answer lies where almost all other industries have ventured – online. 

See also: A New Boom for Life Insurance?

Digital Solutions

At Legal & General America (LGA), the team has taken an aggressive growth trajectory to bring the digital experience to the American term life insurance market. Since launching the digital experience, LGA has found significant success and customer adoption of the new process. With the new model, they found that 90% of those who start the application complete it; that figure was previously 40% when using a non-digital, paper application. The ability to complete some of the application, put it down and come back to it allows users the freedom to not feel pressured to carve out a block of time to sit with an agent or a handwritten application; they can get back to what matters most, the people they’re looking to protect when they’re gone. Twenty percent of applicants receive an instant decision, which means they have a life insurance policy as soon as they complete the application. More than half of applicants are approved without the need for a medical exam. An online experience shifts the agent into a support role, because anyone with access to the internet can use it.

Rather than sit across a table or on the phone with an agent and 25 pages of rigid questions, consumers can open the application where and when they want to fill it out. Not surprisingly, LGA has found that, with its digital application, most applicants are filling out their details later in the evening. And they can reply to only the questions that are relevant to their own medical history and experience. For example, a 50-year-old with pre-existing conditions may have 25 questions while that same 50-year-old with no pre-existing conditions may only have 20 because the dynamic digital application means there is no need to ask questions about medical conditions you don’t have! 

Keeping Consumers, and Agents, in Mind 

When designing the platform for consumers, it is vital to keep the user in mind. Again, thinking about death can be overwhelming, and that can be compounded by looking at a page or screen with five or 10 detailed health questions demanding a response. However, when the application is broken into one question per page, it makes life insurance even more accessible through technology. This platform also allows for increased transparency. The old model required the consumer to ask the agent for the status of their application. The agent then asked the insurer administrator, who had to check with underwriting and then relay all that information back through that same chain. By leaning on transparency, the agent can simply log in and see the status of where the application stands – a more financially leaning pizza delivery tracker of sorts.

All this technology does not remove the agent, either; it simply frees them from the arduous administrative tasks to let them get back to what they love doing – connecting with consumers and helping them find the best solutions for them and their families. Even if they’re the one driving the online application, they can reach more families in their day to increase their own goals. 

Shaving more than 20 days off the non-digital model, the self-guided consumer application can be completed in under 20 minutes, with a life insurance policy in-hand in 25 days on average (if an instant decision could not be made). Investing in technology to make insurance approachable and accessible provides the freedom for all users to find the journey that works best for them. The world continues to spin on a digital axis with the support and backbone of humanity and human connection. When we can harness the power of both, without having to give the heavy topic of death more brain real estate than it truly requires, everyone is granted the freedom to live a brighter life and leave behind the same opportunity for their loved ones


Raju Seetharaman

Profile picture for user RajuSeetharaman

Raju Seetharaman

Raju Seetharaman is senior vice president, IT and transformation, of Legal & General America's insurance division, which includes operating companies Banner Life Insurance and William Penn Life Insurance of New York.

He is responsible for IT and transformation strategy, IT operations and change management, with the mission to combine business strategy with cutting-edge IT expertise to deliver efficient, effective solutions.

Seetharaman is an engineering graduate.

The Future of Electronic Payments

While many hail cryptocurrency as a revolution, a free, secure system developed in India may hold greater promise for exchanging money digitally. 

Image
an ipad with min shopping cart, credit card, credit card machine and piggy bank on it. There is a yellow background.

When I first came across the concept of "reverse innovation" a decade-plus ago, I was intrigued. Those of us living in fully developed economies tend to assume that innovation flows from our shores to countries in the developing world. But not always. When it comes to cost, in particular, many innovations happen in developing economies and, if the rest of us are paying attention, become available to the developed economies.

Vivek Wadhwa, a very smart fellow I've gotten to know over the years, and two co-authors have written a provocative piece in Fortune that argues that, while most of us have been distracted by the battle that cryptocurrency advocates have been waging against so-called fiat currencies (issued by governments) and the high cost of the traditional banking system, India may have come with an answer.

Vivek, not known for pulling his punches, and his co-authors write in Fortune that "Bitcoin long ago died as a digital currency, becoming nothing more than an empty speculative asset with its value most recently plunging from $60,000 to less than $20,000. Meanwhile, as [its] hypesters now promote a mystical Internet world called Web3, India is racing ahead and implementing what the crypto crowd had promised—with its United Payment Services (UPI)."

The Reserve Bank of India and the Indian Banks’ Association set up UPI six years ago and make payments free to build traffic. The system will eventually carry fees, but, according to the article, "only a tiny fraction of what merchants and consumers pay to move money on private payment systems such as those run by Mastercard and Visa."

UPI has grown to the point that 150 million users transact $100 billion of business through it each month. That's a tiny fraction of the trillions of dollars that pass through the international financial system daily but still shows that UPI can scale. A French company just announced that it will introduce UPI into the European Union, the article says, and "merchants in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam, Cambodia and Bhutan accept UPI payments.... The National Payments Corporation of India is now negotiating with Australia to integrate UPI with Australia’s own nascent fast payment rail, called New Payments Platform.... More than 300 banks and dozens of payment applications and startups—including subsidiaries of many major U.S. tech giants—[are] joining UPI."

It seems to me that UPI may have legs, because it is built from the ground up with the kind of security that is only now being grafted onto traditional payment systems and because it uses an open protocol, making it easy for companies to hook into and build services on top of. 

The article says: "By facilitating exactly what [cryptocurrency] was supposed to do—cutting out intermediaries and inducing greater competition—UPI could force a global acceleration of innovation in payment technology."

 

I'm not suggesting anyone rush out and convert all payments to UPI any time soon. Even if UPI becomes a wild success, it will be years before UPI becomes a must-have, at least outside India. But UPI is still worth a look for insurers. It shows that we don't need to wait for some sort of crypto revolution to happen (or not happen) to make great progress on electronic payments -- cutting costs and saving time for customers as well as insurers by taking so much paperwork out of the process. UPI also lays out a road map for how insurers can start to make progress.

As the article concludes: "Shiny new technologies such as [crypto] may be cool, but less flashy efforts driving open standards and interoperability are delivering a real revolution that flies under the radar of the tech gurus in England's Shoreditch and America's Silicon Valley."

Cheers,

Paul

 

Will Web3 Reinvent Insurance?

At Oliver Wyman, we have been helping clients understand Web3 and what it means for insurers, and guiding strategic moves — near-term and longer-term — around this evolving ecosystem. Our latest research finds the Web3 economy is currently under-insured and has huge potential for future growth. Here, we share a practical guide for insurance executives to help separate hype from reality, including Web3 insurance opportunities and risk considerations.

will web3 reinvent insurance?

What is Web3? What are the opportunities and risks for insurers? At Oliver Wyman, we've released a practical guide on Web3 to separate hype from reality, and help leaders navigate through this rapidly evolving space. Our latest research finds the Web3 economy is currently under-insured and has huge potential for future growth. We explore opportunities for insuring the Web3 economy, reaching new customers, and reinventing business models — that may radically change what an insurer can look like.

Read Now

 

Sponsored by ITL Partner: Oliver Wyman


ITL Partner: Oliver Wyman

Profile picture for user OliverWyman

ITL Partner: Oliver Wyman

About Oliver Wyman


Oliver Wyman is a global leader in management consulting. With offices in more than 70 cities across 30 countries, Oliver Wyman combines deep industry knowledge with specialized expertise in strategy, operations, risk management, and organization transformation. The firm has more than 5,700 professionals around the world who work with clients to optimize their business, improve their operations and risk profile, and accelerate their organizational performance to seize the most attractive opportunities. Oliver Wyman is a business of Marsh McLennan [NYSE: MMC].  

For more information, visit www.oliverwyman.com. Follow Oliver Wyman on LinkedIn and Twitter @OliverWyman.


Featured Insights 

Thriving in the Age of Acceleration

10 actions to Reinvent Insurance in 2023

With change as the only constant, what should CEOs prioritize in 2023? Oliver Wyman shares 10 actions CEOs should take to Reinvent Insurance and fuel growth in 2023.

Read More


Think CustomerFirst

Oliver Wyman’s Reinventing Insurance Series

How do insurers unlock new growth and market share? Oliver Wyman’s Reinventing Insurance series shares perspectives on taking a CustomerFirst approach — to drive new business growth with investments deeply tied to customers’ needs.

Read More


Re-envision Client Value

Oliver Wyman’s Reset4Value Series

Customer values are changing, and today there are immense opportunities for CEOs and financial services leaders to fuel growth and drive new revenue streams. Here, we focus on how the pandemic has accelerated change and offer an approach for firms to re-envision client value. We bring in industry trends, analysis, and insights from the front lines, and offer three ways for your firm to Reset4Value and get started.

Read More


Power Up Performance Transformation

Drive the next wave of growth

Oliver Wyman’s latest in the Reset4Value series helps insurers transform cost and ignite growth. Here, we share how leaders can leverage their firm’s culture strengths, enhance the capabilities that matter most, and unlock scarce investment dollars to fund them appropriately.

Read More

Featured Podcasts 

Reinventing Insurance Podcast

Episode: Modernizing your tech stack

On this episode we talk tech and insurance. Paul Ricard is joined by Alex Lyall and Justin Kahn, leaders of Oliver Wyman's Fulcrum technology. We take a deep dive into industry trends, greenfield considerations, and the key ingredients to a successful legacy transformation. Plus, how incumbents can leverage their strengths and get unstuck when it comes to building a modern tech stack. And learn how Fulcrum's proprietary tooling and intelligence is helping life insurers solve their most pressing and complex infrastructure challenges.

Listen Now

Time to Start Issuing Metaverse Policies?

This might be the time to start exploring how the metaverse might find its way into insurance policies in the near future.

AI with binary showing the multiverse

Why travel somewhere when you can just pop on a virtual reality headset and be immersed in that world instead? That is the promise of the so-called “metaverse.”

Some companies may be overselling the technology and the role the metaverse promises to play in people’s day-to-day lives, but, even still, it is a good bet that at least some of our lives in the
future will be lived in that virtual space.

Some early adapters are already embracing it, and some businesses are hedging their bets by spending millions of real-world dollars to put in claims on what might eventually turn out to be valuable virtual real estate.

With those initial moves into the virtual world, the list of potentially insurable risks in the metaverse can be long. Hackers could take control of a user’s account, or lock a business owner out of their virtual storefront.

Businesses that can’t conduct transactions may come looking for protection from business interruption insurance policies, or potentially more.

Anyone keeping the private information of another person could have some exposure if that data gets breached.

And anything valuable is at risk of being stolen by someone trying to make a quick buck at their expense.

So, the short answer is that with money comes risk, and with risk comes insurance. While there aren’t any real metaverse insurance policies to refer to today, this might be the time to start exploring how the metaverse might find its way into insurance policies in the near future.

Business insurance in a virtual world

The first reality businesses are going to have to confront when they begin prospecting for metaverse-based property is that there isn’t just one metaverse. Many companies are looking to make their space the default virtual space. That means businesses need to buy into many metaverse platforms, some of which will inevitably go the ways of Friendster or Myspace.

Most business insurance policies don’t say a word about the virtual space, but a good argument could be made that “all risk” or “comprehensive” policies may need to start thinking about underwriting and claims coming from the meta space.

The first policy most companies buy is a business owner’s policy, or a BoP. These don’t tend to protect property the businesses’ property, though, and instead protect against liability.

So, if a company ends up inadvertently spreading a virus that takes down the cyber town, a BoP may be where they turn for coverage.

A BoP might also help if the company’s software caused physical damage to a user – say a company developed a game for the metaverse that started causing users to have seizures or migraines, or to trip over a coffee table, or fall out of a chair. The liability portion of the BoP may step in here. Policyholders probably would be hard-pressed to get their insurers to cover “mental only” losses, though, so, if someone says the software causes stress or anxiety, a successful claim may be harder to prove.

Business property insurance does promise to keep the owner’s stuff safe, but now the conversation quickly needs to turn on what is the definition of “property.”

From an insurer’s point of view, property damage tends to be considered to be physical damage to tangible things. Many policies exclude “electronic data” as tangible property, so some specific language or riders may need to be developed if a business owner wants to be protected from a hacker vandalizing a virtual storefront.

Typical polices do tend to include some language about cybercrimes, especially data breaches and ransomware attacks, but it is unclear if that is enough to protect the millions being spent in the virtual worlds.

See also: Beware the Metaverse

Personal risk

Individual users also need to be thinking about their insurance needs once they slip into the virtual world.

Much like with the business owner’s policy, the question of who would be on the hook if an individual’s private property is damaged in the metaverse would come down to what that person’s homeowner’s insurance policy says. Many homeowner’s policies specifically exclude digital assets, and others require specific riders to get coverage.

So, what would happen if a hacker gained access to an avatar and drained its inventory of all the NFTs the user so lovingly collected? Theft is usually covered by homeowner’s policies, but whether that protection follows the policyholder into the metaverse is unclear.

One place where homeowner’s policies would likely shine is in defamation. Because homeowner’s – and business owner’s polices, too, for that matter – don’t tend to specify where the defamation or advertising injury has to happen to be covered. So, if someone gets sued because they flamed another person in the metaverse and their comments crossed the line into libel, their real-world policies should still stand in to protect them.

Conclusion

Deciding who needs coverage in the metaverse in many ways comes down to who is at risk and who holds the liability.

Is it the businesses operating on the metaverse platform at risk, or does the platform itself hold the liability? Or is the whole metaverse going to be “user beware”?

What do the terms of service say? And are they enforceable in a court of law in every jurisdiction?

Borders also need to be thought of. In insurance terms, that is the coverage territory, which U.S.-based policies tend to specify as the U.S., Puerto Rico and Canada, but how would these policies handle a server housed in Seychelles, or Belize or China?

Many of these details are going to have to be hammered out by underwriters, legislators, in corporate board rooms, in courtrooms or in some combination.

Emerging technologies bring out the prognosticator in everyone. And one of the most certain things is that most people will get it wrong in the early days, but, if there is value, it will find a way to bubble to the top.

And if it is valuable, it is worth insuring.

The original version of this article ran at insurancequotes.com. 

How Open Source Can Combat Climate Change

More open sources of data and common standards for models will enhance our understanding of the potential implications of climate transition decisions.

Penguins on iceberg

I’ve spent my entire career trying to develop and improve catastrophe and weather-related models and analytics. So, from a personal perspective, if there’s one thought among many others that I would like to get across, it’s a sense of the opportunity to enhance decisions linked to climate risk mitigation and resilience if we use our ever-improving scientific understanding and modeling capabilities wisely.

And I think there’s one thing that holds an important key to unlock that opportunity – openness. When I talk about openness, I don’t mean a willingness from governments and others to set out and stick to commitments to reduce emissions – although that would be rather helpful, of course. I’m referring to two things, actually.

More open-access data

The first being more open-access data. Open-access and curated data can support and encourage improved climate-based risk assessment and decision-making. The public and private sectors should be working together to increase the world’s resilience to current and future climate risk.

It’s essential that those in the climate analytics community come together, wherever they are, to promote the win-win opportunity that comes from the development of publicly accessible, open and curated core data and risk models. The goal should be a global, consistent source of “real” assets data, such as locations of industrial plants and energy transmission facilities, or natural resources, which can be used for both public good and to enable organizations such as WTW to augment the data for commercial applications using proprietary data and intellectual property.

Examples of good work already being done in this area, which should pave the way for more of the same, include the Spatial Finance Initiative’s global asset GeoAsset Data Project, the Insurance Development Forum’s Global Risk Modeling Alliance and the Nasdaq-designed and now publicly curated Open Exposure Database.

As a further indicator of the benefits that this public/private approach can offer, WTW has been working in partnership with the National University of Singapore, flood modelers JBA and open-source public data of real assets to improve understanding of future flood risks in South East Asia.

See also: Time to Move Climate Risk Center-Stage

Common standards for common understanding

My second take on the need for openness, which is linked to the need for better and open models and data, relates to model and data standards and metrics. Right now, there are lots of companies and organizations producing climate hazard models. And as climate science is so fast-moving, they are all making lots of different choices and assumptions for those models. If a multinational business is trying to work out an international climate transition strategy, it almost certainly won’t be comparing the same things from region to region. But the last thing we want in attempting to unify action across the globe to reduce emissions is a VHS versus Betamax situation.

What’s needed is agreement on an open-standards framework for the capture of key climate-conditioned modeling parameters. These should support consistent representation and use of forward-looking models developed by independent modeling organizations to give confidence in the comparison and integration of models across various hazards and regions.

Similar things have been achieved before, but they need someone to take the lead. Nasdaq’s experts did it in relation to the catastrophe model exposure data, OED, which is now used as a common format for a wide range of models from different vendors. And that’s why we’re teaming up with Nasdaq and other organizations to propose a reference framework of standards for climate conditions catastrophe models. 

We’re all in this together

Openness is a subset of collaboration. And if I hear one word used more than any other to describe what’s needed to combat climate change, it’s collaboration.

Let’s make sure that it’s applied in practice to open source data assets and standards that can give us all better and more consistent knowledge about the impact of different future climate transition scenarios.

Don't Be Fooled by the Tech Downturn

Venture capitalist Marc Andreessen warns that big companies think they can now relax but should double down on tech-driven innovation efforts. 

Image
a dark black background with a blue sphere made of connecting dots and lines representing technology and cyber

I'll be quick this week. I'm in Pittsburgh visiting my 92-year-old mother, who finally gave up tennis a few years ago but still takes no prisoners in her duplicate bridge games, and we have puzzles to do. 

But I wanted to pass along a meaty interview that McKinsey did recently with prominent venture capitalist Marc Andreessen. He offers a timely warning for insurers that might be tempted to see the tumbling of tech stocks, including those of insurtechs, as an excuse to slow innovation efforts.

Andreessen says: "The minute tech stocks get hit, a lot of big companies basically say, 'Oh, thank God, we don’t have to take this stuff as seriously.' This happened in a huge way after 2000. One of the reasons why Amazon took off is because all of the traditional retailers, after 2000, said, 'Oh, thank God, we don’t have to worry about this e-commerce thing anymore.' And they just left the field. Borders famously outsourced their online business to Amazon, which, in retrospect, was maybe not the best idea."

His advice: Double down while your competition is relaxing. 

In the interview with McKinsey, Andreessen also makes an intriguing argument for turning the normal innovation process upside-down. Rather than hiring technologists to assist with innovation, he argues, companies should put the technologists in charge of an opportunity and let them run with it.

He makes a more extreme form of that argument that no big insurance company will buy: that the best technologist should run the entire company. He cites Tesla as a success story in an industry where GM, Ford and others are run by traditional managers.

But I think companies should at least experiment with the more limited form of Andreessen's argument. I've written before that technology resources need to move out of the IT department and into the various business operations that they serve, and it makes sense to then see how much technology can drive strategy in those operations. Corporations have increasingly been deploying digital strategies for 25 years now, and it only makes sense that departments, operating sort as fractals of the parent, would be able to see how far they can push the envelope now that IT resources have matured to the point that they don't have to be so centralized. 

Andreessen also lays out three areas that he describes as the ABCs of innovation opportunities. I'm fully on board with the A, artificial intelligence, and the B, biotech -- we've published at length on all the opportunities being created by AI, and genomics is actually improving much faster even than Moore's law would suggest. Those gains will have massive impacts on healthcare and life expectancy and, thus, on insurers. I'm only partly on board with the C, crypto, because, while I see blockchain solving lots of real-world problems, I've never quite figured out what cryptocurrency is supposed to do for me. Yes, fees are still much too high on money that flows through the international financial system, but I don't see how crypto is going to solve that problem, especially when crypto mining already consumes more electricity than all of Argentina. 

Andreessen argues grandly that crypto and Web3 are "building out the other half of the internet" and notes the huge amount of engineering talent that is flowing into the field, but I'm with the McKinsey editor who responds: "A lot of really, really smart people were moving into web technologies around 1998 and 1999. And a lot of those technologies wound up going nowhere."

You can decide for yourself who's right; you've heard my side, and he goes on at length about his.

If nothing else, Andreessen is an original thinker, going back to his days developing the first commercial internet browser in the mid-1990s, extending through his famous essay a decade ago about how software is eating the world and continuing with his efforts to position his VC firm, Andreessen Horowitz, as the marketing engine for their portfolio, moving beyond the traditional role as just financial backer. (I identified Andreessen as clearly brilliant early on, when an interview with him in perhaps 1996 included a sidebar with his five favorite books of all time and listed my look at IBM's travails, "Big Blues," as one of them. I came quite close to convincing the executive team to let me do a fly-on-the-wall book on Netscape, the company built around Andreessen's browser, before the CEO decided he didn't have the time.)

And I'll acknowledge that our relative net worths, rounded to the nearest hundred million, are: Andreessen, $1.6 billion; me, $0.

Cheers,

Paul

P.S. Fun fact: Despite his massive net worth, Andreessen didn't amass the biggest fortune in his family. And the person would bested him did so in the most traditional of ways: through real estate development. That person was his father-in-law, John Arrillaga, who went to Stanford in the 1950s and saw the potential for all the farmland in the area. He bought as much as he could as fast as he could and became one of the biggest landlords in Silicon Valley. He had a fortune listed at $2.5 billion when he died early this year, even after having given away hundreds of millions of dollars, notably to his alma mater. 

ITL FOCUS July: Talent Gap

ITL FOCUS is a monthly initiative featuring topics related to innovation in risk management and insurance.

This month, we're focusing on Talent Gap

ITL FOCUS is a monthly initiative featuring topics related to innovation in risk management and insurance.

This month, we're focusing on Talent Gap

 
 

FROM THE EDITOR 

When my younger daughter was a freshman at Yale, I was encouraged that her intro to economics class included a fairly long section on the economics of insurance -- essentially, an exercise in determining how much people valued the peace of mind they get from having a policy in place. Insurance certainly never came up in any of the economics classes I took way back when, and I took the material as a good sign: A top-tier college was making insurance intriguing for smart, young students.

 

Alas, I couldn't interest my daughter in the insurance industry. And there seems to be a lot of that indifference going around, based on the persistent concerns in the industry about the talent gap. 

 

Jenn Knight, co-founder and chief technology officer at AgentSync, offers some intriguing thoughts on a way forward in this month's interview. 

 

While I've heard lots of people describe insurance's noble purpose as a draw for talent, Jenn framed the issue as well as I've seen anyone do:

 

"If your house catches on fire, the first call is to the fire department, and the next call is to your insurance agent. Like the fire department, insurance is an emergency service that helps you get on with your life."

 

Jenn also explains at length what technology can do to at least remove the annoyances that keep talent from choosing insurance or that may make the industry lose them shortly after they sign on. In particular, she describes how technology can help agencies onboard agents faster and remove much of the load of minutiae that they now have to learn.

 

It's too late for my daughter. She went to law school and is now practicing in DC. But it's not too late for an awful lot of other talented kids. Let's go get them.

 

Cheers,

Paul 

 

 
 
 
Jenn Knight, co-founder and chief technology officer of AgentSync, lays out an approach that seems like it should be obvious but that somehow isn't. Her approach to attracting and retaining talent? Stop driving it away. 
She explains how companies can use technology to onboard talent faster and more efficiently and remove much of the drudgery from their work that can make them seek greener pastures in other industries. 

"In the insurance space, agents are going to be attracted to things that help them go out and have those personal relationships and really drive their business forward. How do we as an industry laser focus on improvement of administration work? Talented people demand that they are supported and enabled with effective and usable technology, and are not being dragged through all kinds of hoops." 

-Jenn Knight
Read the Full Interview
 

READ MORE

 

There Is No 'I' in 'TEAM'

But there is an 'i' in 'WIN.' Let’s
talk talent. Let’s talk football.

Read More

Acting on Diversity, Equity
and Inclusion

Employers who recognize the
importance of these issues will
capture talent and inspire the
workforce. Those who ignore it are
at risk.

Read More

What Are Insurers’ Top
Talent Objectives?

While talent challenges are nothing
new to insurers, new research
shows they are prioritizing talent strategies more than ever in the
post-pandemic era.

Read More

Guide: Making Producer Management a Growth Opportunity

Sponsored by AgentSync 

Download the Guide to Making
Insurance Producer Management a Growth Opportunity. It’s free and will
give you tips to eliminate complexity, expense, and risk by modernizing processes and systems, delighting
your people and partners, while
powering your insurance
company’s growth goals. 

Read More

The Future of Work

As employees start to return to
work after two years of mostly
working remotely, smart employers
are rethinking just about all aspects
of how work is done to get the best
of both the home and office worlds.

Read More

Outsourcing to the Sixth
Century

A story about monks and nuns doing electronic piecework suggests just
how far the gig economy can
stretch, if we think about the
issues creatively enough. 

Read More

 
 

FEATURED THOUGHT LEADERS

 
 

This Month Sponsored by: AgentSync 

AgentSync powers rapid growth for insurance carriers, agencies, and MGAs by offering modern tools for producer management. With its customer-centric design, seamless APIs, and automation, AgentSync's products reduce friction, increase efficiency, and maintain compliance, ultimately helping to improve the broker onboarding, contracting, licensing, and compliance processes. 

Founded in 2018 by Niranjan "Niji" Sabharwal and Jenn Knight, and headquartered in Denver, CO, AgentSync has been recognized as one of Denver’s Best Places to Work, as a Forbes Magazine Cloud 100 Rising Star, an Insurtech Insights Future 50 winner, and is ranked 88 in Forbes – America’s 500 Best Startup Employers 2022.

View all ITL FOCUS topics
 

Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.