Download

The Growing Threat of Cyber Attacks

In the face of all the grim predictions, remember that myriad tools can protect businesses against and mitigate the impact of cyber-related events.

cyber

As cyber criminals’ methods become increasingly sophisticated and their ability to launch attacks with seeming impunity continues, the repercussions for businesses, from the smallest to the Fortune 50, cannot be overstated. Potential targets are not limited to those that have personally identifiable information, personal health information or customer credit card data. In fact, some of the largest cyberattacks over the last two years have not involved the mining of such information at all. Rather, these attacks have either shut down or materially interrupted vital infrastructure, health systems, financial companies and all means of the manufacturing process, including construction, supply chains, distribution and sales.  

The FBI and Department of Homeland Security’s Feb. 17 warning of anticipated cyberattacks against U.S. (and Ukrainian) governmental and commercial networks in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which has now come to pass, highlights the dire circumstances being faced worldwide. Any business that interacts with or depends on the internet for its existence is a target, regardless of size.  

The impacts of such attacks take any number of forms, including: malware, including ransomware (which disables the ability to access IT systems until a ransom is paid); business interruption (income lost because of the inability to access systems); data restoration (reconstructing “lost” company and customer data); social engineering/phishing (loss of money based on the impersonation of a colleague, client or vendor); regulatory fines and penalties; liability to third parties if their information is compromised; and reputational harm. Estimates for losses for these events runs anywhere from $20 billion in ransomware costs alone for 2021 up to trillions of dollars being spent by 2025 to respond to and fight all manner of these attacks.

The Tools to Mitigate Cyber-Related Events 

Despite (or perhaps because of) these grim predictions, it is vitally important to remember that myriad tools can protect businesses against and mitigate the impact of cyber-related events.

Internal Controls

Due to the sheer number of attacks, cybersecurity experts have been able to identify many of the key vulnerabilities that criminals manipulate to gain entry into computer systems, and how to fix them. That list includes:

  • Multi-factor authentication tools to safely access internal computer systems
  • Robust desktop security protocols, including: virtual private networks, data encryption, complex passwords, firewalls and restricted access to admin rights
  • Active management of systems and configurations
  • A continuous hunt for network intrusions and third-party exposure threats
  • Immediate updating and upgrading of software
  • Development and use of a system recovery plan, including regular testing of backups for data integrity and restorability and preparation and annual testing of incident response/ business continuity plan

As this list indicates, system and information security is the key to avoiding (or at least mitigating) cyber-related risks. Whether through dedicated in-house personnel, engaging with an outsourced cybersecurity firm or having those groups work in tandem, companies can see many vulnerabilities and address them as an enterprise-wide project. While there is no “one size fits all” approach, and it is a true investment of both capital and manpower, companies must at least do an initial assessment of their cybersecurity policies and procedures. The biggest mistake companies make is believing that they are not a target because of their industry, their size, their revenue or their footprint. Everyone is a target, so these issues simply cannot be ignored.  

See also: Tips for the Hybrid Work World

Insurance

Another key mitigation tool is purchasing a cyber insurance policy, which allows businesses to transfer risks associated with cyber-related security breaches to first-party reimbursement (e.g., loss to the company itself) and third-party indemnity (e.g., liability claims against the company and regulatory proceedings). A robust cyber policy is structured around helping the company recover and handling the costs that are associated with an attack.

The purchase of insurance will often also act as a catalyst for implementing the tools and processes described above. Cyber insurance carriers are increasingly demanding that many of the items described above be in place or be on track to be put in place before they will even issue a quote outlining the costs and coverages potentially available. Carriers will assess: possible risks pertaining to the company; the strength of cybersecurity controls; and compliance with legal and industry standards. Companies must be transparent during this application and review process, so issues do not arise in the event of a claim.  

No insurance policy is worth the premium paid if it is not available in the event of a loss. As ransomware emerges as one of the more profound financial and operational interruptions affecting businesses and insurance companies worldwide, it’s imperative to seek an independent risk advisor who can serve as a sounding board and help navigate through the various and sudden risks facing enterprises globally.


Kimberly Patlis Walsh

Profile picture for user KimberlyWalsh

Kimberly Patlis Walsh

Kimberly Patlis Walsh is president and managing director of Corporate Risk Solutions.

She brings over 20 years of insurance underwriting, program structuring and multinational client risk advisory representation to her CRS engagements. Prior to joining CRS in 2003, Patlis Walsh served as SVP of AIG's mergers and acquisitions group, structuring insurance and financial solutions to a variety of corporations (publicly traded and privately held) to limit or transfer liabilities within corporate transactions, recapitalizations, bankruptcies and other M&A situations. While at AIG for over 11 years, she held various positions within various underwriting groups to non-traditional risk transfer/finance insurance to address known risks as well as serving as relationship point to a number of global investment clients. Previously, Patlis Walsh was in investor relations at a NYSE-listed apparel company and a paralegal at Fried, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson.


Michael Gallagher

Profile picture for user MichaelGallagher

Michael Gallagher

Michael F. Gallagher is senior vice president and general counsel at Corporate Risk Solutions.

Gallagher is an attorney and adviser with extensive, hands-on experience solving complex legal problems and enhancing business outcomes for clients throughout the U.S. and internationally. At CRS, Gallagher is involved in all aspects of the business, as well as engagements with clients, including analysis of clients' risk and indemnity exposures, insurance contract negotiations and advice on claims advocacy and enterprise risk issues.

Prior to joining CRS, Gallagher was a member of Katten Muchin Rosenman's insurance and risk management practice group for 18 years. Gallagher has handled complex insurance coverage and defense litigation matters, representing both policyholders and insurance companies, involving, among other areas, directors' and officers' liability, errors and omissions claims, intellectual property claims, fidelity and crime coverage, property and casualty claims and business and contingent business interruption claims. He also conducted internal investigations on behalf of clients' boards of directors and independent audit committees, as well as represented several international corporations in complex commercial arbitrations in matters arising in the Middle East, South America and Europe. Prior to joining Katten, Gallagher was an assistant district attorney for Westchester County, New York.

He holds a juris doctorate degree from Fordham University School of Law and a bachelor of arts degree from Fordham University.

Red Alert for Cyber Attacks

Russian hackers may retaliate against companies and countries that have aided Ukraine -- and the rest of us may get caught up in the wash. 

Image
a hoodie by a computer with binary script behind it and the words cyber attack

With Vladimir Putin denied the quick victory he hoped to achieve with his invasion of Ukraine, the Russian military is reevaluating its strategy -- which may now include cyber attacks that could broaden far beyond those that the Russians have been waging against Ukraine for months.

Obviously, no one knows for sure what Putin will do next. But Russia has a history of hacking, even against major powers. According to the Mueller report, Russian government hackers stole emails from the Democratic National Committee in 2016 as part of Putin's effort to help elect Donald Trump president. In 2021, a gang of Russian hackers launched a ransomware attack that shut down the Colonial Pipeline and cut off its supplies of gasoline in the U.S. East and Southeast. And Putin has said that even nuclear weapons are on the table if other countries intervene in his war on Ukraine, while listing 13 countries that have been "unfriendly" to Russia, so it's hard to imagine that cyber warfare isn't somewhere in the cards.

Insurers would do well to prepare themselves and their clients for the possibility of cyber attacks, to the fullest extent possible.

Electric grids have been shown to be especially vulnerable to being shut down by cyber attacks. The same is true for pipelines, such as Colonial, and other infrastructure. But the range of targets could be broad. Perhaps banks would be hit because the U.S. and European allies have imposed sanctions that have hobbled the Russian financial system. Perhaps hospitals would be targeted, too, just to impose some misery on countries that have stood up to Russia. Perhaps oil and gas companies, which have announced that they're pulling out of ventures in Russia, would be hit.

Something doesn't even have to be a direct target to potentially be hurt. Cyber attacks that shut down the electric grid, a major oil or gas pipeline, banks or hospitals could have severe ripple effects if they are broad or lengthy. This is my big fear for the insurance industry: I see no reason why insurers should be a primary target, but they will have to deal with any effects from business shutdowns, homes without heat and electricity, etc.

And cyberattacks have a way of hitting more targets than intended. My time covering such attacks goes all the way back to 1988, when a graduate student at Cornell wrote a "worm" that was designed to show vulnerabilities in a commonly used operating system and, because of an error in his coding, pretty much shut the internet down for days. And Russian government hackers aren't immune to such errors: In 2017, they unleashed the NotPetya worm that attacked Ukraine and did billions of dollars of damage -- including to Rosneft, the Russian oil company. 

As this article in the Wall Street Journal explains in detail, "Russia, in particular, has a history of unleashing cyber weapons that wreak havoc far beyond the computers and networks that were their original targets." And the reckless collateral damage could be even more extensive if Russia turns vigilantes loose on foreign governments and countries.

The article says that "cybersecurity experts are broadly surprised that Russia’s cyberattacks haven’t up to this point been more effective or devastating," and I dearly hope the low impact continues. But I worry about what will happen if Putin becomes desperate.

Let's hope this column looks silly in a couple of months, a wimpy false alarm. But, as I've seen many people note since this Russian craziness began, "Hope is not a strategy."

Stay safe.

Paul

 

 

 

 

Cyber Risk and Insurance in 2022

The cyber risk landscape has always been in motion, but the rate of change has accelerated during the pandemic and will likely remain volatile.

cyber

The pandemic has created new cyber vulnerabilities, heightened existing risk factors and accelerated the pace at which cybercriminals wreaked havoc on even the most secure systems. Undoubtedly, 2022 will see more of the same. 

Many large organizations responded to heightened cyber threats by ramping up their security budgets and deploying state-of-the art security technology. Small and mid-size businesses with less sophistication and smaller budgets are not defenseless, however. By staying aware of the changing risk landscape and implementing basic countermeasures, business owners and their IT professionals can deter cyber attacks and be better prepared to respond if they nonetheless happen. Organizations with a strong focus on cybersecurity also can make a case for more favorable terms from the cyber insurance market, which has seen rates increase and coverage shrink as claims accelerated over the past several years.

A quick tour of the cyber risk and insurance landscape in 2021

Cybercriminals had a banner year in 2021. According to Check Point Research, cyberattacks increased 50% in 2021 as compared with 2020, with each organization facing an average of 925 attacks per week.

With large numbers of employees working from home and using their personal devices for business purposes, corporate networks were left vulnerable to the often-inadequate security practices of individual employees. According to security company CrowdStrike in their 2021 Global Treat Report, this created a “feeding frenzy for cyber predators spurred on by the windfall of easy access to sensitive data and networks.”

Phishing and ransomware were far and away the primary attack vectors, affecting both large and small businesses. Phishing attacks increased in number and sophistication as “fear, concern and curiosity surrounding COVID-19 provided the perfect cover for a record-setting increase in social engineering attacks,” according to CrowdStrike. The Human Hacking report published by SlashNext Threat Labs data shows phishing attacks rose 51% in 2021 as compared with 2020. 

Successful phishing campaigns often resulted in ransomware attacks. Ransomware is not a new cybersecurity threat, but it is one that cybercriminals have learned to use with far more devastating effect in recent years. Since the beginning of the pandemic, ransomware claims have increased four-fold. The average ransom demand increased about 900% as cybercriminals employed increasingly sophisticated and damaging tactics, techniques and procedures. One notable 2021 ransomware attack targeting pipeline operator Colonial Pipeline resulted in $4.4 million being paid to a Russian cyber gang. 

In addition to the cost of paying the criminals, ransomware attacks also can cause downtime and business interruption losses. A 2020 attack on the University of Vermont Medical Center, for example, cost the hospital an estimated $50 million, mostly from lost revenue. 

Many ransomware attacks are directed at supply chains. A single supply chain attack can hit numerous organizations, providing cybercriminals the ability to use a single intrusion to attack multiple targets. Cybercriminals often use smaller, more vulnerable companies in a supply chain to gain access to larger, better-defended companies.

One of the most widespread and sophisticated supply chain attacks targeted SolarWinds, a major information technology firm. SolarWinds unknowingly sent software updates to its customers including U.S. government agencies such as the Department of Homeland Security, the State Department, the Department of Energy, the National Nuclear Security Administration and the Treasury that was tainted with code that left them vulnerable to hackers. More than 18,000 organizations—both public and private—were affected.

Increased losses sparked higher prices and more restrictive underwriting criteria in the cyber insurance market. Prior to 2020, rates were held in check by competition as the cyber insurance market grew and matured. Additionally, underwriting results were generally favorable, which attracted capacity to the line of business. 

See also: ITL FOCUS: Cyber

Loss ratios began to deteriorate in 2018 and 2019. In 2020, according to S&P Global, they shot up 25 points, or more than 72%, due substantially to a surge in ransomware events. In response, insurance premiums began to creep up in 2019 and increased more sharply in 2020 and 2021. “Market pricing” disappeared, with quotes for the same piece of business varying wildly from underwriter to underwriter, all of whom are underwriting from the same submission.

In addition to raising premiums, underwriters tightened criteria and increased their scrutiny of network security protocols. Carriers also reduced capacity on individual risks and on their aggregate portfolio exposures.

Cyber risk management and insurance in 2022 and beyond

Many of the risk and insurance trends seen in 2021 are likely to continue through 2022. Network security at many organizations will continue to be under stress as employees continue to work from home, often using their own devices and security software. More than 50% of corporate executives surveyed by PwC for its 2022 Global Digital Trust Insights Survey expect a sharp increase in cyber incidents in 2022.

Determined cybercriminals can defeat even the most advanced network security. However, business owners and their IT professionals can take simple and effective steps to deter criminals. Hackers look for poorly secured systems and often pass by better-guarded networks. According to PwC, “many of the breaches we’re seeing are still preventable with sound cyber practices and strong controls.”

Foremost to effective cybersecurity is an organization-wide security culture. Cybersecurity is not strictly an IT function—people, more than technology, make an organization secure. Cybersecurity culture must be driven from the C-suite and reinforced by communication, training and incentives for good cyber hygiene. Awareness and education help instill good cyber safety habits and reinforce what employees should and shouldn’t click on, download or explore.

From a technology perspective, multi-factor authentication on all business-critical systems is an effective, inexpensive way to boost security. In addition to the conventional username and password, other identifying information is required such as a personal identification number (PIN) or a specific keystroke pattern. Some experts are advocating password-less authentication—dispensing with passwords altogether in favor of alternatives such as requiring users to input a code that is either emailed or sent via text message. 

Ransomware attacks—which are low-risk but high-return for cybercriminals—will continue to be one of the most common types of malicious cyber events. Organizations need to increasingly focus on backing up data and keeping those backups as secure as possible. Good cyber hygiene may deter attacks, but, once an attack occurs, secure backups are essential. 

An information security architecture known as Zero Trust has grown in popularity in recent years. A Zero Trust approach uses security protocols and technologies designed to limit an attacker’s ability to move within or between systems to reach critical parts of the network. Commercial Zero Trust security solutions may be out of reach of many smaller companies and government entities. But even a very small organization can achieve satisfactory results by implementing policies and procedures to assure that only people who need certain data or applications—whether employees, contractors or vendors—can access them. 

Cyber underwriters are increasingly focused on security issues, so organizations that can demonstrate attention to security best practices may fare better when shopping for cyber insurance. Cyber brokers are rarely network security experts themselves, but the best brokers are immersed in the cyber risk environment and are attuned to underwriter cybersecurity preferences and demands. They thoroughly understand their clients' cyber exposures and security posture and can find the best fit in a market where coverage terms and prices can vary wildly from underwriter to underwriter and even from day to day.

See also: Quest for Reliable Cyber Security

The “next normal” of cyber risk and insurance

The future cyber risk landscape will be shaped by post-pandemic social, political, economic and technological forces and informed by the lessons learned by both attackers and defenders during the present unsettled environment. The cyber risk landscape has always been in motion, but the rate of change has accelerated during the pandemic and will likely remain volatile even as the COVID-19 threat recedes.

The cyber insurance market will continue to respond to a changing threat landscape, but also will be shaped by business, economic and regulatory forces. It also will respond to the internal demands of a still-young line of business as it matures. Working with knowledgeable and creative brokers who can navigate a chaotic marketplace, even comparatively small organizations will be able to deploy a risk management and insurance strategy that will contribute to growth and stability in a changed—and changing—environment.

A Low-Tech Approach to Work Automation

Work automation is not about technology. It’s about process. A process that is best led by the line of business or function head and not corporate IT.

software

Two million people work in the U.S. insurance industry. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 300,000 of these workers will retire in the next three years, and 50% will retire by the end of this decade. 

As it is, there are 200,000 unfilled positions in insurance, and, according to a recent study from the Hartford, only 4% of Millennials and Generation Z are considering insurance as a career option. They want work that’s more creative, expressive, meaningful.     

Throw in COVID and the highest inflation rate the U.S. has experienced in over 40 years and we’re already seeing signs of what this means as last week American Family Insurance, based in modestly priced Madison, WI, raised their minimum wage to $23 an hour. Though we wholeheartedly support claim processors and contact center workers earning fifty grand a year, we also know insurance is a price-driven business, and those same workers will likely scour the market for the best-priced coverage they can find in response to relentless advertising from GEICO, Progressive and State Farm urging them to click and save.   

The time to start automating knowledge work at scale is now. Results are not immediate. The transition to automation - and an automation-first mindset and culture - takes time. 

Work automation is not about technology. It’s about process. A process that is best led by the line of business (LOB) or function head and not corporate IT. The LOB/function knows their business best, they’re closest to the action as things change, and they’ll want to "own" the automation as it rolls out. Thinking of bots as human workers, you want them rolling up to the LOB/function and not the IT organization. Corporate IT does play a vital role in work automation, but it’s a support role, like finance.  

See also: Insurers Turn to Automation

We use a five-step process that’s remarkably low-tech. The five steps are as follows:

  1. Map workflows from standard operating procedure (SOP) documents. The only tools required are MS Excel and Vizio (which you already own).
  2. Identify and quantify specific activities, work products and work product volumes. In the world of knowledge work, there are only 20 possible activities in five categories: receive, review, perform, attend, send. You’ll also want to capture the IT systems required per activity. 
  3. Eliminate waste and wasteful variability exposed by step 2. Workers tend to add their own spin to rote tasks, claiming their approach is unique. Force-fitting work processes into the 20 activities in step 2 exposes this fallacy. You want hard standardization of the best practices within each process/capability.
  4. Identify automation use cases and pilots. Look vertically within specific capabilities, e.g., claims, for enthusiastic stakeholders. Horizontal automation across capabilities (e.g., claims and policy administration) is more technically (and politically) fraught and comes later. Useful guiding metrics include: automation potential percentage and labor-intensive score. That said, be mindful that the ultimate goal is not to automate work per se but to increase operational efficiency and reduce digital customer friction toward higher revenues and retention rates. You’re looking for cost-out, yes, but also "customer-in."  
  5. Build a directional automation business case. Include structure and strategy for scale, security and compliance, disaster recovery and risk management, change management and, last but certainly not least: the recruitment, upskilling and compensation of humans. It’s a truism that the more automation you have the more your humans matter. 

Three observations about the five steps as they apply to most situations.

The first three steps function as a LEAN-like exercise, and as such unearth opportunities for productivity gains and cost-out. This is intentional, as the goal is to find self-funding, budget-neutral automation opportunities especially early on as automation resistance and skepticism are high. Think big, start small, success on a shoestring.   

No major software investments are required. Though software will be necessarily tapped to build bots and string them together, most such tools are available for rent in the cloud and reasonably priced with license costs trending down. There is indeed a lot of large-scale digital transformation going on in insurance, by which we mean multi-year, capital-intensive, platform replacements. The approach outlined above is about rapid evolution over the T-word, working with legacy as-is, data where-at. 

See also: How to Automate Your Automation 

It’s natural to insist on a grand strategy up front, in step 1, before doing anything, but strategy is generated here at the end, in step 5. Work automation starts with the people and culture and internal systems that get work done today. Best to get started, working gradually, organically and, yes, aggressively (you can work through the five steps in as little as eight weeks). The resulting strategy document will feel more rock-solid and informed, with successful pilots to prove the concept. 

Where to start? A recent analysis by McKinsey, with which we agree, says the most "automatable" lines of business in P&C are, in descending order: 1) workers comp, 2) auto, 3) fire, 4) property, 5) inland marine, 6) crop, and 7) general liability. Taking it by function, per the ACORD capability model, we recommend customer service, channel management, claims, contract administration and sales. 

Wherever you choose to start, just break out the SOPs, dust them off and get mapping. Good luck.


Riv Arthur

Profile picture for user RivArthur

Riv Arthur

Riv Arthur is a business leader and technologist working in insurance, healthcare, and private equity.

4 P&C Mega Risks in 2022

These risks are moving the insurance market away from transactional coverage and more toward co-management of risk. 

risk

A global pandemic, supply chain challenges, climate change leading to CAT events and cyber risk have come together to increase claims and raise insurance prices across industries. Not only are these risks not evaporating any time soon, but they’re also likely to increase risk in 2022 for many businesses. 

As a result, the insurance market is moving away from transactional coverage and more toward co-management of risk.  

Understanding these trends — and, more importantly, the risk management solutions that position business owners in the face of underwriters — will be key to securing the optimal insurance coverage in 2022. 

Here are four “mega-risks” we will see play out in 2022 — and how they are already affecting the P&C market:

1. Increased reliance on tech has led to massive improvements across industries. It’s also increased cyber risk for all. 

Attempted online fraud in the hospitality sector is rising 156% year-over-year. In an industry in which 60% of businesses say they’re not ready for cybercrime, cannabis businesses are a major target for bad actors. And, cyberattacks against large food manufacturers halted production at several processing facilities last year. As cyberattacks become more common, cyber insurance rates will rise 20% to 30% this year. 

What can you do? Brokers are partnering with vendors and insurance carriers to address this through risk management solutions, including improved network defenses, multi-factor authentication, employee training and third-party vendor security audits. 

See also: Cognitive Biases and Risk Management

2. Natural catastrophes are raising the stakes. CAT modeling may be the answer. 

In 2021, the U.S. had 19 weather disasters that costs $1 billion or more. 

From wildfires to floods, tornadoes and hurricanes, farms and food manufacturers saw reduced yields from damaged crops. Real estate owners say it’s nearly impossible to find locations that aren’t exposed to flood, fire or storms. Hospitality is losing business as weather disrupts operations. As a result, P&C rates for both restaurants and lodging establishments will rise as much as 20% in 2022. Property rates for other types of commercial real estate will rise 10% or more, as well. 

What can you do? Consider enhanced warning and predictive systems such as catastrophe (CAT) modeling and fire- and water-resistant construction materials when possible. While storms are more foreseeable, they are still out of human control; therefore, a strong risk management solution includes a thorough post-loss response plan for recovery and resuming operations.

3. Attracting and retaining quality employees is a key challenge in 2022. A strong stock market + an aging population is pushing intellectual capital into retirement. 

Vaccine hesitancy is also squeezing labor markets, while leading to a rise of workers’ compensation claims in the healthcare sector. Although WC premiums are expected to remain flat in 2022, the challenge will be at the worker level, as remaining staff will have to work longer hours to make up for their fellow employees. 

What can you do? Brokers can offer employers improved pay and expand extended benefits programs with perks such as paid apprenticeship training programs, vocational skills training programs and mental health services. 

4. Supply chain disruptions are commonplace. Labor shortages and consumer habits have made it hard for businesses to deliver goods and materials. 

In the construction industry, material shortages interrupted cash flow, leading to cost spikes, ruined schedules for projects and busted budgets. Expect construction coverage costs to rise between 5% and 35%, with large, risk-prone projects at the higher end. 

For short-haul drivers, simply leaving port with cargo is an administrative and bureaucratic nightmare. Coverage for courier and delivery fleet will increase by 25% or more.  

What can you do? Resilience is the key to mitigation, as businesses that can should build up materials reserves and develop new relationships with potential backup suppliers domestically. Think both local and regional suppliers. 

See also: 20 Insurance Issues to Watch in 2022

Securing the right partner is critical to reducing risk in 2022

The COVID-19 pandemic has exploded risks and insurance coverage costs, creating a complex environment for business owners and employers of all types.

These conditions make it essential to partner with a broker that specializes in your market, understands your risk level and knows the market inside and out. In doing so, you can build a strong risk management and insurance program that positions your business for a successful year.


Mike Chapman

Profile picture for user MikeChapman

Mike Chapman

Mike Chapman is the national director of commercial markets at Hub International.

Prior to Hub, Chapman held several management positions at various insurance companies, entering the industry in 1986.

A graduate of the University of New Hampshire, he holds Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU), Accredited Advisor in Insurance (AAI), and Associate in Risk Management (ARM) designations. He is a regular speaker nationally on the commercial insurance market and is a frequent contributor to industry publications. He serves on local and national advisory councils for several major insurance carriers.

Tips for the Hybrid Work World

The following are important ways to reduce corporate risk and support employees in both remote and on-site environments. 

employee

We are in a new era of workplace models, and the freedom and flexibility of remote work is incredible in many ways. But there is a second side to this coin. Daily, I interact with organizations that provide in-person services for their communities – services that cannot be performed remotely. Service-based jobs require people to be present to provide those services and include jobs in city government, hospitals, schools and grocery stores, as well as positions in all the trades. Even when there is a way to supplement those roles with remote work, the bulk of it must be performed in person. 

The fact is that physical workspaces are still – and will always be – important, and, at the moment, many organizations are concluding that both on-site and remote work environments will be necessary indefinitely. 

The following tips will help you reduce corporate risk and support employees in both remote and on-site environments. 

For remote workers

Establish work and break guidelines: To maintain productivity and prevent burnout, establish employee guidelines for working hours and breaks. Some remote employees will overwork while others are prone to underwork. Guidelines set clear expectations and help everyone to find balance.

Establish ergonomic guidelines: To reduce physical risk, including the risk of carpal tunnel and repetitive action injuries, put ergonomic guidelines in place for at-home workstations and offer ergonomic training to employees. Dining room tables are often at a different heights than desks and are not appropriate workspaces. Provide guidance on the right height for monitors, desks and surface areas, as well as proper posture. 

See also: Smart Home Devices: the Security Risks

Develop communication standards: To ensure connection during emergencies, put an adequate communications system in place, such as Microsoft Teams or a Slack. Provide employees steps on what to do if they have daily technology challenges and explain how and on what channels the company will communicate in case of an emergency. 

Build teams and trust: To encourage fluid communication throughout the year and a unified direction, focus on team building. AP Keenan puts a significant amount of effort into team building, which allows quality communication and opens the doors to educate and coach employees. In addition, with strong team camaraderie, we can more easily check in with our employees and make sure their mental health is good. We’ve hired people over the past year, and the feedback we get is: “Wow! You really keep in contact.”  

Foster a work-life balance: Help employees create a work-life balance by encouraging them to take time off, just as they did when they were in an office – even if their laptop is within five feet of them. You can especially help employees who are “workaholics” or those who feel guilty not working 24/7 to set boundaries. In addition, make sure your remote employees are not isolating themselves excessively. Happy, balanced employees who interact with others and have a network of support have more to offer at work.

Consider workers' compensation claims: With hybrid models, today’s employers must consider what the workers' compensation situation is in an employee’s home and the liability to the employer versus the employee in that space. As an employer, what is your control over the work environment and your ability to affect safety? Is there enough room for your employee to get around, or are they tripping over drawers or cabinets when they are getting up to go to the restroom?  

Consider your financial liability: To ensure you maintain connection with your employees, consider providing compensation for your remote employees’ phone and internet access. At AP Keenan, across the board, we add a dollar amount to all hourly employees’ paychecks to assist with their phone and utility bills. 

In addition, make conscious decisions about the physical supplies your employees need. When the pandemic began, many companies were able to quickly switch to remote work. They had emergency response plans that allowed them to know where there data centers where, how they were going to provide employees continued connection and how they would get supplies to their people. The reality is that most employees don’t stock office paper or light bulbs at home, and their internet might not support all the work functions or provide the right security. As you decide what employees must provide versus what you will provide, have clear conversations about shifting costs to employees. In particular, consider if you are shifting costs to those who already experience a wage gap.

For in-person employees, you’ll need to provide adequate resources to support the spaces in which they work to reduce your risk and increase their health and productivity. These tips apply: 

Reassess the budget: As employers aim to accommodate the hybrid concept, they risk spreading dollars thin over new costs. Have clear budgeting discussions that highlight the transfer of funds to support remote work as well as the risks of defunding the physical workspace. Will you be removing resources that avoid the severity and frequency of claims? 

Invest in safe work environments: Look around -- does your brick-and-mortar workspace look like a storage unit or a moving facility since the pandemic started?  Are boxes stacked in the hallway?  Are you still ADA-compliant? As the corporate physical space is reduced in favor of remote work, there is often an uptick in claims, such as “slip, trip and fall” scenarios. It’s important for in-person facilities staff to remove obstacles and keep the physical space up to standard. 

Continue safety trainings: Keep employees’ physical safety at the top of the priority list. Dedicate a healthy portion of your budget to maintaining in-person safety and prevention programs to avoid problems. Whether you have one or 10,000 employees in the office, it only takes one injury to result in a claim.  

See also: Cyber Tips for Work From Home

Stay on top of workers' compensation laws: One of the most complex factors employers face when deciding on a hybrid work model is workers' compensation. In California, it’s one of the largest drivers in the workplace and often an incredibly complex expense. Laws change regularly and are bound to change as a result of the shifting workforce. Work with a consultant to stay up-to-date on evolving workers' compensation laws – especially those in your particular state.

Work with your insurer: One of the best ways to control costs and keep people safe is to avoid claims in the first place. To reduce the severity and frequently of claims, make sure your insurer is not just managing claims and providing coverage, but helping you think through these important issues. In the end, your insurer can help you improve your rates, improve your experience, retain your employees and realize a successful future.


Kevin Knopf

Profile picture for user KevinKnopf

Kevin Knopf

Kevin Knopf is Keenan's vice president of marketing communications and assists with writing and distributing information on insurance industry trends, legislation and regulatory issues that may have an impact on Keenan's clients.

Ukraine: How Exposed Are Insurers?

New political risk insurance losses in Ukraine due to Russia's invasion will likely be material but well within the ability of private carriers to perform on their obligations.

ukraine flag

Ukraine (UKR) is one of the largest insured risks for political risk insurance (PRI) and trade credit insurance (TCI). This predates the current situation in Ukraine and started immediately after the country's accession to sovereignty in 1991.

Based on data from the Berne Union, the trade association representing credit and political risk insurers, PRI carriers issued $19 billion of new coverage globally in 2021, of which $2 billion went to cover risks in Europe and $1.6 billion to cover risks in Russia. Based on these figures and other published data, we estimate that PRI insurers have insured between $1 billion and $7 billion in Ukraine risks over the last five years.

New PRI losses in Ukraine due to Russia's invasion will likely be material but well within the ability of private carriers to perform on their obligations. Several factors are contributing to reducing private PRI insurers' exposure in Ukraine:

  • Some PRI and TCI carriers stopped writing Ukraine risk in 2014
  • Carriers with existing Ukraine risk have likely taken reserves against future losses in Ukraine
  • 80% of PRI coverage is provided directly or indirectly by government agencies such as OPIC in the U.S. and by multilateral agencies such as the World Bank's MIGA.

Insured Losses in Ukraine

In Ukraine, PRI and TCI tend to be primarily purchased by foreign companies with cross-border trade or investments in the following industries:

  • Energy
  • Manufacturing
  • Infrastructure/Project Finance
  • Natural Resources

Losses due to Russia's invasion of Ukraine fall under comprehensive political violence, and more specifically under war and civil war and strikes, riots and civil commotion. The full range of PRI and TCI coverages includes:

  • PRI: political violence, expropriation and breach of contract
  • TCI: Short-term credit, medium-/long-term credit and other cross-border credit

PRI coverage protects primarily against loss of assets and profits. PRI's political violence protects against losses due to strikes, riots and civil commotion (SRCC) and war and civil war. TCI's credit default coverage protects primarily against loss of profits due to force majeure; failure to perform on letters of credit due to force majeure; and loss of profits and cost of penalties due to force majeure. PRI and TCI tend to also provide compensation for the cost to the insured of its failure to perform on obligations to third parties, such as penalties for non-delivery of goods or services due to covered risks.

PRI political violence's war and civil war coverage excludes declared war between the permanent members of the U.N. Security Council, which includes Russia.

Loss of profits due to sanctions may be covered by PRI and TCI policies. However, the coverage is structured to cover sanctions by the host (ex: Ukraine) or third-party countries (ex: Russia), not the insured's home country. For example, a U.S. company investing in Ukraine may or may not be covered for sanctions imposed by the U.S.

See also: How to Achieve Cyber Resilience

Markets and Policies

The majority of private carriers providing PRI insurance are based in the U.S., at Lloyd's and in Bermuda. PRI providers include AIG, AXA XL, Chubb, Sovereign, Caitlin and Zurich. The largest providers of TCI coverage are Coface, Heuler Hermes and Atradius. Government or multilateral agencies providing either PRI or TCI or both include OPIC (U.S.), EXIM Bank (U.S.), EDC (Canada), UKEF (U.K.) and MIGA (World Bank).

PRI insurance policies coverages tend to range between $100 million and $4 billion. TCI coverage can range from $250,000 to $2 billion. The main buyers of PRI come primarily from the extraction sector, manufacturing and infrastructure. Those industries are also significant buyers of TCI, in additional to import-export businesses in soft and hard commodities. Rates for PRI tend to range between 0.5% and 2% and for TCI between 0.1% and 1.5%. Above such rates, the products tend to be become either less attractive to buyers or unavailable due to the risk profile of risks. When coverage is available, rates for Ukraine would be at the higher end of these ranges.

Domestic U.S. Cyber Risk

The main risk associated with Russia's attack on Ukraine for business in the U.S. and the E.U. is state-sponsored Russian cyber attacks on U.S. business and critical infrastructure. This is regardless of whether they have operations and investments or do business in Russia or Ukraine. Indeed, Russia has a well-documented history of unofficial cyber attacks on Western assets. The impact of declared or undeclared Russian cyber attacks on U.S. businesses would be covered by a company's cyber risk policy. A PRI policy is not necessary to cover Russian cyber attacks against U.S. businesses in the U.S. Because some cyber policies exclude state-sponsored actions, insureds should contact their insurers to confirm whether state actions are excluded from their coverage.


Michel Leonard

Profile picture for user MichelLeonard

Michel Leonard

Michel Leonard, PhD, CBE is vice president, senior economist and data scientist, head of the economics and analytics department of the Insurance Information Institute.

Dr. Leonard brings more than 20 years of insurance experience to Triple-I, including senior and leadership positions as chief economist for trade credit and political risk at Aon; chief economist at Jardine Lloyd Thompson; chief economist and data scientist at Alliant; and chief data scientist at MaKro LLC. In these roles, he worked closely with underwriters, brokers and risk managers to model risk exposures for property-casualty and specialty lines such as credit, political risk, business interruption and cyber.

Dr. Leonard also currently serves as adjunct faculty at New York University’s Economics Department. Previous academic appointments include adjunct faculty in NYU’s Center for Data Science and adjunct faculty at Columbia University’s Data Science Institute and Statistics Department. 

He holds a bachelor of arts degree from McGill University, a master's in theological studies from Harvard University and master of arts and doctorate of philosophy degrees in political economy from the University of Virginia, focusing on qualitative and quantitative risk modeling. He is a member of the Insurance Research Council advisory board.

Six Things: March 1st, 2022

Breakthrough #Technologies for #2022. Plus, #insurtech's lasting role in insurance; a patient-centered approach to #claims; and more

six things header

 
 
 

Breakthrough Technologies for 2022

Paul Carroll, Editor-in-Chief of ITL

The MIT Technology Review's annual list of breakthrough technologies came out last week, and, as always, it's worth a look, both because of the general framing it offers about technology trends and because of some specific implications for insurance.

From an insurance standpoint, the two most directly relevant are what TR refers to as "the end of passwords" (yay!) and the growing availability of "synthetic" data to train AI in situations where there isn't enough real data available. But the other eight on the list of 10 are intriguing, too, especially for what they suggest about how we might be able to build on the technologies behind the mRNA vaccines against COVID to make additional, huge advances in healthcare.

continue reading >

New Research

Don't miss Majesco's annual consumer report to better understand how the insurance buyer sweet spot has shifted to Millennials and Gen Z and what emerging insurance trends are driving new opportunities.

Download Report

 

SIX THINGS

 

Lemonade: No Sign of Disruption Yet
by Matteo Carbone

For each dollar of premium, claims cost Lemonade 90 cents, marketing cost it 60 cents and other costs added 40 cents. Feel a little betrayed?

Read More

Insurtech's Lasting Role in Insurance
by David Fontain

Thousands of lines of insurance haven't been innovated in 30 years. With so much opportunity, it's time to think about insurtech as a permanent fixture in the larger ecosystem. 

Read More

How IT Savings Can Fund Innovation

Sponsored by Rimini Street

While IT infrastructure is a business necessity, aging IT systems can inflate expenses and limit the ability to spend on initiatives that will really move the needle for a business. In this webinar, we discuss how insurers can optimize their data centers and generate savings that can fund innovation, while improving security.

Read More

 

Auto Insurance in 2022: What to Expect
by Rochelle Thielen

2022 will look a lot like the second half of 2021, but opportunities are emerging for auto insurers to differentiate themselves, especially through telematics. 

Read More

Setting Record Straight on Auto Claims Severity
by John Kanet

While the assumption has been that higher repair costs for advanced driver assistance systems features offset ADAS loss-cost benefits, a new study finds significant benefits.

Read More

A Patient-Centered Approach to Claims
by Dwight Robertson

Properly applied, AI produces better medical outcomes, gets employees back to work faster, reduces litigation risk and lowers the costs associated with claims.

Read More

How to Achieve Cyber Resilience
by Rajeev Gupta

If an organization does not have a well-thought-out incident response plan with trusted and tested backups in place, a cyber attack can be devastating.

Read More

InsurTech Ohio Spotlight with Ron Rock

Sponsored by JobsOhio 

Ron Rock discusses how the insurance industry is rapidly evolving, and the importance of recruiting and retaining top software and programming talent. 

Read Now

 

MORE FROM ITL

 

February Focus: Blockchain

Sponsored by Gigaforce

While blockchain has been an intriguing topic for some time now, interest has skyrocketed in recent months. 

Facebook said late last year that it believes so much in the "metaverse" that it was changing its name to Meta. Microsoft followed quickly with its own vision of how technology could enable a whole new sort of world, where our selves are disembodied and our interactions occur via virtual reality. Venture capital firms such as Andreessen Horowitz are all over the investment opportunities in the metaverse, sometimes referred to as Web 3.0. And pundits are making bold proclamations about how life as we know it is about to change forever. 

Read More

Reconfiguring Your Approach to Underwriting 

Sponsored by Intellect SEEC

Learn how you can vastly increase the speed at which you deliver capabilities and new systems - cutting deployment times to hours or days, from weeks or months, while delivering a clear ROI.

Read Now

 

 

Partner with ITL to create expert thought leadership content.

Custom Content
Promoted Content
Display Advertising
Custom Webinars
Monthly Topic Sponsorships
ITL Partner Packages and more


Learn more and get the 2022 Media Kit

 
 

 

Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.

ITL FOCUS MARCH: Life and Health

For an industry that has long been considered sleepy, life insurance has a lot going on. 

itl focus graphic with a heart that reads life and health

 
 
 

FROM THE EDITOR

For an industry that has long been considered sleepy, life insurance has a lot going on. 

The efforts getting the most attention have probably been those related to improving the customer experience, largely by speeding underwriting by reducing or doing away with the need for medical exams and the providing of blood and urine samples. 

But other big changes are afoot, too. 

Artificial intelligence is being deployed in ways that range all the way from the mundane to the potentially profound. The mundane should still have a big effect, because AI will allow underwriters to capture and manage information much faster and more efficiently than they now can -- for instance, by having the AI take data in a wide variety of formats, including doctors' infamously bad handwriting, and present it in a standardized, easily accessible format. And the sky is the limit on the most ambitious AI initiatives, which could let underwriters do a much better job of assessing risks and could even help insurers reduce clients' risks. (For a great example, check out the article below on the potential for genomics.)

Private equity, always a major change agent, has its sights on life insurance, if only as a source for "permanent capital." This McKinsey article explains in detail.

And I continue to believe that there are many opportunities to embed life insurance in other offerings, such as for mortgages or commercial loans, and for financial advisers to include various forms of life insurance and annuities in their services.

If all that isn't enough, please consider the interview I did with Ronnie Klein, attached below, on the aging crisis that cries out for aggressive action by the life insurance industry.

Cheers,
Paul

 

 
 

INTERVIEW WITH RONNIE KLEIN

 
As part of this month's ITL Focus on life and health, we spoke with Ronnie Klein, a senior adviser at Afiniti and founder of Obtutus Advisory, who has a long history in life insurance, with a focus on aging. He describes what he sees as a full-blown crisis--one that life insurers are uniquely positioned to address. 

""We've seen populations aging and fertility rates dropping for decades. Actuaries, economists and demographers have been predicting this crisis for a long time.""

-Ronnie Klein
Read the Full Interview
 

READ MORE

 

World in Flux: Can Insurance Fill the Gap in 2022?

The level of change has never been greater, and insurance’s opportunities have never been more numerous.

Read More

Predictive Modeling’s New Mantra

With the power of predictive modeling and its resulting efficiencies, life insurers can simplify underwriting, reducing both time and complexity.

Read More

The Need to Offer Better Perinatal Plans

Comprehensive perinatal education helps employers address at least five related opportunities.

Read More

How AI Can Solve Prior Authorization

Physicians spend nearly two full business days per week on prior authorization requests as part of an antiquated, manual process

Read More

2022 Will Challenge Health Insurers

COVID has transformed health insurance and what it means for coverage, pricing and patient care for years to come.

Read More

Genomics Revolution in Life Insurance

Here’s where blockchain stands today — plus how to see the inherent risks and opportunities of using this exciting technology in insurance.

Read More

 
 

FEATURED THOUGHT LEADERS

View all ITL FOCUS topics
 
Share Share
Share Share
Tweet Tweet
 

 

Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.

An Interview with Ronnie Klein

As part of this month's ITL Focus on life and health, we spoke with Ronald Klein, a senior adviser at Afiniti and founder of Obtutus Advisory, who has a long history in life insurance, with a focus on aging. He describes what he sees as a full-blown crisis--one that life insurers are uniquely positioned to address. 

an interview with ronnie klein

ITL:

To start, could you provide a little perspective and frame the aging crisis?

Ronnie Klein:

Prominent colleagues of mine call it a predictable surprise, and I like that term. We've seen populations aging and fertility rates dropping for decades.  Actuaries, economists and demographers have been predicting this crisis for a long time.

The total population of the world is projected to increase through the end of the century, then it's supposed to plateau and come down. However, a lot of that population growth is coming from the non-mature countries. In a lot of the mature markets, we’re seeing population decline or slowing population growth.

It's a major concern because Pillar I [such as U.S. Social Security] pension systems will have a difficult time keeping up with aging populations. There’s going to be a lot of stress on these systems as contributions from fewer workers have to support a growing number of retired people. At some point, benefits will have to change, and people will have less income to live on, unless they have their own personal insurance, including annuities.

It’s a big issue.

ITL:

We’ve heard a lot about aging in Japan. Would Japan, in fact, already be facing the aging crisis, and what countries, including the U.S., would you see following reasonably close on after Japan?

Klein:

Japan tried a program where it was trying to keep up with Pillar I contributions in an actuarial manner as if it was like a private pension plan, but what was considered to be the normal retirement age was getting to be so old. It becomes difficult to sell the public, who have 65 years old in their minds, on the idea that the normal retirement age is now 72. What are you supposed to do: Work from 65 to 72?

That doesn't work for much of the population, whom we might term the blue-collar population. Sure, a white-collar person could possibly work to age 72, but what about someone who's in construction or a bus driver? These people perform important services for the world and deserve a comfortable retirement.

In terms of countries, you have to look at Malaysia, South Korea, Japan and Italy. Spain has real problems, as well, with few people having children. People are just living longer, too, in the southern European nations. It must be those Italian or Spanish wines.

In addition, mass urbanization of the world is contributing to both climate change and global aging. When you move to a big city, you usually live in smaller quarters, which provide less room for families. It’s also very expensive to live there, and, when people have less money, they typically have fewer kids.

ITL:

You’ve certainly painted a picture of a daunting problem. How can the life insurance industry start addressing it?

Klein:

The place to start is education. I should probably get off of my soap box about this, but I think the insurance associations of the world should get together and lobby for teaching financial literacy in schools.

When I moved to Switzerland years ago, the youngest of my four kids was seven, and she told me about how her class went into the forest and learned how to use their Swiss Army knife to whittle wood and make a fire and all that kind of stuff. While learning how to survive in the forest is certainly an important skill, so is financial literacy. School should teach about saving for retirement, the power of compound interest, how life insurance works, auto insurance, homeowners insurance, etc.  It's really important.

ITL:

Beyond education, is there any way for life insurers to work with government?

Klein:

Government is actually our biggest competitor. What I mean by that is, it seems like whenever there's a major disaster, the government steps in and helps people out to the point where they say, “Why do I have to take care of myself? The government will help me if there is a disaster.

After 9/11, I saw an interview with a young widow with two kids whose husband was a senior executive at a firm whose offices were at the top of one of the towers. They lived in one of the most exclusive parts of Long Island. She was crying as she explained that, as the firm allocated funds to the families of victims, she was receiving only $500,000. I thought, “You’re telling me you and your husband didn’t have a $20 million policy on his life?” For that matter, why didn’t the firm have a group policy on all its senior executives?

A $20 million policy is what an adviser would have recommended on someone with his salary. But there’s a sense of entitlement that keeps people from thinking they need to take care of themselves.

The industry has to get together on some sort of a campaign and stop worrying about whether it will somehow stir up trouble. The life insurance industry has always worried about speaking up. Most industry associations just get together for meetings and issue papers, but there has to be a concerted effort by the insurance industry to get out there.

The first thing to do is to recognize the problem and to make the world recognize that we have an aging crisis. Lobby for financial literacy to be on the syllabus for schools. And then explain to the government how life insurance will help. The more people who have adequate life insurance, including annuities, the less there is for the government to cover.  

There should also be changes in Pillar Two [private contributions by individuals and employers for retirement savings]. In an ideal world, things like 401Ks in the U.S. would be mandatory. Pensions should also be portable, as they are in Europe, so you carry your pension with you from company to company. I have three different pensions for the three companies I worked for in the U.S.

The pension problem is only going to get worse, with all these gig workers. These kids are not saving for the future. There's no retirement savings pool for gig workers, and they're not putting money into an IRA.

There are models that work in different countries that can be copied.

ITL:

Thanks. This has been super challenging but also enlightening.


Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.