Download

Underwriting on Climate Must Evolve

Climate models weren't built to predict insurance losses, so underwriters are having to rethink risk management.

Climate

Climate risk has become one of the most frequently discussed topics in insurance, but from where I sit as a climate scientist who has spent two decades studying the performance and use of climate models, including their ability to represent weather extremes, climate risk is still widely misunderstood. 

In the recent Send Infuse webinar, I joined the conversation to help bridge the gap between climate science and underwriting practice. What became clear is that climate risk is no longer a distant scenario or a theoretical modeling exercise. It is already shaping losses, challenging long‑held assumptions, and exposing structural weaknesses in how insurers make decisions.

The industry, from a scientific perspective, is being asked to do something incredibly difficult, which is to try and understand climate change impacts in financial material terms. This translation of climate to financial risk involves the use of tools designed to represent past relationships between hazard and loss. These tools are now applied to explore a future that may look very different from today. Can these tools be informative about future losses? This tension sits at the heart of today's climate-risk challenge.

Climate Losses Are Surpassing Expectations, and It's Not Just Exposure Growth

Recent events illustrate the scale of the shift. Italy's 2023 floods, France's 2022 hailstorms, and the Los Angeles wildfires of early 2025 all produced losses far beyond what models anticipated. These aren't isolated anomalies, and they reflect a pattern we see across multiple regions and perils.

The science tells us hazard behavior is changing. In many places, we are observing nonlinear shifts — including threshold effects, intensification patterns, and clustering of extremes — that traditional catastrophe models were never designed to capture. In a transient climate, it is reasonable to regularly reassess models to assure users that they are still fit for purpose.

This is why I often emphasize that climate risk cannot be reduced to a new data layer or a simple model adjustment. It requires a deeper understanding of how physical systems behave under stress, and how those behaviors diverge from historical norms.

Why Traditional Models Struggle with Climate Scenarios

One of the most common misconceptions I encounter is the belief that we can simply "climate-adjust" existing catastrophe models and use them to explore future scenarios. But catastrophe models were built for a specific purpose: to price financial loss. They are essentially statistical models calibrated to a current reality — in terms of hazard but also socio-economic conditions that shape building standards, defense infrastructure, disaster response readiness, and ability to afford insurance, etc.

Climate models, or ensembles of climate models, by contrast, are designed to explore a plausible uncertainty space (socio-economically, and physical model response). Importantly, the socio-economic scenarios are not assigned probabilities or likelihoods. When regulators ask insurers to assess long-term climate scenarios, there is a clash of scientific perspectives. The mindset of insurance is focused on estimating a likely loss using predictive tools. From a climate science perspective, approaches and tools are designed for understanding system response. By exploring the plausible, firms can assess their ability to meet different types of challenges should they eventuate. If deriving a single estimate of future loss, how meaningful is this value for risk management when in fact many others are plausible?

This is why I have said that "the tools are not developed to be applied in a climate scenario approach where we don't understand how losses might occur." It is reasonable to assume that near-term projections are serviceable, but the further we look into the future, the more cautious we must be about the assumptions implicitly embedded in our tools.

The insurance sector is now at the stage where many other industries have found themselves. They are using familiar tools to answer unfamiliar questions. Eventually, organizations realize that the questions themselves need to change to seek information that is, if not predictable, at least actionable. This implies a shift from a predictive mode to an anticipatory mode of management for the far-forward time horizons.

The Real Challenge Is Governance, Not Just Analytics

While the scientific limitations are real, the operational challenges inside insurance organizations are equally significant. Climate-relevant insights often fail to travel through the organization in a meaningful way. Underwriters may be doing sophisticated work such as running local flood maps, tracking wildfire accumulation, and monitoring aggregates, but that insight rarely reaches reserving, capital, or the board. This is not a failure of effort. It is a failure of structure.

Insurance organizations are highly optimized for efficiency. Information flows sequentially, not collaboratively. Each function performs its role well, but climate risk requires a different kind of conversation — one that cuts across silos and acknowledges uncertainty rather than seeking to reduce it. We need to connect the chain links together to talk about how we do things in a more meaningful way. If we don't, climate risk becomes fragmented, and the organization loses the ability to see the full picture.

Climate Risk Is About Resilience, Not Just Pricing

One of the most important shifts insurers must make is recognizing that climate risk is not solely a pricing problem. It is a resilience problem. And resilience operates across multiple time horizons.

Near-term risks may be manageable with existing tools, but long-term risks require different approaches to monitoring climate drivers, understanding adaptation pathways, and then recognizing that exposure, hazard, and vulnerability will all evolve. It is unrealistic to assume that building standards, land-use planning, or national adaptation strategies will remain static. Yet many scenario exercises implicitly make that assumption.

This is why I encourage firms to think beyond model outputs and ask: What aspects of risk are we capturing? What aspects are we missing? And what decisions are we trying to inform?

A Path Forward: More Cross-Fertilization, More Curiosity

The insurance sector is early in its climate-risk journey, but it is not alone. Sectors such as water management, infrastructure planning, and emergency response have been grappling with deep uncertainty for years. There is much to learn from their approaches, particularly around decision-making under uncertainty.

We need more cross-fertilization between climate adaptation communities and the insurance sector. We need more conversations that bring together scientists, underwriters, actuaries, and risk managers. And we need leadership that recognizes climate risk as a strategic issue, not a compliance burden.

Climate risk is more than a model output. It is a shift in how we understand the world, how we interpret uncertainty, and how we make decisions in the face of change.

The Bottom Line

Climate risk now lives inside the underwriting workflow because the physical world is changing faster than our tools and structures were designed to handle. The challenge is not simply to refine models, but to rethink how information flows, how decisions are made, and how uncertainty is embraced rather than ignored.

As I said during the Infuse webinar, “climate risk is more than data layers and output from catastrophe models. It’s about understanding what risks might look like at different time horizons.” That understanding requires curiosity, collaboration, and a willingness to evolve.

The insurance sector has the expertise and the ingenuity to meet this challenge. It now requires new conversations and new ways of listening.


Marie Ekström

Profile picture for user MarieEkström

Marie Ekström

Dr. Marie Ekström works in the climate and sustainability team of Gallagher Re to give guidance on all matters of climate risk to the (re)insurance sector. 

She is a regional climate scientist with 20+ years of academic and government research experience across a wide range of topics, often interdisciplinary and generally in a climate change context. 

Ekström holds a Fil. Mag. from Stockholm University (Sweden), a Fil. Lic and Ph.D. from Lund University (Sweden), a Marie Curie Intra-European Fellowship hosted at the Climatic Research Unit, University of East Anglia (UK), and since 2021 an associated editor position on the Wiley journal Climate Resilience and Sustainability.

Claims Leakage Costs Insurers Billions Annually

Technology alone won't solve a leakage problem rooted in process gaps and human judgment.

tech

For an industry built on the precise calculation of risk, the persistence of claims leakage presents a striking paradox.

Defined as the difference between what a carrier actually pays and what it should have paid under the terms of a policy, leakage is not a marginal concern. Across the industry, it typically accounts for between 7% and 14% of total claims payouts, against insured losses that regularly exceed $100 billion annually.

But these potential financial exposures only tell part of the story. Claims leakage also corrodes the policyholder relationship at its most critical moment. There's an old expression in insurance: "pricing brings customers in the door; the claims experience keeps them there."

In a personal lines market where consumers have genuine options, and where bundled coverages make a dissatisfied policyholder an attractive acquisition target for competitors, the cost of a poor claims experience extends well beyond the individual transaction. Overpayment is one problem. Losing a customer who felt underserved by a confusing or inconsistent process is quite another.

Addressing leakage begins by distinguishing between its two forms.

  • Hard leakage involves payouts where coverage did not exist: misinterpreted exclusions, undetected fraud, or losses simply not covered under the policy.
  • Soft leakage is more diffuse: unvetted vendor invoices, missed deductibles, duplicate payments, and claims settled without adequate documentation. Both are damaging, both are preventable, and both have the same underlying causes.
The Claims Leakage Troika

Leakage is rarely the product of deliberate action. More often, it results from operational inefficiencies that compound across three connected domains.

1. Process Gaps

Inefficient claims processes create the conditions for financial leakage before an adjuster ever reviews a file. Missing or incomplete First Notice of Loss (FNOL) documentation sets a claim on the wrong trajectory from the outset; incomplete data cascades through the life of the claim, making accurate reserving and coverage determination harder at every subsequent stage.

Duplicate payments, processing the same service, invoice, or repair twice, remain a persistent problem in organizations relying on disjointed or manual payment systems. They are often discovered only in retrospect, if at all. Equally costly is unpursued subrogation: when third-party liability goes unidentified, the carrier absorbs costs it was entitled to recover. The failure is not always one of knowledge; more often it reflects workload constraints that push subrogation opportunities down the priority stack until the recovery window closes.

Prolonged claims management cycles compound the problem in another direction. Delays stack caseloads, generate non-productive administrative costs, and create pressure that pushes adjusters toward expediency, rather than accuracy. Process inefficiency, in this sense, is not just a cost driver; it is a leakage accelerant.

Vendor and supplier management introduces a parallel set of process vulnerabilities. Without pre-negotiated contracts or a carefully cultivated repair network, cost variances can go unchecked and overpayment often becomes the path of least resistance. Even where vendor agreements exist, administrative staff (and in some cases, claims adjusters) are often left manually processing invoices and attaching copies to individual claim files, adding another layer of inefficiency to an already strained operation.

2. The Human Factor

Claims adjusting is, by regulatory mandate in the majority of U.S. states, a human decision-making function. This regulation is concrete recognition that coverage determinations carry weight for policyholders. Human decision-making under sustained pressure increases the likelihood of claim overpayments.

This form of workload stacking, driven by staffing constraints, high caseload volumes, and persistent recruitment challenges across the industry, forces adjusters into assuming a reactive posture, rather than an analytical one. Among the most recognizable symptoms of this is stair-step reserving: the gradual, incremental upward adjustment of claim reserves without the structured analysis that should accompany each change. Reserves set too low, then corrected too late, distort loss ratios and undermine financial planning across the portfolio.

High talent turnover rates exacerbate this problem. Less experienced adjusters, saddled with intensifying claim file management responsibilities, are more likely to falter when executing error-prone tasks, expanding the risk of misapplied coverage terms, overlooked exclusions, or claims settlements executed without comprehensive documentation review.

Turnover also forces adjusters into unfamiliar lines of coverage: for example, a casualty-focused adjuster suddenly handling a surge of property claims, thereby adding to the ever-present risk of claim mishandling and overpayment.

Beyond these operational pressures, inconsistent decision-making injects a subtler form of friction. As adjusters apply subjective interpretations to materially similar claims, they introduce what behavioral economists call "noise" into the system, a form of variance unrelated to the merits of individual claims but instead tied to human inconsistency under pressure. Unlike stair-step reserving or reserve drift, this form of leakage does not leave an obvious trail, making it among the most difficult cost inefficiencies to detect and correct – especially at scale.

None of these outcomes reflect individual failure. They instead expose structural weaknesses: inadequate staffing, insufficient training investment, and the compounding effects of a talent pipeline that has historically not kept pace with demand. These are fundamental management and resourcing challenges, not adjuster accountability problems.

3. Technology Misalignment

Technology can be a potential remedy. But when poorly deployed, it can exacerbate leakage. Legacy claims systems that don't integrate seamlessly with modern data environments leave adjusters manually processing PDFs, photographs, and demand letters without the benefit of system-wide cross-checking. When claims, policy, and payment systems operate in "silos," enforcing compliance in real time becomes nearly impossible, and these gaps between systems open the possibility for serious financial consequences.

Effective fraud detection is another casualty of technological misalignment. Identifying sophisticated fraud, including inflated claims, duplicate billing across carriers, and staged losses, requires pattern recognition across large datasets. Without adequate analytics capabilities and well-developed fraud risk assessment processes, these claims pass through undetected and are absorbed as legitimate losses.

Carriers have increasingly turned to modern, automated workflows to address these vulnerabilities. But the fundamental limitation of technology in this context is well understood by experienced claims leaders: systems are only as effective as the quality of data that powers them and the judgment of the people interpreting their outputs. Automation accelerates decisions, but it does not inherently improve them.

No Shortcuts

AI does not "solve" claims leakage. Experienced people, working from complete and accurate data, using well-designed processes, do.

The insurance industry is in the early stages of significant technological change. AI and machine learning are reshaping claims processing, delivering faster triage, better anomaly detection, and more consistent documentation review. These are real capabilities. The risk behind their implementation lies in treating technology adoption as a discrete goal rather than a component in a broader operational strategy.

The downstream effects of misaligned claims handling are significant. Inconsistent outcomes invite regulatory scrutiny for inequitable treatment of policyholders, creating fertile ground for litigation. Indemnity and defense costs in contested claims continue to climb, and bad faith exposure, where a carrier's handling process is found to have produced an unfair outcome, carries penalties that can dwarf the original claim value.

Critically, regulators and courts do not distinguish between decisions made by a human adjuster and those influenced or generated by an automated system. For this reason, a chain of accountability is first, last, and always human-led.

Standards published by the NAIC, the Insurance Crime Bureau, and other regulatory and advisory bodies provide a framework for consistent, compliant claims handling. But frameworks only deliver results when they are deliberately embedded into daily practice. Standardizing decision-making criteria, calibrating adjuster judgment through structured peer review, and maintaining traceable audit trails are operational disciplines that leverage compliance guidelines to reduce revenue leakage and improve the customer claims experience overall.

Technology extends the capacity of skilled adjusters. It does not replace them.

The carriers best positioned to reduce leakage are those that approach the challenge as a compound problem demanding multifaceted solutions. Adjuster training that builds genuine coverage expertise, not just process familiarity, is irreplaceable. Technology investments that connect systems, surface anomalies, and reduce manual burden extend the capacity of skilled adjusters rather than attempt to replace them. And the organizational discipline to balance judgment with pace, to resist the pressure to close files quickly at the expense of accuracy, requires leadership commitment that no software platform alone can provide.

Claims leakage is not a new problem. What has changed is that the industry has developed a deeper understanding of its key drivers, true costs, and the tools and techniques that make reducing leakage achievable. These results come when people, processes, and technology are aligned toward the same goal: paying precisely what is owed to preserve the financial capacity to serve more policyholders at their moment of greatest need.


James Ballot

Profile picture for user JamesBallot

James Ballot

James P. Ballot is an insurance research, thought leadership, and content strategy leader with more than a decade of experience helping industry, regulatory, business, consumer, and higher education audiences understand and navigate complex industry transitions.

When AI Amplifies Flawed Data

Insurers racing to deploy AI risk amplifying flawed data and inconsistent knowledge unless they first build trustworthy foundational systems.

Insure quality before AI use

Many insurers are rushing to deploy AI before they have taken the time to ensure they can trust what it will say.

The industry is sitting on decades of expertise, but it is scattered. It lives in underwriting guidelines that have been updated over time, claims notes written by different adjusters, engineering reports, inspection writeups, loss history, and a lot of individual judgment that never made it into a system at all. Then, we layer AI on top of it and expect clean, confident answers.

Because of this, users are hitting massive roadblocks when the underlying knowledge is inconsistent, disconnected, or hard to interpret. What many still don't realize is that AI is simply not designed to fix human errors stemming from baseline data inputs. In fact, it only makes it easier to surface those incomplete or misleading answers faster. And in insurance, those answers can show up in major underwriting decisions, claims handling, client advice, and risk recommendations, which can have a negative domino effect on critical decision making in a highly regulated industry.

That said, the issue is not whether AI is "ready." The question is whether insurers have done the groundwork to make their knowledge usable and trustworthy in the first place.

A recent initiative at FM is a solid example of this foundational work in practice. The company enabled more than 1,500 engineers to access decades of engineering knowledge through an AI-assisted platform. The real impact was consistency and confidence, with speed as an added benefit. Engineers could get to the right answer faster, but more importantly, they could trust what they were seeing.

This is a persistent challenge that exists across insurance. Whether it is underwriting appetite, claims precedent, loss control recommendations, or how you respond to a client in a complex scenario, the success of AI depends entirely on what lies beneath the surface.

Here are three things insurers should consider before these tools start influencing real work:

1. Stop organizing knowledge for storage. Start organizing it for judgment.

Most knowledge environments are built like filing cabinets, which works until someone actually needs to make a decision.

An underwriter is typically not thinking, "let me go find one document." They are weighing signals. Prior experience, similar risks, exceptions, engineering insight, loss trends. The same goes for claims, risk engineering, etc. The work is contextual versus linear.

If your knowledge is stored in disconnected places, AI will pull from it in disconnected ways. The answer might look polished, but it will not reflect how real decisions get made.

What worked in the FM deployment is that they did not just make content searchable. They connected it in a way that matched how engineers think about risk. That required a different level of effort.

Insurers need to take the same approach. If you want AI to support underwriting or claims, then your knowledge has to be structured around real decision paths that move beyond document repositories.

2. Assume your answers will be wrong and build for that reality.

This is where a lot of organizations get too comfortable too quickly. There is an assumption that if you are pulling from approved content, the answers will align. That is not a safe assumption once you are generating responses dynamically.

In insurance, being "mostly right" is not good enough. If an AI tool points an underwriter in the wrong direction, or gives a claims professional an incomplete answer, the downstream effect is real. It affects decisions, consistency, and in some cases client outcomes.

The teams that are getting this right treat accuracy as something that has to be earned every day. They test outputs, create feedback loops, and involve subject matter experts in refining results. They also assume gaps will exist and design for continuous improvement.

At FM, trust came from validating how their system performed in real-world scenarios and improving it over time.

That is the mindset insurers need. Not "is this ready to launch," but "how will we know when this is wrong and how fast can we correct it."

3. Decide up front where AI stops and people take over.

A lot of governance conversations sound good on paper but fall apart in practice because they're too vague. In insurance, you need clear, concrete lines to protect the integrity of the work. Where is AI allowed to assist? Where is human judgment required? What needs to be reviewed before it is used in a decision? What level of confidence is acceptable?

If an AI tool is helping draft an initial view of a risk, that is one thing. If it starts affecting pricing, coverage interpretation, or claims outcomes without clear oversight, that is something else entirely.

The strongest implementations treat AI as an extension of the professional. That means building in transparency, showing where information came from, and making it easy for people to challenge or verify what they are seeing.

The closer these tools get to core insurance functions, the tighter that control needs to be.

In summary, there is a lot of energy around AI right now, and for good reason, with tremendous opportunity on the horizon. In parallel, industry rigor should never be sacrificed for speed, and demands an established, accurate data foundation prior to deploying AI tools.

The firms that will get this right are not the ones rolling out the most tools the fastest. They are the ones doing the less visible work, taking the time to structure knowledge properly, putting real discipline around accuracy, and being explicit about where AI fits into decisions and where it does not.

Done right, AI becomes a force multiplier for your best people, makes expertise more accessible, and makes decisions more consistent.

If you skip it, you are just introducing a new layer of risk into an industry that already understands how costly that can be. That is the tradeoff. And it is one insurers need to think through carefully before they deploy at scale.

Reimagine, Retain, Reskill: Staffing the AI-Driven Insurer

Insurance leaders must build workforce strategies alongside AI deployment, retraining employees for higher-value roles as automation reshapes traditional insurance functions.

Staffing Models

AI is reshaping how insurance organizations operate, and the impact on the workforce is already visible. Submission intake, loss run processing, claims setup, and certificate issuance are all work that once required significant manual effort and is increasingly handled by AI.

For insurance leaders, that shift raises a question that doesn't get enough attention: what does it mean for the people doing that work today, and what does the team look like on the other side of this transition?

How AI Is Redesigning Insurance Teams

Carriers implementing AI are reporting real operational gains. But the more consequential change isn't in throughput numbers. It's in what AI is asking employees to do differently. As AI takes over repetitive, preparation-heavy work, the nature of insurance jobs is changing. Roles are consolidating in some areas and expanding in others. New responsibilities are emerging that didn't exist five years ago.

Insurance is not a sector where automation simply eliminates positions. The industry faces a significant and continuing talent shortage, and the work that remains after AI handles the routine tasks requires exactly the skills that are hardest to replace, such as judgment, relationships, and contextual expertise. An employee who previously scanned and indexed incoming mail can be retrained to manage agent relationships or work toward becoming an underwriter. The role doesn't disappear. It evolves into something with greater value and long-term potential.

What that evolution requires is careful planning. Leaders who treat workforce strategy as a byproduct of their AI rollout will find themselves reacting to disruption rather than managing it. The staffing model has to be built alongside the technology strategy, not after it.

Planning for the AI-Driven Workforce Shift in Insurance

AI is fundamentally changing how insurance companies operate. That's why workforce planning can't be an afterthought to AI strategy. It has to run alongside it. Leaders need to think through what new or redefined roles are required, how many resources each will take, who needs training or support, and what triggers staffing changes as automation matures.

Work through the steps below in sequence. Early steps focus on assessment and transition management. Later steps shift toward building the talent infrastructure your organization will need as AI becomes embedded in daily operations.

Step 1: Conduct a role impact assessment

Start by mapping which tasks AI will take over, which it will assist with, and which it won't touch. Categorize roles accordingly as fully automated, partially assisted, or unaffected and be specific about what that means for the people in them.

This isn't about deciding who stays and who goes. It's about understanding what the insurance workforce looks like after AI is in place, so you can make informed decisions about redeployment, retraining, and hiring.

Step 2: Define your transition timeline and pause non-essential hiring

Set clear rollout milestones, identify which manual processes will be phased out and when, and determine at what point staffing changes are likely to occur. Freeze hiring for roles likely to shift before a replacement is made. Use that window to re-scope open positions and determine whether temporary staffing can bridge the gap while AI implementation matures.

Ambiguity about timing creates more anxiety than the changes themselves. A clear timeline gives employees and managers something concrete to plan around.

Step 3: Communicate early, transparently, and with resources to back it up

Tell your teams what's changing, what isn't, and what the plan looks like before the rumors fill in the gaps. Employees don't resist AI because they're opposed to technology. They resist because they're uncertain about what it means for them.

Share timelines, explain how roles will evolve, and provide resources that help employees address their concerns directly, including access to career counseling, answers to common questions, and a clear point of contact for follow-up. Transparency without support is just announcements, and both are required.

Step 4: Crosstrain and redeploy ahead of the curve

Train staff for adjacent roles and build AI-specific skills including data validation, output review, and exception handling before those skills become urgent. Upskilling existing employees is almost always faster and less disruptive than hiring externally for roles that require both insurance knowledge and AI fluency.

Starting that transition early gives employees time to grow into new responsibilities rather than being pushed into them under pressure. The organizations that handle this well aren't waiting for automation to force the conversation. They're building the capability now, while there's still room to do it thoughtfully.

Step 5: Establish human-in-the-loop protocols

Assign staff to monitor AI outputs, manage escalations, and maintain compliance during early AI adoption. Human-in-the-loop oversight isn't a workaround for immature technology. It's a deliberate design choice that keeps your experts in control of decisions that matter while AI agents handle the volume work.

As model accuracy improves and teams build confidence in AI performance, the volume of exceptions requiring human review typically decreases. But getting there requires intentional oversight in the early stages, and the people doing that work need clear protocols and defined decision authority.

Step 6: Review licensing and regulatory requirements before roles shift

Redeploying staff isn't always as straightforward as rewriting a job description. In insurance, certain functions including claims adjudication in particular carry state licensing and certification requirements that follow the work, not just the title.

Identify which positions are governed by these requirements early, and factor compliance into any transition timeline. Incorporate continuing review of licensing, certification, and regulatory obligations into workforce planning so that all AI-enabled functions continue to meet jurisdictional standards as responsibilities evolve.

Step 7: Redesign job roles and career paths

As automation takes over document-heavy and rules-based work, job descriptions need to reflect what employees are actually responsible for now. Revise them to emphasize strategic tasks, AI collaboration, and the new responsibilities emerging from automation.

Define clear career paths so employees understand where their roles are heading and what development is available to them. This step matters both for retention and for accountability. If the job description still describes work the AI is now doing, you've created confusion about expectations, performance standards, and growth.

Step 8: Align staffing strategy with your long-term AI roadmap

Make sure staffing plans support the company's evolving AI strategy, automation goals, and customer experience priorities together, not just the technology rollout in isolation. Use your AI adoption roadmap and industry trends to anticipate the skills and capabilities your organization will need 12 to 24 months out across departments.

Coordinate staffing planning directly with IT and transformation teams so that AI tools and human skills develop in parallel, not in sequence. Roles focused on AI oversight, responsible use, and cross-functional coordination are already emerging at leading carriers. Building a talent pipeline for those positions now is far less costly than filling them reactively later.

Step 9: Build continuing reskilling into the operating model

Workforce transformation isn't a one-time training initiative. Implement structured, continuing reskilling opportunities focused on digital fluency, AI literacy, and adaptability that keep pace with how AI capabilities and workflows continue to change.

Invest in internships and rotational programs across functions to create a continuous pipeline of talent prepared for emerging roles. Quarterly skill refreshes, real-world scenario exercises, and internal knowledge-sharing between teams reinforce a culture where continuous learning is part of the job, not a response to disruption.

AI adoption also offers a concrete opportunity to strengthen diversity, inclusion, and succession planning. By intentionally retraining individuals from underrepresented groups for emerging roles, organizations can build more inclusive leadership pipelines while developing the talent the business genuinely needs. These goals aren't in tension. They reinforce each other.

Step 10: Develop AI oversight and governance roles

As automation scales, organizations need people whose job is to make sure it's working correctly, fairly, and in compliance with regulatory expectations. These aren't IT roles, they're operational ones.

AI workflow owners monitor agent performance and manage exceptions. Responsible AI officers oversee fairness, explainability, and audit readiness. Change and workforce transformation leads maintain employee engagement through continuing transitions. Creating these roles proactively rather than reactively is what separates organizations that scale AI confidently from those that stall.

Step 11: Monitor weekly, document continuously, and adjust based on reality

Track AI versus human workload on a weekly cadence and refine the plan based on what's actually happening, not the original projections. Record role changes, skill gaps, and planning insights as they emerge.

That documentation serves two purposes. Since early AI deployments rarely perform exactly as planned, it guides immediate staffing decisions and becomes the institutional knowledge that makes the next AI deployment faster and more predictable than the last.

The good news is that most insurance organizations still have time to get this right. According to Bevaya's State of AI Adoption in Insurance 2026 Report, 93% of insurers are now actively engaged with AI, and more than half are either testing or running AI in production.

The industry is moving, and that momentum creates a real opportunity for leaders who build their staffing model now, while AI deployment is still maturing, to get ahead of the workforce shifts rather than react to them. Companies that plan early will move through each phase with greater confidence, stronger retention, and less disruption than those who treat workforce planning as something to sort out later.

Balancing Today's Needs with Tomorrow's AI-Enabled Insurance Workforce

AI adoption in insurance is not a future event. It's happening now, at scale, across every major line of business. The carriers and TPAs that come out ahead won't just be the ones that deployed AI first. They'll be the ones that brought their workforce with them, retraining people before the pressure hit, redesigning roles before confusion set in, and building the governance and oversight structures that make automation sustainable.

Insurance has always been a people business. That doesn't change because AI can now process thousands of documents in the time it once took to process 10. What changes is what people are asked to do with their time, their expertise, and their judgment. Leaders who plan for that shift now, with the same rigor they bring to their technology investments, will build organizations that are faster, more resilient, and better positioned to deliver on the promises the industry is built on.

Transforming Insurance Means Bridging Mindsets

Modeling helps insurance leaders bridge stakeholder divides by translating complex transformation challenges into shared understanding across functions.

Alignment

Transformation projects, especially when they're "side of desk," can seem like an unwelcome responsibility and a distraction from the core work of managing a function, yet for operational executives these are frequently an opportunity for senior leadership to evaluate suitability for more strategic roles. More often than not these projects involve a requirement to re-frame well-known challenges, to communicate a vision that sticks, and to demonstrate a capability to see across the business rather than purely within one's own vertical. 

Modeling as a means of facilitating shared understanding among different stakeholders is a key tool for insurance leaders to master.

When we think of models, we might bring to mind financial forecasts or visualizations, but a model can also take the form of an analogy, a prototype, a system map, or even a road map or a project plan. We define a model as a representation of the structure and underlying rules of a concept (or set of concepts). Modeling involves mapping an idea's structure onto a form that makes its defining conditions - the underlying rules that make it possible - easier to see, explore, or test. Moreover, insofar as a model is an abstraction, it can also help to bridge communicative divides between stakeholders with different contexts or different perspectives, thus making it easier to arrive at a shared understanding - which is essential for senior leader effectiveness. Models are tools that bridge mindsets.

Project management is people management

Over the past few years, I've worked on complex transformation programs in which securing alignment on objectives and purpose was as critical as agreement on how to execute. A recent example highlights what may be a familiar challenge for many executives. Our client, Alison, was caught in the middle of a project management nightmare. She had a reputation for successful IT delivery, but the majority of these projects had been focused within her function. Now she was involved in overseeing a multi-departmental program, coordinating the replacement of a legacy underwriting platform. On the face of it, this would appear to have been a simple re-platforming exercise, except for the fact that over time it had become a fundamental source of data for a range of different systems across the enterprise, from policy and CMS systems through to the master ledger. Replacing this system involved changes across the enterprise, and as such, required understanding and buy-in from stakeholders who had limited awareness or meaningful incentive to engage.

The program had executive-level support, which helped open doors and secure time with platform owners and the business, but as the initiative moved from concept to an execution plan, misalignment emerged between finance, operations, and IT leaders. Each stakeholder had different expectations:

  • Finance pressed for outcomes that would require custom development beyond out-of-the-box capabilities of the recommended platform replacement;
  • Forecast efficiencies were contested by operations leadership, affecting the program rationale and budget;
  • IT's preferred vendor shortlist differed from operations' panel - and the latter had engaged their own leadership team to add pressure - raising concerns about impacts to scope, cost, and schedule.

We'll return to Alison's case, but when faced with this level of disconnect, our instinct can be to go on the offensive and tackle differences in perspective as skirmishes to negotiate. Another way of considering this situation, however, is to frame it as perceptual misalignment. In short, each party was interpreting the problem from their own point of view, informed by their own context, assumptions, and expectations. Bringing that to the surface - both for yourself and for your counterparty - can be helpful to isolate legitimate points of difference and exploring how to overcome these. Models are an effective tool to help us achieve this.

Why we see the same thing differently

Each of us perceives the same external environment, but we interpret it through our own lens - personal, for instance, but also institutional, such as different teams or functions that set our context - and these unique lenses lead to differences in understanding. Those differences are valuable because they help us see alternatives outside of our own way of interpreting the world (hence the value of diversity) - but what's more compelling than difference in and of itself is why we interpret our environments differently. Bringing those assumptions and framing conditions to the surface is where the value lies.

Recent research in cognitive psychology supports this focus. Pioneering work by scientists such as Karl Friston, Anil Seth, and Andy Clark asserts that our moment-to-moment experience is informed not only by the data that our physical senses collect but through a complex process of predictive modeling that shares an affinity with Bayesian statistical analysis. They argue that our experience of reality is an interpretation and as such is informed, to an extent, by underlying expectations and assumptions and beliefs. Moreover, while we may see the same world "out there" - outside of the skull-bound brain that manifests our experience but doesn't literally "see" it - we each have our own model of that reality. When we engage with each other we're often challenged by the problem of aligning these interpretive models to arrive at a shared understanding. Starting out with this recognition - that there is an inherent difference in the way each of us "reads" the world - helps us to understand the nature of the divide and leads us to explore why we're interpreting the same situation differently and how we can get onto the same page.

To see this in practice, consider an underwriter and a claims manager separately reviewing the wording of a revised commercial property policy. The underwriter sees a risk selection and pricing instrument, with a mix of conditions, sub-limits, and exclusions. He may consider how the language allows for exposure in line with the firm's risk appetite and how definitions protect against adverse selection. The claims manager reads the same document through a different lens. Drawing on years of experience at point of loss, she sees where clients are likely to contest coverage language, where exclusion wording is ambiguous enough to invite dispute, and where the gap between policyholder expectation and actual coverage may drive complaints. What looks like careful risk architecture to the underwriter is, to the claims manager, a map of potential friction. Our perception is shaped by our background, training, and the mental models we've built over time. Shared models can help bridge that perceptual divide. Analogy, deployed carefully, is one effective tool for achieving this.

Analogy can be a powerful communication and alignment tool when it's deployed with some constraints. We define an analogy as a relational structure between two models (which may be concepts, ideas, stories and so on). Analogies can be effective to help us isolate a concept from a familiar context to analyze it carefully (we can think of this like a discrete "lab environment"), or to explore abstract ideas in terms of more familiar constructs, or even to visualize problems that otherwise couldn't be observed. Think of Einstein's thought experiments when developing general relativity, for instance, imagining two lightning bolts striking the end of a train and thereby exploring the idea that simultaneity is relative and not absolute. Similarly, in one well-known example, mapping a radiology problem onto a military campaign helped to generate options for treating a cancerous tumor without killing the patient. This is the art of constructing an analogy as a model for exploration and communication - isolating the fundamental conditions and rules and consciously mapping them across to a different environment to retain focus and facilitate transfer of insights back to your original problem. When we consider the objective of achieving alignment between stakeholders, mapping a core topic into an unfamiliar setting can help to create a level perceptual playing field.

So far we've considered how modeling can help us to acknowledge and address differences in interpretation of a shared topic. Yet not all stakeholder alignment challenges are the same - there's no "one size fits all" approach. Paul Carlile's insight that misalignment may take different forms serves as a useful guide.

Addressing misalignment with models

If we aim to align stakeholders with distinctly different perspectives, and we intend to use models to do so, it helps to think of these differing viewpoints as being separated by boundaries. Carlile defines three levels of boundaries in this context (syntactic, semantic, and pragmatic). For accessibility, we may re-interpret these boundary categories as defined by:

  • A common language
  • An agreed meaning (but different languages exist)
  • Contextual differences

The first level – "a common language" (Carlile's syntactic) – applies when all parties share a similar understanding, both language and familiarity with the concepts involved, such that communication may involve direct knowledge-sharing without significant modification. A straightforward project status update may be one example of this, shared with leads of different functions who are already familiar with a program.

The second level – "an agreed meaning (but different languages exist)" (Carlile's semantic) – applies to situations in which various parties to a communication may be more or less "on the same page" but arrive at this from different perspectives or different ways of framing it. In this instance, there is a need to translate concepts from one form to another that is more readily understood. Analogy can be an effective tool in this case.

The third level - "contextual differences" (Carlile's pragmatic) - describes circumstances in which some form of transformation is required to communicate and engage. This transformation may require a change or compromise from one or more parties and may involve some cost. Models may help to bring differences to the surface that can be addressed and required changes (such as modifications to the concept design or to the budget or timeframes) may be negotiated to achieve alignment.

Returning to Alison's case, the problem that she faced was that her stakeholders were located across the organization and held very different interpretations of the IT program's impact and outcome for their own functions. As an IT leader who worked regularly with the operations team, she shared a common language that had been developed over time. The disconnect in this case was more an issue of control and resource-management. Framing her challenge in this way allowed her to carve it out from the whole and address it separately, drawing on workflow and process-mapping to illustrate anticipated efficiency benefits and systems maps along with specifications to justify vendor selection. In other words, these models along with a common language created a space where all parties could compare their understanding and negotiate points of difference. Her challenge with finance, however, was more complex.

The challenges that the finance leadership team presented stemmed from their position that they saw the re-platform as an opportunity to build new capability (specifically, to support incentive planning for distribution partners and forecasting) though they had limited awareness of the cost, time, and complexity involved in introducing non-standard features. Rather than litigating this issue with the whole team, Alison mapped a quick analogy that drew on the fundamental conditions of the proposed platform onto an example of upgrading a car's engine from a V6 to a V8 (a process thoroughly distant from both of their fields). This example helped her to illustrate the complexity of the existing transformation even before considering upgrades and additional enhancements. The example was sufficiently detailed and connected to the core problem that the finance team felt they were working through a meaningful problem and it helped to provide a clear example of the trade-offs involved before returning to the re-platforming issue at hand and finalizing the scope.

Transformation projects as proving grounds

Transformation projects, even if they're an added responsibility to an already busy schedule, are an opportunity to demonstrate your capacity to engage a wide range of stakeholders and align their efforts around a shared task. Leaders who understand why people interpret the same situation differently, and who have the tools to bridge that divide, are better positioned to turn that live audition into an appointment. The ability to model - to represent a complex idea in a form that others can see, explore, and act on - is one of the most underrated capabilities an insurance operations leader can develop.


Chris Bassett

Profile picture for user ChrisBassett

Chris Bassett

Chris Bassett is a management consultant with over 10 years of experience in operations strategy. 

He is the founder of Green Bean Consulting Group, which helps leadership teams step outside familiar thinking to tackle complex operational challenges more effectively.

What Leaders Must Still Own in the AI Era

Insurance AI is shifting from delivering software capabilities to producing measurable business outcomes, redefining what leaders must own.

Agentic AI Era

For years, much of insurance technology has been sold in the language of capability: better systems, faster models, smarter automation, more conversational interfaces. But capability alone does not create business value. In insurance, what matters is not whether an AI system can generate activity, but whether it can help produce accountable, measurable results. That is where the next real shift in insurance AI is taking place.

That distinction matters. The insurance industry does not need more demonstrations of what AI can say. It needs more evidence of what AI can actually help organizations achieve.

The real shift: from tools to outcomes

Most insurers have already seen what the first phase of AI adoption looks like. Vendors offer tools that promise efficiency gains, faster response times, more personalized engagement, or better support for frontline teams. Those improvements matter, but they are still only intermediate indicators. A faster conversation is not the same as a better business result. A more fluent recommendation is not the same as a bound policy. A lower handling cost is not the same as sustainable growth.

That is why the transition from a software mindset to a results mindset matters so much.

In my view, the difference can be captured through a baseball analogy. In baseball, the ball itself never scores. You can hit it hard, place it well, and create momentum for the team. But until someone actually reaches home plate, the run does not count.

AI in insurance increasingly resembles the batter. It can open the play. It can improve timing, precision, and opportunity creation. But creating the conditions for a result is not the same as completing the result itself. That distinction becomes especially important in insurance, where trust, accountability, compliance, and human judgment still sit at the center of value creation.

Why agentic AI changes the conversation

What makes the current moment different is that AI is no longer being asked merely to assist. It is increasingly being asked to participate in execution.

In recent years, the international technology sector has increasingly begun to describe the same shift in different terms: AI is no longer just being sold as a tool, but is starting to take on work and deliver outcomes. Sequoia gave this shift one of its clearest formulations by arguing that "services" are becoming the new software, as AI moves from enabling work to increasingly performing it. Sierra has spoken more directly about outcome-based pricing, arguing that customers should increasingly pay not for seats or usage, but for concrete results achieved. The terminology differs, but the direction is consistent: in the global technology market, "selling results" is no longer just a company-specific experiment. It is increasingly being recognized as a broader AI commercialization trend.

What is new, in other words, is not the existence of this model but the language now available to describe it. For years, versions of outcome-based delivery existed without a widely shared market vocabulary. What the current moment provides is not merely stronger technology, but a clearer way of naming and recognizing a shift that had already begun.

A recent QbitAI report on Lingxi Technology illustrates that shift in concrete terms. The report describes how the company applies large-model technology in sales environments through an outcome-based model it calls Results as a Service, or RaaS. According to the report, one insurance client that adopted Lingxi's sales agent generated RMB 2 billion (about US$295 million) in additional premium in one year. Whether one focuses on the number itself or on the broader pattern, the more important signal is this: the conversation is moving beyond whether AI can interact, and toward whether AI can consistently deliver business outcomes.

The Lingxi case is relevant not because it proves that one company has found the universal formula, but because it reflects a broader evolution in enterprise expectations. According to QbitAI, Lingxi's model is built around causal reasoning, post-training, closed-loop feedback, and real business performance rather than generic conversational ability alone. Its ACE (Agentic Customer Engagement) system is positioned not as a lightweight digital tool, but as a customer engagement agent designed to plan tasks, coordinate sub-agents, and support conversion in complex sales environments.

That does not mean outcome-based models became possible only now. A more accurate way to frame the shift is that they are only now beginning to meet the conditions for large-scale viability. Earlier versions could work, but they were heavier, slower, and far more dependent on human effort. What has changed is not the basic logic of the model, but the extent to which AI can now support its repeatability and scale.

That is a meaningful shift for insurance leaders.

Traditional large models are often impressive at generating plausible responses. But in insurance, plausibility is not enough. When a customer hesitates on a product, the critical question is not only what to say next. The deeper question is why the hesitation exists in the first place. Is the issue product misunderstanding, distrust in the claims process, pricing anxiety, family financial pressure, or uncertainty about long-term need? If AI cannot help uncover that underlying logic, then even its most polished recommendation may still be little more than statistical guesswork.

This is where causal reasoning becomes strategically important. The real value of AI in insurance does not come from sounding more human. It comes from being more useful in situations where the outcome depends on good judgment, the right sequence of actions, and clear explanation.

Causal Sovereignty: the leadership question AI does not replace

Whenever high-performing AI enters a business process, leaders often worry that they are losing control. I would frame the issue differently. In fact, when AI begins to take on more of the burden of execution, leaders are forced to return to a more important responsibility: defining what success means, where the boundaries are, and what must remain under human accountability.

That is what I call Causal Sovereignty.

AI can help identify pathways. It can surface patterns, test strategies, adapt interactions, and improve the odds of success. But it does not determine why an organization should pursue a particular outcome, what ethical constraints should apply, or what trade-offs are acceptable in getting there. Those remain leadership questions.

In insurance, this distinction is especially important. AI may help improve conversion, optimize engagement, and support premium growth. But it cannot decide how far persuasion should go, how trust should be protected, how fairness should be interpreted, or what role insurance should play in a broader social safety framework. Those are not merely technical questions. They are governance questions.

So the rise of agentic AI does not eliminate human responsibility. It clarifies it.

Seen this way, the shift is not simply about a new pricing model. It marks a deeper reallocation of responsibility. In the software era, vendors delivered capabilities while clients remained responsible for turning those capabilities into results. In an outcome-based model, providers begin to take on part of that burden directly. What changes, therefore, is not only how value is priced, but how work, accountability, and responsibility are divided.

Three rules for insurance leaders in the RaaS era

If this outcome-based model continues to spread, then insurance leaders should adjust what they demand from AI.

First, demand causality, not just performance.

If a system can tell you that something worked, but cannot help explain why it worked, then you are still managing a black box. In insurance, that is not enough.

Second, define the human-AI boundary explicitly.

Leaders need to decide where AI can act with speed and autonomy, and where human judgment remains non-negotiable. This is particularly important in areas involving compliance, brand risk, ethical sensitivity, and high-stakes commitments to customers.

Third, evaluate AI by business outcomes, not by technical spectacle.

The key question is not whether a model is advanced. The key question is whether it helps produce durable, governable, real-world results.

Insurance executives do not need to become programmers to lead through this transition. But they do need to become better judges of where AI creates real leverage, where it creates hidden risk, and where responsibility still needs a human owner.

The bottom line

AI is becoming more capable of producing measurable commercial value. That is real progress. But the more important development is not that machines are getting stronger. It is that the division of labor between humans and machines is being rewritten.

In traditional baseball, the batter hits the ball and then runs the bases himself. In the age of agentic AI, those functions are beginning to separate. The machine becomes increasingly effective at creating the conditions for progress. The human remains the one who defines the meaning of success, sets the boundaries of action, and ultimately owns the result.

That is why the future of insurance AI should not be framed simply as a story of better software. It is a story about governed outcomes.

AI may create the opening. But in insurance, humans still bring the result home.


David Lien

Profile picture for user DavidLien

David Lien

David Lien is a partner at Lingxi (Beijing) Technology. 

He wrote “Decoding New Insurance” (2020), which ranked among JD.com’s top books. Lien has held leadership roles at Sino-US MetLife, Sunshine Insurance and Prudential Taiwan, leading digital transformations and multi-channel marketing. A 2018 e27 Asia New Startup Taiwan Top 100 nominee, he holds a patent for the "Intelligent Insurance Financial Management System." 

The Surprise in the 'No Surprises' Act

Rising independent dispute resolution (IDR) volumes under the act demand insurers shift from reactive claims handling to enterprise-wide risk strategy.

Legal System

The federal court ruling regarding a dispute under the No Surprises Act (NSA) has been subject to debate throughout the healthcare and insurance sectors. Although the decision was based primarily on the extent of judicial review available for independent dispute resolution (IDR) determinations, its impact extends far beyond the context of this particular case. This ruling signifies a much larger truth for insurers, self-insured employers, TPAs and stop-loss carriers. The next stage of the NSA will be shaped by risk management strategy.

When Congress created the NSA, the intention was to protect patients from receiving unexpected medical bills while creating a method for both providers and payers to resolve payment disputes through a formalized process. However, the federal IDR process has developed into a large-volume operational process that currently affects a payer's forecasting of expenses, compliance responsibilities, potential liability due to litigation and resource usage.

Since dispute volumes continue to grow nationwide, organizations can no longer consider IDR solely as a claims-related function.

A System Developing Scale

The federal IDR process, originally designed as a mechanism for resolving select payment disagreements, has significantly exceeded usage estimates, developing into a national system processing 5.1 million disputes since its inception. The unexpected usage introduces additional risk concerns that include new administrative burdens, such as increased costs associated with managing cases and maintaining consistency within documentation, eligibility reviews and reimbursement strategies.

Consequently, participants in the IDR system have become increasingly sophisticated. As such, there exists greater amounts of data supporting each dispute filed. Filing strategies are advancing and parties are gaining experience and familiarity with the procedures and the decisionmakers. Therefore, the amount of risk involved with each IDR determination extends beyond the dollar value of each determination. Each determination will potentially influence broader reimbursement trends, reserve levels and future dispute activities.

For insurance organizations, the question goes beyond whether IDR will be a permanent feature of the healthcare landscape and shifts focus to how they will manage the associated risks.

Litigation Uncertainty Creates Another Layered Problem

The federal court decision underscores the boundaries of judicial review under the NSA. While the ruling suggests a limited role for courts in revisiting certain aspects of IDR determinations, similar disputes are continuing in various federal courts across multiple jurisdictions. Future appeals and litigation may shape the interpretation and application of judicial review under the law.

For insurers and plan sponsors, this creates a real-world concern. Traditionally, litigation provided an opportunity to clarify the applicable laws and determine whether actions were improper. Without a defined level of judicial intervention, it is more difficult for organizations to predict outcomes and assess their legal exposure.

This does not suggest litigation will cease to exist within the IDR landscape. Instead, it indicates organizations need to plan for a time when litigation results may differ across jurisdictions and unanswered legal issues may persist for lengthy periods. Under such conditions, reliance on courts to resolve operational challenges becomes increasingly impractical.

The ruling also raises broader questions regarding oversight. As dispute volume continues to grow, confidence in the long-term integrity of the IDR process depends upon consistent eligibility standards, transparent administration and meaningful accountability mechanisms. If judicial review is limited, the importance of getting those processes right at the administrative level increases substantially.

The Paradigm Shift from Reactive to Proactive Risk Management

As litigation pathways become less predictable, risk management must begin looking forward. Many organizations historically regarded payment disputes as independent events that occurred individually and therefore could be resolved post-dispute. Such a philosophy is becoming less viable as disputes are occurring in the thousands and each IDR determination can have cumulative financial implications.

A more sustainable model of risk management begins prior to arbitration. Organizations should adopt clear governance models for eligibility review, reimbursement methodology and dispute documentation. Similarly, internal processes should ensure that positions taken during dispute resolution processes are supported by consistent data, defendable payment rationale and adequate documentation.

Equally important is identifying patterns, such as large volume filing activity, frequently disputed categories and geographic trends, which provides useful information relative to future exposure. Organizations that understand where future exposures may occur are better able to allocate resources and respond proactively. The objective of this paradigm shift is not merely winning individual disputes but rather developing an architecture that allows for consistent decision making within increasing complexity.

IDR Has Become an Enterprise Risk Issue

Perhaps the most critical takeaway from recent developments is that IDR cannot be assessed solely from a claims administration perspective. The financial impacts relate to budgeting, reserving and managing health care related costs. Operational impacts relate to staffing, workflow and administrative efficiencies. Legal impacts relate to compliance with regulations, dispute resolution practices and litigation strategy. Collectively these factors raise IDR from a reimbursement issue to an enterprise-wide risk management issue.

As such, greater organizational involvement is required. Allowing IDR to be managed from an enterprise-risk perspective involves collaboration among all relevant departments including legal teams, claims professionals, financial leadership and executive-level stakeholders.

If organizations continue to treat IDR as a normal administrative process, they may find themselves responding reactively to emerging problems. Organizations that integrate IDR into their overall risk management program will be best situated to manage future uncertainty.

Looking Forward

This federal court decision may ultimately be remembered more for what it reveals about the evolving nature of the IDR system than for any immediate legal ramifications. As IDR continues to scale nationally, the healthcare sector is entering a period where operational discipline, data-based oversight and proactive governance will become increasingly essential.

Regardless of how future courts choose to interpret the scope of judicial review under the NSA, one fact appears evident. Those organizations most likely to successfully navigate this evolving regulatory landscape will not be those who focus on individual IDR disputes. Rather, those who recognize IDR as a strategic risk management challenge and invest in the infrastructure, expertise and oversight needed to address it.

What Decision Rights Should AI Have?

Most insurers deploying AI never explicitly decide which decisions the model controls, creating regulatory and operational risk by default.

Tech

Here's a sentence that should alarm every carrier deploying AI:

Most insurers adopting AI never explicitly decide which decisions the model gets to make.

We decide on the vendor. The budget. The implementation timeline. The model-risk review. The filing. Then we switch the thing on and let the boundary between machine decisions and human decisions get negotiated by accident — one workflow at a time, by whomever happens to be configuring the rules engine that day.

It's like hiring a brilliant new chief underwriter, never defining the role, and then acting surprised when they're quietly setting appetite 18 months later.

In a regulated industry, that drift isn't just operational risk — it's the kind of thing a market-conduct examiner asks about. The fix is a discipline I call Decision Rights, and it sorts every decision in your operation into one of three tiers.

Tier 1: DELEGATE — the machine decides, humans audit

Delegate-tier decisions share three traits: they're reversible, low-stakes individually, and high-volume. Routing a first notice of loss to the right queue. Flagging a claim for SIU review. Straight-through processing of small, reversible claims within preset limits. Triaging submissions against appetite. If the model gets one wrong, you catch it, fix it, and move on.

Delegating these isn't surrender — it's strategy. Every hour an adjuster or underwriter spends on a call the machine can make safely is an hour stolen from the calls only they can make.

Two rules keep Tier 1 honest. First, sample audits: humans review a random slice of the model's calls, because unwatched systems drift — and drift in rating or claims handling is how you end up explaining a disparate-impact pattern you never intended. Second, escape hatches: any policyholder or producer can pull a decision up a tier. The insured who says "I want a human" gets one. Always.

Tier 2: AUGMENT — AI drafts, a named human decides

This is the default tier for consequential calls, and it should be the biggest tier in your charter. The model does what it does best: gathers, scores, surfaces options at speed. Then a named human does what only humans can do — weighs it against context, exposure, and fairness, and makes the call with their name on it.

The operative word is named. Augment-tier decisions have a single accountable owner, and that owner must be able to defend the decision from a blank whiteboard, no model in the room. In insurance that isn't a metaphor: if an underwriter can't explain a decline without pointing at a score, you can't issue a defensible adverse-action notice — and you can't answer the regulator who asks why. If you can't explain it without the tool, you haven't decided. You've subscribed.

Tier 3: RESERVE — human-only; the machine may inform, never recommend

Some decisions should never carry an AI recommendation at all — not because the model couldn't produce one, but because the act of producing it contaminates the judgment. A recommendation is an anchor. Once the room has seen "the model suggests deny," every human thought gets measured against deny, and dissent starts to feel like arguing with math.

Reserve-tier in insurance includes: decisions that materially affect a person's livelihood or access to coverage, large-loss and potential bad-faith determinations, anything touching unfair discrimination or vulnerable policyholders, and the company-shaping strategic bets — entering a line, acquiring a book. Plus a catch-all worth memorizing:

Anything you must personally defend to a regulator, a policyholder, or a court.

If you'd be uneasy saying "the model recommended it" under oath, the decision was Reserve-tier all along. AI can still inform — pull the loss history, model the scenarios — but the synthesis, the weighing, and the recommendation stay in human hands from start to finish.

The three-question tier test

For any decision in front of you right now:

  1. Is it reversible? Can you unwind it without harming a policyholder or breaching a filing? If yes, it might be delegable. If no, climb a tier.
  2. Who answers for it? If you can't name the human — and an examiner asks "who decided this?" — you've found a problem in progress.
  3. Would I sign my name to it, in a market-conduct exam? If the thought makes you flinch, it's Reserve-tier.
What happens when you publish one

The first time a program lead publishes a charter, something unexpected tends to happen: half the political fights on the team simply evaporate. The friction was never really about the technology. It was unspoken anxiety over who actually owned what. The charter doesn't restrict anyone — it relieves everyone. People fight hardest in undefined territory. Draw the map, and the shooting mostly stops.

A governance note, because insurance lives and dies on it: AI's arrival tempts organizations to give the algorithm a letter on the RACI chart. Fine — let the model be Responsible or Consulted on plenty of rows. But the A never goes to the algorithm. Accountability requires someone who can be promoted, demoted, thanked, or fired — and someone a regulator can hold answerable. The day your RACI has an A with no heartbeat behind it, your governance is decorative.

Build yours before the tool builds it for you

You can stand up a first draft in an afternoon: list your highest-volume AI-touched decisions, sort each into Delegate, Augment, or Reserve, name an owner for every Augment and Reserve row, and write down the audit cadence for Tier 1. Then publish it, and defend it the way you'd defend any filing — because in this industry, sooner or later, you will.


Matthew Arthurs

Profile picture for user MatthewArthurs

Matthew Arthurs

Matthew Arthurs is a lieutenant colonel in the U.S. Army National Guard and a program-delivery strategist who has governed large engineering and operations portfolios in regulated industries, including insurtech. 

He is the author of the Decisive Edge series, including "Decisive AI: Reducing Decision Debt and Preserving Human Judgment in the Age of Artificial Intelligence."

Legacy Businesses Risk Obsolescence

Legacy businesses face a critical choice: adapt while preserving core values or risk obsolescence by resisting necessary change.

AI

Legacy businesses are feeling the pressure. Pressure to modernize, to adapt, to adopt this new AI tool or that new automated process. Pick up the pace. Cut production time in half — and do it all with half as many humans on the payroll. The message is loud and clear: Get on board or get left behind.

But the real threat to legacy businesses isn't AI. It's not a massive influx of new technology or dramatic changes in the workforce.

The real threat is resistance to change. It's the belief that what worked for the last 50 years will continue to work for the next 50.

I understand the instinct to operate from an "If it ain't broke…" mentality. In many legacy businesses, long-standing systems and processes aren't simply operational choices; they're often tied to memories, milestones, or moments of success and growth in the business. But in an era where the newest technology is driving the conversation and shaping the industry, it would be naive to believe a legacy business can thrive by simply maintaining the status quo.

As a second-generation leader, I feel this conflict personally. I grew up in The Brokerage Inc., watching my parents build it from the ground up, making difficult decisions along the way, never losing sight of their purpose. I saw their work ethic, their dedication, and the sacrifices they made to turn their dream into a reality — a legacy that would outlast them.

When your business also carries personal, emotional ties, leadership comes with a different kind of weight. Every decision must be viewed through several lenses: Will this make the business stronger? Will it help us better serve our customers? Does it require us to sacrifice our core mission or ideals? Can we adapt and stay competitive without losing the values that made the company worth preserving?

So how do legacy business leaders keep up with rapidly changing technology, shifting workforce expectations and a competitive marketplace, while preserving what our predecessors built and entrusted to us?

Reinvent Without Replacing

Reinventing your business does not mean abandoning your identity. In fact, the strongest companies are often the ones that know their identity well enough to inherently understand what should and shouldn't be changed.

Insurance is still a deeply relationship-driven business, especially during major life, health, and financial decisions. Trust matters. Service matters. The ability to guide people through major decisions matters. Those are not outdated values. They're intertwined with our core beliefs and a major part of who we are.

But the way we support those relationships can and should evolve.

With AI bursting onto the scene, many legacy business leaders see it as a disruptor — the antithesis of that deeply personal, human connection that makes up the very foundation of their business. Customers need more than just information. They need guidance. They need confidence. They need someone who can help them understand their options and make the right decisions.

The fear of losing that personal touch is causing some leaders to dig their heels in and double down on their "business as usual" attitude. But what if we could shift our perspective a bit? If we view AI as a multiplier for strong organizations, instead of a replacement for human connection, it could be that extra ingredient that makes already-strong teams even stronger, helping them make an even bigger impact, be more responsive, more efficient, and more focused on meeting the needs of their customers.

Supporting Tradition Doesn't Mean Stagnation

The same balance applies to tradition. I sometimes hear people talk about legacy businesses as if their longevity came from doing things the same way forever. But no business survives for decades without adapting. The founders of long-standing companies have all faced disruption at some point. It may not have been AI, machine learning, or automation, but they had to navigate change, take risks, adjust their thinking and make hard decisions in real time.

A company that is still standing in its second or third generation is not proof that change can be avoided. It is proof that someone before us was willing to change when change was needed.

This perspective has helped me reframe modernization. Change is not a betrayal of what previous generations built. In many cases, it is the most respectful thing we can do for it.

If my parents had not been flexible, determined, and willing to evolve, there would be no legacy for me to help carry forward. So, the question for leaders like me is not, "How do we keep everything the same?" The better question is, "How do we protect the purpose — the reason we do what we do — while adapting to new methods of doing it?"

Guiding the New Generations

That question applies to people, too. There's concern in our industry about whether younger generations are even interested in insurance, sales, agencies, or ownership anymore. I understand the concern, but I choose to view it differently. In my experience, younger generations are interested in this industry, particularly when they see opportunity, mentorship, entrepreneurship, flexibility and purpose. It's our responsibility to provide these opportunities, help nurture their curiosity, demonstrate our purpose, mentor and guide the new generation coming in.

Last week, an old friend and teammate from my college volleyball days called me out of the blue. She coaches a young woman who is about to graduate and start her career in life insurance sales. She and a few friends will be joining a captive agency.

But my friend didn't call to ask if I would recruit the student or entice her to come work with us instead. She called because she knew I would be genuinely excited to hear that a college graduate was entering the industry and that I would love the opportunity to speak to her and encourage her.

She was right. I was excited.

Here's this young woman, fresh out of college, choosing to pursue our industry. She wants to learn how to network, build relationships, generate leads, and maybe one day open her own agency. I told her I thought starting captive could be a great path, because it can provide structure, training, and exposure to the business.

I hung up feeling hopeful. Excited for the future.

There are important moments when we, as leaders, need to recognize our role in preserving and growing this industry. If we only make time to mentor young talent working for us, we're doing ourselves, the industry overall, and this up-and-coming generation a disservice. The industry needs capable, ethical, motivated people entering the business, regardless of where they begin.

And who knows? Maybe one day, when she decides to go independent, I'll be her first call. Maybe not. Regardless of where she ends up, the industry is better off with her in it.

Succession and Stewardship

Another big question that surrounds legacy businesses today is succession. But it's about more than transferring ownership. Of course, ownership matters. Governance matters. Titles, roles, and responsibilities matter. But those are only part of the handoff.

The harder question is whether the next generation understands why this business exists, what core values we uphold that should never be compromised, and how to keep evolving when the market changes again. Because it will.

My parents wanted me to have the opportunity to lead one day, but that opportunity came with the expectation that I understand every aspect of the business, from the ground up. Starting in an entry level position was not a formality. It was crucial for me to see, experience, and respect every moving part of this business, the people doing the work, and the responsibility that comes with every decision.

That experience shaped how I think about change. The farther you are from the day-to-day work, the easier it is to talk about transformation in theory. But when you understand the people, processes and relationships inside a business, you realize change has to be both bold and thoughtful. It must move the company forward without dismissing the people who helped build it.

The Balancing Act for Legacy Businesses

We have to ask ourselves difficult questions. Are we protecting our values, or are we protecting our comfort? Are we honoring our history, or are we hiding behind it? Are we preparing the next generation to preserve what we built while also pushing it forward?

The future will not belong only to the newest companies or the most technologically advanced ones. It will belong to organizations that can combine trust and tradition with flexibility and adaptability. It will belong to leaders who understand that legacy is not a reason to resist change. It's a reason to embrace it and use it to shape the future of your company — so the relationships, trust, and culture it was built on can endure for another generation.

Why In-Plan Annuity Adoption Lags

Even though 92% of workers want employer-offered income solutions, in-plan annuity adoption lags due to education gaps, fiduciary concerns and design complexity.

Annuities

A convergence of forces is reshaping the U.S. retirement landscape. With only about 15% of private-sector workers covered by traditional pensions—and continuing concerns about Social Security's long-term solvency—the burden on individual savings has never been greater.

Asset managers and carriers have responded with in-plan annuity solutions designed to convert savings into guaranteed lifetime income, most commonly embedded within target-date funds (TDFs)—the path of least resistance for sponsors and participants.

Recent Alvarez & Marsal research among participants aged 40–60 highlights the latent demand: Only 3% had heard of in-plan annuities, yet 92% want their employer to offer income solutions, and 84% would be more likely to purchase if automatically included in their plan. Seventy percent ranked guaranteed lifetime income as "most important," with fear of outliving savings scoring 4.29 out of 5.

Despite this, adoption remains low. Only 6–16% of plans currently offer guaranteed in-plan income solutions, with uptake concentrated among larger employers. Participants remain largely unaware.

Yet 2025–2026 marks a potential tipping point. Assets in TDFs with annuity components reached $42 billion by March 2026, up nearly 70% year-over-year. Broader multi-asset portfolios with embedded annuities now exceed $115 billion. TIAA research shows 76% of defined contribution plan sponsors expect demand to grow significantly by 2030. JPMorgan's 2025 survey found 79% of sponsors believe their plans should help participants generate retirement income, and 61% of non-offerers are likely to consider adding an option this year.

Interest is rising. Adoption is not. Here's what's holding it back—and what can accelerate progress.

Common Adoption Challenges

1. Lack of Cohesive Education and Marketing

Industry efforts remain fragmented and provider-specific. A broader coalition is needed to build foundational awareness before stakeholders can meaningfully compare solutions. Without a shared understanding of what in-plan annuities are and how they work, differentiation efforts fall flat.

2. Inconsistent Terminology

Confusion persists between standalone in-plan annuities and TDFs with retirement income features or managed payout strategies. Advisers have historically preferred embedded solutions within the QDIA. The absence of a common taxonomy breeds hesitation and slows adoption across plan sponsors and consultants.

3. Cost and Complexity Concerns

Sponsors cite administrative and operational costs, especially for mid-size and smaller employers. Participants worry about fees and ROI. High-net-worth segments are less cost-sensitive but place greater emphasis on inflation protection and customization. For most plans, perceived complexity remains a significant deterrent to even evaluating solutions.

4. Fiduciary and Litigation Risk

Even with SECURE 2.0 safe harbors for annuity provider selection, fiduciary concerns remain high inside organizations. Only 37% of sponsors feel confident explaining annuity value to decision-makers. The psychological weight of potential litigation often outweighs the regulatory protections currently available.

5. Plan Design and Portability

Participants want simplicity and portability—especially given an average of 13+ job changes over a career. They want a clear answer to: "If I contribute $X, what monthly income will I receive at age Y?" Older participants tend to prioritize flexibility and portability, while younger participants are more interested in accumulation incentives. There is no one-size-fits-all design.

6. Explanation of Benefits at Scale

Participants trust advisors most (4.35 out of 5). Their confidence in researching financial products is high (4.33 out of 5), but confidence in independently purchasing an in-plan annuity drops sharply to 3.42 out of 5. Scaling credible, trusted guidance—whether through financial advisors, trained benefits consultants, or well-designed hybrid models—remains one of the largest barriers to mass adoption.

Driving Adoption with Plan Advisers and Consultants

Advisers and consultants are the most influential gatekeepers. Roughly 90–92% of sponsors work with them, and their recommendations heavily shape what gets evaluated and ultimately adopted. Conversations with experienced plan consultants reveal several practical realities that providers must address.

Advisers Filter Ruthlessly for Fit and Ease

Solutions that feel complex, poorly integrated, or hard to explain to plan committees are quickly dismissed. Recordkeeper-bundled solutions have a clear advantage due to seamless data flows, participant experience, and lower operational lift—if the underlying product delivers clear value. Direct-from-carrier or asset-manager solutions must demonstrate materially better outcomes or stronger fiduciary support to overcome the added friction of an extra vendor relationship.

Fiduciary Risk Perception Is a Major Barrier

Even with safe harbors, fiduciary exposure feels real inside sponsor organizations. Many plan sponsors view involving a trusted fiduciary advisor—whether their existing consultant or a specialized third party—as one of the cleanest ways to satisfy their duties when introducing complex income products. Providers that offer robust due-diligence packages, clear participant outcome data, continuing monitoring tools, and transparent governance support see significantly higher win rates.

Education and Hybrid Support Are Now Table Stakes

Advisers consistently identify participant education and communication as one of the largest remaining hurdles. Hybrid models that combine a plan-level income solution with targeted, personalized guidance at key inflection points (age 55+, termination, or when participants begin thinking seriously about drawdowns) are gaining traction. Pure "do-it-yourself" approaches are viewed skeptically for most participants. Well-designed "do-it-for-me" solutions with smart guardrails and limited, meaningful choice are generally preferred.

Preference for Thoughtful Choice, Not Overload

Sponsors and participants like the idea of having two or three well-designed income pathways rather than a single rigid option. However, the choice must feel meaningful—different risk profiles, liquidity features, or guarantee levels—rather than confusing. True personalization (factoring in age, health, outside assets, and spending goals) is conceptually appealing but often loses to simplicity, cost transparency, and ease of explanation in real plan committee discussions. Winning solutions offer an intuitive core experience paired with a small number of high-value options.

Retaining Terminated and Retired Participants

As plans become more income-focused, attitudes toward allowing former employees to remain in the plan for continuing drawdown are evolving. Advisers see this as both an opportunity for deeper engagement and greater scale, and a new set of fiduciary and operational considerations. Solutions that handle portability, in-plan income, and former-participant servicing seamlessly gain favor.

Adviser guidance is clear: stop leading with product features and start leading with how solutions reduce perceived risk, simplify decisions for sponsors and participants, and improve measurable outcomes.

Driving Adoption with Plan Sponsors

Securing sponsor acceptance is essential—especially through TDF or QDIA defaults—so participants can actually enroll.

Develop Turnkey, Simple In-Plan Solutions

Participants want formulaic transparency: a clear mapping of contributions to future monthly income at a specific retirement age, with limited customization. Standardized, streamlined solutions with straightforward administration are especially attractive to mid-market sponsors who lack the resources or expertise for complex implementations. The rapid growth of TDFs with annuity components demonstrates that embedding income solutions in familiar structures significantly reduces friction.

Offer Flexible but Manageable Menus

Borrowing from the voluntary benefits "cafeteria" model, sponsors can offer a shelf of options that address different participant segments—while avoiding choice overload. Strong defaults paired with decision-support tools are essential. The goal is meaningful choice without overwhelming participants or plan committees.

Tackle Litigation Risk Through Process Excellence

Carriers can help by offering simplified product designs, clear governance frameworks, and options such as funding in-plan income solutions exclusively through employer match or non-elective contributions (reducing participant decision risk). Full use of SECURE 2.0 safe harbors—combined with strong insurer financial ratings, transparent selection processes, and continuing plan committee education—further de-risks adoption for sponsors.

Driving Adoption with Plan Participants

Participant adoption, contribution levels, and long-term retention should be core KPIs for any in-plan annuity provider. Research and adviser feedback point to several high-impact levers.

Design for Radical Simplicity and Portability

Participants value clarity and mobility. Products must deliver an intuitive understanding of the value exchange and accommodate the reality of frequent job changes. Portability features and rollover-friendly design are table stakes for building trust across life stages.

Close the Explanation-of-Benefits Gap

Participants trust financial advisors far more than digital tools or chatbots. Human expertise—whether through financial advisors for higher-net-worth segments or trained benefits consultants and hybrid models for broader populations—will be required in the near term. Clear calculators, scenario modeling, and "If I contribute $X, what monthly income will I receive at age Y?" illustrations are non-negotiable for building confidence.

Provide Credible, Independent Comparisons

Participants want to understand how in-plan annuities compare—not only to other annuity products but also to alternatives such as indexed universal life insurance, real estate, or systematic withdrawal strategies. Credible, easy-to-understand independent or third-party illustration tools will be essential for informed decision-making and for demonstrating relative value.

Demographics matter: younger participants tend to respond to long-term accumulation combined with a guarantee, while older participants and pre-retirees prioritize decumulation security, flexibility, and portability. High-net-worth participants, who already work with advisors at much higher rates, represent an important beachhead for advisor-distributed solutions.

Conclusion

The in-plan annuity market has reached an inflection point. Macro tailwinds—erosion of traditional pensions, heightened longevity awareness, surging assets in TDFs with annuity components, and the SECURE 2.0 framework—have created the conditions for acceleration. But translating interest into widespread adoption will require deliberate, coordinated action across advisers, sponsors, and participants.

Further federal policy clarity (building on SECURE 2.0) and industry collaboration on common terminology, education standards, and best practices would remove significant friction. Carriers and asset managers, however, control the most important variables. They can define clear KPIs for each stakeholder group—adviser recommendation rates, sponsor adoption percentages, and participant enrollment and satisfaction—measure performance rigorously, and iterate quickly with simpler, more trustworthy, and better-designed solutions.

Those who move decisively now—armed with clear evidence of massive latent demand against a backdrop of only 3% awareness—will be best positioned to capture meaningful share of the trillions in defined contribution assets moving into decumulation. The window for leadership in this next chapter of retirement plan innovation is open, but it will not remain open indefinitely.


Chris Taylor

Profile picture for user ChrisTaylor

Chris Taylor

Chris Taylor is a director within Alvarez & Marsal’s insurance practice.

He focuses on M&A, performance improvement, and restructuring/turnaround. He brings over a decade of experience in the insurance industry, both as a consultant and in-house with carriers.