Download

What Cyber Underwriting Is Missing

Cyber underwriting has become adept at measuring technology. The missing signal may be the condition of the organization responsible for keeping it secure.

Organizational Deterioration

Since the ransomware crunch of 2020, cyber underwriting has gotten steadily more external and more technical: attack-surface scans at quote, patching cadence wired into the catastrophe models, and third-party telemetry now feeding the major vendor platforms. Global cyber rates have kept falling through early 2026 even as claim frequency rises.

All of cyber underwriting measures the current state of technology. Almost none of it measures whether the organization behind those controls is deteriorating: losing the people who understand its systems, struggling through major organizational change, or cutting the resources needed to sustain operations.

Is that kind of operational strain visible from the outside and distinguishable from the ordinary noise any large company produces? To find out, we traced public signals in the year before three major breaches: TCS, CDK Global and Change Healthcare – plus a peer control study for TCS. In each case, the deterioration left a public, dated record months before the loss.

The signals are public posts: employee reviews on Glassdoor, AmbitionBox, Indeed and Blind, and practitioner and customer threads on Reddit. We ignored general dissatisfaction and looked for dated observations tied to identifiable roles, in four categories: organizational instability, security dysfunction, financial distress, service degradation.

The outsourcer

The connection is most direct at TCS, a services business where the workforce is the product it sells. Through 2025, it held an A on SecurityScorecard, a rating that spans everything from patching cadence to how exposed its people are to being targeted.

Across the 201 signals, the recurring themes were constant reorganization, experienced staff leaving faster than they were replaced, and people put on work they weren't equipped for. Four months before the M&S attack, a TCS consultant described being presented to clients as a cybersecurity analyst despite never having worked in that role. Months earlier, a SOC analyst listed "slow incident response" among his team's problems.

In April 2025, attackers called the IT helpdesk TCS had run for Marks & Spencer since 2018 and talked staff into a reset; M&S put the profit impact near £300 million. Jaguar Land Rover followed months later, at an estimated £1.9 billion cost to the UK economy. TCS ran IT there too, though the public record doesn't establish that its people were the ones socially engineered.

The obvious objection is that every Indian IT major generates this kind of noise. So we ran the same collection on Infosys, Wipro and HCLTech: 501 signals across the three, against TCS's 201. All four show reorganization noise. But security staff are about 8% of TCS's signals against roughly 3% at the nearest peers. While the baseline volume varies by firm, only TCS showed a concentration of security-role complaints describing problems within the security function itself.

The buyout

At CDK, the pressure came through ownership. Brookfield took the company private in 2022 in a deal backed by roughly $5.8 billion of debt, and public posts began documenting the operational consequences.

From June 2023 to the day before the attack, employees across engineering, support, sales and training described the same sequence: repeated layoffs, work shifted to the outsourcing partner Genpact, and the people who understood the systems walking out with each cut. A trainer who left in February 2024 traced it to the top: a 30% margin wasn't enough for the CEO, so he cut across the board to reach 40%. That same month, a director's advice to management consisted of three words: "stabilize the talent drain."

Security leadership also became harder to identify. David Hahn, CDK's first publicly identifiable CISO – a role the company first filled in 2020 – joined Ballistic Ventures as CISO-in-Residence in December 2022. We found no public evidence of a successor before the ransomware attack. Across dealership forums, users described repeated outages, with one writing during a July 2023 incident that the platform was "up for 3 minutes and then down for 30."

In June 2024, BlackSuit ransomware hit and froze nearly 15,000 dealerships, about $1 billion in dealer losses. CDK never disclosed the intrusion vector, so no causal link can be drawn. What the public record does show is that the organization operating those systems had been under visible operational pressure for a year beforehand.

The pattern is structural: across private-equity portfolios, where the incentives are the same, S-RM found 72% of firms had a serious cyber incident in their portfolio within three years. In February this year, Bloomberg reported on Ivanti, which Clearlake Capital had taken private. Cost-cutting there stripped out the engineers who understood the company's VPN code, and Chinese state hackers exploited the resulting flaws to reach US government and corporate networks. Some government and corporate buyers, Bloomberg reported, now factor private-equity ownership into how they assess security products. In the same report, Rob Leahy, former CIO of NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, said ownership structure should be part of any product risk assessment: "Are they investing in the future or are they not?"

The rollup

Change Healthcare was assembled by serial acquisition and run for margin, where cost-cutting meant deferring integration. Optum, UnitedHealth's health-services arm, absorbed it in October 2022.

Across the 142 signals we collected from Change and its new parent, employees repeatedly described experienced staff leaving and the loss of institutional knowledge. One review summarized the effect as "letting the knowledge walk out the door." Another, posted in November 2023, three months before the breach, described acquired companies as "not integrated into network sometimes ever."

In February 2024, attackers got in through a single internet-facing Citrix portal with no multi-factor authentication (MFA). By the CEO's later congressional testimony, it ran on technology acquired in 2022 that had never been brought under the company's own MFA policy. The breach reached 192.7 million people, at a cost UnitedHealth put at $3.09 billion for 2024 alone, the largest healthcare data breach on record.

Change is one of three Optum acquisitions to have been breached since 2023; Solutran and Episource followed, the last hit twice, in 2023 and in 2025. Two years after the attack, UnitedHealth was still consolidating 18 acquired medical-record systems down to three. Acquisitiveness itself leaves a statistical trace: a 2025 study of 5,072 U.S. firms found the more a company acquires, the more breaches it experiences, the effect growing when acquirer and target come from different businesses.

Organizational deterioration is already familiar to cyber insurers. It appears in breach investigations, claims files and post-loss reviews, where staffing shortages, restructurings and operational strain often help explain how technical failures developed. By then, however, those signals are explanatory rather than predictive. The cases here suggest that some of the same patterns are visible months earlier in public operational data.

Three cases chosen for how they ended cannot establish predictive value on their own; that requires knowing how often the same signals appear at companies that never suffer a loss. The TCS peer comparison is a first attempt at that question.

Cyber underwriting has become increasingly sophisticated at measuring the state of the technology. Whether the organization behind those controls is changing in ways that affect cyber resilience is not yet part of how the risk is priced.

How to Accelerate Recovery From Floods

Bipartisan legislation would use federal mitigation funds to support parametric flood insurance, accelerating disaster recovery in underinsured communities.

flood

Forecasts suggest this year's hurricane season could bring lower than average storm activity. But disaster risk is not measured solely by the number of named storms.

It only takes one major flood to expose the vulnerabilities that persist across the US flood protection system. And increasingly, flood losses are not confined to coastal communities or storm surge alone. Flooding driven by heavy rainfall, overflowing rivers, and flash floods are increasingly affecting communities far beyond traditional flood zones, often in places where insurance take-up is low and financial resilience is limited.

This reality highlights an urgent policy challenge; America's flood protection gap continues to widen at a time when economic exposure is growing.

Flooding can happen almost anywhere, yet millions of American households and businesses remain uninsured or underinsured against flood risk. When disasters strike, the consequences extend well beyond individual property losses, which alone are already devastating. Delayed recovery affects local employers, municipal budgets, infrastructure systems, housing markets, and broader regional economic activity.

Insurance plays a critical role in helping individuals, businesses, and communities recover more quickly and reducing long-term economic disruption. Strong insurance participation supports financial stability after disasters, accelerates rebuilding, and reduces reliance on post-event federal assistance. It's an essential component of economic resilience for all Americans.

That's why Congress should advance the bipartisan Community Flood Resilience Act, introduced by Congressman Andrew Garbarino and Congressman Gregory Meeks.

The legislation reflects a pragmatic recognition that resilience requires both physical mitigation and financial preparedness. By allowing a portion of federal flood mitigation assistance funding to support community-based parametric flood insurance solutions, Congress is advancing a thoughtful public-private sector approach to disaster resilience.

This legislation does not replace the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). Instead, it acknowledges that public and private solutions can work together to expand protection, improve awareness, and strengthen recovery capabilities. In today's evolving risk environment, collaboration is essential.

Community-based parametric insurance provides funding when predefined conditions are met, such as measured rainfall levels, river heights, or other objective flood triggers. Because payments are tied to those triggers rather than lengthy loss-adjustment processes, communities can access funds much more quickly after a disaster. Faster access to funding can help local governments stabilize essential services, support small businesses, and assist vulnerable populations during the critical days immediately after flooding occurs.

Speed matters after disasters. Delays in recovery funding often translate into prolonged economic hardship for communities already under strain. Parametric insurance policies can deliver payments within 30 days, or less, when the funds are needed the most.

The legislation also emphasizes education, outreach, and transparency. Participating communities must describe how they promote flood insurance awareness, encourage mitigation efforts, and communicate clearly about how these products function alongside traditional coverage. These provisions recognize that resilience begins with understanding what's at risk.

The insurance industry has long played a foundational role in supporting economic growth and recovery following catastrophic events. As risks evolve, innovation in risk transfer and resilience financing will increasingly become important complements to infrastructure investment, stronger building standards, and disaster mitigation programs.

Public-private collaboration will be critical to narrowing the protection gap. Legislation like the Community Flood Resilience Act demonstrates how policymakers can encourage innovation while strengthening community preparedness and preserving the role of insurance in supporting economic resilience.

Resilience is built before disasters through smarter planning, stronger mitigation, and broader financial protection. Public policy that improves flood insurance participation and accelerates recovery better protects homes and businesses, and promotes the long-term economic stability of communities across the country.

As flood risk expands beyond traditional geographic boundaries, policymakers need tools that strengthen both physical resilience and financial preparedness. The Community Flood Resilience Act is a practical way to do both.


Adrian Hall

Profile picture for user AdrianHall

Adrian Hall

Adrian Hall is CEO US for Swiss Re Corporate Solutions.

He is also a member of the Swiss Re Corporate Solutions global executive committee and a board director for Swiss Re Corporate Solutions America Insurance.

Previously, he was the managing director & head, UK, Ireland, South Africa and EMEA Wholesale, and CEO & Chief, Agent Canada, for Swiss Re Corporate Solutions. An insurance industry veteran with over 30 years of experience, he has lived and worked across five continents.

Hall holds a bachelor of science degree in business from University of Wales, Swansea and a master’s certification in marketing leadership from York University, Schulich Business School, Canada.

Radical Efficiencies in Insurance

Aerial imaging provides near-real-time intelligence that takes cost out of claims, providing a blueprint for efficiency in other parts of the insurance industry. 

Interview

Paul Carroll

The insurance industry has long operated in a paper-driven, inefficient way, with only about 60 cents of every premium dollar going out in claims. Improving operational efficiency could help get more people insured while reducing costs—which is why we delve into the topic every year for ITL Focus. To start us off: How does Eagleview's technology make the claims process for property insurance more efficient than it has been historically?

Patrick Gill

Eagleview has been in existence for more than 25 years.  We started with government use cases such as tax assessment but quickly expanded to other industries such as insurance based on the notion that what works for government tax assessors likely also works for inspectors and appraisers of any type, including insurance claims use cases. We're flying airplanes with proprietary camera technology over the entire U.S. and large parts of Canada on a regular basis. We capture high-resolution imagery both with orthogonal—so, top-down—views, as well as views from each 45-degree angle. This enables us to build 3D models of properties. From that, you can extract measurements, study the roof condition, and analyze other attributes of a property.

One of Eagleview's most significant contributions to the insurance industry has been providing precise, independent, and objective property measurements. One of the big parts of the claim is the reconciliation between what the adjuster thinks needs to be done to repair a property and what the contractor or homeowner thinks. This frequently resulted in unnecessary disputes and inefficiencies—arguing over the size of a roof, for example, with people up there with competing tape measures coming up with different numbers. Eagleview created a standard that both contractors and insurance adjusters could agree on and made that go away.

There are plenty of other things to debate, but suddenly, the measurement portion of building a roof repair or roof replacement estimate went away. To your core thesis here, Eagleview has always been about trying to deliver operational efficiency into the insurance claims process.

How much detail you can have about a property before you have to physically roll out to it creates all kinds of opportunities for efficiency. Our capabilities have expanded well beyond measurements to include a broad range of property intelligence.

Our mantra is: How much better can you operate if you know more before you go? A lot of money is spent on third-party ladder assist companies going up and doing the tall and steep structures, for safety reasons and lots of other things. But if you don't know for sure what property is tall and steep, oftentimes you're sending out your own adjuster. If he gets out there, then realizes that it's tall or steep and then needs to order a third-party ladder assist, that costs time and maybe means another visit to the property—waste that can be eliminated if you can have that information upfront.

That's one example. Where we've been moving is: How much more data can we serve into the claims triage and routing process to make sure they're intelligently managed, with the right resources the first time for the cleanest, fastest, most efficient resolution?

Paul Carroll

I imagine that once a hailstorm hits an area and you fly a plane over it, aerial imagery can help insurers make decisions about the whole area and recovery process, beyond what they can know about individual houses. 

Patrick Gill

Resolution hasn't quite gotten to the point where you can see actual hail hits. We're almost there, but not quite. The long-term vision is straightforward. A huge hailstorm hits Colorado Springs, we quickly get a plane over the area, and then claims can be handled remotely.

But I'll tell you what the first phase in that direction is: There's a lot you can do by starting to integrate several different data sources to get to smarter expectations about the damage from that hailstorm in Colorado Springs.

There's weather data that, on its own, you're not going to make claims decisions on, but it's excellent input. What if you know the age of the roofs on all those properties that were likely hit? What if you knew the roof condition of each of those properties? All of a sudden, you can quickly assess the higher-risk properties, the ones that are most likely going to need to be addressed, versus the ones that may fall outside of scope and may be less likely to be a valid claim.

So you can categorize better what types of claims these are, which then gets back to who are the right people to go do the adjustment. If I know there was a storm with two-inch hail, and I know this group of properties has 20-year-old roofs, it may be more efficient to go ahead and write the roof replacement check right away and not send an expensive, experienced adjuster out there to do an assessment. Maybe send someone to grab some photos and confirm the situation.

We’re in an in-between state, but you can already be much smarter about what has likely happened than you could even three years ago based on the data.

Paul Carroll

The historical data you've accumulated, giving you multiple images of the same property over the years, has to help with claims assessment after a storm, right?

Patrick Gill

That's correct. In places where there's a lot of activity, whether it's hail or a hurricane, we have more looks at what's happened. When I mentioned roof age earlier, that's exactly how you determine it. We look back to find where there's been a significant change in that roof, then count forward to understand the roof's age.

We have a new AI product—I know everybody has a new AI product, but we have an agentic AI solution called Eagleview Horizon that is in early access mode with customers right now. It allows a claims leader to do exactly the type of thing you're asking. Show me all the older roofs in poor condition in the path of that particular storm so I can sort them into the proper workflow.

What would have been a data science project even a year ago—probably hard to fund internally and would have taken weeks to pull all the different data sources together—you can literally do in five to 10 minutes now.

Paul Carroll 

What about drones? Are they something Eagleview would do directly, or are you focused on collaborating with drone operators?

Patrick Gill

We have experimented with drones and operated a network of pilots but have decided not to provide that service ourselves. It's a complicated, messy thing to manage a pilot network.

Our focus is on building the capability to ingest imagery captured from drones and other aerial platforms, then applying our AI and damage detection models consistently across those data sources.

Paul Carroll

Looking ahead two or three years, what features do you hope to add?

Patrick Gill

The most exciting development is the pace at which the underlying technology continues to advance.

Flying over properties on a regular basis, you don’t just see changes in roof condition. You see changes like a new presence of a pool or the evolution of a particular property. These are very interesting to the insurance industry. They're also interesting to our large customer base in local county government—tax assessor's offices, but also 911 emergency services for understanding how you access a location.

On the underwriting side, obviously you could spot a negative change—the degradation in condition—but you could also see an improvement if there's more defensible space for wildfires, there's no more tree overhang. You can actively monitor the state of a property in a way that hasn't been available.

Insurance has dealt in static data. So the notion of change detection at scale is going to be, in my mind, game-changing in terms of how the insurance industry and other industries can understand what's going on in the real world.

Paul Carroll

One of the things I find interesting and exceptionally powerful, having covered information technology for decades, is that when you start wiring the world and collecting all kinds of data you find other uses for it. There's a company called Ting Labs that produces a device that you plug into your wall, and it detects electrical problems that could cause house fires. But they're also finding that they can detect problems in the grid, and they can let utilities know when there's an outage because a whole bunch of homes lose power at the same time. If power goes off in the winter, pipes may freeze, and you may have a flooding issue; they can alert people to that, as well. 

I can imagine all kinds of uses for the kinds of data you're collecting.

Patrick Gill

Today, you literally have to look at side-by-side images of the same property at different times to draw conclusions. The way computing power and AI have evolved, you can now do that without manual review, which means you can do it at scale and then feed that intelligence into other systems where insurance carriers are making decisions, so much more cleanly and easily.

We’re on the cusp of this all being in plain language and queryable. Claims managers will be able to get much, much more sophisticated about how they plan broadly. Carriers will be much, much smarter about what's going on in their book of business or in their preparation for a particular CAT event.

Getting back to your premise around how you drive operational efficiency, there's going to be substantial opportunities to improve efficiency.

Paul Carroll

Here’s hoping. 

This is great. Thanks, Patrick.

 

About Patrick Gill

Patrick Gill

Patrick Gill is Senior Vice President and General Manager of Insurance & Commercial Solutions at Eagleview where he is focused on expanding customer value and strengthening Eagleview's leadership across property intelligence markets.


Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.

The Ghost in State Farm's Machine

State Farm's sweeping cuts to agent compensation signal how private equity thinking now shapes even mutual insurers' operating models.

Ghost in the Machine

State Farm just told 19,000 captive agents the deal has changed. Deferred compensation? Gone. Health benefits? Reduced. Renewal commissions? Squeezed in favor of new-business production.

State Farm is a policyholder-owned mutual—the largest in the country—not a private equity play. Yet the announcement reads like it came straight out of a KKR, Apollo, or Blackstone operating playbook.

For decades, State Farm's model rested on a simple premise: a book of business is not self-sustaining. It requires labor. Agents weren't just selling policies; they were maintaining them—fielding calls, resolving issues, retaining customers, spotting risks before they became claims. Renewal commissions weren't a bonus. They were the operating system.

But operating systems get deprecated.

Every generation redraws the line between labor and leverage, between what requires a human and what can be systematized. The real question isn't whether people add value. It's whether they add the same value they once did—and whether that value supports the same cost structure.

Seen through that lens, State Farm's move wasn't surprising. It was inevitable.

Three forces have been quietly closing in.

First, competition. Progressive and GEICO operate without an agent-heavy cost base. They built direct models—leaner, faster, less sentimental. As they gained share—Progressive recently passed State Farm as the top writer of auto policies in the US—State Farm was forced to respond.

Second, management migration. Over the past two decades, executives have moved through private equity portfolio companies, internalizing a shared language—almost a mantra—of efficiency, productivity, and return on capital. What was once distinctive to private equity is becoming simply how management thinks.

Third, AI. Service calls, billing questions, renewals, first notice of loss—tasks that once justified large workforces and long-tail commissions—are increasingly handled by software that doesn't sleep, doesn't churn, and declines in marginal cost over time.

This doesn't make human agents obsolete. It makes legacy compensation models obsolete.

Human value doesn't disappear, it concentrates in complex cases, edge scenarios, trust, judgment—the hard stuff. But the routine? The repeatable? The predictable? That's already slipping out of human hands.

The private equity approach asks a relentless question of every line item: if we were building this today, would we pay for it this way? That question is destabilizing inside legacy models, because once you ask it honestly, a lot of "strategic investments" start to look like habits. And habits, over time, get expensive.

So this isn't a story about private equity taking over State Farm. It's something more consequential: the normalization of a worldview private equity helped industrialize. Nothing is sacred—except the spreadsheet. Every cost is conditional. Yesterday's logic expires faster than anyone wants to admit.

Cost cutting is the easy part. Plenty of companies are doing that—and calling it strategy.

The harder move is what comes next: reinvesting those savings to build something better. Better experiences. Stronger capabilities. New forms of growth that justify the disruption.

In the end, the winners won't be those who simply get leaner. They'll be the ones who get smarter about where humans still matter—and ruthlessly disciplined about where they don't.

That's the real ghost in the machine.


Riv Arthur

Profile picture for user RivArthur

Riv Arthur

Riv Arthur is a business leader and technologist working in insurance, healthcare, and private equity.

Climate Risk Disclosure Rules Are Causing Confusion

Recent changes in the EU and California may delay climate risk disclosure requirements, but the need for organizations to understand the risks remains unchanged.

Climate Risk Management

The latest changes to the EU's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) have raised applicability thresholds and postponed reporting for many companies. California's SB 261 has been stayed, pending appeal. Meanwhile, the UK's Sustainability Reporting Standards are yet to be finalized.

Such delays may tempt some to pause or deprioritize climate risk management, particularly as economic pressures mount, capital becomes more expensive and supply chains remain under strain.

But regulatory stays should not distract from the fundamentals of climate risk management. The reasons any business needs to understand the climate-related threats to its resilience remain unchanged. For an organization, that means not stepping back from efforts to grasp the climate risks that could put their business at a disadvantage in terms of investment, supply chain opportunities, the cost of insurance and more.

To help risk and sustainability professionals continue to drive forward the climate and sustainability agenda, it is worth looking at why and how to maintain focus on building an organization's understanding of its climate risks, regardless of regulatory changes.

Climate risk is a business risk

Recent CSRD developments have increased applicability thresholds and delayed reporting for many companies. While significant, these changes aren't the key driver of how climate risk is affecting businesses, your investors, supply chains and customers.

Climate risk remains a business risk. CSRD thresholds and timings have moved, the principles for climate risk management haven't.

An organization may now be able to choose to pause on climate risk reporting, depending on its geographic location, but doing so could affect how investors and partners across its value chain view the business.

External stakeholders continue to judge and value a business based on its response to climate-related risks and regulations. Many lenders and investors in particular continue to embed climate and sustainability factors into their own processes and decision making.

If an organization can't demonstrate a detailed understanding of its climate risks and plans to manage them effectively, including commitments to stay on the front foot by embracing climate reporting requirements, capital may become more expensive or move toward organizations with more persuasive positions on climate risk.

Better disclosure and understanding by a company of its risks, including climate, can also influence IPO success. Even a "compliant but minimal" approach could risk underperforming those peers going further.

Customers may be shifting toward products and services with stronger climate and sustainability stories. Across an organization's supply chain, existing and prospective partners may also be evaluating partners based on their climate risk management credentials.

Addressing climate risk as a threat multiplier

Climate-related risks cut across and amplify other risks. They affect a company's existing assets, revenue streams, workforce, supply chain and directors' and officers' exposures.

Regardless of an organization's regulatory reporting requirements under CSRD or any other framework, both climate change and the net zero transition are key drivers of the business' risk profile.

Climate is, at its essence, a set of risks; threats to resilience that can be better understood by using analytical techniques and a wide-angle view on company assets, supply chains and the connections across these.

Insurers use risk models to price coverage and offer capacity. If an organization appears to have a poorer grasp of its risks, climate or otherwise, when compared to peers, this can lead to higher premiums or challenges securing capacity at all.

Climate risk is a risk like any other. To manage it, a business needs information. Effective climate risk management starts with a clear view of both physical and transition risks. Physical risks include extreme weather, flooding and wildfires, while transition risks stem from policy, technology shifts and changing markets.

Advanced analytics and industry-specific data sets will help an organization understand both its physical and transition risk exposures, translate these into financial impact and prioritize the actions to mitigate, adapt, manage or transfer these risks more effectively and efficiently.

In doing so, business leaders will be able to show stakeholders across the value chain that they are taking informed strategic decisions, while also remaining aligned with evolving regulatory and stakeholder expectations.

Investors, insurers, supply chain partners and customers can then take confidence in an organization's response to climate-related volatility, even as uncertainty continues.

Can Insurers Break Free From the POC Trap?

Insurers struggle to scale AI beyond the proof-of-concept stage due to poor data management, not the technology itself.

Management Over AI

The insurance industry faces a key question: How can insurers successfully industrialize their AI initiatives?

Scaling AI requires a distinct approach relying on: compliance, security, and traceability. Not meeting these requirements prevents projects from moving beyond the early stages, especially when they lack clear governance, performance indicators and risk management.

AI itself is not the factor impeding or slowing down the crucial passage from POC to fully deployed projects. The real issue lies in the approach and environment in which AI initiatives are developed and industrialized. Projects are still approached from a very traditional perspective rather than as potential business use cases, overlooking the need to factor in elements such as IT infrastructures, operations and, crucially, data management.

In this case, the distinction lies in the way data is being managed. Organizations with poorly structured and scattered document silos struggle with the technological debt of outdated systems including legacy enterprise content management (ECM) platforms and archives. Data management makes a difference when it comes to successfully industrializing insurers' projects as well as being one of the main difficulties they can encounter.

Scaling up with strong decision making

To succeed, organizations must rely on clear strategies driven by high-value business use cases that show immediate and significant affect in areas that are key to the business, for example the automation of claims processing.

They should also increase the focus on modernizing the existing ECM platforms while refraining from launching a complete overhaul. As counterintuitive and challenging as it might sound, this balance is essential to success and can be achieved by intelligent information management and keeping up with the latest AI implementations.

Finally, they take into account challenges related to governance and compliance from the very beginning: data traceability, model explainability, and compliance with regulatory frameworks.

The key to success: a strong information foundation

What differentiates insurers that have successfully scaled their AI projects from others is the way they approached the issue: they started with data rather than starting with AI. Insurance is a document-driven industry; its value lies in leveraging its content: policies, claims files, contracts, correspondence, broker communications, loss reports, medical records, underwriting submissions, and regulatory documentation.

Some insurers are still dependent on legacy systems, traditional ECM/DMS platforms which are now showing their limits and slowing access to information. Their lack of flexibility, combined with the proliferation of repositories, make the use of information difficult.

To overcome these difficulties insurers must rely on technological solutions incorporating AI to automate the creation of a unified, structured, and accessible information environment. But in order to be truly impactful and bring long-lasting innovation, this can't simply be merely a new layer added on top of an existing system: what is really needed is a thorough modernization of native platforms, contextualized in real-time thanks to advanced AI tools.

Inspired industry leaders are those who know how to prioritize long-lasting sustainable industrialization over short-term and rapid changes. Integrating AI solutions is a starting point, but not the solution itself. The ideal conditions for large-scale deployment have to touch all assets of the business, from talent acquisition to fill the new skill gap to investing in research and development and, especially for a consumer-facing industry like insurance, transparency and the ability to explain the benefits stemming from the technology upgrades.

Organizations that can't align with this approach are likely bound to be left behind in the no man's land of unrealized POCs, while others successfully scale up projects and introduce innovations.

The Insurance M&A Deal Closed. Now the Work Begins.

Insurance M&A success depends less on closing the deal and more on preserving culture, supporting local leadership, and strengthening relationships post-acquisition.

After the deal

After working at just about every level of an insurance agency, you start to see M&A differently. I've been the person taking out the trash, the producer trying to win the account, the leader trying to make payroll, and now the CEO thinking about how to build something bigger without losing what made the business work in the first place.

It's easy to talk about acquisitions in financial terms. The numbers matter, of course – no one builds a successful brokerage on good intentions alone. But if you've ever sat in the producer's chair, serviced the client, worked through a tough renewal, or built a relationship with a carrier over many years, you know the numbers only tell part of the story. Sometimes, they're not even the most important part.

Insurance is a relationship business, and agencies aren't just books of business. They're local reputations, client histories, carrier relationships, producer instincts, service teams, personalities, and a few quirks that somehow become part of the culture. When an agency joins a larger organization, the transaction may close on paper within weeks or months – but the real work begins after that.

The deal isn't the finish line

One of the biggest mistakes in acquisition-driven growth is treating the close as the win. The legal documents are signed, the press release goes out, everyone shakes hands, then the team moves on to the next deal.

But for the people inside the agency, that's where the questions start.

Will my role change?

Will my clients feel the difference?

Will the culture change?

Will this still feel like the place I helped build?

Those questions are not a distraction from integration. They are integration.

If leaders don't address them, people will fill in the blanks themselves. And blank spaces rarely get filled with optimism – they get filled with rumors, assumptions, and hallway theories.

The best post-acquisition strategies are built around a simple idea: people aren't being absorbed. They're being supported, connected, and brought into something larger. That takes discipline. You have to listen before you start changing things, understand why the agency works, and learn what the team, clients, and local market already trust. Skip that work, and you can end up damaging what made the agency worth acquiring in the first place.

Preserve what makes the agency valuable

Successful independent agencies grow because they have something that works: a trusted team, a strong local brand, deep carrier relationships, a niche they understand better than most, a service model clients value, or a culture that makes people want to stay.

I'm a big believer that the riches are in the niches. In this industry, specialists matter. The best people usually have something they really know. It may be a coverage area, a region, a class of business, a client type, or a set of relationships that took years to build. A larger organization shouldn't flatten that – it should amplify it. The goal isn't to make every partner agency look, sound, and operate exactly the same. The goal is to understand what should be supported at scale and what needs to stay close to the client.

In many cases, the larger organization can take on back-office support, improve data and reporting, modernize tech stacks, expand market access, and reduce administrative burdens. This will give producers and service teams more room to do what they do best. But relationships, local market knowledge, client trust, and specialized expertise should be protected with intention.

Growth should make great agencies stronger, not generic.

Provide the clay to work with

You have to give your team the clay to work with. That means giving people the tools, resources, data, support, and freedom they need to shape something meaningful. It does not mean handing them a script and asking them to become someone else.

Insurance professionals are entrepreneurial by nature. Producers especially want to build, solve, connect, and win. Service teams want to take care of people and do right by the client. Local leaders want to protect the reputation they've built.

A larger brokerage can bring a lot to the table, but it has to show up as support, not control.

For example, better data shouldn't feel like someone is watching over your shoulder. It should help leaders make better decisions, help producers identify opportunities, help teams reduce manual work, and give the business a clearer view of what's working.

New systems, reporting, workflows, and processes can be valuable, but only if people understand the "why." If the only message is, "Here's the new way we do things," you'll lose people. If the message is, "Here's how this helps you serve clients, grow your book, and spend less time fighting the machine," you have a much better chance of earning buy-in.

Culture is built in the day-to-day

Every company says culture matters. Far fewer do the slow, practical work required to protect it during growth.

Culture isn't a set of values added to an onboarding deck. It's how people make decisions, solve problems, and treat each other when the work gets hard. It's how leaders communicate when the answer isn't clear. It's how wins are shared, how conflict gets handled, and whether employees feel respected after the transaction closes.

In insurance, culture shows up in very practical ways – affecting how producers collaborate, how teams respond under pressure, how leaders talk about clients, how quickly people adapt to change, and whether employees feel like they are part of the future, or simply along for the ride.

That's why communication after a deal can't be a one-time announcement.

People don't need every answer on day one. They know business is complicated. But they do need to know that leadership understands the questions. They need to hear what's changing, what's not changing, and why. And they need to see local leadership remain engaged.

Local leadership still matters

One of the smartest things a larger brokerage can do is listen to the leaders already inside the agency. They know the clients, the history, and the way work actually gets done. They can translate change to the team in a way that feels credible, because they've earned their trust. They can also identify when something looks good in theory but won't work in practice.

That feedback is gold, even when it's inconvenient.

A strong growth model doesn't silence local leadership. It gives those leaders better tools, more support, and a broader network while still respecting what they know.

This is especially important in today's market because insurance is becoming a war of capabilities. Agencies need more resources than ever: technology, data, analytics, specialty expertise, carrier access, compliance support, talent development, and operational infrastructure. But capabilities only matter if they actually help the people closest to the client.

Long-term value is built after the announcement

The insurance industry will continue to consolidate. There are too many structural reasons for it: succession planning, talent pressure, technology investment, carrier complexity, margin pressure, the need for scale. But long-term success won't come from acquiring the most agencies. It will come from helping the right agencies get stronger.

Growth happens when clients stay, producers keep producing, leaders keep leading, and teams believe they have more opportunity than they had before. It happens when the business becomes better, without forgetting what made it worth acquiring in the first place. That's the real work of insurance M&A.


Curtis Barton

Profile picture for user CurtisBarton

Curtis Barton

Curtis Barton is the founder and CEO of ALKEME Insurance, a full-service insurance agency.

Since its founding in 2020, ALKEME has completed over 80 acquisitions and serves its customers from more than 90 locations across 30 states. 

A Strategic Shift in Insurance Distribution

Insurance carriers are shifting from merely managing producer networks to leveraging distribution data for strategic competitive advantage.

Insurance Distribution Shifts from Management to Intelligence

After decades of inefficiencies, insurance carriers, MGAs, and agencies have finally begun to invest in their technology to modernize and improve distribution management. The goal is straightforward: automate producer onboarding, simplify licensing and appointments, maintain compliance, and process transactions more efficiently.

As the industry works to catch up with these investments, they've revealed a stark reality that most distribution systems were designed to execute processes rather than generate strategic intelligence. This distinction is significant because the next competitive advantage in insurance distribution won't come from simply managing producer networks more easily, though that is important; rather, advantage will come from understanding the networks more deeply.

Distribution data is the untapped goldmine in the insurance industry. The winners are already prospecting the land.

The Data Exists, You Need To Use It

Every interaction within a distribution management platform creates valuable information. Appointments, licensing timelines, agency affiliations, geographic distribution, product sales, producer tenure, renewal activity, and more data points are readily available to companies that use a centralized database.

Historically, this data has been stored to primarily support administrative functions. Once a transaction is complete, the information is saved but its strategic value goes untapped. If you ask a carrier how many appointed producers they have they can easily answer. However, if you were to ask them for more detailed insights the answers become much more difficult — or impossible — to produce.

Which newly appointed producers have generated the highest premium in their first 90 days? Which agencies consistently outperform peers in specific product lines? Where are producers successfully cross-selling multiple products versus writing only one line of business? Which states have the strongest producer recruitment outcomes relative to onboarding investment?

These are critical business questions, not operational ones. And these are the kinds of insights distribution data will be able to provide.

Reporting Vs. Intelligence

There is a distinct difference between reporting and intelligence. Reporting tells you what happened, but intelligence helps explain why it happened and what should happen next.

Let's consider producer recruiting. Many organizations measure success by the number of producers appointed each quarter. But appointments alone don't determine business value. What if data revealed that producers recruited through one regional agency network generate twice the lifetime premium of those recruited through another channel? Or that producers with certain business characteristics consistently become top performers within six months? These insights could fundamentally reshape how an organization invests in recruiting.

This isn't theoretical. One MGA connected its appointment engine directly to live production data. Instead of maintaining — and paying state fees for — appointments across its entire roster, the system now fires an appointment the moment a producer submits their first application and initiates termination when production goes dormant. Producers go from signup to production-ready in minutes instead of weeks, and state appointment fees dropped by more than 50% because the roster finally reflects reality. A report would have told this MGA how many producers it had appointed. Intelligence told it which appointments were actually earning their keep.

Identify High-Performers Earlier

One of the biggest opportunities lies in identifying successful producers much earlier in their relationship with a carrier. Many carriers and MGAs recognize top producers after they've built an established book of business and hit certain milestones. These recognitions work to build and solidify strong working relationships between top producers and carriers. This goodwill is effective, but it is only built after producers deliver large results.

What if they could identify high-potential producers within their first few months? Organizations could build these relationships earlier, and create a stronger connection with up-and-coming talent.

By analyzing historical production patterns, onboarding activity, product mix, submission behavior, and engagement trends, AI-powered analytics could recognize signals and patterns that have historically preceded long-term success. Perhaps producers who complete onboarding in less than 30 days, immediately write across multiple product lines, and maintain consistent submission activity during their first quarter have historically become top performers.

If these patterns emerge early, distribution leaders could proactively invest in those relationships through targeted marketing support, additional training, and even mentorship. Rather than reacting to success after it occurs, organizations could help accelerate it.

Opportunities Hidden in Geography

Distribution intelligence has the potential to uncover geographic expansion opportunities that may not be immediately obvious.

For example, a carrier may believe it has saturated a particular state because of the number of appointed producers operating there. However, a deeper analysis might reveal that neighboring counties with similar demographics have significantly lower producer density but higher policy growth potential.

Alternatively, the data may show that commercial lines producers are outperforming personal lines producers in a specific region, suggesting an opportunity to adjust recruiting priorities or product offerings.

These insights would allow organizations to make expansion decisions based on measurable market intelligence rather than calculated assumptions.

From Dashboards to Decision Engines

Collecting data is important, but not using it creates little value. Real opportunity comes from gleaning valuable insights and making them accessible to business leaders.

Modern dashboards need to move beyond displaying static metrics. They should benchmark producer performance, identify emerging trends, forecast recruiting outcomes, and highlight opportunities requiring immediate attention.

Imagine a distribution executive opening a dashboard that identifies states where onboarding times have increased, predicts recruiting shortfalls for the next quarter, highlights agencies exceeding profitability benchmarks, and recommends where additional field resources should be deployed.

Those are strategic business decisions powered by data, not just operational reports.

The Future Is AI

As AI continues to mature, the possibilities become even more compelling. Instead of simply analyzing historical performance, AI will increasingly help organizations anticipate future outcomes and identify lucrative opportunities.

Predictive models may identify producers who are likely to disengage before production declines become visible. They could flag onboarding delays that historically lead to lower first-year performance or detect compliance trends that indicate elevated regulatory risk before violations occur.

There will be a shift from responding to problems after they've affected revenue or operations, to intervening proactively before major harm is done.

Insurance has never lacked distribution data. Historically, it has lacked access to organized data and is now missing the ability to transform that information into strategic insight.

The organizations that gain the greatest competitive edge over the next few years won't simply automate more workflows and organize their back-office processes. They'll use distribution intelligence to make smarter recruiting decisions, strengthen agency relationships, optimize geographic expansion, and anticipate future risks before they materialize.

Distribution data isn't an administrative byproduct, but a strategic asset organizations can use to inform better decisions across every stage of the producer lifecycle.

The future of distribution isn't just better management; it's better intelligence.


Ido Deutsch

Profile picture for user IdoDeutsch

Ido Deutsch

Ido Deutsch is chief revenue officer at Producerflow, which modernizes and streamlines producer onboarding and licensing.

While studying for his MBA at UC-Berkeley, he teamed up with Luis Pino to build Agentero and led go-to-market functions. Deutsch built Producerflow from within Agentero, and it became its own startup in 2025.

 

Navigating Regulatory Plurality in African Insurance

African insurance programs fail not from regulatory complexity but from uncoordinated regimes governing the same risk simultaneously.

Navigating Regulatory Plurality in African Insurance Markets

From our experience, the insurance supervisor is rarely the authority that creates the greatest constraint for a program entering African markets. The insurance code is often the clear part. The difficulty tends to arrive later, when foreign exchange restrictions hold up a remittance, or when a local content obligation surfaces from legislation that was never drafted with insurance in mind, or when a sector regulator turns out to require cover that nobody priced into the program. Each requirement is manageable on its own. What catches people out is that they all bear on the same program at once, and rarely announce themselves at the same time.

This is what gets lost when the market simply calls Africa complex. The word is not wrong, but it points the wrong way. Complexity suggests disorder, and disorder counsels caution, whereas what these situations show is something with structure, several distinct regulatory regimes, each identifiable, each governing the same program in parallel. We would call it regulatory plurality, and the distinction matters because a structure can be coordinated where disorder can only be feared. It is a narrower idea than legal pluralism or multi-level governance, which describe coexisting sources of authority in the abstract. The concern here is operational, the way several regimes bind one program and collide at the point of design.

The risk, then, never sits inside a single regime. The difficulty is in the points where they meet. Any single regime, taken alone, is manageable, and the response that works is coordination begun at the design stage, before placement forces the question.

Africa has 54 sovereign jurisdictions, each with its own legislation, supervisor, and administrative practice. The variation is genuine, but it is the wrong place to locate the difficulty. The number of jurisdictions is not what makes these programs hard to run.

Regional harmonization has already reduced the fragmentation, though it has done so unevenly, in blocs and not across the whole. The clearest case is the CIMA zone, the Conférence Interafricaine des Marchés d'Assurances, which aligns prudential standards across 14 mainly Francophone countries in West and Central Africa under a common insurance code. Practitioners outside the Francophone tradition routinely underestimate that coherence. But CIMA is one family among several, sitting alongside the Maghreb codes, the Anglophone common-law markets, the Lusophone systems, and Francophone states such as the DRC that keep their own regulator outside CIMA entirely, so that even a shared language guarantees nothing about a shared framework. And within CIMA the harmonization reaches only so far, because each member state keeps its own legislator, layering national rules on top of the common code. Some states mandate local brokerage outright, some permit co-brokerage with a foreign business introducer, others restrict it to a strict framework, so that a placement structure lawful in one member state can be constrained in its neighbor under the same code and the same currency.

We have seen this variance directly on a pan-CIMA industrial and logistics program we coordinate, where the placement architecture had to be adjusted country by country even though every entity sat under the same insurance code. Cameroon, Gabon, Congo and Chad did not accept the same co-brokerage structure, and a wording accepted by one national supervisor drew a query from the next. Harmonization at the prudential level, in other words, does not settle the level at which the business is actually placed.

What this points to is that the regulation bearing on a program is never a single body of rules. It is several regimes layered over one another, each developed on its own track, and the friction is almost always in how they overlap. The division that matters is by source. One regime comes from insurance law itself. The others come from everywhere else and bind the program regardless.

The insurance-internal regime is supervisory regulation. This is the one body of rules that comes from insurance law and the insurance regulator. It covers licensing, admitted insurer obligations, local retention rules, policy wording control, and the prudential standards governing whether a carrier is financially sound. It is the layer international practitioners know best and the one that dominates compliance discussions. Local admitted requirements set how the program has to be built, determining which risks the master policy can carry, which have to be placed locally, and on what terms. The code can even dictate timing, setting the window in which a premium must be paid for cover to hold. Getting this regime right makes the program legal but not yet workable, because four further regimes sit outside insurance law and bind it all the same.

The first of those external regimes is financial system regulation. Foreign exchange controls, banking settlement constraints, and capital repatriation rules govern how money crosses borders. The industry tends to treat this as a banking matter when it is squarely an insurance one, and the misclassification proves expensive. Premium remittances, claims settlements, and intra-group reinsurance flows all run through these rules, and their application turns on a jurisdiction's current account position and monetary stance. The friction wears more than one face. Sometimes it is a conversion and valuation mismatch that stalls a local invoice against its master premium, sometimes a settlement delayed for months while a repatriation queue clears, and sometimes the opposite problem of a dollarized market where the local currency barely figures. A program can clear every supervisory test and still stall because the money will not move cleanly.

The next two often arrive together, which is why they are easy to confuse, but they are worth keeping apart. The first is local content regulation. Here a distinction has to be drawn that is easy to lose. Most markets already require a share of the risk to be retained domestically, but in the CIMA zone and other code-based systems that retention is a function of the insurance code itself, part of the supervisory regime already described. Local content regulation proper is something narrower and more concentrated, standalone legislation, outside the insurance code and answering to its own authority, that conditions operation in a strategic sector on the use of domestic goods, services, and professional capacity. It clusters in particular jurisdictions and does not spread evenly across the continent, with the resource economies furthest along, and for insurance it can mean placement requirements, mandatory use of local brokers, and limits on cession to non-resident reinsurers that sit above whatever the code already demands. The trap is precise. A program can satisfy every retention rule in the insurance code and still breach a local content act that sets a higher bar, because the two are different instruments answering to different authorities, and only one of them is visible from inside insurance law.

This regime also shows up outside insurance legislation altogether, in the administrative platforms several states have built to control imported cover directly. Single-window import systems such as GUCE, GUOT, ORBUS or SEGUCE, run from the trade or customs side and not by the insurance regulator, condition the clearance of imported goods on proof of local insurance placement or local broker representation. A program can be entirely compliant with its insurance code and still be held up at the border because the cargo cover behind the shipment was not structured to satisfy the platform. It is local content regulation in its most literal form, enforced by an authority that has never read the insurance code at all.

The second is sector-specific regulation. The distinction matters because local content law governs who carries the risk, while sector law governs what has to be covered at all. Extractive industries, energy, telecommunications, and public infrastructure run under their own legislative frameworks, which often make insurance compulsory or set minimum coverage standards as a condition of licensing, and these obligations come from mining codes, petroleum legislation, construction law, and procurement rules, all of them outside insurance law. The clearest example is not exotic at all. In most Francophone markets construction carries a compulsory 10-year structural liability, the décennale, imposed by law and entirely outside the insurance code, which a program built only to the code will simply miss. Elsewhere the sector rule and a local content rule travel in the same statute, a petroleum act carrying both a compulsory cover requirement and a domestic retention share, which is exactly why a reader who treats the two as one will miss whichever obligation they were not looking for.

The last external regime is the fiscal and tax framework. Premium taxes, parafiscal charges, stamp duties, and withholding taxes on cross-border reinsurance flows vary widely and bear directly on a program's economics. In some markets the fiscal load is heavy enough to redraw structural decisions, shifting the balance between local placement and international reinsurance, or the choice between admitted and non-admitted coverage. It belongs to the jurisdiction's wider fiscal architecture, a separate body from insurance law, and it tends to surface at settlement, once the design is already fixed.

Each of these regimes is manageable on its own. The exposure comes from each answering to a different authority, resting on a different legal instrument, and following a different institutional logic, so that when separate teams or advisers handle them as separate compliance exercises, no one owns the interactions between them, and they show up only when they cause a problem.

One program we have coordinated shows how the regimes arrive in sequence, each one only visible once the last has been dealt with. A mining risk is placed globally and fronted into a producing economy, every admitted requirement met under the insurance code. The code sets the first constraint. The risk has to be carried locally and cannot simply be fronted from abroad, so a substantial share, here about half, is retained by domestic carriers, and the master placement has to be broken back down into local policies. That much is foreseeable. Less foreseeable is a second retention the code never mentions. The petroleum and mining legislation sitting above the program sets its own local content floor, higher than the code's, answering to a different authority, and satisfying the insurance regulator does nothing to satisfy it. Raising local retention to meet it is straightforward on paper. In practice the local carrier prices the retained premium in local currency, and the figure bears little relation to the master premium once conversion and local ceding charges are applied, so settlement stalls while the two are reconciled. The brokerage on the retained share, and the parafiscal and withholding charges attaching to the cross-border portion, then have to be rebuilt separately, because the master pricing never carried them. No single rule here is obscure. The retention sits partly in the insurance code and partly in the sector legislation above it, the currency friction in the exchange regime, the charges in the fiscal framework, each answering to a different authority, and the trouble is only ever visible when they are read together.

The same program makes a further point once a loss occurs, because the regimes do not rest at placement. They return at settlement, and more sharply, with a client waiting to be paid. On a major fire claim of ours in the region the coverage position was never in question, clear on the wording; the difficulty was everything that followed it, the currency conversion on the indemnity, the local insurer's own reinsurance recoveries, and the pace at which funds could actually reach the client. A coordinator who has planned only for the placement stage meets the same frictions again, later and under more pressure. A loss does not suspend the regimes that shaped the program. It tests them.

Compliance, then, has to be judged at the level of the whole system, and coordination is what that demands. The expertise to handle each regime alone generally exists. What no one owns is managing the points where they touch, from the design stage onward.

In concrete terms, the master policy architecture must be aligned with local admitted requirements before coverage terms are fixed, and foreign exchange constraints mapped against premium flows before pricing is agreed. Local content thresholds need checking against both the insurance code and any standalone act, including the administrative platforms that enforce it outside insurance law entirely. The coordinator has to identify sector-specific obligations at inception, before placement begins. And the fiscal cost of cross-border flows has to be built into the commercial logic from the outset. None of this is sequential. All of it must be held in view at once, and again at claims stage, because a loss does not suspend the regimes that shaped the program, it tests them.

Front-loading integration is a familiar principle in program management, but what distinguishes the African insurance case is that the regimes were built separately, are administered by separate bodies, and were never reconciled with one another in the drafting. Reconciling them falls to the program coordinator, and it has to be done ahead of placement, and revisited at every claim that follows.

The environment has structure. Calling it disordered is the mistake, because it is a set of overlapping regimes each governed by its own logic. Reading it as one insurance regime and four that bind from outside, financial system, local content, sector-specific, and fiscal, makes operating across 54 jurisdictions no easier, but it gives the difficulty a shape and locates the work where it belongs, in coordinating the regimes the legislation itself leaves uncoordinated.

That work falls to whoever holds the whole program, the international coordinator on one account, the client director on another, the program lead on a third. The title varies, the function does not. It means holding all five regimes in view at once and reconciling them before a single policy is placed, and again at every point a claim moves money across a border. It is demanding, but it is not disorder, and that is the point worth ending on. These markets are not the chaotic environment the word complex quietly implies. They are navigable, provided the regulation is read for the layered structure it actually has, and provided the program is built by people who can hold that structure together, the operations specialists whose competence is exactly this, as distinct from the brokers who place the risk and the underwriters who price it. The market has begun to seek them out. What these markets reward is the judgment to treat complexity as structure, and to rely on the expertise that can navigate it.


Arthur Michelino

Profile picture for user ArthurMichelino

Arthur Michelino

Arthur Michelino is director of international coordination at Ascoma International.

He previously was head of international coordination at OLEA Insurance Solutions Africa and international coordinator for key accounts at Diot-Siaci. He began his career at Willis Towers Watson (formerly Gras Savoye), implementing international programs for the mid-market segment.

It's a Wired, Wired, Wired, Wired World

As sensors have demonstrated during the World Cup, the globe is becoming so wired that it's possible to spot earthquakes, wildfires, and floods in time to mitigate harm.

Image
Early Warning

When Norway won games during the World Cup, so many people jumped up and down that earthquake sensors picked up tremors in Oslo. The same was true when Mexico won games; tremors were detected in Guadalajara and other parts of the country. 

That's some impressive fan support. Vamonos, Mexico! Dra til, Norge!

But detecting the tremors also required some very impressive sensors — of the sort that can help insurers increasingly head off injuries and property damage from earthquakes, wildfires, and floods by giving people advance notice of the impending trouble.

Let's have a look. 

Earthquake sensors are top of mind for me because of the devastating quakes in Venezuela and because of the 5.6-magnitude quake in late June that shook parts of Northern California where I lived until recently. 

Sensors in Google phones managed to alert more than 11.4 million people in Venezuela that a major earthquake was coming, at least several seconds before they felt the impact, according to the New York Times, and as much as two minutes ahead of time. It's not clear how many lives were saved and injuries prevented — and the losses were devastating, with nearly 4,500 deaths confirmed from the 7.2- and 7.5-magnitude earthquakes — but many people surely managed to protect themselves by quickly taking cover. 

What Google is doing is intriguing, and potentially a model for other alert systems. Google has turned all its phones into sensors that take advantage of the fact that earthquakes create two types of waves, as part of a system that is available in nearly 100 countries. One type (P-waves) travels very fast but does little damage. The other (S-waves) does the vast majority of the damage but travels significantly more slowly. Google's phones detect the fast-arriving P-waves as they travel through the ground, and, when Google sees all phones in an area lighting up at once, it knows S-waves and rumbling are coming. 

It's rather like thunder and lightning. Google's phones see the lightning and can tell people that thunder is coming. (The obvious difference being that, in the case of earthquakes, the damage comes after the alert, while lightning is both the alert and the cause of damage.)

The systems don't necessarily provide a lot of warning. P-waves travel at 5-6km/sec, while S-waves spread at 3-4km/sec. So you'd need to be perhaps 20 miles away from the epicenter to get five seconds of warning. People will need to be educated about what to do with those five seconds (drop, cover and hold on) and become accustomed to the idea of alerts, so they don't freeze when the warnings arrive. 

But the sensor network could still get a lot of people away from whatever might fall on them, even with little advance notice, and prevent other damage, too. A woman I know was on an on-ramp for I80 in Berkeley when the Loma Prieta earthquake hit Northern California in 1989. The on-ramp collapsed, dropping her 30 feet onto a pile of rubble. The collapse not only totaled her car, of course, but had her in and out of surgery for years, and left her traumatized from knowing how many people were crushed beneath her. With just five seconds notice, she would have been able to pull off the road and stop short of the elevated roadway. 

In the recent California quake, the governor's office bragged that the state's new early warning system had alerted more than 1 million residents before the shaking started in their area, drawing on feeds from some 600 sensors installed around the state. The system is also available in Oregon and Washington, and Apple offers a similar sort of alert system, drawing on sensors that others have installed.

Insurers don't have a role to play in the development of networks like Google's and don't have to help with the sort of deployment of hard-wired sensors like those in California, but they can certainly assist with the education. Those that do will not only reduce injury claims but will earn good citizen points. At a time when insurers are looking for ways to engage with policyholders more often — not just when collecting premiums or paying claims — offering education about how to protect yourself seems like a promising avenue.

Sensors that can detect wildfires before they get out of control are likewise becoming far more sophisticated and are being deployed on the ground, in the air, and in satellites. Personally, I'm most intrigued by what's happening with satellites, both because they can cover nearly unlimited territory, almost minute by minute, and because I believe in having others do as much work for me as possible. 

Google doesn't sell its phones on the basis that they'll detect earthquakes. People buy the phones for the obvious reasons, then Google adds a bit of software, et voila! A detection network is suddenly deployed. I think the same potential is there to add wildfire detection capabilities to the thousands of low-earth satellites that Elon Musk and others are deploying to facilitate communications. Let them pay for the expensive hardware and the launch, then add a camera and other forms of sensors that can look down and spot even small fires.

Floods, thus far, require dedicated networks of sensors, but there's progress there, too, as Houston is showing. Cities are installing small, inexpensive sensors that monitor water levels constantly, which usually providing hours of warning about developing floods. Cities can also warn motorists in real time to avoid underpasses where water has collected. 

Because these networks of sensors can't just be piggybacked onto other hardware, progress can be slow — adoption remains spotty, for instance, in Central Texas even in the wake of the disastrous flood a year ago that killed 130 people, including 25 young girls and two counselors at a summer camp. But the technology is there and will continue to make inroads.

A rule of thumb I developed some years ago now, as part of what I call the Laws of Zero, is that you can assume that any bit of information you want will be available to you at what looks like zero cost (compared with today) if you look down the road a ways. 

The concept is me looking for areas outside computer chips where the magic of Moore's law can apply. Moore's law — essentially, that the power of a computer processor doubles every year and a half to two years at no increase in cost — means that a unit of computing power that cost a dollar in 2000 costs roughly 1/600th of a penny today. So, free (almost) for anyone making long-range plans in 2000.

I won't go into all seven of the areas I identified, but it's pretty easy to see how sensors fit the Laws of Zero pattern. Moore's law will drive the cost of the computing and any memory toward zero. WiFi and satellite connectivity are becoming ubiquitous, so there's no marginal communication cost. Batteries are also plunging in cost, and many sensors won't even need them, either because they can use solar power (whose cost is heading toward zero) or because they're built into bigger systems such as Google phones or Starlink satellites. 

The Law of Zero about sensors means we will keep seeing progress. Insurers won't even have to pay for that progress. They can just piggyback on what others are doing, then help policyholders understand how to take advantage of the progress — reducing claims while earning good will.

In the meantime, if you aren't watching the France-Spain World Cup semifinal this afternoon, or at least sneaking the occasional peak while at work, I'll bet you'll be able to tell the result if you have access to seismograph readings from Paris and Madrid at 5pm or so Eastern time. 

Cheers,

Paul