On Dec. 18, Avengers: Doomsday opens in theaters, and millions of us will happily pay to watch Earth's mightiest heroes face a villain bent on bringing the world to its knees. It's a great escape, partly because we know the heroes always show up in time. Real life offers no such guarantee, and last week showed how close we already live to our own doomsday script.
Consider how recently the world ran on paper. Not long ago, people received a printed paycheck every week. Many of us remember our parents planning lunch hours around getting to the bank, or racing there Saturday morning before the branch closed at noon. Bills were paid by paper check, mailed to the mortgage company, the electric company and the oil company. Insuring a car or a house meant calling an agent. Buying anything "from a computer" was pure Isaac Asimov.
Today, the entirety of human knowledge fits in a device the size of a deck of cards that nearly everyone carries in their pocket. That has been liberating. But it has also left us almost completely dependent on invisible systems we assume will always be on and safe from disruption, whether the threat is a malfunction, a cyberattack or simple human error.
The past week showed how quickly those systems can grind to a halt. On Nov. 12, a Microsoft outage took down Outlook, Teams and Copilot – the backbone of millions of businesses – across dozens of countries for more than half a day. The next afternoon, a communications failure forced the FAA to ground every departing U.S. flight for more than four hours, the longest nationwide shutdown since 9/11. Then on Nov. 16, a software bug in JPMorgan Chase's own hardware disrupted online banking, branch transactions and Zelle payments, spilling over to customers at other banks doing business with Chase.
Chase said there was no evidence the outage was cyber-related, and that is exactly the point. If an internal glitch can rattle America's biggest commercial bank, imagine what a deliberate, coordinated attack on power grids, water systems and communications networks could do. Governments urge households to keep emergency supplies, including cash, on hand. Is your company following the same advice?
Do business continuity plans cover this?
For many companies, the honest answer is "not really." Most plans are built for hurricanes, fires, the loss of a building and other localized events. Backups reside in another state, employees work from home, and operations shift to a recovery site. All of this assumes the Internet, the power grid, and the rest of the economy are still working somewhere.
Financial regulators have pushed for more. In 2019, the FFIEC reframed its guidance from business continuity planning to business continuity management, with a focus on operational resilience and the ripple effects of outages across the financial system. The industry also created Sheltered Harbor, a standard for backing up critical customer account data nightly to an offline, air-gapped vault so customers can still reach their funds after a worst-case cyber event. Sheltered Harbor is now winding down, with its specification moving to its parent, FS-ISAC, but the principle stands.
Still, even these measures assume someone, somewhere, can restore the data and run the systems. A nationwide, prolonged outage is a scenario few plans address head-on.
Can companies function when the rest of the world can't?
Not entirely. If customers can't reach essential services, payment rails are down and vendors go dark, no amount of preparation will preserve business as usual.
But "not entirely" is materially different from "not at all." The goal is keeping your promises: knowing who your customers are, what they own and what you owe them, and honoring the most critical obligations through manual processes until systems return. That is what makes recovery possible, and it preserves trust when it matters most.
Building on the plan you already have
Organizations don't need to start over. They need to extend the plans they already have:
- Add a "dark scenario." Model a weeklong nationwide Internet and communications outage combined with an attack that corrupts your own backups. Ask what breaks first.
- Define minimum viable operations. For an insurer, that may mean confirming coverage, taking claims, and issuing emergency payments for catastrophic losses. For a bank, it may be cash access, balance verification, and critical payments. Everything else can wait.
- Keep offline, immutable copies of critical data. Maintain air-gapped backups, plus periodic printed records of policies, account balances, and key contacts.
- Bring back the manual playbook. Stock paper claim forms and check stock, set pre-approved emergency payment limits and clear signatory authority, and keep the procedures in print. Give a defined role to people with institutional memory of how the work got done before your digital transformation.
- Plan communications without the Internet. Think satellite phones, two-way radios, pre-arranged meeting points, and agreements with local broadcasters to reach customers.
- Pressure-test your vendors. Your plan is only as strong as your cloud providers, core processors and payment networks. Know what each would do in this scenario.
- Take care of your people. Employees will face the same disruption at home. Plan for staff who can't get to work, need cash, or must care for their families.
- Practice it. Run tabletop exercises in which nothing digital works. Gaps found in a conference room cost far less than gaps found in a crisis.
Will you really be there?
Nearly every bank and insurance ad promises some version of "we're there when you need us." Those promises were written with storms, fires, and floods in mind. But a slogan has no fine print. When the screens go dark, customers will expect the companies that made those promises to show up.
Insurers, whose very reason for being is to anticipate the worst, are well placed to lead, both by hardening their own operations and by helping clients understand how their coverage would respond to a systemic event. Would a cyber or business interruption policy respond to a days-long cloud outage that wasn't caused by an attack? To a bank glitch that delays payroll? After last week, many risk managers are likely asking those questions for the first time. Insurers and brokers with clear answers ready will earn trust before the next outage arrives.
In the end, a policy or a bank account is a promise, and trust is what customers are really buying. A company that goes silent in a crisis may never regain it. One that shows up, even with a pen, a paper form, and a phone tree, will be remembered for it.
Is it really possible to be fully prepared?
No organization can solve everything a large-scale shutdown would throw at it. But there is a big difference between a plan that misses a few angles and one undone by what the 9/11 Commission called a "failure of imagination." The organizations that have thought it through, protected their data, and kept manual workflows open will be the ones that help their customers first and recover fastest.
In the movies, doomsday is averted by heroes in capes. In real life, it will be survived thanks to the continuity planner with a binder of printed procedures, the claims veteran who remembers how to cut a paper check, and the IT lead who already knows which vendor to call. They are the real superheroes. Now is the time to give them what they need.
Households once ran on a checkbook, a stamp, and a Saturday trip to the bank. Could your company run that way again if it had to?
