When I ran the editing operation for the Wall Street Journal's European edition in the '80s, the "lockup" at midnight (or so) was frequently so chaotic that I posited what I called Carroll's law. Building on Murphy's law – everything that can go wrong will go wrong – Carroll's law said Murphy was an optimist.
I'm feeling déjà vu, given all the technology-related chaos of the past week, centered on Friday the 13th, when all U.S. air traffic was shut down for hours and Microsoft's Outlook was only intermittently operating after a full-on outage the day before, for what amounts to the email backbone for the world economy.
As much as there are individual reasons for those outages and other recent ones, the problems point to a pattern. The transition we're going through to a completely wired, AI world is so fundamental that two things are true:
1) We need to be a lot more careful about work like the upgrades to the FAA system, and we can head off a lot of problems if we are.
2) There will still be chaos from time to time, including for the insurance industry, especially as we start to roll out AI agents. So buckle up.
Let's have a look.
I first started thinking a couple of weeks ago about writing about the risks that arise from connecting everything to everything through the Internet of Things. The impetus was a wave of attacks on refrigeration systems throughout Europe – including in France, the U.K., Italy, Belgium, Sweden, Luxembourg and Estonia – followed by similar attacks on commissaries at U.S. military installations. The hackers raised the temperature inside 900 freezer units across 17 countries to as high as 120 degrees Fahrenheit, causing millions of dollars of food to go bad overnight and be thrown out.
France, which suffered two-thirds of the attacks on freezers, blamed Iran, and geopolitical tensions could well lead to such attacks. North Korea, Russia and China all have active military cyber units.
It's also possible that teenagers who in the past might have spraypainted graffiti on a school wall will now use AI to indulge their anger and show off in much more destructive ways.
In any case, the cyber attacks show that the power of the IoT comes with a potential downside. Connecting essentially every device to every other device gives hackers more routes into systems they want to attack. And industrial systems, such as those that let supermarkets monitor and manage refrigeration centrally typically aren't built to the same security specifications that the main IT systems are.
Insurers will have to be alert both about clients and about themselves. Clients may suffer theft, business interruption, claims of negligence against directors and officers, and so on. Insurers may face attacks themselves as they link to more sensors, third-party data sources, and providers of digital services such as payments. Insurers certainly make juicy targets, given all the important information they have on individuals and businesses.
The Wall Street Journal published a story with the headline, "Supermarket-Fridge Hacks Show Risk of Linking Everything to the Internet", that said: "Artificial intelligence suddenly makes the problem much bigger, because hackers are automating their hunt for exposed web connections and running searches at blistering speeds." The article adds that 20% of IoT devices already have at least one known cybersecurity vulnerability.
It turns out, though, that the refrigerator cyberattacks were just the start. On Thursday, bleeding into Friday, Microsoft's Outlook email system went down. As Wired wrote in a story headlined "The Microsoft Outage Is a Warning for the World": "The outages have caused widespread disruption to schools, courts, governments, and law enforcement agencies—plus countless businesses and millions of employees—around the globe, highlighting how many of the world’s most crucial systems rely upon technologies from a small number of tech companies. And when they fail, the ramifications can be huge."
Full details on the cause of the outage have yet to be provided. At the least, it shows the danger of concentration for a key service such as communication. We've actually seen even more, though smaller, examples of dangerous concentration just since Friday. United Airlines, which controls a major chunk of air travel in the U.S. and internationally, had to delay all departing flights for more than an hour and a half on Monday because of a software issue. A technical glitch with software at Chase Bank delayed online banking and caused transaction glitches for both itself and other major banks.
Concentration will only increase from here, so we need to be prepared for the fact that a single problem can cause widespread trouble.
There is some speculation that AI may have played a role in the Outlook trouble, given that Microsoft laid off 4,800 employees in July and just offered voluntary buyouts to 60,000 people, or 27% of its workforce, while saying the company is turning more coding work over to AI.
Which brings us to the FAA communications disaster that shut down air travel for five hours in the U.S. on Friday. The current official explanation is that a single, old router in Arkansas was overwhelmed during an upgrade to new technology, but some officials initially said an upgrade to AI technology known as SMART may also have been involved. Oddly, the disagreement is very public and at the cabinet level – the secretary of Transportation insists the AI work had no bearing on the outage, while the secretary of Homeland Security has suggested at least twice that the AI initiative may have been to blame.
Whatever the exact problem, the FAA issue should be the simplest to avoid. It just requires some basic hygiene. For instance, you have to give yourself a way to instantly undo an upgrade if it starts to go south. And whatever you do, you don't do a major upgrade during a busy period -- such as a Friday afternoon, when millions of people are flying somewhere for the weekend. You do the upgrade in the middle of the night, when a problem can be corrected before much of anyone notices.
But people will ignore basic principles of software management, just as they'll be too reliant on single sources of key digital services such as communication and will be too slow to tackle the vulnerabilities that come from connecting to systems and services that aren't secure enough. And AI will greatly accelerate the pace at which problems surface. So we should consider recent events as warnings of future problems, not as one-offs.
There is good news in the short term, though, for those of you who are superstitious types. Friday wasn't just the 13th; an astrology-curious acquaintance tells me Mercury and Venus both ended their retrogrades that day, bringing some supposed relief after weeks of celestial troublemaking. (Mercury, I'm told, can be especially problematic. It's blamed for everything from miscommunications to travel mishaps.) But both planets have resumed their normal forward movement across the sky, so astrologers give us an all clear – or at least a mostly clear, because the planets' "shadow" periods will last for a few weeks.
Cheers,'
Paul
P.S. I later learned, courtesy of Google, that many people had beaten me to the Carroll adaptation of Murphy's law. Oh, well.
