Download

Brace Yourself for 'BYO' AI in the Workplace

As companies innovate in their use of generative AI, a complication is coming: Individuals will bring their own versions to work. 

Image
woman working with AI

In 2009, I gave a talk to a group of about 20 Silicon Valley CIOs, who were focusing on a novel question: what to do about all the personal smartphones employees had begun using since the introduction of the iPhone two years earlier. 

The inclination was to ban them for business purposes, or at least to tightly restrict their use. After all, employees had almost exclusively used company-issued electronics for their work, and CIOs liked the control that ownership of the devices gave them. 

Besides, smartphones introduced all sorts of complications. What if a company sanctioned the use of personal phones and an employee got distracted and had a car accident? Would the company be liable? What about protections for corporate data? If employees routinely used personal devices for work, they could much more easily walk off with company secrets. How would you even incorporate all the different flavors of smartphones into the IT infrastructure?

Now that we're a bit more than two years into the generative AI revolution, we're about to face the same sort of adjustment and discomfort because "bring your own" AI to work will happen more and more.

The good news is that, as employers and employees cope with the confusion, we can learn some lessons from what happened with smartphones and other waves of innovation. 

Let's have a look.  

The first lesson is that employers can't resist the trend toward BYOAI any more than King Canute could command the tide to stop coming in. Current employers are getting accustomed to using generative AI and will want to keep using the same large language model (LLM) when they move to a new employer. All the digital natives entering the work force from college will expect to have access to the AI tools they've been using in coursework or experimenting with on their own. 

Employers will have more control with BYOAI than they did with smartphones, because licensing fees for LLMs can be steep, and most employees will rely on their employers for access, rather than just heading to Best Buy and purchasing something on their own. In addition, as insurance companies increasingly develop specialized tools for agents, claims representatives, underwriters, etc., employees will have to fit into the corporate system.

Still, some uses of generative AI, such as individual productivity tools for research and writing, will be based on personal preference, and employers should be prepared to try to accommodate employees. Employers should actually encourage experimentation with models and templates built on top of them. That's because, while most innovations need to be sponsored by a manager or even the C-suite, a lot of innovation with generative AI can bubble up from the lower ranks. Yes, rethinking a claims process is a major, departmentwide or companywide endeavor, but individuals are finding ways to improve productivity for themselves and the small groups they may work in, and that sort of progress should be encouraged.

A second lesson from earlier technological leaps is that there will be legal issues. There are always legal issues. 

One will concern just what I can bring with me if I go to a new employer. If I've finetuned an editing template on top of an LLM you've bought me access to and did the work on your time, is that template my property or yours? I suspect it's yours, but those are the kinds of issues courts will sort out. 

Generative AI will also make it easier for people to walk off with information that companies will view as proprietary data and trade secrets. Part of the magic of generative AI is that it can amalgamate data from so many different sources, so quickly, and many companies are using that capability to speed underwriting and other capabilities. But that ease of access also means many employees may be able to get into far more internal systems than they could in the past. 

There will also certainly be copyright violations, because generative AI systems scoop up so very much information and sometimes don't flag that what they're producing in reply to a prompt is drawn almost verbatim from text or an image. That's a problem, in general, but will be more severe with LLM use that happens outside of corporate standards. 

The third big lesson I see is that BYOAI will make it harder to have a "single version of the truth," just as spreadsheets and PowerPoint presentations did. With spreadsheets and PowerPoints, individuals would use corporate data but would interpret it in their own way. They would sometimes get the data wrong or misinterpret it. They would also supplement the data with other sources. When they were done, they had come up with their own version of the truth, and it stayed on their computer, generally not available to others and not synched up with others' versions of the truth. 

CIOs have been fighting the battle over data consistency for decades, and they'll face it again with generative AI, in general, and with BYOAI, in particular. People will again download information, process it with AI, add their thoughts and produce a version of the truth that will generally stay on their computer. That so many companies operate in the cloud these days could make synching up easier, but CIOs will have to work to make sure they don't face the kind of splintering that happened with earlier technologies.  

How, then, should insurance companies react to the issues that BYOAI will raise?

Some MIT researchers have three general suggestions, as reported in the MIT Sloan Management Review.

They warn, off the top, against banning BYOAI tools:  

“If we restrict access to these tools, employees won’t just stop using generative AI. They’ll start looking for workarounds — turning to personal devices and using unsanctioned accounts and hidden tools. [In that case], rather than mitigating risk, we’d have made it harder to detect and manage.”

Then, they recommend:

"1. Build specific guidance. 

Leaders should develop clear guardrails and guidelines that enable employees to experiment safely with generative AI tools. Company experts in technology, law, privacy, and governance should be tapped to develop policies on sanctioned and unsanctioned generative AI use and specify which tools are acceptable and under what conditions.... 

"One leader on the MIT CISR Data Board [said] their organization clearly communicated approved uses of generative AI to employees, such as using publicly available information in their AI queries, versus off-limits uses, such as uploading data that contains personally identifiable information, strategic information, or proprietary data. The organization also had a clear process in place for anyone who was unsure about whether AI use was appropriate....

"2. Develop training and establish communities of practice. 

"Organizations should develop AI direction and evaluation skills to help employees use generative AI tools effectively. This training should cover the AI models that power generative AI tools, ethical and responsible use of AI, and how to critically judge AI-generated content....

"For example, the data and analytics unit at animal health company Zoetis holds twice-weekly office hours during which employees can learn how to start using generative AI tools and ask questions. This helps employees learn, improve over time, and build confidence..... 

"3. Authorize certain generative AI tools from trusted vendors. 

"Staying current with the ever-evolving market for AI tools requires considerable time and effort. To crowdsource this process, create a cross-functional team tasked with evaluating tools and giving feedback to IT about which tools promise real value....

"To simplify AI access and encourage employee use, Zoetis set up a generative AI app store in which employees can apply for tool licenses and learn about effective and responsible use. For each tool, employees can access guides for getting started, watch training videos, read the organization’s AI policies and guidelines, and more. Employees are also encouraged to submit stories describing how they used a tool. This feedback has helped the organization understand which tools deliver the most value for employees."

I suspect we'll wind up feeling our way through a lot of the issues, through trial and error, much as those Silicon Valley CIOs wound up doing with smartphones. But at least we can get a sense from history of the sorts of issues employers and employees will face as they adjust to generative AI and can avoid some of the potholes we've hit in the past.

Cheers,

Paul 

The Case for TPAs in an AI Claims Environment

Generative AI reshapes third-party administrators' role in insurance claims, creating challenges but also opportunities to serve carriers better.

Coding Script

While third-party administrators have a long history of serving the insurance industry and have bright prospects, they face a once-in-a-generation change: generative AI.

AI Incoming

Prognostications on the impact of AI are ubiquitous – with insurance claims ripe for transformation. Several opportunities exist for AI to enhance or redefine the claims process, such as:

• Fraud Detection

• Claims Prioritization

• Claims Processing

• Settlement

• Subrogation

While the possibilities are nearly endless, the trend is clear – AI is changing the nature of the claims business in a way that will affect the relationship between third-party administrators (TPAs) and carriers.

First, AI is changing the nature of claims administration by challenging where human interaction (and judgment) is needed. Simple claims will see auto-adjudication without the need for an adjuster. We are already seeing carriers experimenting with this approach in the event of simple auto claims where photos and documentation result in near-instant decisions.

Second, AI should have a deflationary impact on the cost of administering claims. Pricing assumptions to manage claims on behalf of another entity are largely driven by labor costs. AI will change this by creating capacity for claims personnel, achieving both margin improvement for the TPA and potential cost savings for the TPA's client.

Third, AI will affect non-claims administrative work, such as in the contact center. AI use cases are often focused on call deflection, but everything from workforce management to key contact center metrics (e.g., average handle time [AHT]) will be affected by AI, creating additional capacity and challenging key assumptions in the TPA model.

A Brave New World For TPAs

AI will challenge the TPA market, but it will also present opportunities for those nimble enough to take advantage of them. The market has had an 8% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) over the last five years, and the increased cost associated with claims administration will only increase growth for TPAs. 

There are three opportunities for TPAs to provide greater value to insurance carriers:

  1. Embrace the Complex – AI will drive down the volume of simple claims that require adjusters. It will also highlight the need that carriers, managing general agents (MGAs), employers, and others in the insurance ecosystem have for expertise to process the most complex claims. TPAs that possess the expertise to manage these claims will be in a position to grow market share.
  2. Provide Data and Analytics Services – TPAs have an opportunity to leverage AI in their own operations to provide valuable insights to carriers and employers. Specifically, they can focus on providing data on what is driving claims for carriers to better underwrite in the future. This has historically been an area where carriers have struggled to gain insights.
  3. Loss Prevention Services – In an era where the frequency and severity of claims are increasing, understanding how to mitigate or even potentially prevent claims provides even more valuable insights, both to TPAs and their clients. TPAs that can gain insights from their data and engage in root cause analysis on behalf of their clients can develop business units focused on loss prevention.

Why Now?

The TPA market has historically been controlled by large players. Specifically, TPAs servicing large/jumbo carriers and employers for claims administration have been able to keep entrants out due to their size.

AI changes all of this. The ability to leverage AI and other technologies successfully will allow traditionally smaller players to compete with medium and large TPAs.

In addition to this, carriers, MGAs, and others in the insurance ecosystem are exploring creating their own TPAs to meet their unique needs. What once was an expensive capability is now significantly more affordable due to technical innovations.

TPAs that do not look to enhance their existing offerings with new value risk losing significant market share. TPAs can no longer afford to simply rely on their size and scale to keep entrants out of the market, particularly if they are not price competitive.


Chris Taylor

Profile picture for user ChrisTaylor

Chris Taylor

Chris Taylor is a director within Alvarez & Marsal’s insurance practice.

He focuses on M&A, performance improvement, and restructuring/turnaround. He brings over a decade of experience in the insurance industry, both as a consultant and in-house with carriers.

Wildfires Expose Major Home Insurance Gaps

Recent California wildfires expose critical gaps in home insurance as climate risks reshape coverage options nationwide.

Silhouette of Firefighters Near the Blazing Fire

The recent wildfires in Southern California have had a devastating impact, further straining the insurance industry and exposing serious gaps in traditional home insurance. With at least 200,000 displaced residents, 16,000 structures destroyed, and $250 billion in estimated economic losses, this catastrophe is poised to become the costliest natural disaster in U.S. history, surpassing even Hurricane Katrina.

As severe weather becomes a pressing reality for more Americans, insurers must reexamine existing policies and explore new models to ensure both consumer protection and industry sustainability. This latest catastrophe underscores the need to address three critical areas: population growth in disaster-prone areas, extended seasonal disaster threats, and the role of immediate services and assistance to displaced policyholders. By recognizing these challenges, we can develop solutions that better serve clients and support their financial stability.

Increasing Risk in Fire-Prone Areas

Housing development and population growth in disaster-prone areas present a growing challenge for the insurance industry. As residents move to these regions seeking affordable housing, they may not fully understand the exposure to potential loss associated with their location. In the last 30 years, the populations of high-risk counties have grown three percentage points faster than low-risk counties. From an insurance perspective, underwriting policies in these high-risk zones has become increasingly difficult. Insurers must account for heightened risk factors through higher premiums, reduced coverage options, or, in some cases, complete withdrawal from certain markets (such as California and Florida).

Extended Seasonal Threats

Furthermore, the Southern California wildfires occurred outside the typical wildfire season (June to October), highlighting the consequences of extended seasonal threats. Data from the NOAA illustrates how wildfires and other extreme weather events are beginning to persist year-round, beyond the scope of traditional risk planning. While factors like prolonged drought conditions can be managed and mitigated, insurers must account for today's increasingly unprecedented climate landscape in their policy offerings. This is also where local municipalities can collaborate with state and national funding programs to tackle projects designed to protect and future-proof infrastructure and property.

The Challenges of Displacement

In the aftermath of a wildfire, affected residents are faced with a slew of immediate hurdles, including finding temporary housing and accessing funds for essential expenses. The emotional and financial toll can be overwhelming, exacerbated by delays in claims processing and uncertainty about when or if their losses will be fully covered.

While insurance plays a crucial role in disaster recovery, the current claims process is often too slow to meet urgent needs. Policyholders may struggle with steep deductibles, lengthy claim assessments, and documentation requirements that hinder the rebuilding process. While many insurers cover temporary housing and other costs while a policyholder's home is uninhabitable, disbursement of these funds is frequently delayed by claim verification procedures, exclusions or coverage limits, leaving people responsible for significant out-of-pocket expenses. The average claims cycle for catastrophic events reported in 2023 was over 34 days, prompting a look at supplemental coverage to secure one's more immediate needs in the aftermath of a disaster.

The Need for Comprehensive Coverage

With these concerns in mind, the industry can look to parametric-style insurance solutions to expedite flexible financial relief. Payout models based on predefined triggers, like a wildfire, can ensure that policyholders have the resources they need when they need them most.

Multi-peril supplemental coverage, like Recoop Disaster Insurance, can diversify protection across multiple hazards while stabilizing premiums and reducing financial strain on traditional insurers. Partnerships between traditional home insurers and supplemental disaster insurers can establish robust, comprehensive coverage, particularly in high-risk regions where traditional policies are becoming increasingly unaffordable or unavailable. By offering lump-sum funds for a variety of perils within a single policy, the industry can simplify the process for homeowners and provide timely, critical first dollar coverage and financial assistance needed for meaningful recovery when the insurance industry's response threshold is tested most.

Forging Ahead

The Southern California wildfires serve as yet another wake-up call for the insurance industry. Traditional models are struggling to keep pace with the growing scale and frequency of natural disasters, leaving both insurers and the insured in a precarious position. By adapting to changing risk landscapes, exploring multi-peril coverage solutions, and putting client support at the center of industry strategy, insurers can evolve to provide more resilient protection for an increasingly uncertain future.


Darren Wood

Profile picture for user DarrenWood

Darren Wood

Darren Wood is the founder and president of Recoop Disaster Insurance, which offers a multi-peril disaster insurance product.

Wood has over 25 years of insurance experience. He served as the division president for Holmes Murphy, a top 25 insurance broker. He held senior project management and operational leadership roles with Marsh Consumer (now Mercer).

Wood received his degree in accounting from Simpson College, earned his project management professional (PMP) designation and is a veteran of the U.S. Army.  

4 Strategies to Kickstart Your Technology Search

Insurance leaders are rapidly adopting tech tools. Following four key steps can make the purchase process nearly painless.

Red Dot Lights on Black Surface

Insurance leaders are rapidly adopting tech tools. Following a few key steps can make the purchase process nearly painless.

Generative AI is primed to disrupt insurance and all other sectors. A recent IBM survey found that 77% of insurance executives say they must adopt AI quickly to keep up with their rivals. Beyond AI, the insurance technology market is predicted to grow 27% by 2033.

So, what happens when it's time to adopt new technology? For any tech solution that has the power to transform your business, you must meet disruption with deliberation.

Consider why the technology is needed and how it fits into the business. Then start your purchase by thinking about the decision process.

Identify key stakeholders

Before heading down the road of deploying new technology, identify everyone affected by it: the staff who use it, the clients who benefit from it, and the executives who approve the budget. Then, make sure to bring them along.

Getting support from each of these stakeholders takes more than just a pitch. Be transparent and remember that communication involves listening as well as sharing feedback.

Talk to stakeholders about why the new technology is needed and listen to any concerns. Technology should help meet business goals—such as improving renewal rates, reducing claims cycle times, or enhancing agent satisfaction—rather than being a trendy upgrade. Keep those goals in mind, and note challenges, wants, needs, and expectations.

Staff might have concerns about their job security, for instance. Be honest about those impacts. Emphasize that the goal isn't to replace them but to reduce repetitive work so employees can focus on higher-value tasks.

Or it might seem like leaders are resistant to change. Many independent agencies like paper and have been using their current processes for a long time. Make it clear why change is needed.

Launch a search—and prepare for responses

Organizing the search is a key step to finding the best partner for the job. Whether launching a formal request for proposal (RFP) or conducting an internal evaluation, detailing the process will help make a transparent, predictable, and auditable deal.

Here are the four steps of crafting a great request for bids:

  • List goals. Detail how the new technology will be used. The vendors are the experts. By sharing your goals, vendors can help find unexpected ways to accomplish those goals.
  • Outline the scope of the project. Transparency starts right away. List the expectations for the vendor and get ahead of any potential hurdles.
  • Set the budget. Be clear about how much money can be spent on the project. And discuss internally how much extra to set aside in case the project grows beyond the original scope.
  • Lay out the timeline for making a decision. Set a timeline for the decision process and stick to it. Let vendors know what steps are along the way and how communication will happen.

Laying out each of these pieces helps the communication process with vendors and makes it easier for them to know how to respond with all the useful information.

Self-evaluation, then evaluation

Maybe the most important step is what comes after the search: evaluation.

Before even looking at the first response, detail the decision process including the criteria that will be used for evaluating responses and how internal disagreements will be resolved.

Putting the decision process in writing can help in the tricky situation of getting too many good responses that need to be narrowed down.

If the call is tough to make, consider what is most important for meeting business goals. The lowest-price vendor might not offer key features or integrate with other tools. Or the technology with all the bells and whistles might be more than what's actually needed.

When evaluating a vendor, consider everything they have to offer. Not only should they meet the project's goals but also assess whether they can provide continuing support and if you trust them as a partner, because relationships matter.

Once you're ready to make a deal, stop to make sure everything lines up with the criteria that was set in the first place. The end goal is to find the solution that will best serve clients. Don't lose sight of that.

Know when to pivot

Ending an agreement or restarting a search isn't easy. When a vendor just isn't working out, don't fall for the sunk-cost fallacy. Refer back to the original criteria.

It's time to pivot when you've exhausted all possible workarounds. If the business doesn't meet the needs of the three stakeholder groups—clients, business leaders, and employees—or can't meet the terms of an agreement, it's time to pull the plug.

Flexibility is key to adapting when things don't go as planned.

When implemented thoughtfully, technology can benefit insurance agencies and carriers tremendously. These steps can help focus the decision-making process on what matters most and avoid common roadblocks.

With the right approach, new technology can help enhance customer service, improve operational efficiency, and stay competitive in an evolving market.

Cyber Insurers Expand Into Services

Cyber insurers evolve beyond claims support, offering security tools to strengthen policyholders' digital defenses.

Gold-colored Abus Padlock With Key

From real-time threat intelligence and continuous risk assessments, to penetration testing and cyber awareness training, the range and sophistication of tools and services designed to help businesses strengthen their cyber resilience strategies today is impressive.

Yet many U.S. businesses — even those that are larger, with typically bigger security budgets — still do not fully use proactive cybersecurity services. The 2024 Cybernews Business Digital Index, for example, shows that 84% of analyzed Fortune 500 companies scored a D or worse for their cybersecurity efforts, while small businesses often lack the resources to implement robust cybersecurity measures themselves.

Looking more granularly, there are further gaps to uncover across businesses of all sizes. For example, GetApp research suggests that 72% of C-suite executives — who hold critical business data — are targeted by cyberattacks, yet 37% of companies provide no extra protection for them. Meanwhile, just one in five companies say they're "very well prepared" to defend against high-volume AI-powered bot attacks.

These gaps sit alongside the fact that cyber threats are increasing in frequency, complexity and severity, triggered by geopolitical instability, out-of-date encryption methods and, of course, advances in AI. The result has seen the 2024 global average cost of a data breach reach $4.9 million — the highest figure yet and a 10% increase from the previous year — while ransomware alone costs an average of $5.2 million, with thieves having stolen over 1 billion records.

While some businesses operating among these risks have recognized the importance of investing in strategies that anticipate and mitigate risks before they materialize, gaps still remain.

Recognizing this, the cyber insurance industry is stepping in with efforts to strengthen the cyber defenses of its policyholders.

A shift benefiting policyholders, brokers and insurers alike

Aside from rising cyberattacks necessitating change, cyber insurance providers are also aware that any efforts that encourage businesses to be more proactive in this field are beneficial to all parties involved.

  • Brokers: By positioning themselves as a trusted adviser and key part of businesses' resilience strategies, brokers can offer clients more than just policies.
  • Policyholders: By following integrating advanced security solutions as part of their insurance adoption, businesses can not only reduce their exposure to cyber risks but also strengthen their overall security posture. What's more, some insurers even offer enhanced coverage benefits for policyholders who fully implement these defenses, reinforcing the value of leveraging insurance as a tool for resilience even more.
  • Cyber insurers: By positioning themselves as partners in resilience, rather than just claims support providers, insurers can help businesses strengthen their cybersecurity posture, ultimately leading to fewer claims and a more robust underwriting model. As policies are increasingly structured and priced based on real-time risk assessment and continuous security improvements, rather than just historical data, the shift will ultimately transform the future of underwriting and claims.

Cybersecurity services and tools on offer

With the above in mind, many insurers are now offering their policyholders a range of cyber services at no additional cost. Examples include:

  • Micro penetration testing: Preliminary penetration tests that uncover hidden system weaknesses before adversaries can exploit them.
  • Phishing simulation and cybersecurity training for new policyholders: Advanced phishing simulations that mimic real-world attack methods to train employees to spot and avoid social engineering tactics.
  • Cyber risk insights and recommendations: Comprehensive scans and diagnostics to quickly identify potential vulnerabilities, coupled with recommendations on remediation.
  • Continuous risk assessment: of networks, endpoints, and cloud environments—ensuring any anomalies or threats are flagged in real time.
  • Integration with leading security and IT platforms: Quick and seamless integration, enabling real-time risk scoring and insights.
  • On-demand surveillance: of actively exploited vulnerabilities that have the potential to affect policyholders during widespread cyber events.

Alongside these, some are also branching out into offering subscription-based cyber resiliency services. These aim to offer advanced capabilities that will significantly enhance policyholders' cybersecurity posture, without requiring costly in-house resources. Examples include Managed Detection and Response (MDR) Security Operations Center (SOC)-as-a-Service, Penetration Testing-as-a-Service (PTaaS), Cybersecurity Training-as-a-Service (CTaaS), and monitoring of user access to cloud services.

The new industry standard

As cyber risks continue to evolve, it's my view that this proactive model of cyber insurance — one that goes beyond financial protection to actively enhance security resilience — will become an industry standard. And in the long run, businesses that embrace this shift early will be better equipped to defend against cyber threats, while allowing insurers to benefit from stronger risk profiles and brokers to play an even greater role in safeguarding their clients' digital assets.

Cyber insurance is no longer just about recovering from cyberattacks — it's about preventing them in the first place.

Harnessing the Power of AI in Insurtech 

AI revolutionizes insurtech through streamlined integrations, automated claims processing and enhanced customer experiences.

An artist’s illustration of artificial intelligence

Over the last few years, artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning have become integral to the insurtech industry. According to PwC, the global AI insurance market size was $4.59 billion in 2022 and is projected to reach approximately $80 billion by 2032, with North America leading the way. Most companies, whether they are traditional insurers or insurtechs, have a plan to implement artificial intelligence into their business operations and propel the industry forward.

As an insurtech, Cover Genius has embraced AI and machine learning since our inception to provide dynamic recommendations through our API. However, as LLMs (large language models) and generative AI continue to evolve, they promise to revolutionize even more business processes, such as integration, content creation, claims processing and distribution.

Streamlining integration

One area where AI can significantly support insurtechs is by streamlining integrations. Insurance policies are inherently complex, with different structures depending on the region, geography and underwriter. This complexity often makes launching an integration a time-consuming process, requiring extensive testing to ensure the right policy reaches the right customer in the right market.

However, AI is transforming this process by automating test cases and improving launch times. This technology enables faster, more efficient integrations, allowing brands to easily update or launch new offerings across markets. Previously, these changes required significant investment, making companies hesitate to change their offerings, even if it meant making them better.

By automating and streamlining the integrations, AI empowers insurance providers to improve and evolve their offerings with minimal investment, saving valuable time and resources while ensuring their policies meet regulatory requirements.

Content creation and claims processing

Another key area where AI is changing the insurance industry is content creation and claims processing. AI can assist in automating email responses, Web UI (user interface) translations and copy generation, leading to more personalized customer experiences, improved engagement with insurance offers and faster operations.

Additionally, AI enhances the claims process by facilitating document translation and data extraction during the claims process, making it easier for insurers to verify claims against policy coverage. By automating routine tasks such as data extraction, document verification, and initial claim assessment, companies can reduce manual intervention and human error. In addition, AI-driven chatbots and virtual assistants can handle repetitive, administrative queries from clients, freeing staff to concentrate on higher-value-added tasks, such as coverage-related queries.

Complex claims cases will always require human oversight, but this approach helps speed response and resolution times so customers are not out of pocket on expenses for too long. At Cover Genius, we combine AI capabilities with human expertise to create claims experiences that are faster, more personalized and supportive of customers in their time of need.

Distribution and personalization

In distribution, AI enhances customer support by answering questions throughout the policy lifecycle – not just at the time of a claim. For example, advanced demand modeling and automated segmentation can contribute to more tailored offerings. If a customer books a winter flight to Switzerland, they can be identified as a candidate for ski coverage in addition to standard travel protection. As segmentation becomes more sophisticated, it unlocks new ways for customers to interact with platforms, making it easier to access relevant information and coverage quickly.

Balancing risk and compliance

AI is still a new technology, so while it is a powerful tool that can improve aspects of insurance, companies must proceed with caution, especially in areas where they are providing consumers with information about insurance products. For example, AI chatbots have often provided false answers or bad advice that do not align with actual business policies. From a risk perspective, insurtech companies must ensure they are not providing consumers with coverage advice while AI technology is still in its infancy.

Additionally, companies should remain aware of data considerations, such as customer consent and data ownership, when implementing AI measures. By carefully weighing the benefits and risks associated with AI adoption, insurtech firms can harness the full power of this groundbreaking technology while minimizing potential pitfalls.

Conclusion

AI has already transformed many aspects of the insurtech landscape, and its continued evolution promises even greater advancements. By leveraging AI for integration, content creation, claims processing and distribution, insurtech companies can maximize efficiency and deliver better services to their customers. However, balancing innovation with risk management is essential to ensure responsible and sustainable growth of AI in the insurtech sector. With careful planning and strategic implementation, AI has the potential to reshape insurance and create a more efficient, customer-centric industry.

Crisis Communication Is Key in Disasters

Drawing from personal disaster experience, an insurance expert reveals how crisis communication can make or break recovery efforts.

Close Up Photo of Coconut Tree

In recent years, our communities have faced an onslaught of destructive events—from devastating hurricanes to widespread wildfires. These challenges underscore the critical need for effective crisis communication, particularly from insurance providers who serve as a crucial support system when disaster strikes. 

Drawing on my personal experiences—first, losing our home to Hurricanes Helene and Milton, and now witnessing the Myrtle Beach wildfires of 2025 and the concurrent California wildfires—this article explores how timely, empathetic, and clear communication can make all the difference for individuals affected by these events.

Wildfires in Myrtle Beach and California, 2025

As of March 7, 2025, fires in the Myrtle Beach area—particularly in Carolina Forest—have ravaged over 2,000 acres, leading to widespread evacuations. Meanwhile, California has also been battling significant wildfires this year, adding to the urgency of improving crisis communication strategies nationwide. Whether in South Carolina or on the West Coast, dry conditions and strong winds have fueled these fires, placing enormous pressure on both residents and emergency responders. In these situations, communication from local authorities and insurance providers must offer support, clarity, and reassurance.

Successes in Crisis Communication

Effective crisis communication can mean the difference between confusion and clarity, fear and reassurance. Several recent examples demonstrate how timely, transparent, and well-executed messaging has helped mitigate the chaos and support those affected. These successes provide valuable insights for future crisis responses, helping organizations refine their strategies to better serve communities in need.

Timely Evacuation Alerts

Local officials have used social media, television, and radio to issue evacuation orders promptly, giving residents real-time updates to inform decisions and reduce potential casualties.

Operational Transparency

Emergency responders continue to share regular updates on firefighting progress, containment efforts, and safety guidelines, building trust and keeping misinformation at bay.

Gaps and Opportunities

Federal Assistance Clarity

Inconsistent or incomplete messaging on resources like FEMA support has left many people unsure of the financial and logistical help available.

Insurance Communication

The coastal insurance crisis, compounded by multiple natural disasters, now faces new complications because of these wildfires. Policyholders remain uncertain about coverage details, claim-filing procedures, and next steps amid continuing threats.

Inclusive Messaging

Vulnerable populations—including older adults, non-English speakers, and those without reliable Internet—risk missing critical updates. More diverse communication strategies are essential.

Reflecting on Hurricanes Helene and Milton

My family and I witnessed firsthand how different communication approaches can either intensify or alleviate stress. While the context differs between hurricanes and wildfires, the core lessons about the importance of effective communication remain consistent. Hurricanes Helene and Milton provided two contrasting examples:

The Misstep: Stress-Inducing Insurance Emails

  • Generic Messaging: Failed to address specific circumstances and referred to late payments, even though my policy was fully paid.
  • Poor Timing: Arrived after the initial danger yet instantly launched into administrative details instead of first asking about safety.
  • Excessive Detail: Overly lengthy policy explanations and repetitive fine print added to stress rather than clarifying next steps.
  • Transactional Tone: Brief mention of safety was overshadowed by an impersonal focus on payments and deadlines.

Impact: In the midst of displacement and overwhelming anxiety, I found myself searching for reassurance. Instead, the email only deepened my uncertainty.

The Success: Outreach From Duke Energy

  • Regular, Timely Updates: Essential information on outages, restoration timelines, and safety tips.
  • Visible Leadership: Messages from Duke Energy State President Melissa Seixas showcased genuine concern.
  • Multi-Channel Outreach: Emails, texts, mobile app, and social media ensured diverse audience reach.
  • Supportive Tone: Acknowledged hardships and offered practical guidance.

Impact: This approach dispelled uncertainty, making us feel informed and supported.

Key Takeaways for Insurance Providers

Both the wildfires and hurricanes highlight several essential lessons for insurance providers:

1. Timeliness Is Critical: Address immediate safety concerns before policy details.

2. Personalization: Use available customer data to personalize communication.

3. Clarity and Conciseness: Simple, clear messaging cuts through chaos.

4. Empathy Over Transactions: Prioritize human needs over administrative matters.

5. Multi-Channel Reach: Ensure broad accessibility of messages across various platforms.

6. Visible Leadership: Executive-level involvement reassures and builds trust.

A Personal Reflection and Call to Action

Having lived through these events, I recognize how important clear, empathetic communication is during times of crisis. Insurance providers and stakeholders must commit to human-centric outreach to effectively support affected communities. This can be achieved by implementing practical steps such as:

  • Developing Pre-Disaster Communication Plans: Establishing clear, preemptive messaging frameworks ensures swift and coordinated responses when crises arise.
  • Enhancing Digital and Multi-Channel Outreach: Leveraging text alerts, social media, and mobile apps increases the likelihood that critical information reaches all policyholders, including those with limited Internet access.
  • Training Customer Service Teams for Crisis Response: Ensure frontline staff are equipped with the knowledge and tools to provide clear, compassionate guidance during disasters.
  • Simplifying Claims and Assistance Processes: Reducing bureaucratic complexity in post-disaster claims can alleviate stress for affected individuals.
  • Building Stronger Partnerships with Local Authorities: Coordinate with emergency management agencies and community leaders to amplify messaging and resource distribution.

By integrating these steps into their crisis response strategies, insurance providers can foster trust, provide timely support, and ultimately improve outcomes for those impacted by disasters.

Conclusion

The wildfires in Myrtle Beach and California, alongside past hurricanes, demonstrate the indispensable role of crisis communication. Insurance providers can significantly ease the trauma and uncertainty following such events by adopting comprehensive, empathetic, and timely communication strategies.

Stay safe, stay informed, and remember that clear, compassionate communication can be a powerful lifeline during a crisis. 

Consider reaching out to your local representatives or insurance providers to advocate for improved crisis communication policies and preparedness plans.


Alan Burger

Profile picture for user AlanBurger

Alan Burger

Alan Burger is the CEO of InfoSlips North America. 

With decades of expertise in customer communication (CCM/CXM), he specializes in leveraging technology, including AI, to turn transactional documents into dynamic, meaningful interactions.

Risk Managers Must Prevent Investor Surprises

Chief risk officers must identify emerging risks to prevent investor surprises and potential shareholder litigation.

Professional in Black Blazer

It is no secret that surprises that affect a company's results are anathema to investors. Negative surprises naturally upset investors, but even positive surprises can do the same. Such reactions are true for individual retail investors as well as investment managers and analysts. For retail investors, a negative surprise can result in share price declines and possibly dividend declines in their holdings. For investment managers, a negative surprise can result in the same issues but can also damage their credibility if their buy/sell ratings are not aligned with the new reality that the surprise created. Likewise, a positive surprise can hurt their credibility if it is misaligned with their ratings.

Chief risk officers know that when a risk is not identified or is not well managed, it can lead to a surprise affecting company performance. When companies practice true enterprise risk management (ERM), all types of risks are identified, prioritized, and managed, with a heavy emphasis on those that can materially affect the company's ability to meet its strategy and financial goals. In addition, ERM has the remit to identify emerging risks, those that are less obvious and less developed. To optimize the ERM process, the chief risk officer needs to be part of strategic discussions, be knowledgeable about what is going on throughout the organization and in the macro environment, be up to date on key performance indicators (KPIs), and be involved in new initiatives, or important risks could be missed.

Ultimately, risk management's input to the board of directors and senior management is essential so that a comprehensive understanding of company risks, including potential surprise areas, is created at the highest levels. With that understanding comes an enhanced ability to fine tune what is released in public disclosures and reporting documents.

Public companies are used to filling out SEC required forms and reports. SEC's Form 10-K Section 1A and 7A and Form 20-F both require disclosure of risks. This content gets a lot of attention from regulators and investors. For many companies, filling out these sections has become almost rote. When reading the filings of companies in the same industry, the content barely varies from company to company. Of course, companies do list some risks unique to the company. Generally, companies are less likely to list a unique risk that they are trying to resolve before it becomes too big or too public. Finally, companies cannot and do not list risks they have not even identified.

Did a tech giant adequately recognize or report the risk of its consumer demand falling in China before it was sued by shareholders? Did a coffee producer and retailer realize that the meager reporting of its risks relative to its massive China expansion plans would result in a shareholder class action? Did a well-known consulting firm recognize or report the risks involved in consulting with drug makers to increase sales of opioids before it faced shareholder dissatisfaction? Did a beer producer realize or report that a new marketing initiative might not go as planned or might even backfire to result in a drop in sales? Did a healthcare company realize or report the full extent of the risks with its AI initiatives before regulators started looking into its practices? If they did identify the risks and did report them, then their investors had a chance to consider the possible effects of the risks. However, if the risks were not recognized, then the board and senior management did not get a chance to mitigate them or determine if they should be disclosed. And, if not disclosed, then any surprise they caused that hurt company results would very likely be received with dissatisfaction among investors.

Situations like the ones described above carry the potential for deleterious effects on share price, sales revenue, reputation, and shareholder litigation. In terms of shareholder litigation vis-à-vis unreported risks specifically, the April 2024 U.S. Supreme Court ruling, in Macquarie Infrastructure v. Moab Partners, LP, held that "a corporation's failure to disclose certain information about its future business risks, without more, cannot form the basis of a private securities fraud claim under Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rule 10b-5." That does not shield corporations completely from lacking transparency about their risks. Suits can still be attempted despite this ruling, and liability remains if reported risks are represented inaccurately, such as when a risk is not expressed at the right level of materiality or a risk is made to seem like a future risk but is actually currently present.

Clearly there is a distinction between what must be reported due to regulations and what could be reported to ensure against surprising investors. The universe of risks that must be reported is smaller -- for example, those related to cyber incidents and environment/climate impacts -- than the universe of risks that could be reported. Nevertheless, nothing stops investors from trying to sue despite the chances of prevailing, and nothing stops investors from fleeing a company that has failed to be transparent about its risks. The current plethora of shareholder actions attests to this.

Questions posed at company earnings calls have shown that investors are paying attention to the risks companies choose to disclose or risks they suspect the company may be susceptible to. These investors know that a company that recognizes and addresses its risks is one that can avoid surprises better than others that do not. Transparent companies tend to be valued more favorably than those that are not transparent.

None of this is to say the chief risk officer should be the one deciding on what the company does or does not report. Nor is the point that the chief risk officer is solely responsible for addressing risk. Specific risk owners and senior management are primarily responsible for doing that. The point is that risk management, as a function, has a key role in identifying risks, including risks that may not be quite so obvious but that could lead to a negative surprise. ERM dictates that the full panoply of risks is within scope. As long as risks are communicated to the board and senior management, they will be enabled to make the best decisions about what to disclose and report.


Donna Galer

Profile picture for user DonnaGaler

Donna Galer

Donna Galer is a consultant, author and lecturer. 

She has written three books on ERM: Enterprise Risk Management – Straight To The Point, Enterprise Risk Management – Straight To The Value and Enterprise Risk Management – Straight Talk For Nonprofits, with co-author Al Decker. She is an active contributor to the Insurance Thought Leadership website and other industry publications. In addition, she has given presentations at RIMS, CPCU, PCI (now APCIA) and university events.

Currently, she is an independent consultant on ERM, ESG and strategic planning. She was recently a senior adviser at Hanover Stone Solutions. She served as the chairwoman of the Spencer Educational Foundation from 2006-2010. From 1989 to 2006, she was with Zurich Insurance Group, where she held many positions both in the U.S. and in Switzerland, including: EVP corporate development, global head of investor relations, EVP compliance and governance and regional manager for North America. Her last position at Zurich was executive vice president and chief administrative officer for Zurich’s world-wide general insurance business ($36 Billion GWP), with responsibility for strategic planning and other areas. She began her insurance career at Crum & Forster Insurance.  

She has served on numerous industry and academic boards. Among these are: NC State’s Poole School of Business’ Enterprise Risk Management’s Advisory Board, Illinois State University’s Katie School of Insurance, Spencer Educational Foundation. She won “The Editor’s Choice Award” from the Society of Financial Examiners in 2017 for her co-written articles on KRIs/KPIs and related subjects. She was named among the “Top 100 Insurance Women” by Business Insurance in 2000.

Rising Rates and Extreme Weather in 2025

The insurance industry faces unprecedented challenges as extreme weather, rising costs, and market shifts reshape the coverage landscape.

Lightning and Tornado Hitting Village

The insurance industry in 2025 faces challenges that build on the difficulties of recent years. Economic pressures, escalating claims costs, and the increasing frequency of extreme weather events are putting brokers, agents and insurance companies in uncharted territory. With homeowners' premiums projected to rise by more than 15% in high-risk regions and auto premiums set to climb 5%, all of us in the industry are forced to reassess our strategies and client engagement.

To address this shift, VIU by HUB's Outlook and Personal Insurance Market Rate Report has identified three pivotal trends shaping the landscape.

1. Extreme Weather Is Now a Constant Threat

We're no longer dealing with seasonal risks – natural disasters are happening year-round. In 2024, the U.S. experienced $62 billion in insured losses - 70% above the 10-year average. Hurricanes, floods and wildfires are becoming more frequent, pushing carriers to reconsider their exposure. Some are even exiting high-risk markets entirely, leaving clients to scramble for limited and often costlier coverage options.

For brokers and agents, this means playing a more advisory role. Clients are not just looking for policies; they need guidance on how to protect what matters most. Helping them navigate shrinking coverage options and rising costs is now part of the job description.

2. Rising Costs Are Reshaping Consumer Expectations

Soaring costs for labor, materials and other expenses are driving premiums higher across all coverage lines. In some regions, the cost of homeowners insurance has become prohibitive, with 8.5% of mortgage holders opting to go uninsured. This affordability crisis not only affects consumers but also poses risks for lenders and real estate professionals as potential home sales falter due to insurance hurdles.

As trusted advisers, we need to help clients find smart, affordable coverage solutions and take care of them throughout their protection life cycle. Embedding full-service digital insurance brokerage platforms, such as online comparison tools that offer end-to-end insurance solutions, can empower clients with more choices and price transparency while streamlining the purchasing process. Companies across industries, including relocation service providers, employee benefits solutions and financial institutions, are adopting this approach to create a seamless, integrated experience that keeps clients protected.

3. Strategic Partnerships Are Key to Industry Resilience

In fact, 45% of companies are planning to form new alliances within the next two years. Even more so, embedding insurance solutions into customer-facing platforms is proving to be a game-changer.

Take a mortgage servicing company, for example, which integrates home insurance into the mortgage application process. This approach not only simplifies coverage access for homeowners in disaster-prone areas but also strengthens customer satisfaction and can create revenue streams for the mortgage provider.

Plus, it is a two-way street. Brokers and agents can leverage partnerships to enhance their value propositions with their clients. Offering integrated solutions builds trust and long-term relationships while addressing the evolving needs of the modern consumer.

What This Means for Brokers, Agents, and Insurance Companies

Adapting to these trends requires a combination of strategy, flexibility and innovation. Here are some key ways to stay ahead and better serve clients:

1. Prioritize Education and Transparency:

Clear, actionable insights build trust. Help clients understand their risks and coverage options.

2. Leverage Technology to Provide Tailored Solutions:

Digital tools can streamline the insurance quoting process, tailor recommendations and provide more value, enhancing the client experience and improving retention.

3. Embrace Strategic Partnerships:

Collaborate with organizations that help you deliver embedded insurance solutions when and where clients need them most.

4. Address Affordability Concerns:

Clients will appreciate your ability to find cost-saving strategies, such as bundling policies or adjusting deductibles without sacrificing protection.

5. Stay Ahead of Climate-Driven Risks:

Inform and help clients prepare for increasing weather-related perils by clearly communicating potential risks and recommending relevant coverages—like flood insurance—even when they are not mandated but still pose a significant threat.

The challenges of today's landscape are immense, but they also present opportunities. By planning in advance, employing technology, and prioritizing meaningful client relationships, brokers, agents and insurance companies alike can thrive in this rapidly changing environment.

Insurers Must Rebuild Trust Through Transparency

As insurers face mounting volatility, rebuilding policyholder trust through increased, more open communication becomes critical.

Two White Rod Pocket Curtains

According to McKinsey's Global Insurance Report 2025, "the world's insurers are enduring a particularly volatile age." 

The insurance industry is at a crossroads in terms of public perception. Recent tragic events highlight this reality, from the cancellation of policies just prior to the LA fires and the subsequent request by carriers for rate increases to the dire situation in Florida, where carriers are leaving the state en masse as property insurance costs spiked 72% in the last five years.

While some insurers have made strides in terms of their communication with policyholders, far too many are lagging behind, waiting to see what the others will do. This leaves a void that the public is filling with stories of abandonment, greed, profit over people, and a host of other negative descriptors.

What the insurance industry needs now, more than ever, is to realize that things must change. Immediately.

Given the current chaos, insurers should be a trusted beacon that promises to be there in insureds' darkest hour. That starts with greater transparency and increased communication with constituents.

I remember the days when meeting with your insurance agent was the norm, When disaster struck, they were just a phone call away. Too often today, a question or complaint results in an automated response that doesn't even acknowledge what the person receiving the communication is going through.

For all of the benefits and convenience that technology has provided—from easy access to information online to streamlined claims and AI chatbots—it has also weakened the personal connection between insurers and their insureds. While we can't return to those days, there are ways for insurers to be more transparent, make those critical connections and rebuild trust.

One approach is to hold regular opportunities for insureds to ask questions, discuss concerns, and even air grievances before they boil over and create a pervasive sense of mistrust. Right now, many consumers feel there is no path to having a substantive dialogue with what should be a trusted adviser. While such events must be well-managed, it is critical that they be done live and with real people.

Insurers also need to act as a true partner and resource, beyond just processing claims. This means sharing with policyholders where they can turn to for immediate assistance and providing regular status updates, so they are informed and know what is actually being done.

It is also more important than ever for insurance leaders to be highly visible on the frontlines with information on how they are responding to consumer crises as well as addressing the very real challenges the industry is facing. If mistakes were made, address them. By the same token, when there is misinformation about what insurers are doing, correct them. While consumers are unlikely to feel sympathy for the industry, they should understand the financial straits that have insurers at the risk of failure.

Recent months have tested the resilience of this sector like no other in recent memory. But I believe in the future of the insurance industry and its ability to grow and improve despite these unpredictable times. By offering greater transparency and delivering communications that fulfill promises to insureds, I believe the insurance industry can once again reclaim their position as a trusted partner.