The AI market in the insurance industry is set to hit $80 billion by 2032, yet nearly two-thirds of carriers have a gap between their AI vision and reality. In essence, carriers understand what they want from AI and see the significant value it can drive but are struggling to actually put this into practice, especially in the property sector.
Marrying vision and reality is critical, however, as carriers look to scale automation, re-orchestrate and transform workflows, and fully realize the potential of AI across the lifecycle of a claim. There is a substantial downstream impact on claimants and clients, as well.
There are a number of steps a carrier needs to take to find success with AI in 2026 and ensure they are future-proofed and ready for the next era of property claims.
The AI Journey for Property Carriers
First and foremost, carriers need to understand where they are on their AI journey. This is important in identifying what the next steps are, what's feasible in the short term, and eventually in the long term, and aligning company communications, operations, workflow, training, and more.
At the moment, anywhere from 58-82% of carriers are leveraging AI tools in their operations, but only 12% claim to have fully mature capabilities, and only 7% have achieved scalable AI success. This means that 93% of carriers are still in the part of their AI journey in which they are identifying how to scale AI to a point at which it is driving real, measurable outcomes. What we've seen so far is that adoption of AI has been popular in areas such as intake, triage, and documentation, but fully integrated technology and end-to-end AI workflows are still far away for most carriers. This, in turn, results in a fragmented technology experience, rife with different tools, vendors, and solutions. This limits AI's impact. It keeps value confined to each step in the lifecycle of a claim, can lead to inconsistent data or silos across systems, and weakens output.
Reliance on pilot programs or point solutions is the first step in an AI journey, but it certainly can't be the last. Most importantly, this technology is rapidly advancing, and the longer it takes carriers to find value and scalability, the further they'll fall behind the competition.
The Challenges Facing Carriers
There are three main challenges facing carriers. First is integration of AI into legacy technology. The majority of claims systems weren't built with API connectivity in mind, which introduces difficulties immediately into scaling this technology across workflows. Before integration even begins, carriers need to ensure that their claims systems can support orchestration.
Second is training a disconnected property workforce. An often-overlooked aspect of AI in the property space is preparing for the challenges that can arise when adjusters are managing heavy caseloads and working in the field. Support systems are critical to success in this area, and AI and any other new tools cannot feel like a burden to them. Training and communication in best-use cases are important in presenting these tools as benefits. This can be streamlined through rollout plans that align with day-to-day workflows, prioritize flexibility, and implement continuing training opportunities.
Finally, expecting AI tools to drive perfection is a key challenge. This technology won't deliver perfect outcomes from day one, but through gradual improvements can drive real change in processes. If too much focus is placed on perfection, then widespread implementation can be delayed. Instead, carriers should prioritize progress first and perfection second when measuring AI against real-world baselines, with the goal of refining capabilities over time.
What Real Impact Can Look Like
When challenges are addressed and overcome, and carriers understand how to progress from point A to point B in their AI journey, real impact can be achieved. This will be seen in a number of ways across operations.
Main points of impact will be evident in faster claims reviews in which AI is helping adjusters summarize claims, extract data, and capture notes more efficiently, as well as in improved program outcomes, smoother workflows across internal and external systems, and smarter claim routing. AI tools can evaluate loss severity, complexity, and fraud risk at intake, assisting in routing claims to the right recovery resource sooner.
In addition, adjusters will see stronger field operations through enhanced drones, sensors, and tablets, which enable faster mitigation, better assessments, and quicker resource mobilization.
The data backs up this impact. Intake automation has reduced average claim processing from 10 days to 36 hours, AI photo analysis boosts claim handling efficiency by 54%, and much more.
Prioritizing Human Expertise
A key consideration in the integration of AI is the increasingly important role that humans play, and will continue to play, in this process. AI should be seen as a tool to augment and support workforce expertise, rather than replace it.
This technology is powerful, but cannot be used to replace human judgment, empathy, or real-world experience in the claims process. Losses can be ambiguous, emotionally sensitive, or require nuanced, complex coverage decisions that AI cannot handle, and require human professionals to consider context, communicate clearly, and advocate for policyholders throughout each stage.
In essence, AI is a catalyst, not a cure-all, and carriers must aim to apply AI selectively while keeping people at the center of their claims decisions. Striking this balance will be the difference in staying ahead and remaining competitive in a rapidly changing technological and regulatory landscape.
For Sedgwick's full report on "Future-Ready Property Claims," click here.
