Ever since the word "content" began to be used as a generic description of all the video, audio and writing that people like me do, I've not-so-quietly seethed about the leveling that word connotes. Nobody sets out to write the Great American Content. Authors aspire to write the Great American Novel. I don't write Six Things so I can email some "content" to you. I try to provide some perspective, some useful insight.
"Content" springs to mind because generative AI sure is producing a lot of it, and much of it is as bad as the word suggests. To this point, the concern has mostly been about AI slop--slapdash writing and oddly formed images. But there's another, more insidious type of material that AI is producing: what I think of as "AI beige."
It's not as clearly off as those pictures where a stray bit of an arm is floating in midair or a hand has six fingers. The problem is that you can easily convince yourself that your AI is generating smart visuals and writing, when it's actually producing a forgettable beige that leaves you at a competitive disadvantage.
I'll explain.
My realization about the danger of AI beige began when my older daughter wrote an article for Quartz about what AI claimed it could do for online dating. She wrote:
"Generative everything — bios, prompts, openers — risks pushing profiles toward a smooth, samey median, making it harder to tell whether you like someone or just their autocomplete. Profile refiners can make dating apps worse by sanding off the idiosyncrasies that signal real, human compatibility....
"What happens when two people send each other messages with a chatbot?
"Do the chatbots fall in love?"
More recently, EY produced a report that explained what it called "the sameness trap." EY wrote about conducting an exercise hundreds of times across the globe, in which people used AI to develop a brand image. Everybody seemed to find the exercise fun and inspiring, and "each team believed it had created something novel, [but].collectively they had created the same thing."
Imagine doing all the work to go to market with one of those brands and finding the other two on the shelf right next to you. Differentiation is out the window.
AI will often produce results like that, because the models work in the same way, drawing on the same data (having all basically Hoovered up everything on the internet) and trying to develop the same best practices.
AI can still be plenty useful and help with creativity, but you have to use it right. You won't get a Think Different or Just Do It slogan if you ask an AI to narrow in on a recommendation, but you might get something that starts you toward a very different, innovative sort of brand if you ask the AI to get a bit wild, or even very wild. You'd have to brainstorm from there and have the humans take over, but the AI can help broaden the range of ideas you consider.
EY suggests putting AI at the end of the process. Don't let the AI "speak" first on a topic, because it carries a high-tech cachet that makes it come across as the smartest in the room, and people become reluctant to voice ideas once the oracle has spoken. EY says to frame AI in an adversarial position:
"AI brings the patterns and the data of what has already happened. The human takes that intelligence and forms a position. Then we ask AI to challenge it. Tell us what we’re missing. Generate the counterfactual. The argument we haven’t considered. What would someone who disagreed with us say that isn’t in here?"
In either case —at the front end or the back end — you want to be aware that your competitors are using AI, too, and are probably being steered in the same direction you are.
It's common for businesses to pay too little attention to what others are doing. Long before AI became a factor, every computer company started telling me in the 1980s that "We don't sell boxes; we sell solutions." In the 1990s, every startup began its presentation to me by showing a PowerPoint slide that read, "We have the best people." And so on.
In some parts of the business, insurers don't need to worry about having their AIs produce differentiated results. With communications with customers, for instance, if you come across as concerned and professional, the customer isn't going to call up your email and figure out how it compares with a competitor's on the same topic. So having an AI guide you toward best practices is fine, however beige they might be.
But when it comes to branding, sales pitches and strategy, you need to be sure to Think Different.
Just Do It.
Cheers,
Paul