Download

Key Risks for Directors, Officers to Watch in '22

Risks include market volatility, the prospect of pandemic-related insolvencies, rising scrutiny on ESG and the urgency of cyber resilience.

|

Board members and company executives can be held liable for an increasing range of scenarios. Today’s market volatility, with the increased threat of asset bubbles and inflation, the prospect of a growing number of insolvencies due to the pandemic environment, together with rising scrutiny around the environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance of companies and the urgency for robust cyber resilience are key risks for directors and officers (D&Os) to watch in 2022, according to the latest annual D&O report by Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty (AGCS).

Uncertain insolvency issues continue to be key topic in the D&O space

The withdrawal of support for companies established during the pandemic sets the stage for a gradual normalization of business insolvencies in 2022. The Euler Hermes Global Insolvency Index is likely to post a +15% y/y rebound in 2022, after two consecutive years of decline (-6% forecast in 2021 and -12% in 2020). 

While the wave of insolvencies has so far been milder than anticipated, mixed trends are expected across the world. In less-developed markets, such as Africa or Latin America, the number of insolvencies is expected to increase faster compared with more developed economies, such as France, Germany and the U.S., where the impact of the governmental support is expected to last longer. 

Traditionally, insolvency is a major cause of D&O claims as insolvency practitioners look to recoup losses from directors. There are many ways that stakeholders could go after directors following insolvency, such as alleging that boards failed to prepare adequately for a pandemic or for prolonged periods of reduced income. 

Market volatility, climate change and digitalization key issues 

The financial services industry, but also companies from other sectors, continues to face multiple risk management challenges in the current economic climate. Markets are likely to become more volatile with the increased risk of asset bubbles and inflation rising in different parts of the world. At the same time, more banks and insurers are expected to assign individual responsibility for overseeing financial risks arising from climate change, while investors are paying closer attention to the adequate and timely disclosure of the risk that it poses for the company or financial instrument they invest in. The tightening regulatory environment, the prospect of climate change litigation or ‘greenwashing’ allegations could all potentially affect D&Os. 

Meanwhile, digitalization has accelerated following COVID-19, creating enhanced cyber and IT security exposures for companies. This requires firms’ senior management to maintain an active role in steering the ICT (information and communication technologies) risk management framework. 

See also: CISOs, Risk Managers: Better Together

IT outages and service disruptions or cyber-attacks could bring significant business interruption costs and increased operating expenses from a variety of causes, including customer redress, consultancy costs, loss of income and regulatory fines. Last, but not least, brand reputation can also suffer. All this can ultimately affect a company’s stock price, with management being held responsible for the level of preparedness.

Heightened litigation risk in the U.S.

Litigation risk continues to be a top D&O concern, in particular around shareholder derivative actions, which are increasingly being brought on behalf of foreign companies in U.S. courts. 

Since early 2020, a group of plaintiffs’ firms has brought more than 10 derivative lawsuits in New York state courts on behalf of shareholders of non-U.S. companies seeking to hold directors and officers legally and financially accountable for various breaches of duty to their corporations. 

The financial hurdles to bring suit in the U.S. are significantly lower than in many other countries, and U.S. courts and juries are considered more plaintiff-friendly than many others around the world. The consequences to directors and officers forced to defend themselves in derivative litigation before U.S. courts can be severe. In what may turn out to be a record-setting settlement for a U.S. derivative lawsuit, in October of this year defendants agreed to pay a minimum of $300 million to settle litigation brought in a New York state court by shareholders of Renren, a social media corporation based in China, and incorporated in the Cayman Islands, after allegations of corporate misconduct.

Elsewhere in the U.S., the report notes that a decision by the Delaware Supreme Court in 2019, Marchand v. Barnhill, which focused on the fallout from a listeria outbreak, is potentially leading to greater exposure for individual corporate directors in the form of shareholder derivative suits, as it is seen to have lowered the previously high standard required for plaintiffs to prove a board’s failure to comply with their duty of care, as established in the landmark Caremark Int’l verdict in 1996. Board members must accordingly re-examine whether there is sufficient Side A cover (which covers liabilities incurred by an individual in their capacity as a director or officer) in their D&O insurance program.

Scrutiny over SPACs

Another emerging risk in the global D&O insurance space comes from the growth of so-called Special Purpose Acquisition Companies (SPACs), also known as "blank check companies." These represent a faster track to public markets. Advantages fueling the growth of SPACs over traditional initial public offerings (IPOs) include smoother procedures, less regulatory and process burdens, easier capital sourcing and shorter timelines to complete a merger with target companies. 

During the first half of 2021, the number of SPAC mergers in the U.S., both announced and completed, more than doubled the full year total of 2020, with 359 SPAC filings raising a combined $95 billion. The growth of SPACs in Europe may not match the scale of the U.S. boom, but there is still a growing expectation that it will increase despite a less favorable company law environment compared with the U.S. In Asia, the market is slowly gaining momentum, with a significant uptick in companies in China, Hong Kong and Singapore as a new route to accessing capital markets.

See also: Where Were the Risk Managers for King’s Landing?

SPACs carry a set of specific "insurance-relevant" risks, and losses are already reported to be flowing through to the D&O market as both the SPAC and the private target company typically obtain D&O coverage. Exposures could potentially stem from mismanagement, fraud or intentional and material misrepresentation, inaccurate or inadequate financial information or violations of rules or disclosure duties.

In addition, a failure to finalize the transaction within the two-year period, insider trading during the time a SPAC goes public, a wrong selection of a target to acquire or the lack of adequate due diligence in the target company could also come into play. Post-merger the risk of the go-forward company to perform as expected or failure to comply with the new duties of being a publicly listed company also needs to be considered.

To learn more about D&O risk trends, please see the full report at AGCS annual D&O report: 2022.


Joseph Caruso

Profile picture for user JosephCaruso

Joseph Caruso

Joseph Caruso is regional head of financial institutions in North America for Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty. Based in New York, Caruso joined AGCS in 2015 as regional head of financial institutions, NA and helped launch the financial lines practice.

Let the Games Begin! Customers Love Them

How insurers can use gamification to bolster customer experience, keep and win new clients with external and intrinsic motivation.

People love to play games. And gamification can help carriers leverage behavioral psychology to increase sales and reduce customer churn — especially as people buy more insurance online. 

Carriers that have adopted gamification in their marketing strategies are already experiencing the benefits. For instance, Aetna, a health insurer, saw a 50% increase in healthy behaviors from their clients after implementing gamification techniques companywide. 

What Is Gamification?

Gamification refers to the use of game design elements to improve customer experience and customer engagement. They can include quizzes, contests, point systems and leaderboards.

Gamification can make tedious processes fun! Some of the best ways to gamify your customers’ interactive experience include: 

Several insurance companies have adopted gamification in their marketing strategies. Some of the most common applications of gamification in insurance include: 

  • Educating customers on products/services 
  • Simplifying complex processes 
  • Promoting innovative business models 
  • Promoting the company’s brand 
  • Promoting awareness for healthy behavior 

Gamification in Insurance

Lead Generation 

Some insurers are using gamification to educate clients on their products. Carriers can facilitate this by creating gamification systems and applications that provide customers with information about the different insurance plans available to them. 

For example, Tryg, a Danish insurer, created a quiz about dental health. The quiz was intended to generate leads for their outbound team and increase awareness of their dental insurance products. The test had five teeth-related questions, such as, can white wine stain your teeth the same way red wine can, etc. 

The quiz produced 595 leads, and a 29% conversion rate for those who completed it. Those who participated were informed beforehand they’d receive a call from Tryg’s outbound team, who answered questions about their products and gathered even more leads. 

This method of gamification taps into the user’s emotions by making them feel like they have accomplished something by completing the quiz while the insurer promotes their brand and educates clients on their products/services. 

See also: Gamification: Key to Engaging Sales Force

Encouraging Healthy Living

Gamification can also influence people to change their behavior for the better by raising awareness for healthy behavior. 

For example, UnitedHealthcare, a health and life insurance company, created a program called “UnitedHealthcare Motion” that uses a gamification app to help companies improve the health and well-being of their employees. 

Each plan member is given an activity tracker and an app to record their daily activity. The app is personalized using local maps so users can know what 10,000 steps look like. If an employee meets their daily walking goals, they get an opportunity to earn $1,000 for out-of-pocket medical expenses. 

UnitedHealthcare’s gamification is successful because it generates competition and accomplishment among the users who meet their goals and allows the users to progress over time. 

Building Brand Affinity 

Some insurers are even integrating branded elements with existing games and applications to increase brand affinity with a new user base. 

For example, Farmers Insurance Group, a home, auto and life insurance company, integrated a Farmers-branded blimp to Zynga’s popular FarmVille simulation game. In the FarmVille game, each user is given a virtual farm with crops to protect and harvest. 

The carrier-branded blimp can help protect players’ crops from withering away. Thanks to one retro-pixelated blimp, the Farmers brand is now associated with the concept of protection -- in a fun way -- in the minds of countless players.

This is an excellent example of how insurers can use gamification to their advantage without creating an entire system or application from scratch. 

Tapping Intrinsic Motivation

Insurance companies need to understand how gamification can influence emotions and behavior. 

Psychologists point to two types of motivation: intrinsic and extrinsic.

  • Intrinsic motivation occurs when we perform an activity for our internal satisfaction and internal rewards rather than material rewards. 
  • Extrinsic motivation happens when we complete a task based on external causes, such as avoiding punishment or receiving a reward. 

While extrinsic motivation is helpful in the short term, intrinsic motivation produces more lasting results. 

When customers are intrinsically motivated through personalized gamification strategies, they are more likely to have long-term loyalty and be satisfied. This is because intrinsic motivation goes beyond points and badges; it affects a user’s sense of competence and self-efficacy. 

For example, suppose an auto insurer created a customer engagement/road safety awareness program where users track their driving behavior through telematics. The insurer could identify hazardous driving behaviors the user shows and improve their safety based on the data. In that case, gamification ultimately affects intrinsic motivation because the user's action is motivated by the internal satisfaction of driving more safely, continuing to best himself and potentially lowering his premiums.

Creating a Meaningful Gamification System

Scott Nicholson, an author and professor of game design and development at Wilfrid Laurier University, says scoring systems are based on assumptions and biases of businesses that created the game. To create a gamification system that has long-term success, carriers must generate games that connect with users’ goals and values. 

For example, people have different priorities when it comes to their health. Insureds experiencing high levels of stress might find more value in a game that rewards them for meditation. Overweight customers might prioritize a game that encourages them to exercise daily. By adding options to the game, insureds can focus on areas that are most important to them and establish a more prosperous relationship with their carrier. 

See also: Building Healthy Workplaces

Get in the Game 

Insurers need to understand how gamification can help customers stay engaged, understand insurance products better, lower their premiums and improve their lives all at the same time. As insurance becomes more digitized, carriers should experiment with gamification across their digital properties to better connect with customers. With gamification, they can better understand what customers want and simplify complex processes to speed purchasing of insurance products. 

Of course, insurers also need modern systems for underwriting, rating and processing new and renewal business before committing to gamification.  Without state-of-the art internal systems, gamification is more likely to fizzle than sizzle and frustrate rather than entice.

A New Year's Resolution for the Industry

The industry has a great story to tell, and we'll tell it better if we strip out the over-the-top language in the New Year.

sixthings

Robin Merttens, a partner at InsTech London, posted a clever essay last week laying out a New Year's resolution for the insurtech community he serves. It is: "Please can we collectively resolve to rein in the use of superlatives and hyperbole in 2022 and get back to describing what we do in clear, simple and proportionate language?"

I'd like to broaden that resolution to the whole industry, as part of my occasional rant on how the insurance industry's language holds it back.

In his essay on LinkedIn, Robin goes off on the use of superlatives, such as "best" (especially "best of breed" and "best in class"), "unrivaled" and "leading."

He writes, "You are saying that you reign supreme and that there are none better at what you do worldwide/in your class/of your breed. This is wrong at so many levels, starting with the fact that in most cases it’s simply not true.... To make matters worse, the words are so overused as to have become meaningless. You can’t all be the best, although one of you is, and that doesn’t matter because no one believes you anyway!"

He also takes a shot at empty buzzwords, such as "next generation," "new era," "cutting edge," "revolutionary" and "state of the art."

He then offers a solution: "an application that sits on your browser and detects and deletes meaningless words and inappropriate superlatives in all marketing material. It’ll be like cyber protection, but instead of detecting inbound malware it will filter hyperbole."

Robin says he'll call the app Hogwash, use the domain name www.hogwash.bs and, using the lingo currently employed by insurtechs, describe the app like so:

“Hogwash is a unique, state-of-the-art drivel detector which combines best-of-breed technology and cutting-edge AI to provide an unrivaled way to eradicate technological trumpery. It is a world-beating solution that makes the very best use of next-generation technology to detect and filter hyperbole.”

The app would strip out all the fluff and tell you that “Hogwash is a bullsh*t detector.”

I'd sign up for that app. You?

I'd just add, having edited thousands of articles from established companies for ITL, that I can assure you the insurtechs aren't the only offenders. Incumbents aren't quite so likely to claim that they've discovered fire, but they still can't resist hyperbole that we'd all be better off without.

Some of my pet peeves, which I hope we'll all see less often in the New Year:

Companies rarely write about "crises" and "catastrophes" when they can write about "major crises" and "major catastrophes" -- there can be a minor crisis or minor catastrophe? It's bad enough that "transformation," "disruption" and "revolution" get tossed around so liberally when most change is incremental, but I'll often see references to "major transformation" and "major disruption," even though, again, such upheavals don't come in "minor" varieties.

"Proactive" is another one that generally sets my teeth on edge. People sprinkle that word throughout their writing to try to show they're really working hard, generally at serving customers. But step back for a second. Verbs are actions. Putting "actively" in front of a verb, which people do often, means you're saying you're actively taking an action. Now add "pro-," which connotes another level of aggressiveness, and you're saying that you're aggressively, actively taking an action. We get it.

I can see a use for "proactive" when it's used to distinguish from a reactive stance, but not otherwise.

One more: "New" is a great word, but it doesn't need to be used three or four times in a paragraph, let alone in a single sentence. Yes, you're introducing new products, creating new businesses and setting new records, but could you really be introducing old products, creating old businesses and setting old records? And don't even get me started on "new innovations" -- new new things -- which I actually see quite a bit. What you're doing comes across loud and clear without "new" sprinkled everywhere, and the writing will feel much stronger without it and the other superfluous words that Robin and I are harping on.

Those words aren't, by any means, the only problems that sap power from the writing I see in the insurance industry. (Looking at you, "decisioning" and "trialing.")

And the sorts of problems Robin and I describe are hardly the worst of the language problems facing the industry. I've written previously about what I think of as the bigger problems, which concern obtuse language that confuses customers and that can even make them believe we don't have their best interests at heart. I've written about those bigger problems here, here and here.

But, at the risk of scaling back my ambitions for the industry, I'll settle this coming year for less hyperbole. The industry has a great story to tell, and we'll tell it better if we strip out the over-the-top language. Doing so would represent a major, new, best-of-breed, unique, transformative step forward.

Happy New Year!

Paul


Paul Carroll

Profile picture for user PaulCarroll

Paul Carroll

Paul Carroll is the editor-in-chief of Insurance Thought Leadership.

He is also co-author of A Brief History of a Perfect Future: Inventing the Future We Can Proudly Leave Our Kids by 2050 and Billion Dollar Lessons: What You Can Learn From the Most Inexcusable Business Failures of the Last 25 Years and the author of a best-seller on IBM, published in 1993.

Carroll spent 17 years at the Wall Street Journal as an editor and reporter; he was nominated twice for the Pulitzer Prize. He later was a finalist for a National Magazine Award.

Six Things: December 21, 2021

The real threat to auto insurers. Plus, managing new age construction risks; the opportunity in ecosystems; emerging risks with long tails; and more.

sixthings
 
 

The Real Threat to Auto Insurers

Paul Carroll, Editor-in-Chief of ITL

For decades, executives at auto makers have complained about all the revenue and profit they create for others but don’t get a taste of themselves. The manufacturer generates, say, $3,500 of gross profit on the sale of a $30,000 car while creating far larger opportunities for others — the commission paid to the dealer, plus revenue from repairs, service, insurance and more.

Auto makers have repeatedly tried to capture more of the downstream revenue related to car sales and are now taking dead aim at insurance. There’s reason to think they’ll make inroads, too, because insurance is increasingly based on data on driver behavior — and auto makers have easy access to all that data.

continue reading >

An Underwriting Arms Race

Join Denise Garth for an all new podcast featuring Vantage Risk's Gail McGiffin where they discuss what are the underlying drivers in commercial/specialty lines segment, how data is driving the volution of underwriting, and insights in how to change your mindset to achieve speed to market.

Listen Now

 

SIX THINGS

 

The Opportunity in Ecosystems
by Toni Tomic

Ecosystems are laying the groundwork for a network-based economic order that promises to reshape our lives and our lifestyles as consumers.

Read More

Managing New Age of Construction Risks
by Michael Pignataro

While digitizing has improved customer The global construction market is set for a sustained period of strong growth post-COVID-19, with radical changes in design, materials and processes.

Read More

The Virtual Insurance Agent

Sponsored by Creative Virtual 

With conversational AI, insurance companies can deliver easier and more convenient digital support to customers, improve agent experience and productivity, and reduce contact center traffic.

Read Now

 

Incumbents Are Slow on ‘Open Insurance’
by Maarten Bakker

Incumbent insurers and banks still seem in no rush to strengthen their currently weaker position to capture the value from Open Insurance.

Read More

Insurers Must Bond With Agents
by Denise Garth

The future is going to include stronger insurer/distributor relationships. Agents want it. Insurers need it. Customers will benefit from it.

Read More

3 Powerful Data-Driven Strategies
by Leandro DalleMule

With super granular data continuously becoming more accurate and available, some companies will take advantage and win the market

Read More

Emerging Risks With Long Tails
by Donna Galer

Brokers and risk managers should prepare for possible claims many years from now related to climate litigation and "forever chemicals."

Read More

Soft Landing, Headwinds and Rebound

Sponsored by Rimini Street 

Paul Carroll Editor-in-Chief and Dr. Michel Leonard, CBE, head of the Triple-I’s Economics and Analytics Department, discuss the Triple-I’s latest Insurance Economics Outlook for Q4 2021 focusing on this year’s unusually wide range of growth and inflation forecasts and key performance indicators for the P&C industry in 2021

Read More

 

MORE FROM ITL

 

December Focus: Smart Home

"Even before a commercial version of the internet browser was invented in the early 1990s, the rich, geeky types I dealt with in my travels at the Wall Street Journal were figuring out ways to wire their homes to ward off possible intruders."

Read More

Global Insurance Forum Experts Series  

Sponsored by International Insurance Society 

Over this six-part series, hear from industry leaders about building an innovation culture, leveraging data for success, and more.

Watch Now

 

Partner with ITL to create expert thought leadership content.

Custom Content
Promoted Content
Display Advertising
Custom Webinars
Monthly Topic Sponsorships
ITL Partner Packages and more


Learn more and get the 2022 Media Kit

 

GET INVOLVED

 

Write for Us

Our authors are what set Insurance Thought Leadership apart.
Get Started
 

SPREAD THE WORD

 
Share Share
Share Share
Tweet Tweet
Forward Forward
 
 
 
SUBSCRIBE TO SIX THINGS

 


Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.

Moving From Legacy Systems to the Cloud

Organizations gloss over culture change, but it is critical for any modernization, migration or digital transformation project.

For most organizations, cloud migration is more than just a change in software. It’s a transformation that requires a culture change and buy-in from not only IT but also the business units whose processes are ultimately affected.

In today’s business environment, moving from legacy to the cloud most often means moving to a software-as-a-service (SaaS) solution that resides in the cloud. A recent report by Gartner forecasts that end-user spending on cloud services in 2022 will reach $482 billion. SaaS will remain the largest segment of cloud services, with spending expected to reach nearly $172 billion, Gartner indicates. 

For surety companies and insurance carriers in general, the legacy system may vary. In some cases, the migration might mean moving from an older, on-premises version of software, while in other instances it involves moving from a custom-built, in-house system.  

But the success of any cloud migration or modernization project is hinged on factors outside of the technology itself. Organizations tend to gloss over the culture change, but it is critical to the success of any modernization, migration, or digital transformation project. 

Deloitte explains: “Digital transformation calls for more than just updating technology or redesigning products. Failure to align the effort with employee values and behaviors can create additional risks to an organization’s culture if not managed properly, whereas a comprehensive and collaborative effort can help shift the culture to understand, embrace, and advance digital transformation.”

The culture shift may include rethinking the way projects are completed, and which teams and stakeholders are involved in the modernization process. The reshaped culture and the change management team will inform the various phases of the legacy-to-cloud migration process, and, to be successful, an advocate must guide it. 

Understanding the role of the change manager

That advocate is the change manager. In advocating for the implementation, this individual will drive the culture change. Organizations frequently discover that the biggest naysayer, or person who at first is opposed to change, can end up as the most vocal cheerleader once they understand the benefits of change. A good advocate helps to spread the buy-in to others in the organization. For this reason, the change manager can’t be an outsider. That person must be a key stakeholder who understands and wants the process improvement and its resulting benefits for the organization and who is trusted by others within the organization.

See also: 3 Powerful Data-Driven Strategies

One accountable and empowered business owner

Along with the change manager, it is also critical to designate one person as the business owner — a business decision maker with the authority to make key design decisions and say yay or nay to requested changes as they unfold, understanding clearly the impacts to the project. Decision making by committee can kill a project. 

Time commitment is a significant consideration when determining the right business owner. As this individual will set the tone for the direction of the project and is often the project’s greatest champion, the business owner must be visible, must understand key risks and issues and must be able to dedicate the amount of time required for the life of the project.

Rethinking the preparation stage

Planning and gathering requirements are crucial for any successful modernization or cloud migration project. This preparation stage includes a vital gap analysis, in which current processes are evaluated against a forecast of future needs. Once the gap analysis is complete, the results can be compared with the future SaaS solution’s capabilities.  

The business users who will be most affected by the cloud migration must be part of the requirement-gathering phase. Here’s why: The SaaS implementation will be smoother and more successful if they, rather than the IT department, specify the required capabilities of the new system. This departure from the traditional IT-directed approach requires a shift in thinking but will pay off. 

Be realistic about project scope and resources

When taking on a migration to cloud, or any type of digital transformation, organizations need to move away from “big bang” or “flip a switch” expectations, which are unrealistic for a successful modernization project. It’s critical for the organization to understand the scope of any digital transformation or cloud migration project, including how much and what level of work is involved, and what resources are necessary.

The availability of business and technical resources is a common challenge when implementing a SaaS solution. Internal resources involved with the implementation must be able to commit for the entire project, from the business owner and change manager to every other modernization team member. Organization leaders must recognize that the project will be impaired if resources or subject matter experts are not available. If a key person can dedicate only a minimal amount of their time to the implementation, the project will quickly lose ground. 

Rethinking IT projects as business solutions

Moving from a legacy system to a SaaS solution looks different from traditional IT projects and often means a new way of thinking about systems and IT, particularly in the insurance industry. Modernization projects must be reframed as business solutions, not merely IT changes, that transform the entire business model. 

McKinsey wrote in an article about the effect of IT modernization in the insurance industry: “Insurers too often treat systems transformations as IT projects rather than acknowledging them for what they are: overall business transformations.” 

Business users must play a more active role when implementing a SaaS solution. Because SaaS solutions are typically built using low-code models, organizations don’t always need IT resources involved from a traditional software development standpoint. Although IT team members will be involved in application programming interface (API) integrations, data migration and security, most of the testing can — and should — be done by the business users, not IT. 

See also: Data Security to Be Found in the Cloud

Keeping future evolution in mind

There are a variety of benefits and advantages to choosing a SaaS solution over proprietary systems for modernization. As McKinsey notes, “Standard systems are typically much more streamlined and include ready-made functionality for pricing, underwriting, customer self-service and automation and claims processing. As a result, they can improve efficiency across the enterprise.”

When implementing a SaaS solution, it’s recommended that organizations stick as close as possible to the base functionality of the software. If the base SaaS system is too modified or customized, every future deployment will require more work, from the SaaS solution provider’s development, deployment and testing to the client organization’s testing, that will strain resources and drive up costs. If the original solution is altered too drastically, future upgrades could be a problem, as well.

To avoid having to customize a SaaS solution, it’s better to make sure the solution fits your organization’s needs from the start. Finally, the culture change necessary for a successful and effective modernization project needs to start from the top. Bringing teams together is a must to set goals and expectations when moving to a cloud-based solution. But culture change is most effective when steered by the leadership team. They must make the transformation a clear priority for the organization, or the move forward will be unnecessarily challenging.


Tracy Banderob

Profile picture for user Tracy Banderob

Tracy Banderob

Tracy Banderob is SVP of client management at Tinubu Square, an industry-leading SaaS (software as a service) platform vendor enabling credit insurance and surety digital transformation.

Does P&C's Future Lie in Datasets?

Datasets originating from third-party providers could enrich the insights insurers desperately need to offer accurate and timely quotes to clients.

|

Thinking ahead was the mark of an effective insurer in 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic required constant adaptability and intelligence. When insurance needs were changing day by day and week by week, responding quickly and flexibly with accurate quotes and appropriate product lines was essential. 2022 will be no different. 

We may move past a global pandemic, but new risks are constantly evolving, and insurers must be on their guard. With new coverage markets growing in the uncertain spaces of cyber and climate, companies must be faster and more agile than ever before.

Datasets originating from third-party providers could enrich the insights insurers desperately need to offer accurate and timely quotes to clients. In addition, exciting developments in modeling tools and analytics contribute to an elevated decision-making process for carriers, as underwriting grows easier.  

The more you know… 

Predicting and pricing risk requires insurers to be well-educated on each instance before underwriting, and gathering the necessary information could take valuable time and resources. But with the introduction of spectacular new datasets, insurers can speedily access up-to-date assessments of a risk anywhere in the world. 

These datasets are also more accessible now than ever before, with many data companies dedicated to specific data targeted toward different industries. Not only this, but companies also understand the value of a well-constructed interface, creating digital spaces where insurers can easily navigate gigantic data sources via clickable features and useful plug-ins. Going even further, the incorporation of AI capabilities into these knowledge bases can advance the underwriting process to a new level. Machine learning can even build a preventive element into insurance practices, adding important value beyond a simple quote.  

See also: P&C Commercial Lines in 2021

Capturing new niche markets 

Insurers must be quick off the blocks when building new product lines and securing influence in emerging markets, and the specialized insights datasets provide are invaluable for this. The end customer will only benefit if an insurer can offer more targeted services and stay ahead of the coverage curve, so it makes sense to collect all the information possible around a risk, at speed, to quote accurately. This kind of knowledge will massively improve service delivery, leading to seamless purchasing journeys for clients and simpler underwriting for carriers. Everybody wins. 

Those insurance lines created using the power of data, and constructed on agile, customizable platforms, will make for a radical change in the criteria for quality in the P&C space. Gone are the days of basic and homogenous contracts distributed slowly and without personalization: There are so many resources out there for insurers today that past standards no longer measure up. Insurers must make sure to make the most of the powerhouse of datasets and prioritize finding intelligent, innovative platforms upon which to build these new, richer product lines. 

In 2022, smart insurers will capitalize on every technological innovation available to them, leading the pack in digital transformation and combining data insights with smart product design to leapfrog competitors. If nothing else, the introduction of datasets prove that an insurance revolution is not just on the way: It is already here, and forward-thinking insurers will not be left behind.


Greg Murphy

Profile picture for user GregMurphy

Greg Murphy

Greg Murphy is executive vice president for North America at Instanda. He is an accomplished financial services executive with a passion for transforming the customer experience and improving the reputation of the industry.

The Real Threat to Auto Insurers

Auto makers have repeatedly tried to capture more of the downstream revenue related to car sales and are now taking dead aim at insurance.

sixthings

For decades, executives at auto makers have complained about all the revenue and profit they create for others but don't get a taste of themselves. The manufacturer generates, say, $3,500 of gross profit on the sale of a $30,000 car while creating far larger opportunities for others -- the commission paid to the dealer, plus revenue from repairs, service, insurance and more.

Auto makers have repeatedly tried to capture more of the downstream revenue related to car sales and are now taking dead aim at insurance. There's reason to think they'll make inroads, too, because insurance is increasingly based on data on driver behavior -- and auto makers have easy access to all that data.

Toyota recently became the latest manufacturer to announce an insurance offering, joining Porsche, Ford, General Motors, Tesla and several others. While traditional insurers need to get drivers to install dongles to monitor their actions behind the wheel or, increasingly, build systems around drivers' smartphones, manufacturers have a raft of sensors already built into cars and just need permission to use them for insurance purposes.

The spread of 5G and increasing power of so-called edge computing make it much easier for manufacturers to monitor driving behavior. Edge computing lets behavior be monitored and evaluated by increasingly powerful processors in the car itself -- at the edge of the computing network, rather than having all the data be transported back to a central data-processing center -- and the rollout of high-bandwidth 5G mobile networks allows for robust, high-speed connections between manufacturers and their products.

Manufacturers can also save on commissions and advertising because they can embed an offer of insurance into the auto sales process, when the car buyer needs to get insurance somewhere and is demonstrating trust for the manufacturer.

Car makers also gain in ways that insurers can't. Tesla, in particular, has talked about taking what it learns about accidents and reflecting that knowledge in the design of future cars. All manufacturers could benefit by using insurance to strengthen a relationship with a customer, making it more likely that the person would use the dealer network for repairs and service.

It's even possible to imagine car makers expanding on the insurance model and helping drivers avoid accidents. While manufacturers already increasingly include safety features such as automated braking, they could use detailed knowledge of danger spots to warn drivers that they're approaching potential trouble. Insurers and other third parties could take this sort of prevention approach, too, but it's always easier to work with a system that's built into a car rather than having to retrofit it.

Traditional insurers still have plenty of advantages -- in particular, all the expertise on pricing and claims processing that they've developed over the decades. So, I'm not saying anybody needs to fold its tent and go home. But I do think auto makes pose a credible threat to traditional insurers and warrant careful monitoring.

Cheers,

Paul


Paul Carroll

Profile picture for user PaulCarroll

Paul Carroll

Paul Carroll is the editor-in-chief of Insurance Thought Leadership.

He is also co-author of A Brief History of a Perfect Future: Inventing the Future We Can Proudly Leave Our Kids by 2050 and Billion Dollar Lessons: What You Can Learn From the Most Inexcusable Business Failures of the Last 25 Years and the author of a best-seller on IBM, published in 1993.

Carroll spent 17 years at the Wall Street Journal as an editor and reporter; he was nominated twice for the Pulitzer Prize. He later was a finalist for a National Magazine Award.

Emerging Risks With Long Tails

Brokers and risk managers should prepare for possible claims many years from now related to climate litigation and "forever chemicals."

In recognizing some of the latest emerging risks, it would be wise for risk managers to review their policy retention practices. The obvious consideration is how long policies should be kept. Other considerations include whether all policies should be kept the same amount of time, how accessible they should be and what is the best way to store them. Risk managers should consult with their legal and compliance colleagues as well as their brokers and professional associations to determine what is best for their situation. 

Imagine what it was like in the '70s and '80s when the courts were changing the intended meaning of “sudden and accidental pollution” in commercial general liability (CGL) policies. Companies were being sued and having to remediate years of environmental harm from pollutants that had been seeping from their industrial sites.

Risk managers needed to amass the company’s insurance policies dating back over many years so they could make claims to one or various insurers from whom they had coverage during those years. If they did not retain their policies or these were hard to find, they would turn to their broker. However, the brokers involved were not always able to find these old policies, either, due to having been involved in numerous mergers and acquisitions over the years or due to their own ineffective retention practices.

It was quite an uncomfortable, expensive, and time-consuming time for companies, brokers, and insurers. Ultimately, the industry adopted the absolute pollution exclusion in CGL policies, and insurers started offering stand-alone environmental covers. Asbestos claims created the same type of need to gather policies from years past. Out of this debacle, a relatively new type of service firm came into being: insurance archaeology.

There are two new risk phenomena that could create the same type of need to gather policies from years past. 

The first phenomenon is climate litigation. With the growing acceptance of "attribution science," it looks likely that companies of all sorts could be litigated against for having had a detrimental effect on the climate, resulting in floods, fires and other catastrophes. For those unfamiliar with attribution science, one explanation is, “Climate attribution science aims to establish the relationship between anthropogenic emissions and specific extreme weather events. Progress in this field is allowing claimants to better pinpoint and quantify the environmental impact of projects, policies and laws.” In other words, “Attribution science really is this idea that you can go in and examine the climate models and you can run different essentially alternate universes that ask, “What would have happened in our normal climate before global warming? How often would you see a Category 5 storm hit the Gulf Coast? Or how often would you get a million-acre wildfire in California?” Thus, a plaintiff will posit that if were not for CO2 emissions from XYZ company’s operations, or other potentially climate-affecting actions, a loss event would not have happened. 

An S&P Global paper states, “We believe the volume of climate litigation may continue to grow, as may the impact of associated juridical decisions in the policies, commitments, finances -- and even business models -- of defendant organizations. Investors are likely aware of the growing body of climate litigation and how it could affect the value-at-risk in their portfolios."

The second risk phenomenon is forever chemicals, also known as PFAS. PFAS is short for perfluoroalky and polyfluoroalkyl substances and includes chemicals known as PFOS, PFOA and GenX, created as early as the 1940s. These chemicals do not easily break down and last for long periods in whatever they are treated with or ingested by. 

According to CNN, “A study from 2007 by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimated that PFAS chemicals could be detected in the blood of 98% of the U.S. population.”

See also: Navigating the Future of Risk Management

They were used in some food packaging, pots and pans, paints, water repellents, cosmetics and other commonly used products. Today, they can be found in water, in soil and in us. Studies conducted in mice have indicated that such chemicals can cause a variety of health issues.

If or when there is a clear link between these chemicals and specific human health cases, not only the chemical manufacturers but also those that sold the products made with the chemicals could be sued, thus unleashing a tsunami of insurance claims by affected parties. 

The emerging risks will create a need to gather policies for the years leading up to the litigation to see what coverage may apply.  Hence, the need for making sure these documents will be available for review is real and present.


Donna Galer

Profile picture for user DonnaGaler

Donna Galer

Donna Galer is a consultant, author and lecturer. 

She has written three books on ERM: Enterprise Risk Management – Straight To The Point, Enterprise Risk Management – Straight To The Value and Enterprise Risk Management – Straight Talk For Nonprofits, with co-author Al Decker. She is an active contributor to the Insurance Thought Leadership website and other industry publications. In addition, she has given presentations at RIMS, CPCU, PCI (now APCIA) and university events.

Currently, she is an independent consultant on ERM, ESG and strategic planning. She was recently a senior adviser at Hanover Stone Solutions. She served as the chairwoman of the Spencer Educational Foundation from 2006-2010. From 1989 to 2006, she was with Zurich Insurance Group, where she held many positions both in the U.S. and in Switzerland, including: EVP corporate development, global head of investor relations, EVP compliance and governance and regional manager for North America. Her last position at Zurich was executive vice president and chief administrative officer for Zurich’s world-wide general insurance business ($36 Billion GWP), with responsibility for strategic planning and other areas. She began her insurance career at Crum & Forster Insurance.  

She has served on numerous industry and academic boards. Among these are: NC State’s Poole School of Business’ Enterprise Risk Management’s Advisory Board, Illinois State University’s Katie School of Insurance, Spencer Educational Foundation. She won “The Editor’s Choice Award” from the Society of Financial Examiners in 2017 for her co-written articles on KRIs/KPIs and related subjects. She was named among the “Top 100 Insurance Women” by Business Insurance in 2000.

3 Powerful Data-Driven Strategies

With super granular data continuously becoming more accurate and available, some companies will take advantage and win the market

As data and technology become more accessible, insurance companies are finding new ways to use them to outperform the competition. While there are many options to put data to work for your organization, three main strategies have emerged in the insurance industry: 1) introducing new business models; 2) capturing new value; and 3) leveraging new cost structures. The results of these strategies are setting the bar for how a thoughtful approach to data and analytics can change the old and established insurance game.

New business models are here to stay

The direct-to-consumer (D2C) model is well-known and relied on heavily across many industries, such as auto insurance. A number of factors have prevented commercial insurance carriers from selecting the D2C model, though. In fact, direct response carriers write less than 1% of all commercial and workers’ compensation premiums, according to the most recent Market Share Report by the Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of America (IIABA). According to the IIABA, 25% of personal auto insurance is sold through direct response carriers, a far greater proportion than commercial insurance.

One of the factors that puts personal auto insurance at an advantage over commercial insurance is the simplicity of the product ― hence, a shorter submission process and shorter submission form. That type of experience is what customers expect when buying a product online. Until now, this reality has stymied commercial insurers. However, new data sources are enabling commercial insurers to simplify insurance applications through submission form pre-filling or complete digital on-boarding.

Next Insurance, an MGA turned insurance company, is offering insurance online and drastically reducing the number of questions in a questionnaire by using new data sources and leveraging artificial intelligence and machine learning technology. In fact, most Next Insurance customers can buy a policy in five to 10 minutes. While there are a few other important factors that prevent commercial insurance companies from adopting a D2C model, data from third-party sources helps eliminate the potential for a poor customer experience because of a long questionnaire or unknown risks taken on by the carrier.

One of the ways insurance companies are using their internal data is to establish adjacent businesses, a concept known as data monetization. These new revenue opportunities do not rely on collecting new data; rather, they can repurpose the vast amount of data insurers already collect. An insurer can sell the data anonymously to other industries that find it profitable. This could be useful for predicting trends of a particular car company or even predicting the direction of an entire industry. Quandl, for example, gathers daily counts of how many new car insurance policies are sold by auto insurance providers and sells this information to investors. An adjacent business revenue stream like this is not tied up for liquidity or capital requirements, bringing even more value to insurance companies.

See also: How We Can Overcome Uninsurability With Data

Capturing new value

Lloyd’s Emerging Risk Report about drones highlights negligent or reckless pilots as one of the fundamental risks of drones.

Many insurers ask if photographers use drones, but they do not ask more details about that usage. This can be troubling for insurers, as different uses have different consequences if the pilot is negligent or has an accident. A wedding photographer who has an accident with a drone, for example, would face very different consequences than a landscape photographer would. Not knowing this information during customer acquisition or being too narrow with eligibility requirements can hurt an insurer.

With up-to-date data, carriers can develop new business streams in various directions. For example, as a business changes over time and expands to new areas by offering new services or getting exposed to additional risks, carriers are able to automatically offer additional insurance coverage ― or deny others, and adjust rates and limits in a surgical manner.

Furthermore, carriers can quote businesses based on their exact risk rather than that of other businesses in a similar category. Reducing, or potentially eliminating, information asymmetry can revolutionize insurance. 

Leveraging new cost structures

Data is enabling new and veteran commercial insurers to minimize costs and leverage new cost structures. For example, Lemonade insurance is maximizing automation to create a new expense ratio paradigm. According to a blog post by Lemonade, the company operates with an average of 2,500 policies per employee, compared with other “efficient legacy insurance carriers that have about 1,200 policies per employee.”

Lemonade’s digital platform takes in data through third parties and its own customers throughout a policy’s lifecycle and stores it for easy use across the whole insurance value chain. Thus, data automation at Lemonade can drastically reduce the need for employees to spend time in low-value processes, as the data already moves policies through the customer journey automatically. Lemonade can then deploy its valuable resources, e.g. underwriters and claim adjusters, to profitably generate more and better business. 

Lemonade also handles claims through data. Lemonade’s claims bot can review a claim within a few seconds. The chatbot cross-references the claim with the policy data and applies anti-fraud algorithms, reducing the need to have a person review every claim that comes in. Furthermore, Lemonade automatically collects all incoming data, increasing the accuracy and speed of the anti-fraud algorithms and ultimately reducing false claims.

Summary

Since the inception of insurance, insurers have relied on data and statistics to determine how to price risk. But for many years data was scarce. It is not anymore. The above examples are just the tip of the iceberg of how insurance companies are using data to evolve.

Data improves the customer experience through bots, simpler insurance applications and more tailored coverages and limits. Insurers also have the opportunity to use their own data to create businesses that can be separate from insurance entirely. With super granular data continuously becoming more accurate and available, it will be interesting to see which companies will take advantage of this opportunity to win the market ― and one thing is for sure, those that don’t will not be around to see the change.


Leandro DalleMule

Profile picture for user LeandroDalleMule

Leandro DalleMule

Leandro DalleMule is general manager, North America, at Planck.

He brings 30 years of experience in business management to the team. Prior to Planck, he spent six years as AIG's chief data officer. He also was the senior director of big data analytics for Citibank and head of marketing analytics for BlackRock and held leadership roles in Deloitte's advanced analytics practice.  

He holds a B.Sc. in mechanical engineering from the University of Sao Paulo, Brazil, an MBA from the Kellogg School of Management, and a graduate certificate in applied mathematics from Columbia University.

The New Mandate: 'Video or Vanish'

Communicating with customers via personalized videos can increase sales and lower churn while reducing the load for call centers.

In today’s world, a brand’s ability to personalize the customer experience is more critical than ever, perhaps nowhere so much as in the insurance industry. When buyers are busy or stressed and products seem complicated — that’s when personalization comes to the rescue. It makes next steps clear and adds a human touch to each interaction.

Video takes this a step further. It simplifies the message, it’s engaging and, quite frankly, it’s more fun than reading endless paragraphs of legalese.

Gen Z has already discovered this. If you want to reach this newest cohort of consumers, it’s “video or vanish,” as Forbes notes. Video is by far their favorite form of media (twice as important as gaming, Google and music). But it’s not just Gen Z that likes watching video. Already, the medium accounts for over 80% of consumer internet traffic, according to Cisco.

The rise of both video and personalization has only accelerated during COVID-19 as consumers turn to digital tools to replace or enhance in-person interactions. The good news is that personalizing digital communications — including through video — for your insurance customers is easier than ever before. 

For one, consumers are increasingly willing to share data. According to a recent global study by Accenture, 66% would share data on their habits to enable personalized services. Indeed, Accenture included personalization as one of its three pillars for the future of insurance.

Luckily, video has advanced in recent years and is no longer the one-size-fits-all medium of generations ago. It can be dynamic and data-driven, unique for every customer who watches it, even if you have millions of customers around the globe, speaking different languages and living vastly different lives.

The challenge, then, isn’t the technology or even getting the data. It’s how to personalize the customer journey in a way that supports loyalty and retention, and that means more than just adding a first name to an otherwise generic message. When do you reach out? What do you say? What gets results? Answers to all this and more below.

Upgrade Your Quote Follow-Ups

Typically, acquisition efforts are the most difficult to personalize. This is when you have the least data on your prospective customer.

But think about the quote request process. Here, you do have meaningful data about your future customer, so what do you do with it if they don’t convert? This is an important opportunity to remind them how you can help meet their needs and to do it in a way that’s memorable and personal. It’s good for the customer experience and your bottom line.

See also: Why Cyber Strategies Need Personalization

A quote follow-up video does exactly that. It greets people by name and explains their recommended coverage with easy-to-understand language and visuals. This kind of personalized video has increased policies sold by a whopping 40%. You can even add a clickable call-to-action directly in the video, making it easier for viewers to convert.

Tip: If you don’t have data on what potential customers are looking for, let them tell you. The latest video technology lets users input their requirements directly into the video to generate a personalized quote in real time.

Make a Good First Impression

Let’s talk about the onboarding process. Hello, paperwork.

Getting started with a new insurance carrier or plan can be confusing for many people. A personalized welcome starts the relationship off right and is a great way to introduce them to the details of their specific coverage. Here are some important things to include at this stage:

  • A personal welcome
  • An overview of coverage details
  • Outlining benefits
  • Steps to set up their online account

Here’s an example from SelectHealth that shows this in action.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5PmRcLJHk0

And it works. We’ve seen lifts in customer satisfaction of 30% to 50% following personalized onboarding videos.

Take the Pressure Off Your Call Centers

In its road map to digital transformation, McKinsey identified customer service as one of the critical activities to tackle first. The right digital touch here can increase cost savings by 40% and lift ROI by five percentage points.

The key is letting customers self-serve in a way that’s seamless and boosts satisfaction. Enter personalized video. It can be a lifeline to a customer in crisis mode, especially when they’re going through the notoriously complicated claims process. (That’s the other area McKinsey labeled a top candidate for digital transformation).

A video personalized for the customer’s unique situation is human, relevant and cuts through complexity. By providing next steps in an accessible digital format, you’re letting customers get what they need right away, reducing calls to call centers by as much as 73%.

Tip: Try a personalized follow-up after someone contacts support. You can summarize the call and what the customer needs to do now in a personalized video that’s automatically generated and sent to the customer.

Remember — the secret to personalized customer care is being proactive.

See also: 6 Ways to Transform Customer Experience

Using Personalized Video to Wow Customers

Only 28% of insurance customers report being happy with their level of personalization. That’s a lot of room for improvement.

Fortunately, there are many more opportunities to connect personally — yet digitally — with your customers. Offer related insurance products you know will benefit them. Get in touch to remind them of the value you bring, increasing retention for the long term. You might even reach out with a personalized GIF on your customer’s anniversary to let them know you haven’t forgotten the special day. Ultimately, the greater care you put into treating your customer as a valued individual, the greater the impact. 

This strategy has certainly produced results for brands we’ve worked with, including over 20 of the world’s leading insurance companies. MetLife, for example, saw a 12-point NPS increase as a result of their policy renewal personalized video campaign. AXA reported an 8X increase in conversion rates and 20% churn reduction. 

Brands can launch their data-driven video campaigns in a matter of days, doing it themselves with Idomoo’s self-serve platform or letting us handle the details. To see how other companies are leveraging dynamic video, check out some of our favorite personalized insurance campaigns.


Yaron Dishon

Profile picture for user YaronDishon

Yaron Dishon

Yaron Dishon is the chief revenue officer and general manager of Idomoo USA. A seasoned executive with experience supporting startups in all stages of development, Dishon has a passion for identifying and shaping disruptive technologies.