Download

Steve Ballmer's Classic Mistake

The former CEO of Microsoft seems to have way overcomplicated an app for the new arena for his Los Angeles Clippers — offering an object lesson for the rest of us.  

Image
basketball

Steve Ballmer, the former CEO of Microsoft and one of the world's richest people, recently opened his $2 billion Intuit Dome, which will be the home of his Los Angeles Clippers NBA team. The arena is drawing rave reviews. 

The app that goes with it? Not so much. 

Ballmer appears to have fallen in love with his new arena so completely that he assumed customers would treasure it, too. He also seems to have let the coders run the show when it came to building the app, so "customer-centric" became "coder-centric."

So let's have a chuckle at the expense of a man who's worth, oh, $125 billion more than we are — then make sure we don't make the same, all-too-common mistakes that he did. 

How far off the mark is the Intuit Dome app? Here is how a guest columnist for the Washington Post described the experience of taking his son to a Billy Joel concert there:

"There was no way I would have downloaded the Intuit Dome app if I hadn’t received a bunch of scary emails with subject lines that started with a red exclamation point and said that no one would be allowed into the arena without it. And although I had purchased two tickets, one would have to be transferred to my 15-year-old son’s own Intuit Dome app. We had to show these tickets on the app to get in. I could not move these tickets to my Apple Wallet, use a screenshot or print them out.

"To use the Intuit Dome app, I had to surrender my address, email and phone number (none of which, unlike every other app I have used, it was able to autofill). If I wanted to buy anything at the Intuit Dome, I had to give the app my credit card information because neither cash nor Apple Pay would be accepted. The app strongly encouraged me to take a selfie for my “Game Face ID,” so it could use facial recognition. It wanted my license plate number for parking....

"It was a time investment that might make sense for someone who is going to the Intuit Dome very often. For instance, an L.A. Clippers player....

"The app brags about how its 'Zoom Thru' tech allows me to 'navigate Intuit Dome like a pro.' This is not my goal. My goal is not even to be an amateur. My goal was to eat popcorn and listen to Billy Joel."

You can see where Ballmer is coming from. He wants to design an entire experience befitting his team's expensive new home, and he's assuming he'll have lots of repeat customers who will happily adapt to the arena's rules, which ought to produce efficiencies in the long run. 

But that's not how customers think. As the columnist wrote, he and his son weren't looking for an Intuit Dome experience. The columnist wanted to buy tickets, get into the arena, and watch a concert. That's all.

The classic line about marketing is that "the consumer doesn't want a quarter-inch drill; the consumer wants a quarter-inch hole." But the Intuit Dome app focused on delivering a branded, quarter-inch drill — and, in the process, let the technology get decidedly unfriendly. 

The columnist wrote:

"In the week before the concert, the Intuit Dome app asked me to update it three times, which is weird because most apps do that automatically. Then, as I was finally entering the stadium, my app logged me out. An attendant came over and used an iPad to look me up, though she could not find our tickets....

"After five minutes of recovering passwords, the nice woman said I was close enough to solving the Intuit Dome app’s three riddles to be allowed inside."

I've known Ballmer for going on 40 years, since I covered IBM for the Wall Street Journal back in the days when the IBM-Microsoft relationship was core to the nascent personal computer industry. He's a seriously smart and disciplined fellow who will surely address all the problems with the Intuit Dome app. And quickly. A year from now, we'll all have forgotten we had this conversation.

But I hope these early problems will stick with you, because remembering them could head off problems. The temptation is so very strong in business to view the world from an internal perspective, not from the customer's, as hard as we may try. And I see insurance companies at least tempted to make that mistake when it comes to apps.

Just about all the major insurance companies have apps that they expect customers to use to make a payment, ask a question, or file a claim. I also see insurers talking about wanting to interact more often with customers. 

But a lot of customers don't want an Allstate or Geico or State Farm experience any more than they want an Intuit Dome experience. They just want to do their business with you and move on. They likely don't want to interact with you more often, unless you have something useful to tell them or to do for them. 

They want you to fit into their lives. They don't want to have to fit into yours.

Cheers,

Paul

P.S. A couple of Ballmer stories:

The first time I met him was in April 1987, for breakfast at the Plaza Hotel in New York. IBM was making an announcement that day that was designed to retake control of the PC operating system, and Microsoft wanted to get ahead of the announcement by briefing the major media. But Ballmer wasn't there. Not 10 minutes after the appointed time. Not 15. Not 20. I went ahead and ordered breakfast. Finally, 45 minutes late, a large man plops himself down in the seat opposite me, wearing a T-shirt and running shorts, covered in sweat, and with dirt and pebbles on the back of his shirt and underside of his forearms. He had gone out for a run in Central Park, and his back had gone out. He had spent the last hour and a half, mostly lying by the side of the road, eventually managing to get upright and hobble over to the fancy restaurant at the Plaza.

Talk about a dramatic entrance.

I got a bit of an inside look at how he operates when Bill Gates offered to open Microsoft's archives to me for a book I was doing on IBM's problems, "Big Blues: The Unmaking of IBM," published in 1993. I spent a week at Microsoft headquarters in Redmond, WA, where Ballmer set me up in a small conference room next to his office. Every morning at maybe 8, he'd come in with boxes of material and brief me both on what was in them and on the people he'd arranged for me to interview that day, to give me the Microsoft side of the early days of working with IBM. Every night at 7 or so, he'd come back and spend maybe an hour with me answering any questions that had come up. 

That was all extraordinarily helpful. Once I had so much detail from Microsoft, the IBM folks could either let that version stand unanswered or find a way to respond — and soon enough almost every IBM executive who had turned down my request for an interview for the book found a way to talk to me at length.

The revealing part came because my base of operations abutted Ballmer's office. He had insisted on having the smallest size of office available at Microsoft, even though he was the No. 2 executive, and he was like a caged animal in there. He sounded at times like he was literally bouncing off the walls. He bellowed so much, at least in those days, that he had to take voice lessons to learn how to be himself while not damaging his vocal cords. He was mostly enthusiastic but could also be extraordinarily loud when upset. I've never seen such range of emotion in an executive. 

A Novel Approach to Curbing Healthcare Costs

In this Future of Risk interview, Quizzify CEO Al Lewis lays out an unconventional, bottoms-up approach to healthcare: He educates consumers to only pursue care that will likely benefit them and not expose them to harm. 

al lewis interview
headshot of al lewis

Al Lewis wears two hats, both professionally and to hide his bald spot.  

Hat #1: Validation of Outcomes. Al is the founder of the Validation Institute, the authority on measuring validity of health outcomes. His two books on outcomes measurement both topped the trade bestseller list, while one earned kudos as the best healthcare book of the year. 

Hat #2: Employee Health Literacy. As “Quizmeister-in-Chief” of Quizzify, his mission is to teach employees to use healthcare services appropriately, using a Jeopardy-meets-Choosing Wisely-meets-Comedy Central format. Quizzify is authorized to display the Harvard Medical School shield. Examples:

  • Extensive trivia quizzes about lifestyle/nutrition, and especially how to find the hidden sugars
  • Customizable health benefits questions
  • Gentle but effective dissuasion of use of weight loss drugs. A 28-question “Curb Their Enthusiasm” quiz is used for “self-preauthorization,” to cull out all but the most committed users, who should be the only ones you finance
  • Slashing the cost of emergency visits and admissions by weaponizing EMTALA to protect you and your employees from hospital overcharges. Most of your ER bills will only have three digits in them if you follow his guidance

He graduated Phi Beta Kappa with honors from Harvard, where he taught economics, as well. He also graduated from Harvard Law School, albeit with no honors that time -- other than winning their annual trivia contest, of course. 


Paul Carroll

Health insurance has always driven me nuts. It just doesn't work the way it's supposed to work. The idea was that you would have these massive forces pitted against each other, but they've all been co-opted. Pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) were going to be middlemen, saving everybody money, but now they’re champs at collecting hidden fees. Health insurers were supposed to push back against unnecessary medical procedures, but they've learned that they're really just sort of a cost-plus operation, so they're in no great hurry to push prices down. 

All that said, I’ve always been intrigued by Quizzify, because you take a very different tack toward health. You go bottom up, rather than top down. Employers hire you because you say, Let's make the consumer smarter, because there are a lot of things that will not only make them healthier but also take cost out of the system. 

That's more of a preamble than I intended. I’d be interested in your historical perspective on health insurance and the enormous costs of our healthcare system in the U.S.

Al Lewis

You're spot on. Historically, all these great innovations like HMOs, PPOs, wellness, PBMs, and now even value-based care were supposed to solve our problems. But they’re classic examples of the observation that every cause starts out as a movement, becomes a business, and degenerates into a racket.

A main reason our costs are so high is there’s no economic disincentive for employees to push back on those rackets, because they pay only a small fraction of the bills. Most companies just give every full-time employee a benefit and say, It’s yours to spend. There’s nothing else in business where every employee gets an unlimited budget and no training in how to spend it.

Some companies that self-insure explain to employees that when they spend money, it drives up costs for everyone. I say, No, no, no, that doesn’t work. 

It’s just the opposite. You have to show people that it’s in their very own best interest not to demand or agree to many drugs, tests, and procedures – not because it's going to cost the company money but rather because too much healthcare can often be bad for their health. And that's exactly what we teach: Just because it’s healthcare doesn’t mean it’s good for you.

Paul Carroll

You and I have been talking for a long time about the wild claims wellness vendors have made about how they can save money for employers. I remember a piece you wrote years ago about a vendor’s claim that by screening 1,000 people it could prevent a heart attack. You calculated that the screening and preventing that one heart attack would cost $1 million and that 90 or 99 people would get unnecessary, possibly harmful treatment because of false positives from the screening.

Al Lewis

The false positives will always get you. Vendors didn’t have a clue about false positive math. Or regression to the mean or participation and survivor bias. Or maybe they did know all that and weren’t telling their customers.

Paul Carroll

Overuse is a point you make nicely in your description of Quizzify’s origin. Tell us a bit more about how it works today.

Al Lewis

If you educate people on their healthcare by asking them an entire year’s worth of trivia questions where the answer is always pointing you toward using less healthcare because you’re using too much, you're going to lose your audience. People are going to say: “Oh, they're just trying to save money on insurance.” So we have multiple topics in our monthly quizzes – questions on nutrition, mental health, gut health, health benefits. Even everyday health, like: “Is it safe to dip a chip after someone double-dips?” Makes the whole quiz fun and not a Debbie Downer. 

Our most popular topic is nutrition because it’s not just useful but also is a lot of fun. We mock companies, and we name names. We don't do this like the wellness industry does and just tell you to avoid added sugars. No, we actually show ingredient labels and ask: “Here is a bottle of Naked Juice that says in bold letters it has no added sugar. How much added sugar does it actually have?” The multiple choice answer is 53 grams. That's the level of specificity we get to, and people eat that stuff up. No pun intended.

Paul Carroll

Where do you most move the needle in terms of savings on healthcare costs?

Al Lewis

We don’t save a nickel on nutrition, and we don’t lie to employers to say we do.

Where we save the money is in the stuff that happens right away. You’re familiar with what we teach people about dental care. The savings are huge, because it turns out that most cavities don’t need to be filled, but something like 120 million are nonetheless filled every year in the U.S. It's the number one clinical procedure, by far. Instead, all the dentist needs to do in most cases is coat the cavity with silver diamine fluoride, like mine did after I asked for it, but we teach that you have to ask. Took two minutes, totally painless, and cost $40. So you save maybe $120 by not filling the cavity. Do the math: $120 times 120 million is more than $14 billion a year. 

If your dentist says they've never heard of the treatment, they're lying. They just don’t proffer it because it’s an existential threat to their finances.

We save a lot on scans, too. Our trivia questions teach that a CAT scan emits 100 times the radiation of an X-ray, and suddenly employees stop demanding inappropriate ones. Americans do twice as many scans as people in other countries, and with nothing to show for it. Just cutting back on the number that get demanded gives you about a 20% savings on that coverage right away.

That doesn’t include the savings from gentle pushback on scans doctors propose. My very own doctor suggested a CAT scan to me the other day as a follow-up to an ultrasound, but I asked the classic question that Quizzify teaches employees to ask: “Would the result change the treatment plan?” She acknowledged that it wouldn’t, so we didn’t do the CAT scan. 

Without Quizzify, nine people out of 10 would have had the scan done on the doctor’s say-so.

The best example of all is the weight loss drugs, where we have this 27-question intro quiz called, “Before Your Journey.” It's very simple. You require people to take the quiz, probably as part of your wellness incentive program. The PBMs get very upset and threaten your rebates if you try to do conventional preauthorization on your own, but they can’t stop you from educating your own employees in your own wellness program.

This is not preauthorization. It’s employee education.  Employees just take the quiz. If they still want the drugs after learning about Ozempic Face (with a great, wrinkly, before-and-after picture) or the fourfold increase in your chance of impotence, or 25 other things, we support them with a year-long curriculum to help manage digestive side effects and then teach them all the tricks that the food industry uses to addict them to sugar. 

But about 80% of the people who start the initial quiz do not continue to the drugs, once they understand more about the downsides. These are mostly people who would have dropped out after a certain number of months anyway after wasting a ton of your money, so everybody wins except Novo, Lilly, and the big PBMs.

Paul Carroll

You also have an emergency room consent form that I know is quite popular.

Al Lewis

We do a lot with ERs. We show people pictures of two free-standing centers. One is urgent care, and one is an ER. We help people understand which is which, and which will charge far more than the other.

As for the consent form, a federal law says patients can propose whatever price they want to propose in an ER. The ER can reject your offer, but they still have to treat you the same as everyone else if they do. Quizzify’s Consent says the patient agrees to pay twice what Medicare would pay for the visit, and Medicare doesn’t pay much, so two times Medicare is usually under $1,000.

In fact, we’re going through this personally right now. My wife had an ER visit. We didn’t sign their consent form and gave them the Quizzify Consent instead. They accepted it, but then we got a bill that was as if they never saw what we wrote down, plus they upcoded a test to rule out Lyme Disease; they coded the test as a Level 4, a code that is reserved for moderately severe issues. The difference in cost is mind-blowing. But we have irrefutable documentation of our consent and that we are a Level 2 or 3, so we sued In small claims court, and I’m sure the bill will get knocked way down. I always win these things.

When you use Quizzify’s Consent, your charge for an X-ray will be maybe $60. You’ll pay $18 for crutches, not 10 times that. I have the actual invoices for those charges from a case in Pittsburgh. If anyone wants to write to me, I’ll send ‘em.

Paul Carroll

Every little bit helps, and some of these issues you’re tackling aren’t exactly little. 

Thanks, Al.


Insurance Thought Leadership

Profile picture for user Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership

Insurance Thought Leadership (ITL) delivers engaging, informative articles from our global network of thought leaders and decision makers. Their insights are transforming the insurance and risk management marketplace through knowledge sharing, big ideas on a wide variety of topics, and lessons learned through real-life applications of innovative technology.

We also connect our network of authors and readers in ways that help them uncover opportunities and that lead to innovation and strategic advantage.

Five Ways Technology Can Help Mid-Sized Carriers Reduce Costs

To combat rising costs, mid-sized insurance carriers should adopt technology solutions to reduce operational costs, streamline processes, and improve customer retention.

Reduce Costs

A 2023 study by the American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) reveals that the insurance industry saw a net underwriting loss of $26.9 billion in 2022, the largest underwriting loss since 2011. More recently, AM Best’s First Look Report shows that the U.S. property/casualty (P&C) industry recorded a net underwriting loss of $21.2 billion in 2023. That’s a slight improvement over the previous year, but it's concerning, nonetheless.

In an industry that is all about risk, this level of loss is alarming, especially when global trends beyond our control drive it. Inflation, climate change-fueled natural disasters, state regulations, and other factors are all to blame. There’s not much the insurance industry can do to curb inflation or the ravages of climate change. However, we can take a good, hard look at the things we can control. Reigning in costs around operations, claims management, and focusing on growth are all examples of things we can and should improve to keep costs down. By investing in technology to identify and solve operational challenges, carriers can be more profitable and create more value for their customers. 

Identifying Operational Bottlenecks

Mid-sized insurance carriers face various challenges that can lead to financial losses. Understanding these areas can help them take proactive measures to mitigate risks. Common ways mid-sized carriers might be losing money include inefficient claims management, labor-intensive processes, and legacy technology that fails to provide a solid customer experience. Modern technology can do more of the heavy lifting to streamline operations and reduce costs.

Mid-sized insurance carriers must actively address these potential areas of loss by adopting technology, improving risk management practices, and ensuring that operational costs are under control. 

So, where should they start?

Making Strategic Tech Investments

Let’s approach this in terms of emergency room triage. The first step is always to stop the bleeding. Where are the worst injuries that need your immediate attention? Mid-sized insurance carriers can leverage technology to streamline costs in these critical areas. 

  1. Automation of Routine Processes. Are your agents still using outdated tools like spreadsheets or re-keying customer information more than once? That’s a problem that’s costing you money. Implementing automated claims processing reduces the time and labor involved in assessing and paying out claims. By investing in AI and machine learning, carriers can improve claims evaluation, detect potential fraud, reduce human error, and make more informed decisions with minimal human intervention.
  2. Customer Self-Service Portals. Offering secure online customer portals where insureds can manage their policies, obtain insurance coverage cards, verify information, file claims, and make payments reduces the need for customer service staff and enhances customer satisfaction. Our research shows that customers who engage repeatedly with their insurers’ portal have a 25% higher retention rate.
  3. Data Analytics and Predictive Modeling. When it comes to risk assessment, leveraging big data and predictive analytics helps carriers better assess risks, leading to more accurate pricing and reduced loss ratios. In addition, the ability to analyze customer data can help identify patterns and trends that inform more targeted marketing and sales efforts, reducing customer acquisition costs. Analytics can help carriers leverage customer data to identify payment trends, user engagement, and the ability to track customer journeys and identify areas for improvement. It can even help carriers explore new revenue streams by dynamically offering customers new risk products based on their individual needs and preferences. 
  4. SMS/Text Messaging. Outbound messaging plays a pivotal role in customer retention and premium renewal collections. Our research shows that 26% of customers whose policies were on the verge of lapsing promptly paid their premiums after receiving a single SMS alert notifying them of the impending policy cancellation. Furthermore, sending a cancellation message via SMS on the renewal day slashed cancellations by 52%.
  5. Chatbots. Implementing AI-powered chatbots to handle simple customer inquiries can decrease the volume of calls and emails, freeing up human resources for more complex issues. Customers used to avoid chatbots at all costs. However, improvements in AI have changed that. Research shows that Millennials prefer to engage with chatbots first for basic assistance. 

By adopting these technologies, mid-sized insurance carriers can significantly reduce operational costs, improve efficiency, and stay competitive in an increasingly digital marketplace. 

To stay competitive, carriers need to focus on new customer acquisition and retaining existing customers while finding ways to keep operational costs under control. The good news is that technology solutions are available today that can solve many of these challenges at a reasonable price. It comes down to leveraging technology to demonstrate to your customers that you anticipate their needs. This is crucial for winning new business and building loyalty with the customers you already have. 

 

Sponsored by: ITL Partner: insured.io


ITL Partner: insured.io

Profile picture for user insured.io

ITL Partner: insured.io

Insured.IO provides mid-market insurance carriers with the most complete and modern SaaS customer self-service platform for mobile, desktop, and telephone IVR that is affordable and can be maintained with minimal ongoing technical support. It serves the complete insurance product lifecycle, including sales, payment, FNOL, and analytics. Using cloud-native technology, the platform easily and quickly integrates with any insurance core systems and can be tailored to each carrier’s unique needs. It delivers real-time data synchronized across all channels, providing greater process automation, reduced CSR utilization, and great business intelligence that improves operating performance. Insured.IO can be up and running in as little as 60-90 days.

Can We Insure Against Heat?

While climate discussions often focus on the indirect effects of rising temperatures, such as intensifying hurricanes and wildfires, some innovators think we can write insurance covering the direct effects on people and property. 

Image
rising temperatures

While the devastation from Hurricanes Helene and Milton has given all of us a lot to think about these past few weeks, I'd like to focus for a minute on a far less obvious but intriguing issue that the insurance industry could address as it helps the world adapt to climate change: What if we can insure against heat?

A construction company can purchase insurance covering, for instance, flooding that would raise costs and delay the completion of a project. What if that company could buy insurance covering delays and cost increases because heat made it too dangerous for people to work outside for days or at least required that they be given lengthy water breaks inside? What if property owners could buy coverage for the direct damage that heat might do to a roof? 

The idea of insuring against the direct effects of heat came up at an interesting gathering last month of a group called CIRCAD that is combining academic research capabilities with insurance expertise to advance the industry's ability to mitigate the effects of climate change.

The two-day, inaugural meeting offered a number of provocative ideas, including the possibility of using nature-based solutions to limit damage from storms and of having communities tackle prevention and purchase insurance, in some sort of combination with the property insurance that individuals and organizations buy now. 

I'll get to those ideas and introduce you to CIRCAD, but let's start with heat.

Jordan Clark, a senior policy associate at Duke University, who made the presentation on heat at the CIRCAD meeting in Atlanta, said the first requirement is an agreed-on way to measure heat. That may sound simple. Heat is temperature, right? But humidity is also a factor when it comes to the effects of heat on people and property. And, if you're insuring people, what you really need to know is how the heat might be endangering them — which means monitoring biometrics such as heart rate, blood pressure, and perspiration. 

So, not simple, but it feels to me like there's opportunity there. If construction can be covered for heavy rain and flooding, why not heat? Phoenix faced 113 consecutive days this year with temperatures above 100 degrees Fahrenheit. If construction wasn't halted or at least slowed on some of those days, well, it should have been. 

At the least, heat considerations should become a factor in existing lines of insurance. Heat can clearly impair health and even lead to fatalities, and it does more damage to property than we may understand, given our reliance on historical records.

When I caught up with Jordan after the meeting, he said: 

"There is increased wear and tear on siding and roofing materials and HVAC units due to extreme heat and fluctuations.... Homes, for instance, may be more likely to suffer wind damage than underwriters understand.

"This past summer, there were drawbridges in the New York City area where authorities had to bring out a powerful sander because parts had expanded so much that the bridges couldn’t close. Amtrak had to suspend service at times because the rails just got too hot. Heat increases wear and tear on bridges and other infrastructure at the county and municipal level. Heat can cause big problems for the electric grid."

For now, Jordan said, "We’re mostly looking at the data and having conversations [about how to possibly insure against heat]. But we’ve been increasingly engaging with certain sectors, such as construction and some municipal and county governmental organizations. And we have a pilot project going with an electric utility that pays it if temperatures reach a certain level, to cover the expected cost of shutting off power and having to compensate its customers."

He said more, too, in an interview. If you've stuck with me this far, you might also be interested in an insightful interview I did with Veronika Torarp, a partner with PwC, for this month's ITL Focus, which, as it happens is on Resilience and Sustainability. Among other things, Veronika said this about heat:

"There's an opportunity for prevention, through different ways to help with cooling and generally reduce exposures. That certainly will have implications on workers’ compensation and other lines, such as business interruption, when operations are affected by extreme heat. The first step for insurers is understanding the risk exposure that more severe heat is introducing to the lines they're already writing and products they’re already offering their clients. Once you understand what that risk profile is, there's also an opportunity to think about if you can introduce specialized coverage or specific endorsements or specific products around heat exposures."

The sort of back-and-forth between those two interviews — between the theoretical approach of an academic and the let's-find-something-valuable-to-do-now approach of an insurance pro — is the raison d'être of CIRCAD. (The back-and-forth may even have happened between Jordan and Veronika in real time at the meeting, as Veronika was among the 100 or so who attended.)

CIRCAD (which stands for the rather ungainly Center for Innovation in Risk analysis for Climate Adaptation and Decision-making) structured the meeting as mostly a series of 10 proposals by the academics (from Duke and the University of Georgia) for projects that would be funded by the major insurance companies represented there. The goals, timelines, and dollar amounts were placeholders, really just designed to get a conversation started — and they did. I've seldom seen a meeting as energized as this one.

Among the other ideas that really popped for me was the notion of community-based insurance. Some perils clearly relate to community (if the brush in my yard ignites in a wildfire, it's a danger to all the houses around me, and vice versa) and some others can (a seawall is rarely an individual effort), so why shouldn't insurance happen at the community level? A community focus would certainly get people to cooperate more on prevention.

The insurance professionals raised plenty of questions. A key one concerned equity. If your house is up on a hill while mine is in a valley by the river, why should you pay as much for a community flooding policy as I do? Another concerned concentration of risk. Several insurance executives said any company offering community-based insurance would need to have a portfolio of risks — not just flooding in one region, but flooding spread geographically, together with wildfire and other perils. 

But the idea certainly sparked some interest and will be pursued. (If you want to read more, here is a long report on a pilot project for community-based insurance in New York City.)

The possibility of nature-based solutions also sparked considerable discussion. The idea is that some combination of individuals, organizations, insurers, and government might, for instance, plant mangroves along shorelines to prevent erosion in storms. 

You can already see the complexities here. It will take a lot of work to decide who pays what, given the benefits they receive. Nature-based solutions are also rarely quick fixes. Mangroves don't grow overnight. 

Still, I'm sure that idea will be pursued, along with those about heat, community insurance, and several others. We're in the very early days, but I suspect you'll be hearing in the next couple of years about projects with ties to CIRCAD.

I encourage you to check out the group. If you have questions, you might connect with Francis Bouchard, managing director, climate, at March McLennan, who is one of the leaders of the group. 

I think it will not only generate some important work about climate but could be a model for aligning research at universities such as Duke and Georgia with major questions and opportunities in the insurance world.

Cheers,

Paul

 

A Season of Change for Life Insurance and Annuities

Traditionally, the L&A sector accepted outdated technology and manual processes, but now the industry is realizing that it can no longer settle. 

Person Holding Brown Plant Stem

For more than a decade, the life insurance and annuities (L&A) industry has been undergoing a transformation driven by multiple factors. Since the financial crisis of 2008, the industry has faced a series of formidable challenges, including global uncertainty, volatile markets, and a worldwide health crisis. The overall industry has proven resilient, but in recent years we have seen a resurgence of the L&A market, and the impact of this boom will continue to be felt as we look to the future – even as we start to see rates decline.

Today’s savvy individuals view life insurance and annuities not only as a family security blanket but also as a smart investment option. In 2023, total U.S. annuity sales reached a record $385.4 billion, marking a 23% increase over the previous year, according to LIMRA. This trend is also mirrored in the data from our platform – which is currently used by a third of advisers in the U.S. and which shows a nearly 27% year-over-year increase in annuity sales to date, with no signs of slowing down. Payout rates for guaranteed lifetime annuities have been at their highest levels in more than a decade, driving increased demand from first-time buyers, who have been capitalizing on the higher interest rates of recent years. And even with the beginning of rate cuts, the L&A market is expected to remain resilient, with factors, including an aging population and a turbulent equities market, continuing to make structured annuities products attractive. What we have been seeing in recent years is a shift in consumer behavior, as more individuals recognize the dual benefits of financial security and investment growth that L&A products provide.

Let's delve into the recent developments in life insurance and annuities and explore areas where this sector can grow and evolve further to better support consumers, all while strategically positioning itself to meet future demands.

Consumers are increasingly driven by financial mindfulness

Today's consumers are increasingly vigilant about their spending habits, thanks in part to various technology tools that help them budget and track their expenses. Consumers are not only monitoring their expenditures but are planning for future stability, which includes setting clear financial objectives and aligning their short-term decisions with their long-term goals. When it comes to long-term financial planning and security, life insurance and annuities are the cornerstones. Further increasing focus on improving financial literacy and financial management will drive more demand in the L&A sector.

See also: Solving Life Insurance Coverage Gap

The lasting impact of an era of favorable rates  

The higher interest rates of recent years made life insurance products more attractive to consumers and more profitable for insurers, resulting in more competitive offerings. Higher rates also meant that the returns on the investments that back life insurance policies and annuities increased, which allowed insurers to leverage this era of higher profitability to innovate and diversify their product lines - enhancing their market appeal. This competitive edge has not only helped to attract new customers but to strengthen the loyalty of existing policyholders. Even with further cuts on the horizon after a prolonged period of high rates, the impact of this innovation, coupled with macro conditions such as the volatility of the stock market and a record number of Americans approaching retirement age, are likely to continue to fuel demand for annuities.

An opportunity knocks

The 2024 Insurance Barometer Study revealed that many middle-income Americans, those with household incomes ranging from $50,000 to $149,999, are still facing a significant life insurance coverage gap. Even though more than half of this group (54%) expressed a strong intention to purchase life insurance, a large segment of this 50 million-person demographic remains hesitant to pursue life insurance due to a lack of information. When it comes to empowering middle-income Americans to bridge their shortfall in coverage and more effectively protect their financial futures, it is crucial that the L&A space addresses this information gap. Both manufacturers and distributors of life insurance alike should consider how they can do this in the way policies are sold and distributed, with necessary support from technology. 

Plugging the gap 

While it is clear that a lack of knowledge around life insurance acts as a bottleneck, it also presents a significant opportunity. Various tools in the market today can help manufacturers and distributors make complex financial products easier to understand for clients. For example, advanced digital illustration software uses imagery that simulates real-time scenarios and predictive analyses to make the information much easier and clearer to understand. Tools like this also enable advisers to quickly provide more accurate and personalized recommendations. Moving beyond traditional sales methods, digital sales platforms, including e-applications and illustrations technology, offer interactive and engaging experiences that significantly enhance consumer education and power self-service decision-making processes. These advancements are critical in making life insurance more accessible and understandable, which ultimately drives higher adoption rates and closes the information gap.

Expectations of digital experiences remain high 

When it comes to any type of purchasing, it’s no secret that technology has revolutionized industries. Consumers are now setting the standard for digital transformation, and it is not a one-way street. Both customers and those who work in the L&A industry now expect seamless and connected solutions across all aspects of their interactions. It’s important for the L&A sector to take note. 

Digitization is not a one-time transformation, but rather it’s an evolution that requires companies to continually analyze and adapt. Initially, offering online purchases of insurance did significantly simplify processes. Yet, with the emergence of specialized software for functions such as case management and underwriting, many companies found themselves dealing with incompatible systems and fragmented data. This fragmentation of data substantially complicates product delivery due to simultaneously fragmented processes across the entire value chain, hindering speed and efficiency.

Although fragmentation can be a challenge, recent technology advancements are leading the industry toward more integrated, end-to-end systems that connect the entire L&A value chain, reducing complexity and improving not only scalability but also the end-user experience. 

See also: Revolutionizing Life Insurance Uptake in Younger Markets

The season of change 

Life insurance and annuities can serve as a valuable complement to retirement and investment strategies, offering significant advantages that enhance overall financial planning. To effectively support customers on their financial security journey, the L&A industry must answer the call of technology to build seamless experiences. Traditionally, the L&A sector accepted outdated technology and manual processes, but now the industry is realizing that it can no longer settle. As technology infiltrates the space, we are seeing a shift in how motivated the market is to accelerate digital transformation. This has sparked a newfound competitive spirit, with carriers and distributors prioritizing digitization efforts to enhance speed, accuracy, and customer experience -- from quote to commission. This mindset shift is a driving force for the industry. Those who choose to embrace it now will position themselves with a competitive edge in a season of change.

A New Era in Life Insurance Underwriting

Life insurers are expanding their approach by incorporating non-medical data sources, such as driving reports, credit histories, and public records. 

Close-up Photo of Matrix Background

Traditionally, life insurance underwriting has relied heavily on medical data to assess risk, but the use of data is encouraging insurers to expand their approach by incorporating non-medical data sources, such as driving reports, credit histories, and public records. When used together, these data points create a fuller picture of the applicant, enabling more nuanced risk segmentation, offering new opportunities for both insurers and applicants. 

Medical and non-medical data are commonly used in life insurance underwriting workflows, but their simultaneous consideration is less typical. The 2024 Life Insurance Mortality Risk Management Study, published by LexisNexis Risk Solutions, highlights that, by combining medical and non-medical data, insurers can better segment applicants, even within populations traditionally deemed high-risk. 

The Shift Toward Data Integration

This trend toward diverse data usage within the underwriting process is a fundamental shift in how risk is assessed. For decades, life insurers used medical data alone to determine an applicant’s insurability. While effective, these methods are often time-consuming and costly. By introducing non-medical data into the equation, insurers can develop a more comprehensive understanding of an individual’s risk profile without relying solely on medical information.

For instance, combining medical data with non-medical insights uncovered that applicants with type 2 diabetes or asthma, typically considered high-risk, might still qualify for accelerated underwriting. Specifically, the research showed that 10% of applicants with type 2 diabetes and 60% with asthma have average or better-than-average mortality risk. However, an applicant with both a recent DUI record and a diagnosis of alcohol abuse was found to have a mortality risk five and a half times higher than average. This level of insight is invaluable for tailoring risk management strategies.

See also: The True Cost of Big (Bad) Data

Enhancing Operational Efficiency

The integration of medical and non-medical data is also transforming the operational efficiency of the underwriting process. The traditional underwriting model often involves multiple layers of review, including medical exams, lab tests, blood draws, and detailed health histories. This process can be slow and drawn out, leading to delays in policy issuance and, in some cases, applicant drop-off.

The study by LexisNexis Risk Solutions found that incorporating non-medical data could reduce the need for invasive medical exams and allow for quicker decision-making. Applicants who might have been flagged for manual review based on medical data alone could be reclassified for accelerated underwriting when their non-medical data suggests lower-than-expected risk. LexisNexis Risk Solutions was able to identify 60% of applicants with asthma who are good candidates for accelerated underwriting, as well as the 20% who warrant closer scrutiny in manual underwriting. With insights like this, carriers can more effectively analyze applications and make optimal use of underwriting resources. This not only speeds up the underwriting process but also reduces costs for insurers, making the entire operation more efficient.

Further, the ability to make faster, data-driven decisions is increasingly important in today’s market. Consumers are becoming more accustomed to seamless, digital-first experiences, and the life insurance industry is no exception. In addition to incorporating non-medical data, the availability of electronic health records (EHRs) can further expedite the life underwriting process. By having near-real-time access to both non-medical data and electronic health records (EHRs), insurers can quickly retrieve and analyze comprehensive medical information side by side with non-medical data, eliminating the need for time-consuming manual collection and review of paper-based records. A streamlined underwriting process that delivers quick results can significantly enhance the customer experience, making it less likely that applicants will abandon the process due to frustration or delays.

Broadening Access 

Another aspect of using more data is its potential to broaden access to life insurance, particularly for populations that are traditionally underserved. High-risk applicants, such as those with chronic conditions like diabetes or asthma, often face challenges in obtaining life insurance or are subject to higher premiums and lengthy underwriting processes. However, by considering non-medical data, insurers can identify segments within these populations that present lower-than-expected risks. 

The 2024 Life Insurance Mortality Risk Management Study found that among the 50 million individuals studied, 10% have type 2 diabetes. While traditionally not selected for accelerated underwriting due to a high standardized mortality rate (SMR) of 157%, the study found that 10% of these individuals could be good candidates for accelerated underwriting by combining medical and non-medical data. These individuals might otherwise be overlooked for faster processing under traditional models that rely solely on medical data. With more data sources, insurers can offer competitive rates and streamlined processes to applicants who may have been previously categorized as high-risk, thus expanding coverage to a broader demographic.

See also: A Data Strategy for Successful AI Adoption

Future Implications for the Industry

As the life insurance industry continues to evolve, the integration of medical and non-medical data is poised to play an increasingly important role in shaping the future of underwriting. This aligns with larger trends in the insurance sector, where data-driven decision-making is becoming the norm. Advances in artificial intelligence and machine learning are enhancing the ability to analyze complex data sets, enabling insurers to refine their risk models and make more informed decisions.

Beyond improving the accuracy and efficiency of risk assessments, this approach could also lead to the development of new insurance products tailored to specific risk profiles. Insurers might also use integrated data to identify emerging trends and risks within their portfolios, allowing them to adjust their strategies and offerings. As the industry becomes more data-centric, those who embrace these innovations will be better positioned to meet the evolving needs of their customers and remain competitive in a rapidly changing market.


Matthew Stull

Profile picture for user MatthewStull

Matthew Stull

Matthew Stull is the director of data science at LexisNexis.

He has over 15 years of experience developing and deploying predictive analytics in the insurance industry. He has degrees in mathematics and literature from La Salle University and has completed graduate work at DePaul University in statistics.

Steps to Begin Transforming Claims

The key is to use AI and the cloud for agile, incremental improvements that allow a "perform while transforming" journey. 

Magnifying Glass and a Document

Since the COVID pandemic, there's been a dramatic rise in costs associated with insurance claims. Many factors, including climate change, inflation, and the increase in the price of repairs or replacement items, have driven the increase. There is now enormous pressure to reduce insurance claims costs.

The good news is that several technologies can help. Leveraging AI and cloud computing and combining with rich data sets and low code/no code platforms can reduce costs and the time it takes to service claims. The hidden bonus is that these technologies go a long way toward improving the customer experience.

The key is to use these technologies to develop and deploy a comprehensive multiyear strategy with agile, incremental capability delivery—what we like to call the "perform while transforming" journey. 

However, embarking on a claims transformation and cloud adoption voyage can often lead to cost and schedule overruns. Migrating from legacy platforms to newer solutions is fraught with issues, including difficult business processes, manual, time-consuming tasks, and challenging integration issues. In addition, shuttering legacy systems, saving valuable records, and coming up with ways to address integration issues across multiple claims platforms can be very taxing. 

Understanding the potential issues is critical when heading down this path. Insurers must take a strategic approach to claims transformation to ensure short- and long-term success. 

Experience shows that using a modular plug-and-play architecture simplifies the transition. One strategy is to map a series of micro-transformations in three- to six-month increments to complete the transformation in one to two years. Taking a "bite-sized approach” to transformation leads to better results in both productivity gains and creating a better customer experience. For example, adding a claims tracker to customer-facing applications offers customers real-time insights into the claim status, reducing the number of calls to the agent.

One key to success is sourcing the correct data from existing platforms to ensure it matches what claims servicing agents see when fielding customer calls. For payments, it's the same—accessing information in digital apps in real time instead of via mailing checks leads to a better customer experience and improved customer retention. 

See also: How to Optimize Insurance Claims Management

Build a better data hub

Going down the path of claims transformation begins with a journey toward creating a solid data hub that democratizes valuable data. When a single data source is used throughout the entire company, all departments benefit. However, it's essential to establish access and control guidelines to ensure that data is used to generate positive results. IT leaders must design and implement data governance and access controls. 

One strategy is to use a multi-tenant architecture to separate company data and data from outside resources. Another option to get the most out of claims transformation is to design a system where the data hub can be segregated into domains with specific purposes for staging, transforming, testing, and providing data to the claims applications.

A benefit of this process is that IT departments don’t have to tackle challenging and complex legacy applications, reducing the core systems’ reporting and analysis workload. This helps reduce the time it takes to process claims since legacy applications frequently were built as “mods” or customized to meet the needs of the vendors’ products. IT leaders should also consider that new and improved data hubs can train GenAI solutions to create synthetic test data, which helps simplify test scenarios while not potentially tainting the original customer data. Over time, data hubs can deliver important training data for customer-facing AI solutions. 

See also: Why Do Insurance Claims Take So Long?

Keys to success for a claims transformation journey

While claims aren't the most exciting part of the insurance sector, they are a critical part of the overall success of any insurer. 

In today’s highly competitive insurance industry, company leaders focusing on designing and implementing a claims transformation increase their odds of financial success. Modernizing claims platforms, designed with incremental improvements to showcase benefits to stakeholders, will put insurers on a better path. 

While large-scale cloud reinvention and digital transformation may take a few years to implement, this type of agile approach greatly improves the claims ecosystem. It reduces costs, spurs innovation, streamlines operations, and leads to a vastly superior customer experience.


Saptarshi Mukherjee

Profile picture for user SaptarshiMukherjee

Saptarshi Mukherjee

Saptarshi Mukherjee (Rishi) is  U.S. region consulting head, insurance, at Wipro.

He has more than 25 years of consulting advisory experience in driving complex transformation initiatives with Fortune 500 clients globally. 

Trends in Data Breach and Privacy Risk

The frequency of large cyber claims (>€1 million) in the first six months of 2024 was up 14%, while severity increased by 17%.

A Padlock on a Fence

A new report on the cyber risk outlook by Allianz Commercial reveals that cyber claims have continued their upward trend over the past year, driven in large part by a rise in data and privacy breach incidents. The frequency of large cyber claims (>€1 million) in the first six months of 2024 was up 14% while severity increased by 17%, according to the insurer’s claims analysis, following just a 1% increase in severity during 2023. Data and privacy breach-related elements are present in two-thirds of these large losses. Overall, the total number of cyber claims in 2024 is expected to stabilize, following a 30% increase in frequency during 2023, which resulted in 700-plus claims.

The growing significance of data breach losses among cyber insurance claims is driven by a number of notable trends. A rise in ransomware attacks, including data exfiltration, is a consequence of changing attacker tactics and the growing interdependencies between organizations sharing ever more personal records. At the same time, the evolving regulatory and legal environment has brought an uptick in so-called "non-attack" data privacy-related class action litigation, resulting from incidents such as wrongful collection and processing of personal data – the share of these claims has tripled in value in two years alone.

See also: Top 10 Challenges for Data Security

"Non-attack" claims increase as privacy litigation ramps up

The rise in "non-attack" data privacy claims is the consequence of developments in technology, the growing commercial value of personal data, and a developing regulatory and legal landscape. For example, unlike the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), privacy regulations in the U.S. are less prescriptive and open to interpretation, while plaintiff lawyers are hungry for potential sources of revenue. This is creating a gray area that is ripe for class action litigation, the report notes.

We are seeing more data privacy breach claims in the U.S. where there is a growing trend for class action litigation against large U.S. and international corporations related to privacy violations, such as around consent and data usage. The cost of some of these claims can be even larger than a ransomware incident, in the hundreds of millions of dollars.

Over the last year, in particular, data breaches have emerged as one of the fastest-growing areas of U.S. class action litigation. Over 1,300 were filed across a wide range of data privacy regulations in 2023, more than double the number filed in 2022 and four times that filed in 2021, according to law firm Duane Morris. 

Multiple class action lawsuits have been launched against organizations across a wide range of industries, including healthcare, social media, and gaming, for using tracking tools such as Meta Pixel to monitor consumer behavior, while entertainment streaming platforms have also been targeted, alleging that they may have violated privacy protection rights. Large data breach events can also evolve into hyper litigation, with one event triggering a slew of class actions. More than 240 lawsuits related to the 2023 MOVEit data breach were consolidated into a single multidistrict ;itigation in October 2023. And with large numbers of claimants, there are incentives for parties on both sides to settle. The top 10 data breach class action settlements last year totaled $516 million, a significant increase over the $350 million recorded in 2022. 

The risk of data breach litigation is also growing in Europe. Heightened awareness of data protection rights, a rise in the availability of third-party litigation funding, and a more consumer-friendly litigation environment could make mass data privacy claims a reality, albeit not on the same scale as in the U.S., the report notes. 

AI to power and prevent future data privacy breaches

The fact that almost every industry is now using artificial intelligence (AI) will have a significant impact on the cyber and privacy risk landscape. AI relies on the collection and processing of vast amounts of data, including personal, health, and biometric information, for training AI models and making predictions or recommendations. But AI tools such as chatbots can create potential privacy, misinformation, and security risks if not properly managed. With so much data being collected and processed, there is a risk that it could fall into the wrong hands, either through hacking or other security breaches. There are also concerns around potential breaches of privacy laws, such as whether organizations have proper consent to process data through AI. 

See also: The Evolving Landscape of Cyber Risk and Insurance

From data exfiltration to data protection

Despite a general trend for increased investment in cyber security in recent years, many data breaches, including some of the largest mass data exfiltration cyber attacks over the past 18 months, are the result of weak cyber security within organizations or their supply chains. 

Such incidents can lead to a large claim involving regulatory fines, notification costs, and third-party litigation, in addition to extortion demands, first-party costs, and business interruption.

Data breach risks are best mitigated through good cyber hygiene, including strong access controls, database segregation, backups, patching, and training. Having better oversight of any cyber weaknesses in their supply chains is an area where many companies need to improve.

To read the full Allianz Cyber Risk Trends Report, please visit: cyber-security-trends-2024.pdf (allianz.com)

The Growing Challenge of Extreme Droughts

The Mediterranean shines the spotlight on the vulnerability of food supply chains to droughts, which are predicted to become more prevalent under climate change.

Arid Tree on Sandy Desert

The Mediterranean region has been experiencing a severe drought, driven by a complex interplay of meteorological and hydrological factors. Northern Africa has been enduring these conditions for over six years, as have southern Italy, Spain, and Portugal for approximately two years. In Cataluña, in the northeast of Spain, the drought persisted for more than 1,300 consecutive days. 

Precipitation shortfalls 

The Mediterranean climate is characterized by hot, dry summers and mild, wet winters; but, since 2021, winter rainfall has significantly decreased, especially in the Iberian Peninsula and the Maghreb in Northern Africa. The Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) has consistently shown negative anomalies across southeastern Spain and northern Africa, indicating a substantial lack of rainfall.

In March 2024, reservoirs in Cataluña were at just 15% of their capacity, though some relief came with late April and early May 2024 rainfall, raising levels to nearly 30% capacity.

Snow cover in the Alps and Apennines has also been well below average. Snow cover in Italy, for example, has decreased by 63% compared with the 2011–2022 average, resulting in reduced snowmelt and low river and reservoir levels. Furthermore, in 2023 and early 2024, Mediterranean temperatures were often more than 2°C above average, exacerbating the drought and increasing water demand.

Much-needed rainfall during the summer of 2024 has helped alleviate some of the drought conditions. As a result, since July, much of the region has shifted from a drought alert to a drought warning, reflecting the gradual improvement while underscoring the continuing risks.

See also: Parametric Insurance Can Tackle Climate Risks

Agricultural impacts and economic losses 

Drought has affected everything from municipal water supplies to the integrity of infrastructure. A significant consequence is the availability of water for agriculture. Spain, one of the largest European producers and exporters of fruit and vegetables, has been hit particularly hard. 

The olive, a cornerstone of Mediterranean culture and cuisine, exemplifies the drought’s severity. To meet growing demand, global olive production has tripled since the early 1960s. Spain leads the olive market, contributing 45% to the annual U.S. $15 billion global market; Italy and Greece each contribute around 10%.

However, warmer winters coupled with a prolonged drought have significantly reduced olive yields. In Spain, production fell to half of its usual volume in 2022–2023. 

The loss in olive production for Italian and Spanish growers during the 2022–2023 season was estimated at €4.15 billion (U.S. $4.45 billion). Retail prices for olive oil rose more than 2.5 times, making it one of the most shoplifted items in Spain. 

Recently, the situation has begun to improve, with production nearing the five-year average, indicating that prices are expected to start normalizing. 

While this story highlights losses to olive growers, many other Spanish farmers have suffered drought-related losses as well. With around 40% of Europe’s fruit production concentrated in Spain, concerns about global food security are mounting as the climate warms.

Government response and challenges 

The Spanish government has responded by approving €2.2 billion (U.S. $2.36 billion) in aid for the agricultural sector, including €40.5 million (U.S. $43.5 million) in insurance subsidies; however, most of Spain’s olive farmers will not benefit, as only 4.5% of the country’s olive grove area is insured.

Around 80% of Spain’s olive groves are rain-fed and highly vulnerable to changes in precipitation, with the remainder using irrigation systems. Increasing irrigation might boost olive production, but in recent decades it has caused environmental issues. In areas such as La Loma, Spain, the over-extraction of groundwater for irrigation has depleted aquifers, leading to long-term unsustainability.

See also: Climate and Catastrophe Risk Strategies

Climate change and future drought risk 

Climate change is expected to exacerbate drought in the Mediterranean by causing higher temperatures and shifting precipitation patterns. These changes will lead to faster soil moisture depletion and reduced water retention, affecting water availability for agriculture and other uses. 

WTW’s Global Climate Hazard Indices show that areas already under water stress, such as mid- and northern Cataluña, are likely to experience more frequent droughts (up to 1.5 times) in the next decade even under a "middle of the road" climate scenario. Conditions could worsen if we fail to shift to a lower-carbon economy and instead follow a high-emissions trajectory. For instance, drought frequency could significantly increase in the coming decades, not just to northern Cataluña but also to most of the Spanish Mediterranean coast under a fossil fuel economy. 

Other Mediterranean regions, such as southern France, Italy, and northern Africa, may also see more damaging drought, with frequency increasing on average 1.4 to 1.6 times in most areas by the next decade. 

Addressing drought risks and opportunities 

Companies can benefit from risk screening their portfolio of assets, operations, and supply chain to identify exposure now and under different future climate scenarios. This may lead to deeper dives on the most at-risk sites, to inform decisions about how best to avoid, reduce, or transfer risk. This type of work assists with risk management directly and informs disclosure and reporting on climate-related risks and opportunities, including the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, International Financial Reporting Standards, and the Securities and Exchange Commission climate rule.

Balancing Humanity in the Age of Generative AI

Striking a balance between AI-driven interactions and authentic human experiences is vital for earning customer trust and maintaining empathy.

Photo of Woman Being Examined

Companies are rushing to harness the benefits of generative AI (GenAI) tools such as ChatGPT, Copilot, and DALL-E. While GenAI promises cost savings and efficiency, however, customers still value genuine human connections. Striking a balance between AI-driven interactions and authentic human experiences is vital for earning customer trust and maintaining empathy.

See also: A Reality Check for Generative AI

Despite the excitement around GenAI, customers remain cautious, selectively trusting AI with low-risk tasks like crafting communications, creating meal plans, or generating workout routines. However, when it comes to more complex, high-stakes interactions, customers prioritize privacy and security. A 2023 study by the International Association of Privacy Professionals highlighted these customer concerns:

- 57% believe AI poses a threat to privacy.

- 53% think AI makes it harder to protect personal information.

- 81% worry about how their data will be used.

- 69% don’t trust companies to use AI responsibly.

While businesses explore AI for efficiency, customer-focused companies are addressing these concerns by being transparent about data usage and providing customers with control over their data. Offering human interaction channels alongside AI solutions helps maintain consistent and trustworthy experiences.

Customers Desire Authentic Empathy

In 2023, a peer-to-peer emotional support service faced backlash for using ChatGPT to communicate with users who expected human empathy in a vulnerable and challenging situation. While GenAI can deliver empathetic-sounding responses, customers were disappointed by the lack of authentic human connection, particularly in an emotionally challenging journey.

This incident underscores the importance of aligning empathy with customer expectations. For emotionally charged moments, such as dealing with insurance claims after the loss of a home or loved one, customers often seek real human support. As Danny Allred, leader of the conversational AI strategy at Nationwide says: 

“Companies need to consider how the transparent artificial empathy is transformed into authentic empathy with a person. This is where they will see real value in leveraging Gen AI at scale while still retaining the human element.”

By balancing GenAI’s scale with human intervention, companies can offer genuine empathy where it matters most.

See also: Balancing Technology and Empathy in Claims

Focusing on the Customer

To meet customer expectations, companies should assess key customer journeys and feedback to determine where human touch is needed and where AI can be beneficial. These interactions typically fall into two categories: consultative and transactional.

Consultative interactions require guidance, empathy, or emotional support. Here, human connections are essential, and AI should enhance, not replace, these interactions. For example, AI can support employees in providing empathetic service during claims or new product purchases.

Transactional interactions prioritize speed and efficiency, such as bill payments or routine policy changes. AI can automate these tasks, improving convenience for customers.

Recognizing the difference between consultative and transactional experiences allows companies to design more effective digital interactions. However, these distinctions aren’t always clear-cut. A transactional interaction may shift to a consultative one if the customer encounters issues, requiring empathy and human intervention. 

Customer journey orchestration technologies can help businesses identify these shifts in real-time, allowing them to intervene with empathy and prevent negative experiences. 

By ensuring that customer needs drive engagement strategies, companies can build trust and loyalty. Involving customer experience teams in AI strategy decisions ensures that AI is used to enhance customer well-being, ultimately helping them thrive.


Torrin Webb

Profile picture for user TorrinWebb

Torrin Webb

Torrin Webb is a senior CX consultant with Nationwide and a Certified Customer Experience Professional (CCXP)

He has worked in experience management and consulting for over six years and holds customer experience, data analytics, and digital product management certifications from Forrester, Google, and the University of Virginia.