Independent agencies are always looking ahead, but they're still focused on how much work it takes to place and service a policy today. Underwriting remains tight, carrier appetites change, and remarketing eats up time and resources. At the same time, clients expect clear, timely communication and fewer surprises.
In a recent Vertafore survey, independent agencies told us what will shape their operations in 2026. Three trends emerged:
- Using AI automation to reduce manual work
- Preparing for uncertainty in carrier appetite and placements across admitted and E&S markets
- Prioritizing proactive, consistent client communication as a defining trait of high-performing agencies.
What connects these trends? Operational efficiency supported by the right technology.
High-performing agencies aren't trying to predict every market shift, and they're not just adding headcount to keep up with more work. Instead, they're focused on how the work gets done. The agencies that win in 2026 are using technology designed for their workflows to reduce manual effort, adapt quickly to appetite shifts, and communicate consistently with clients.
Using AI to reduce manual work in insurance agency workflows
Carriers always ask for more information, pose follow-up questions, and make adjustments as requirements change. When agencies run that work through manual steps and disconnected systems, it quickly turns into duplicate entry, rework, and resubmitting applications.
To manage this workload, agencies are turning to more AI automation because they can't scale this work by hiring alone. In the survey, nearly 30% said they expect AI-driven process improvements to deliver the strongest return on investment in 2026, and more than one-third said the greatest value will come from AI embedded into the solutions they already use.
Today, agencies are successfully using AI-powered solutions to pull data from ACORD forms and carrier documents so the information can be reviewed instead of re-entered. AI supports everyday service work, validating information before it reaches service or sales, and even determining whether it makes sense to move forward before spending time investing in a full rating.
Over time, these improvements will expand further. AI takes on more of the manual work—redundant clicks, document routing, and non-licensed processes that consume time. This automation works in the background so teams can focus on licensed work and client conversations.
Managing carrier appetite shifts and E&S placements efficiently
Carrier appetite changes are expensive when agencies aren't structured to adapt. Every shift means rebuilding submissions, re-entering information, and spending more time redoing work that was already completed.
In the survey, nearly half of agencies said they expect to place about the same amount of business in the E&S market this year, and 40% expect to place more than they did in 2025. That tells us E&S isn't going away. Agencies are already seeing movement in both directions—some accounts shifting back to admitted markets as appetite expands, and others moving into E&S as underwriting tightens.
When an agency uses systems that are not integrated, a carrier decline can mean significant manual work—re-entering data, rebuilding documents, and recreating submissions from scratch. In the E&S market, where supplemental applications often appear late in the process, this friction adds up fast.
To manage these changing processes, agencies are using submission and application management tools to collect and organize risk information once by integrating with their agency management system. They pair these tools with benchmarking solutions to understand which carriers or MGAs will be most likely to write the risk, then carry the information out to the market without someone having to re-enter it. Solutions that talk to each other keep the work moving and teams don't have to rebuild the same submission over and over.
Why consistent client communication separates high-performing agencies
After years of pricing pressure, underwriting changes, and continuing remarketing, clients rely on access to their agents more than ever. They want to talk about coverage shifts and rate increases before they happen. When they have to call and ask why something's changed, it's often too late—they're already shopping.
This emphasis on consistent communication showed up in the survey. More than half of respondents agreed that providing proactive, timely communication will set high-performing agencies apart in 2026.
But for busy agencies, it's difficult to provide a higher level of outreach. Juggling renewals, remarketing risk, and doing the daily work that keeps the doors open keeps teams from picking up the phone or sending an email. When delivery depends on individual effort, important messages become reactive and clients get frustrated.
That's why using a marketing automation tool for communications is so important. These solutions can either be integrated within your existing management system or built into your CRM or AMS tool. Agencies that use these tools turn routine messaging like renewal updates, document readiness, and general market info over to technology, and use the time savings to have deeper conversations about more important issues. Automating second-tier communication means clients stay informed and agency professionals aren't spending time manually writing and sending emails.
Using this technology also means clients receive intentional touchpoints that show a higher level of attention and care. Agencies can automatically send focused reminders to homeowners about fire season, educational materials about important topics, or alerts about upcoming trends. Templated messages go out on time and people step in where judgment and empathy are required.
It may feel counterintuitive, but automating routine communication often improves satisfaction. Clients feel informed and have clearer expectations. Teams aren't overwhelmed trying to reach everyone at once. With the right solutions carrying some of the load, agencies can elevate their clients' experience and reduce workloads.
Operational efficiency matters for independent agencies in 2026
Across the three themes—AI-driven workflows, E&S readiness, and automating client communication—the common thread is operational efficiency.
The agencies that will perform best in 2026 won't predict every market move. They will invest in how work gets done—making sure their systems talk to each other, their processes are disciplined, and their teams aren't buried in manual tasks.
It's not really a technology story. It's about how agencies manage their business day to day. And the agencies that focus on that now are going to be in a much better position in 2026 and beyond.
