February 1, 2017
Why Trump’s Travel Ban Hurts Innovation
by Vivek Wadhwa
Trump’s executive order banning immigrants from some Muslim countries sent shock waves through the tech industry.
Silicon Valley exports technology and imports the world’s best talent. That is how it has helped grow America’s economy and boosted its competitive advantage. President Trump’s executive order banning immigrants from some Muslim countries sent shock waves through the tech industry over the weekend because it was a loud and clear message to the world that America’s doors are now closed, and that xenophobia and bigotry are the new rules of law.
It is no wonder that executives at almost every major technology company, including Alphabet, Facebook and Apple, have made statements defending immigrants and distancing their companies from the president. These companies are worried about their survival and the future of the country.
Let there be no doubt that immigrants are essential to our economic present and future. These newcomers start a disproportionate number of U.S. businesses, particularly in advanced technologies. Immigrants and foreign-passport holders occupy a growing majority of places in graduate education programs in computer science, mathematics, physics and other hard sciences. They play an outsize role in U.S. research and innovation.
A 2012 research paper I co-wrote, “America’s New Immigrant Entrepreneurs: Then and Now,” documented that 24% of U.S. engineering and technology startup companies and 44% of those based in Silicon Valley were founded by immigrants. My research also determined that immigrant
Study after study has found that immigrants are more likely to start job-creating businesses, not only in tech but across the economy. In 2014, 20% of the Inc. 500 companies had immigrant founders. That’s despite immigrants accounting for less than 15% of the U.S. population. According to research by economist Robert Fairlie for the Small Business Administration, immigrants are more than twice as likely to found businesses as non-immigrants, and 7.1% of immigrant-founded businesses export their products outside the U.S. as compared with only 4.4% of non-immigrant-founded businesses.
Clearly, blocking the path of immigrants into the U.S. cuts off the exact economic growth serum that has made America great. Creating an atmosphere where immigrants are fearful and uncertain about their future will reduce their incentives to open businesses here and stay. This is becoming even more so as other countries increasingly court educated immigrants and entrepreneurs. Those who support the president’s executive order say that the intent is to block people from countries where terrorism is sourced. But it’s not so simple.
By blocking entrance based on passport or country of birth rather than objective criteria, the executive order paints all immigrants from those affected countries and possibly dual passport holders with the same scarlet letter. What if the next Mark Zuckerberg happens to be Iranian? Or if an Einstein happened to be born in Libya? Let’s not forget that Steve Jobs’s father was Syrian — and he would have been banned from entering the U.S. under Trump’s dictate.
Yes, it is true that the affected countries are not the largest sources of immigrant entrepreneurs. But setting a precedent like this can mean that a politician can use this weapon against other countries that have become critical in supplying talent to fuel U.S. innovation. What if a frustrated president elected to block immigrants with Mexican, Chinese or Indian passports? The scenario, totally unthinkable a few months ago, is today entirely plausible.
In my 2012 book, “The Immigrant Exodus: Why America Is Losing the Global Race to Capture Entrepreneurial Talent,” I documented the stories of numerous immigrant entrepreneurs who were forced to leave the country because of shortages of skilled immigrant visas, called green cards. It wasn’t that we didn’t want these people here; American politics was caught in a political quagmire on skilled immigration. As a result, the country began suffering a brain drain, with highly skilled foreign-born doctors, engineers and scientists returning home.
With this executive order, Trump has made it clear that immigrants will have to worry about being singled out even after they have become lawful permanent residents; that their religion and place of birth may be the deciding factor in whether they are allowed to reenter the U.S. after going abroad. This will no doubt turn the trickle of skilled workers permanently leaving the country into a flood. Entrepreneurs who had wanted to come here will have now second thoughts.
Whether or not the courts uphold the legality of the executive order, the damage has been done. Already, the number of billion-dollar technology startups, commonly called “unicorns,” that are located outside the U.. has been increasing dramatically. Fifteen years ago, almost all were in the U.S., while today 86 of the 191 unicorns are in countries such as China and India. We can expect this trend to accelerate because the Trump administration has just added fuel to the fire of innovation abroad and handicapped our own technology industry.