Biggest Home Insurance Factors for 2023

Rising costs, general anxiety about the economy and a surge in relocation that began during the pandemic are driving insurance shoppers to seek more options.

Person holding a drawing of a house in their hands

The $800 billion U.S. home insurance market is being challenged by three significant market conditions. The companies that respond the best to these challenges will provide the biggest benefits to consumers and win their trust, while old-fashioned insurance agencies that fail to adapt risk becoming irrelevant very quickly.

How Inflation Affects Home Insurance

Inflation wreaks havoc on all types of consumer goods and services, and insurance is not immune. The cost of insurance goes up during periods of inflation in response to the cost of things that affect claims and premiums.

For example, the cost of repairing a home has increased this year. Materials and labor costs have gone up due to inflation and a shortage of skilled labor. As the cost to cover a claim surges, insurance providers raise their premiums. That's a costly double hit for the consumer.

For consumers who are already feeling their budgets squeezed by rising prices just about everywhere, higher insurance rates can be crippling. 

Customization of insurance coverage is key during times of high inflation. It's important for consumers to compare rates from as many companies as possible to make sure that they aren't paying more than they need to, or paying for things on their policy they don't need.

Companies that can leverage bundles while lowering overhead by keeping staffing and internal costs down are able to pass more savings on to the buyer. Times of higher inflation put a strain on everyone, but they can also reveal the insurance companies that are really working with the consumer's best interest in mind.

See also: We're Flying Blind on Climate Risk

Natural Disasters Are Increasing

Tracking data on natural disasters reveals a dramatic increase in catastrophic events, especially from 1980 to today. In the last 10 years, natural disasters have cost the U.S. $200 billion per year. As costs of repairs increase with the frequency of natural disasters, the cost of insurance premiums will follow.

In addition to homeowner's insurance premiums going up across the country, many property owners are not properly insured against catastrophic events such as floods. According to FEMA, floods are the most common and costly natural disasters in the U.S. Still, many homeowners are misinformed about flood insurance. There are several misconceptions about what flood insurance covers, how to buy it and what it should cost. It's important to consult an agent who can offer guidance on insuring a home against natural disasters. Too many homeowners discover after a flood that their policy doesn't actually include flood insurance.

Homeowners who think they are protected because they live in a desert climate that isn't listed as a flood zone should consider the recent deadly flooding that occurred in southern Nevada, including Las Vegas. In fact, 25% of all flood claims come from people living outside of high-risk flood areas.

With climate change causing an increase in catastrophic weather events across the country, the environmental impact to the insurance industry will only become more severe. It's important for consumers to understand what their policies do and do not cover when it comes to natural disasters.

This type of coverage is also a big differentiator when comparing insurance companies.

Relocations, General Anxiety and Rate Increases Trigger More Insurance Shopping

A rise in remote work opportunities encouraged many Americans to move during the height of the pandemic and continuing into 2022. The Southeast saw the biggest increase in population, as people left places like California, New York and Chicago for the warmer and less congested Southeast states such as Texas, Florida and South Carolina.

This influx of new residents offers a valuable opportunity to insurance companies that cover Southern states. Providers that can offer competitive rates and superior customer service should be able to grow despite challenging economic times.

According to a Consumer Pulse Survey conducted by Transunion in Q2 of 2022, topping the concerns of most Americans are inflation, the possibility of a recession and increased housing costs. As people reduce their spending in response to anxiety, they also take a closer look at their current expenses, including what they pay for home insurance. More consumers are likely to visit digital insurance aggregators in times of uncertainty. The ability to personally compare rates from over 50 insurance providers at once, without having to speak to a sales person, gives people a sense of control that they want, especially when facing an uncertain future.

The homeowners insurance market is very complex and still fragmented despite recent consolidations. Many insurance companies have failed to modernize their systems to the levels of customization and speed that consumers expect from service providers. That puts offline insurance companies at a huge disadvantage -- at the very same moment when more people are shopping around.

The type of insurance company that will be seen as the remedy to all of the insurance anxiety people are feeling will be one that has the best access to the data needed to deliver quotes from the most providers, offer a seamless online shopping experience and be able to ensure people that they are getting the coverage they need at the best price.

Survivors know how to turn challenges into opportunities. The home insurance landscape will reveal this truth as well as any industry heading into 2023.

Adrian Dzielnicki

Profile picture for user AdrianDzielnicki

Adrian Dzielnicki

Adrian Dzielnicki is a licensed insurance broker and CFA (chartered financial analyst) and the co-founder and CEO at

Before Nsure, he co-founded Graviton Capital, one of the largest microcap investment banks in Poland. In less than 10 years, he took more than 60 companies public on the Warsaw Stock Exchange, raising over USD$200 million. He received his masters in economics from Wroclaw University.

Read More