Download

Why MGAs Keep Taking Over

Managing general agents now sit at the operating core of specialty insurance, and carriers that still treat them as a side channel are misreading the market.

Insurance

For most of the last century, insurance had a simple pecking order. Carriers held the capital, employed the underwriters, and decided which risks to take. Distribution was something that happened around the edges. That order is gone. 

Managing general agents (MGAs) now sit at the operating core of specialty insurance, and carriers that still treat them as a side channel are misreading the market. According to AM Best, U.S. MGA premium reached $108.7 billion in 2025, up 18% from the previous year. The number of MGAs writing over $500 million doubled between 2023 and 2024. Growth is not spreading evenly across thousands of small players. It is concentrating in a handful of strong operators, and capital is chasing them.

A structural shift

Risk has become harder to price. Cyber, climate-exposed property, and marine need granular data and specialist judgment, and generalist underwriting teams inside large carriers cannot deliver either at speed. MGAs can. They have built their businesses around proprietary data, concentrated talent, and purpose-built technology. They launch products in months, where carriers take 18 months or more. In many niches, they also post better loss ratios, and the gap widens as risk gets more complex.

The smartest carriers have stopped trying to close that gap internally. They rent a solution.

The economics are the real story

Speed gets the headlines, but economics explains the boom. Industry ROE recovered to roughly 10% in 2024. Beneath that average, capital-light MGA platforms earn fee-based revenue with no balance-sheet drag, and leading platforms report EBITDA margins of 25-35%.

MGAs look good partly because someone else holds the tail risk. The carrier or reinsurer carries the volatility while the MGA collects the fee. That is a brilliant model when underwriting discipline is strong. The highest-return seat in the value chain is no longer pure risk-bearing. It is risk selection, distribution, and data. But that only holds if the party bearing the risk is choosing partners with real rigor.

Four engines, one flywheel

The boom runs on four reinforcing models:

  • Specialty. Cyber, crop, marine, and excess casualty are increasingly MGA-led, because focused platforms beat generalists on speed and data depth.
  • Fronting. Fronting carriers turned capacity into a utility, so a 20-person MGA can write nationally from day one.
  • Embedded. Insurance sold at the point of sale is projected to reach $700 billion globally by 2030.
  • Parametric. Once a curiosity, now mainstream for climate, travel, and event risk, with the MGA designing the trigger and owning the data.

Each feeds the next. Specialty needs fronting capacity, fronting enables embedded distribution, and embedded data makes parametric products viable. Miss one engine, and you are likely to miss the flywheel.

Geopolitics is now an underwriting input

The timing is not accidental. Trade fragmentation, sanctions complexity, and state-sponsored cyberattacks have turned geopolitical risk from a footnote into a pricing variable. Trade credit, marine war, and political violence covers are repricing in real time.

Cyber is where it all collides. Gallagher's 2026 Cyber Insurance Market Outlook sees global cyber premium growing from about $23 billion in 2023 to as much as $50 billion by 2030. MGAs are writing the leading edge of those new exposures, and carriers who cannot see inside those books will find out about problems the hard way.

Five moves for the next 12 months

If MGAs are the growth engine, the carrier's role changes. The winners will look less like underwriting factories and more like fund-of-funds managers, selecting MGAs the way an institution selects asset managers: explicit return hurdles, data-sharing covenants, and clear exit triggers.

Governance is the binding constraint, and it is where we expect the most carriers to stumble. A weakly supervised MGA channel is an adverse-selection machine. The carriers that succeed will industrialize oversight the way they once industrialized claims. Those that treat delegation as a way to outsource accountability will learn that regulators and reinsurers do not accept that argument.

The window is narrowing. The best MGAs already hold multi-year capacity commitments from a small group of forward-leaning carriers, and late movers will compete for the second tier on worse terms and weaker data rights. Strategic Shift expects the market's structure to be largely set by 2028.

  1. Audit the portfolio. Map every MGA relationship by premium, loss ratio, data flow, and strategic fit. Cut the bottom quartile without sentiment.
  2. Build the onboarding rails. Legal, data, and operational infrastructure should let you onboard a new MGA in 90 days, not nine months.
  3. Put geopolitics on the board agenda. Pricing, exposure, and reinsurance triggers need senior oversight, not a line in the risk register.
  4. Make data a contract term. Granular data, real-time reporting, and audit rights should be standard, not negotiated favors.
  5. Decide where to build versus partner. Internal MGAs make sense for proprietary data, scarce talent, or regulated lines. Everywhere else, partner.

Geopolitical fracture, climate intensification, capital reallocation, and data-driven distribution are converging, and the MGA model sits at the center of all four. The carriers that earn the best returns will not be the ones writing the most premium. Carriers need to audit MGA relationships by premium, loss ratio, data flow, and strategic fit. Build the legal, data, and operational rails to onboard a new MGA. Renegotiate contracts so that granular data sharing, real-time reporting, and audit rights are standard. Put geopolitical pricing and exposure in front of the board. And decide deliberately where to build an internal MGA, which makes sense for proprietary data, scarce talent, or regulated lines, and where to partner.

This article draws on Strategic Shift's whitepaper The MGA Boom.

How AI Is Redefining Credit Protection Insurance

AI enables CPI providers to evolve from product suppliers to strategic partners by adapting at retail speed while maintaining governance.

Insurance

In embedded insurance, the brand that owns the customer relationship increasingly sets the pace of innovation. For Credit Protection Insurance (CPI) providers, that creates a fundamental challenge: how do you remain strategically valuable when another company controls the customer experience?

Artificial intelligence could help reshape that relationship. Its greatest potential may not be simply to automate decisions or personalize protection but to enable insurers to adapt, execute, and innovate at the speed of the brands through which their products are distributed.

CPI occupies a unique position in the insurance market. It is often offered at the moment a customer is making another purchasing decision, such as financing a vehicle, buying a high-value technology product, or taking out a loan. As a result, the insurance experience sits inside a broader customer journey designed and controlled by another brand.

As those journeys become more digital, personalized and responsive, insurers have an opportunity to redefine the value they bring to their distribution partners. The question is whether they can become sufficiently adaptable and integrated to help those partners deliver better customer experiences and stronger business outcomes.

AI could enable insurers to assess more information, identify customer needs more precisely, and tailor protection to individual circumstances in real time. But the opportunity goes beyond personalization. AI could make the insurance experience as responsive and adaptable as the retail experience surrounding it.

Insurance Has to Keep Pace with Retail

Consumers increasingly experience digital retail as something dynamic. Offers change. Journeys are personalized. Products and promotions can be adapted rapidly. Global brands can evolve customer experiences across different markets while retaining the consistency of their overall proposition.

Insurance embedded within those journeys cannot afford to operate at a fundamentally different speed.

Consider an automotive brand offering finance and protection as part of a digital purchasing journey. The manufacturer may be able to adapt the experience according to the vehicle, market, customer, or commercial objective. When the insurance component remains relatively static, it risks becoming the least adaptable part of an otherwise highly responsive customer experience.

AI potentially changes that equation.

With access to appropriate data, an insurer could understand more of the context surrounding a transaction, identify relevant protection needs, and adapt offers to individual circumstances. It could also recognize when particular protection may not provide sufficient value.

But insurers also need to translate those decisions into action: configuring protection, generating quotes, enrolling customers, issuing policies, and supporting changes throughout the policy lifecycle.

The distinction is between AI that informs an insurance decision and AI that helps turn that decision into governed business execution.

From Supplier to Strategic Partner

As embedded distribution grows, insurers face a strategic trade-off. Partnerships with major consumer brands can create enormous distribution opportunities, but the brand increasingly owns the customer relationship.

The retailer controls the experience, distribution, and brand. The insurer can become less visible, raising the risk that insurance providers are viewed primarily as interchangeable suppliers of product and capacity.

The question is how insurers make their position within that relationship more defensible. One answer is to become increasingly valuable to the company that owns the customer relationship.

An insurer capable of helping a partner launch protection propositions across different markets, adapt to different customer journeys, and respond at the speed of a modern retail business offers considerably more than an insurance product. It becomes part of the partner's ability to deliver its own customer proposition.

AI could deepen that capability by helping insurers respond more intelligently to evolving commercial requirements, without treating every product variation or new market opportunity as a separate technology project.

The commercial implications are significant. Faster launches help partners capture opportunities. More relevant offers and streamlined enrollment can improve conversion. Responsive billing, servicing, and claims can strengthen customer satisfaction and retention.

Importantly, the insurer's value extends beyond enabling the initial sale. Every subsequent interaction influences how customers perceive the brand through which protection was purchased.

The future competitive advantage in embedded insurance may therefore not depend on owning the customer relationship. It may come from becoming indispensable to the company that does.

Consumer Duty Raises the Stakes

Greater adaptability cannot come at the expense of customer outcomes. This is particularly important in markets such as the UK, where Consumer Duty is raising expectations around how financial services companies demonstrate fair value and good outcomes.

AI introduces both opportunities and responsibilities. Much of the discussion around regulation understandably focuses on bias, transparency and accountability. But used responsibly, AI could also help insurers determine whether the protection being offered genuinely fits the circumstances in which it is being sold.

It could reduce irrelevant offers, identify where different protection may be more appropriate or recognize situations where an offer should not be made at all.

AI should not simply help insurers demonstrate that the correct sales process was followed. It could help them demonstrate why the resulting decision made sense for the customer.

As CPI becomes more dynamic, insurers therefore need to achieve two things simultaneously: retail-like adaptability and insurance-grade accountability.

The Foundations Determine Which Version of AI You Get

None of this happens simply because an insurer deploys an AI model. If customer, policy, product, and distribution data remain fragmented across different systems, AI inherits those limitations. Decisions may become faster without necessarily becoming better.

The same applies to product infrastructure. An insurer cannot realistically adapt protection alongside its retail partners if every variation requires extensive redevelopment. Nor can it support an international partner effectively if entering each new market means creating another technology estate and operating model.

This is where the relationship between AI and the insurance core becomes critical.

AI can interpret information, identify opportunities, and coordinate activity. But those capabilities must connect to the systems that manage insurance products, policies, billing, claims and customer relationships.

An AI-driven recommendation has limited value if the insurer cannot act on it efficiently. A more relevant protection offer matters only if it can be configured, priced, presented and issued within the customer journey. Similarly, a servicing decision must be capable of producing an appropriate, authorized change to the policy or customer record.

The opportunity is to connect intelligence directly to governed insurance execution.

That requires adaptable products, reusable insurance capabilities, appropriate permissions, consistent business rules, and openness.

Insurers and their distribution partners will increasingly operate across different technology environments, AI models and agentic systems. The ability to work across those environments, rather than requiring every interaction to take place within a single proprietary ecosystem, will become increasingly important.

Governance must scale alongside that flexibility. Insurers need to understand what information informed a decision, which rules and models were applied, what protection was presented and why. They also need to monitor outcomes and identify when decisions produce unexpected results.

These capabilities allow insurers to move beyond personalization towards provability: connecting the information available about a customer, the decision that was made and the outcome that followed.

For insurers supporting embedded distribution, that has commercial as well as regulatory significance. The strongest partners will be those capable of helping consumer brands move quickly without forcing them to choose between customer experience and insurance governance.

That is a very different value proposition from simply supplying a CPI product.

The Real Test for AI in CPI

AI will undoubtedly improve efficiency in CPI, automating decisions, reducing manual intervention, and enabling insurers and their distribution partners to respond to customers in real time. But those benefits are the starting point rather than the destination.

The greater opportunity is to make insurance more responsive to customers, more adaptable to the retail environment, and more valuable to the partners through which it is distributed.

As insurers become less visible to the end customer, their ability to create value for the brands that own that relationship becomes increasingly important.

The winners may not be the insurers that make the fastest AI-driven decisions. They may be those that combine intelligence, adaptability and governed execution to help their partners make better decisions, act on them and demonstrate the value they deliver.

In the AI era, competitive advantage in CPI will increasingly depend not simply on the protection insurers provide, but on how effectively they enable the businesses through which that protection reaches customers.

Insurers Adopt Property-Level Fire Suppression Analytics

Property-level fire suppression analytics enable insurers to assess individual risk characteristics beyond traditional community-wide classifications, improving underwriting precision.

Insurance

Fire-related losses remain one of the most significant and persistent sources of property claims for insurers. While catastrophic wildfires often dominate headlines, everyday residential and commercial structure fires continue to generate billions of dollars in insured losses each year. According to the National Fire Protection Association, U.S. fire departments responded to approximately 470,000 structure fires last year, resulting in an estimated $15.3 billion in direct property damage.

For decades, property insurers have relied on community-wide fire protection classifications to help evaluate fire risk. Those classifications have provided a consistent framework for assessing local fire protection capabilities and incorporating that information into underwriting and pricing decisions. They remain an important part of property underwriting today.

But the underwriting environment has changed. Rising replacement costs, tighter underwriting margins, increasingly sophisticated catastrophe models, and unprecedented access to geospatial data are reshaping how insurers evaluate property risk. At the same time, advances in cloud computing, geospatial analytics, and artificial intelligence now make it possible to evaluate fire suppression characteristics at the individual property level rather than relying primarily on community-wide averages.

That evolution changes the underwriting question. Beyond knowing whether a property sits within a well-protected fire district, insurers can assess how quickly firefighters can reach it, establish a reliable water supply, and begin limiting damage—and what those capabilities mean for expected fire losses.

Fire Protection Is Not Uniform Within a Community

Traditional fire protection classifications evaluate important characteristics of a community, including fire department resources, staffing, emergency communications, equipment, and water supply infrastructure.

Those measures remain valuable, but they also reflect an era when insurers had far less visibility into fire suppression at the individual property level.

Two homes located within the same fire protection district can have meaningfully different fire suppression profiles. One property may be minutes from multiple staffed fire stations, have excellent road access, and sit within a short hose lay of a nearby hydrant. Another may require a substantially longer response, rely on fewer responding stations, or have more limited access to reliable water supplies.

From an underwriting perspective, those properties do not present the same level of expected loss, even if they share the same district-wide classification.

That distinction becomes increasingly important because fire severity depends heavily on timing. Every minute required to reach a property, establish a water supply, and begin suppression can influence how much of a structure is ultimately damaged.

The Operational Variables That Matter

Modern geospatial analytics now allow insurers to evaluate fire suppression through a far more operational lens. Rather than assigning a single assumption to every property within a district, carriers can evaluate characteristics such as:

  • Road-network drive time from responding stations
  • Distance to nearby hydrants or other reliable water sources
  • The number of stations capable of responding within defined drive-time thresholds
  • Staffing models, including career, volunteer, or blended departments
  • Suppression redundancy if one station is unavailable or already committed
  • How these variables interact to influence expected fire severity

Each factor provides useful information individually. Together, they offer a much more realistic picture of how quickly suppression resources can reach a property and begin controlling a fire.

That operational perspective moves underwriting beyond geographic averages and toward a better understanding of how individual properties are actually protected.

Why Hydrant Data Matters

Among the many operational characteristics that influence fire suppression, hydrant proximity is one of the clearest examples of why property-level intelligence matters. Reliable hydrant location data allows insurers to evaluate a characteristic that can have a measurable effect on and relationship to claim severity at an individual property.

Research has shown that homes located within approximately 250 feet of a fire hydrant experience about 9% lower fire severity than homes located 250 to 500 feet away. At greater distances, the differences become even more pronounced. Homes located within 250 feet of a hydrant or other reliable water source can experience nearly half the fire loss severity of comparable properties located more than 1,000 feet away.

Historically, hydrant information was often treated as a simple eligibility measure—a property either met a distance threshold or it did not. Today, comprehensive hydrant datasets enable evaluation of hydrant proximity as a continuous risk variable, providing a more detailed understanding of how water availability can influence fire outcomes.

Hydrant proximity is only one component of a property's overall fire suppression profile. But when combined with drive-time modeling, station staffing, road network analysis, and station density, it becomes part of a much richer operational picture of how quickly suppression resources are likely to reach a property and limit loss.

From Classification to Prediction

Perhaps the most significant evolution is that many of these variables can now be evaluated against actual insurance claims.

Rather than relying primarily on generalized assumptions about community fire protection, insurers can increasingly identify which combinations of operational characteristics most closely correlate with fire severity and economic loss.

That represents a meaningful shift in underwriting philosophy. Instead of asking whether a property belongs to a particular fire district, insurers can ask more predictive questions. How quickly are suppression resources likely to arrive? How rapidly can firefighters establish a reliable water supply? Which operational characteristics are most closely associated with severe claims?

Those insights allow carriers to differentiate between properties that may appear similar under traditional classifications but have materially different expected loss characteristics.

A Broader Transformation in Property Underwriting

Fire suppression analytics is part of a broader movement across the property insurance industry.

Whether evaluating wildfire exposure, hurricane risk, flood susceptibility, hail damage, or severe convective storms, insurers are steadily moving away from broad geographic assumptions and toward property-level intelligence.

The goal is not simply to collect more data. It is to use data that more accurately reflects the factors that drive actual losses.

That approach enables more precise underwriting, more refined pricing, improved portfolio management, and better identification of profitable business opportunities. It also allows carriers to recognize lower-risk properties that might otherwise be overlooked when entire districts are treated similarly.

Turning Insight into Underwriting Decisions

Community classifications remain a useful foundation for evaluating fire protection. Property-level suppression analytics adds the detail needed to distinguish risks within those communities.

For insurers, the practical value lies in translating those differences into underwriting and pricing decisions that more closely reflect each property's expected loss. A home with faster access to staffed stations and a reliable water supply may warrant a different assessment from one with fewer resources or longer response times—even when both share the same community classification.

How to Prepare for the Super El Niño

With a super El Niño upon us, how can organizations protect themselves from weather amplified by climate change?

Insurance

This year, the world is facing a "super" El Niño, likely amplified by continuing climate change. This is happening at a time when businesses are also facing significant geopolitical and economic pressures that heighten volatility.

In this environment, organizations will need to challenge their modeling assumptions and build their own view on business vulnerabilities. While El Niño weather cycles have always driven weather volatility by shifting rainfall patterns, increasing drought risk in some regions and triggering intense flooding in others, there is evidence that El Niño and other climate or weather patterns are starting from a higher baseline in the wake of continuing climate change.

As sea surface temperatures rise, each El Niño now builds on an already warmer system, rendering what once seemed extreme or 'super' El Niño cycles as more likely. When the baseline for cycles that have long sat within standard catastrophe modeling changes, risk and insurance managers need to adapt to protect businesses.

Now is the time for organizations to build their own risk profile, one that may differ from the standard insurance view. Because while insurance models show how their risk may be priced, they may not show how disruption from increasingly common, extreme weather cycles will move through a business.

How does El Niño amplify physical climate?

If an organization operates across multiple regions, a strong or "super" El Niño can bring hotter, drier conditions in some locations and heavier rainfall in others. That can increase drought, heat and wildfire risk in parts of Australia, Southeast Asia and the Americas, while raising flood risk in parts of South America, East Africa and the southern US. It can also shift storm patterns, with fewer Atlantic hurricanes and more in the Pacific.

If a business is global, a weather shock in one part of the world can quickly become an operational or financial problem somewhere else in its value chain. A severe El Niño can disrupt supply chains, reduce water availability and damage infrastructure, with knock-on effects on production and energy reliability.

Past strong El Niño events, including 1997–98 and 2015–16, showed the same pattern of a single climate pattern triggering simultaneous stresses across multiple regions and business dependencies: drought in some regions, flooding in others and widespread disruption across food, water and livelihoods.

Risk, insurance and sustainability functions need to reassess how these extreme events, compounded by geopolitical volatility, could interact across an organization's value chain regularly.

Scenario stress testing can also help move away from looking at risks in silos. It provides a framework to quantify cascading impacts, understand how a risk profile could change and judge exactly how much disruption an organization can absorb.

Are standard catastrophe models keeping up?

Organizations may need to start treating insurance-recognized natural catastrophe model outputs as a starting point for deeper analysis rather than a full picture of your risk.

Most organizations still rely on catastrophe models to quantify risk, often by looking at perils such as flood or windstorm one at a time.

While these models remain useful, many depend on historical claims data and insurance-market assumptions that may no longer hold under today's climate conditions and compounding geopolitical pressures. They often reflect an insurance market view of risk: how the market sees exposure by peril, sector or line of business. In order to better manage the risks, a business instead needs to consider the specific vulnerabilities, dependencies and connections across its assets, operations and value chain.

If model inputs don't reflect the already climate-amplified conditions and specific vulnerabilities in an organization's operations and value chain to these compounding effects, they can understate potential losses.

How can you better risk manage recurring extreme climate events?

Start by defining risk tolerance in financial terms: how much loss can a business absorb and how often. Then stress-test those thresholds against scenarios that reflect current conditions and cascading effects, rather than historic averages.

Such inputs will give a better basis for benchmarking risk appetite and deciding what level of likelihood and financial impact a business is prepared to absorb on its balance sheet. If probabilities have shifted, an organization's current appetite and limits may no longer protect it.

Use analysis to decide what to retain, what to transfer and where higher limits or additional protection make financial sense. In a soft market, buying additional protection may cost less than absorbing the financial impact of a severe event.

Granular risk analysis to support better decisions

High-level models can't capture the specific vulnerabilities of a company's assets and operations. Carrying out more detailed assessments, supported by scenario stress testing, helps you build a business-specific view of risk.

By showing how exposure turns into loss across its operations and value chain, a business can build on the generalized market view to develop a clearer understanding of where disruption is most likely to occur, how it could spread and what the financial consequences could be.

Once an organization has a clearer view of its true risk profile, it can align financing with a future where extreme events happen more often. That may mean combining traditional insurance with captives, alternative risk transfer, targeted retention and adaptation measures, based on whether the business is best placed to retain risk and where transfer still adds value.

The stronger an organization's understanding of risk, the more confidently it can decide which losses belong on its balance sheet and which should be transferred, and where adaptation can reduce losses and improve the economics of the company's overall program.

Are We Really 'Trusted Risk Advisors'?

The test is the client file. Is it just information about transactions, or does it provide a full picture of the client's business?

Insurance

We have been talking about trusted risk advisors for years. How do we know whether we are developing them? Start with the client file.

If an experienced insurance executive opened a commercial client's file tomorrow, what would it reveal? Would it demonstrate a thoughtful process for understanding the client's business and managing its risks? Or would it primarily contain applications, quotations, policies, endorsements, certificates, loss runs, emails, and renewal instructions? Those documents are necessary. But they principally document an insurance transaction.

A risk advisor's file should document how the client's risks were identified, evaluated, discussed, and addressed. Agency and carrier leaders should be able to see that work when they review it.

For years, insurance industry leaders have urged agents and brokers to become trusted risk advisors rather than simply take orders and compete on price. My passion is helping insurance professionals develop the knowledge and judgment to understand a client's business, recognize exposures the client may overlook, and help management make informed decisions about risk. Their value extends beyond placing coverage to evaluating alternatives, recommending practical solutions, and following through as the business changes. 

For agency and carrier leaders, putting that vision into practice requires training, resources, and accountability that support advisory work. And when an agency tells me its producers are risk advisors, I want to know what they actually do differently.

What the Client File Reveals

Consider a growing regional contractor. A conventional insurance file will probably tell us its payroll, revenue, vehicle count, equipment values, subcontractor costs, loss history, and current insurance program.

Now consider what may have changed since the last renewal. The contractor has entered two new states, taken on larger projects, and accepted broader indemnification obligations. Employees are using personal vehicles for company business, and growth has outpaced the last review of property values and business income needs. Would the file reveal those changes? Would it show what anyone did about them?

These are not merely underwriting questions. They are business risk questions. And they illustrate why the distinction between selling insurance and advising on risk matters. Business decisions can change a client's risk profile well before the insurance program is reviewed. The risk advisor's job is to understand those changes.

In one matter I reviewed as an expert witness, the owners of a commercial building had requested a higher insurance limit. The agent recommended substantially less coverage based on a replacement cost estimate. After the building was destroyed by fire, the valuation became a central issue. My opinion was that the estimate relied on faulty information about the property and understated its replacement cost.

That experience is one reason I want to see more than a valuation report and a policy limit in the client file. What information went into the estimate? How was it checked? Why was less coverage recommended than the owners requested? What did the owners understand when they accepted that recommendation? A risk advisory file should help answer those questions.

The TRUST Framework

The TRUST framework provides a practical way to organize that work:

  • Talk Before You Tell.
  • Recognize Hidden Risk.
  • Understand the Whole Picture.
  • Solve Beyond Insurance.
  • Track and Follow Through.

Agency leaders can use these five steps to review what is happening in their own client files.

Talk Before You Tell

It is easy to hear a client describe a problem and immediately start thinking about coverage. The harder discipline is to keep asking questions until we understand the business issue behind it.

A meaningful risk advisory process begins with discovery.

  • What does the client actually do?
  • How does it make money?
  • What is changing?
  • What are its critical assets and dependencies?
  • What contractual obligations has the organization assumed?

The answers may have significant insurance implications, but they begin as business questions. A useful file records what we learned and what needs attention. Another completed checklist adds little if nobody acts on the answers.

Recognize Hidden Risk

Clients generally know they need property, general liability, automobile, and workers' compensation insurance. But clients cannot ask about an exposure they have not recognized. They need us to notice it.

Suppose our contractor begins temporarily storing expensive customer equipment during a project. Management may see this as a minor operational change. A knowledgeable risk advisor sees another question: What responsibility has the client assumed for property it does not own?

The exposure may ultimately be addressed through insurance, contractual arrangements, operational controls, or some combination of the three. But first someone must recognize it. A file containing only the resulting quotation would miss the most important part of the work: recognizing the exposure in the first place.

If premium placed is the only measure of success, the agency provides little organizational incentive to spend time on exposures that may never produce a policy. Agency leaders need to decide how they will recognize and support that work.

Carriers have a stake in this as well. Better exposure identification can improve submissions, give underwriters a clearer understanding of the risk being assumed, and help focus loss prevention efforts.

Understand the Whole Picture

We organize insurance work by coverage: property, liability, workers' compensation, and cyber. A client's business decisions rarely fit within those boundaries.

A contractor entering a new market may simultaneously change its contractual risk, automobile exposure, workers' compensation exposure, regulatory environment, and catastrophe exposure.

A company acquiring another business may inherit property, employees, contracts, cyber vulnerabilities, and liabilities that were never contemplated when the existing insurance program was designed.

The advisor must therefore see the client as an enterprise rather than as a collection of policies.

Carriers have underwriting, claims, and loss control expertise that can help producers recognize these connections. How much of that knowledge reaches the producer before a loss, and how easily can the producer use it with a client?

A strong relationship between a carrier and an agency should involve more than the efficient transfer of submissions and quotations. It should improve the quality of risk information flowing in both directions.

Solve Beyond Insurance

A risk advisor must be willing to recommend a solution that does not involve selling a policy. Insurance finances some consequences of loss; it does not prevent the loss itself. A risk may need to be avoided, reduced, contractually transferred, retained, or controlled operationally.

Consider water damage. The insurance solution might involve reviewing property coverage, deductibles, limits, and exclusions. The risk management solution might also involve water sensors, automatic shutoff devices, preventive maintenance, or changes in where critical equipment is located.

Cyber provides an even clearer example. Buying cyber insurance without discussing multifactor authentication, backups, employee training, vendor controls, and incident response planning addresses only one portion of the problem.

An agent does not need to give legal advice to recognize that a contract needs legal review. The same principle applies to engineering, cybersecurity and safety issues: recognize the need and help bring the right specialist into the discussion.

For agency owners, that may require developing networks of outside expertise. For carriers, it creates opportunities to differentiate themselves through loss control, risk engineering, data, claims expertise, and other services that support the advisory relationship.

Track and Follow Through

A good risk review usually ends with unfinished business. Someone needs to verify values, obtain legal advice, investigate a coverage alternative, or make a decision.

What happens next? Too often, the answer is that the issue disappears into an email chain until the next renewal. A strong advisory process should establish:

  • the issue identified;
  • recommendations and alternatives discussed;
  • the client's decision;
  • information still required;
  • responsibility for the next action; and
  • a follow-up date.

At the next review, we should be able to see what was completed, what remains open, and why.

Technology can now gather data, prefill applications, assist with coverage comparisons, and automate routine communications. As carriers and agencies make the insurance transaction more efficient, they also need to ask where the producer adds value. If technology handles more of the transaction, what will clients need from their agent or broker?

I believe much of that value must come from something technology cannot accomplish by itself: understanding the client's business well enough to identify exposures, challenge assumptions, evaluate alternatives, and help management make informed decisions about risk.

The Question Agency Leaders Should Be Asking

Agency leaders frequently say they want producers to become trusted advisors. But organizations ultimately produce the behaviors their systems encourage.

Agencies routinely measure new business, retention, premium, revenue, and cross-selling. What do they measure about the quality of advice?

  • Does the agency's account review process identify material changes in the client's business?
  • Are recommendations and client decisions recorded?
  • Are unresolved risk issues assigned and followed?
  • Do producers have access to specialists when a client's problem extends beyond their expertise?
  • Most importantly, if senior management periodically reviewed client files, would those files demonstrate an advisory process?

If the answers reveal little evidence of an advisory process, calling employees "risk advisors" does not make them risk advisors.

Carriers Should Be Asking a Related Question

Insurance companies have invested heavily in helping agencies transact business more efficiently. That investment should continue. But carriers should also consider how they can help distribution partners advise better.

Carriers possess enormous amounts of risk knowledge. They see claims across thousands or millions of insureds and employ underwriters, claims professionals, risk engineers, and specialists with expertise an individual agency could never replicate.

When claims experience reveals a recurring exposure, how does that information reach agents and their clients? When an underwriter identifies a gap, does the conversation end with a coverage requirement, or does it help the client understand the underlying risk?

Show Me the File

Borrowing the famous line "Show me the money!" from Jerry Maguire, I would say, "Show me the file." If we are building trusted risk advisors, let's see the evidence.

If I were sitting with the senior leadership team of an insurance agency that told me, "Our producers are trusted risk advisors," I would ask to see several client files. If I were sitting with a carrier that told me, "We help our agents deliver more value to their clients," I would want to understand exactly how.

The file should show what we learned about the business, which exposures we discussed, what the client decided, and who is following up on unresolved issues. If the file answers only "What insurance did we sell?", the relationship is still largely transactional. A true risk advisory file answers a much more important question: "How did we help this client understand and manage risk?"

Technology may give producers more time to advise. Whether they use that time well should be visible in the client file. Before we congratulate ourselves on building trusted risk advisors, let's open a few files and see.


Michael Gay

Profile picture for user MichaelGay

Michael Gay

Michael Gay, CPCU, AAI, AAI-M, AINS, AIS, ARM, CRIS, RMPE, is principal at Michael Gay Consulting.

He has more than 40 years of property and casualty insurance experience spanning underwriting, brokerage, agency management, program administration, risk management, consulting and expert witness work. He is coauthor of Risk-Proof Your Business: The Complete Guide to Smart Insurance Choices.

 

Innovation Creates Potential. Execution Creates Performance.

Automotive services companies that execute consistently at scale outperform those that simply innovate first or grow fastest.

Insurance

The automotive services industry has no shortage of new ideas. The harder challenge is turning those ideas into consistent commercial results.

A pilot, product launch or signed agreement can demonstrate progress, but none of those milestones proves that a business can perform at scale. Commercial value develops when customers adopt the product, the program becomes part of daily operations, and the organization can deliver consistently as participation and transaction volume grow.

Building a product and building a sustainable business around it require different capabilities. A strong concept may create the initial opportunity, but long-term performance depends on sound product and pricing decisions, underwriting alignment, implementation ownership, scalable service infrastructure, reliable data, and clear accountability.

Dealers and companies that manage those elements well are better positioned to turn market opportunities into measurable results. They may not be the first companies to enter a category or the largest providers in the market. Their advantage comes from being able to deliver consistently after the initial sale.

Early Success Does Not Prove Scale

Being first to market can create an early advantage, but that advantage has limited value if the business cannot support customers after launch.

A similar shift is taking place in insurtech, where investors are placing greater emphasis on demonstrated commercial traction. According to CB Insights' State of Insurtech 2025 report, just 24% of 2025 insurtech deals with a Commercial Maturity score went to companies in its earliest "Emerging" or "Validating" categories, compared with 46% of deals across the broader venture market.

The shift reflects a more practical evaluation of innovation. Investors still value new ideas, but they are directing more capital toward companies that can demonstrate commercial maturity, scale and repeatable performance.

Automotive companies should apply the same standard when evaluating a product or provider. They should look at how many customers are actively using the product, how reliably the service is being delivered, and whether the provider can manage a significant increase in volume without weakening the customer experience. They should also test whether the economics remain viable as participation and transaction volume grow.

Early results matter, but they do not provide a complete picture of how a program will perform at scale.

Scale Changes the Requirements

The pressure to execute at scale applies to established companies just as much as it does to startups.

The U.S. auto dealer market remains highly fragmented, but consolidation continues as larger dealership groups expand through acquisitions and new franchise opportunities, according to Morningstar's 2026 analysis of the sector.

At the same time, broader M&A activity remains active. KPMG's 2026 Global M&A Outlook found that 56% of surveyed dealmakers expected their M&A pipelines to be higher in 2026 than in 2025, with private equity respondents reporting particularly strong deal expectations.

Consolidation can provide access to more capital, technology and operating resources, but it also creates additional complexity. A larger organization has more customers, systems, processes and service points to manage. Without a disciplined operating structure, each addition creates another opportunity for inconsistency.

For dealers, insurers, F&I administrators and automotive service providers, company size is only one consideration. The more important question is whether the organization can maintain its service standards as volume, complexity, and customer expectations increase.

Scale changes the operating environment. More claims are submitted. More customers require support. More systems must connect. More handoffs occur between teams and partners. A process that works at low volume can become a point of failure when transaction levels increase.

That is why scale must be tested operationally, not assumed.

Execution Is a Business Capability

A scalable operating model must support additional volume without creating corresponding service problems.

Claims should be processed according to consistent standards whether a program serves 1,000 customers or 100,000. Customer service teams should provide the same level of support across markets. Technology should connect with a partner's existing systems without requiring a new manual workaround for every implementation.

Execution also requires coordination across areas of the automotive services industry that have traditionally operated independently. F&I products, tire and glass services, repair networks, and roadside assistance may have different operating models, but customers experience them as parts of the same service journey.

When a handoff fails, the customer does not distinguish between the company, system or department responsible for the problem. The failure affects every brand associated with the transaction.

Managing those handoffs requires defined processes, clear ownership and testing under real operating conditions. It also requires continuing improvement based on service data, partner feedback, and customer outcomes.

For that reason, execution should be managed as a core business capability.

Hiring more people does not automatically create scale. Adding technology does not automatically create scale. Expanding into more markets does not automatically create scale. The processes behind the operation must remain reliable as transaction volume and complexity increase.

AI Amplifies the Operating Model

The same principle applies to AI.

Technology can increase the capacity of a sound operating model, but it cannot substitute for one.

AI can improve areas such as scheduling, claims intake, customer communication, and workflow management. It can reduce manual work, improve response times, and help teams manage higher transaction volumes.

But if the underlying data is unreliable, workflows are inconsistent, or responsibilities are unclear, automation carries those weaknesses into the new process. In some cases, it can expose them faster by increasing the amount of work moving through the system.

Companies evaluating AI should therefore look beyond the technology itself. They should examine the operating environment in which it will be used.

  • Is the data reliable?
  • Are the workflows clearly defined?
  • Are exceptions understood?
  • Is ownership clear when something goes wrong?

The quality of the infrastructure, data, and processes will have a direct effect on the quality of the result.

How to Evaluate a Partner

Automotive companies should evaluate potential partners based on their ability to perform, rather than relying primarily on company age, size, funding, or market visibility.

The evaluation should include practical operating questions:

  • Has the provider demonstrated that its infrastructure can manage meaningful volume?
  • What happens when claims spike or demand changes unexpectedly?
  • Which parts of the implementation are proven, and which are still being developed?
  • Can the provider integrate with existing systems and processes?
  • Does it have the service infrastructure to support customers after launch?
  • Are its pricing and underwriting models aligned with the economics of the program?
  • Who owns the implementation?
  • Who is accountable when something does not work?
  • Can the provider support growth without creating a corresponding increase in service failures or operating costs?

These questions provide a clearer view of the provider's operating model than a sales presentation alone.

Technology should be evaluated as part of that model, not separately from it. Its value depends on how well it supports implementation, service delivery, customer experience and growth.

The automotive services industry needs new products, stronger technology and better approaches to longstanding problems. Innovation creates the opportunity, but execution determines whether that opportunity becomes a durable business.

A concept may be promising. A pilot may produce strong initial results. An agreement may create expectations.

A sustainable business develops when an organization can repeat that success across customers, markets, and transaction volumes while maintaining reliability, sound economics, and accountability.

In automotive services, the strongest competitive advantage is the ability to deliver what was promised consistently and at scale.

Marine Insurance Shifts to Detect Dark Vessels

Marine insurers are shifting from a system where vessels provide their location, to models using ocean physics to detect dark vessels.

Insurance

For decades, maritime risk assessment has relied heavily on a singular foundational layer: cooperative tracking. Through the Automatic Identification System (AIS), underwriters and claims adjusters have historically built risk models based on where a vessel says it is.

However, as dark vessel activity, geopolitical evasion tactics, and AIS spoofing become increasingly sophisticated, the limitations of self-reported data are becoming evident. In congested chokepoints and high-risk corridors, relying primarily on AIS position and declared flag state is no longer a true risk assessment—it is essentially a receipt.

To evaluate complex marine risk effectively, the industry is undergoing a paradigm shift. We are moving away from cooperative tracking and toward "deterministic risk," leveraging the undeniable physics of the ocean to establish independent, objective baselines.

The Blind Spot of Cooperative Tracking

Cooperative tracking models are inherently vulnerable because they require the asset to participate in its own surveillance. When an AIS transponder is switched off or its signal is manipulated, the traditional risk picture goes dark. Trend lines break, historical averages become unreliable, and claims adjusters are left parsing conflicting statements rather than evaluating objective environmental conditions.

The solution to this data gap lies not in building better AIS algorithms, but in bypassing the need for cooperative signals altogether.

Fusing Multi-Spectral Data to Establish Physical Reality

You cannot hide a hull from the physics of the ocean. A vessel operating "dark" still displaces water, interacts with subsurface currents, disturbs sea-surface roughness, and leaves a thermal signature.

Today's most advanced maritime intelligence architectures are capturing these physical realities by continuously ingesting and fusing multiple layers of environmental and spatial data. By combining up to 18 distinct layers—including space-based synthetic aperture radar (SAR), bathymetry (seafloor topography), sea surface temperatures (SST), chlorophyll-a density, and geomagnetic disturbance data—risk models can detect the physical presence of a hull rather than waiting for a digital signal.

Because SAR can penetrate cloud cover and operate in total darkness, it provides an all-weather capability to detect vessels that have intentionally gone dark. When SAR data is fused with environmental data like mixed layer depth and wave height, anomalies become mathematically distinct. A deviation from the established environmental baseline equates to a deterministic risk signal.

From Reactive Tracking to Forward-Looking Probability

For marine insurers, the transition to deterministic risk grids unlocks entirely new capabilities across both underwriting and claims:

  • Underwriting and Voyage Planning: Rather than looking backward at "where the vessel was," deterministic models provide a forward-looking probability map. By evaluating route-specific exposure, environmental hazards, and dark-vessel congestion corridors, underwriters can forecast where vessels will be and where deception is mathematically likely to occur, up to 60 days in advance.
  • Forensic Claims Analysis: Following a loss, claims adjusters often face hurdles in establishing the exact ground-truth environmental conditions at the time of the incident. Multi-layered data fusion replaces fragmented weather reports with court-admissible, objective intelligence, streamlining complex investigations.
  • Compliance and Sanctions: Compliance teams are empowered with objective behavioral baselines rather than relying on self-reported documentation, allowing for proactive mitigation in high-risk zones.
Conclusion

As marine risk grows more complex, the tools used to evaluate it must evolve beyond the data an asset is willing to share. By looking at the ocean's physical signals—the gradients, temperatures, and topography that cannot be hidden or spoofed—the marine insurance industry is finally moving from reactive observation to true, physics-grounded risk prediction.

AI Fraud Finds a Weak Spot

AI-generated fake IDs are flooding rental applications, turning lease approvals into unsecured credit decisions with little regulatory oversight.

Insurance

In September 2025, a man calling himself Igor was approved for two apartments in Hollywood, each renting for $5,300 a month. His bank statements, proof of employment and ID all cleared. Two days later, the landlord's bank flagged the cashier's checks for first and last month's rent as fraudulent.

When the owner, Michael Renkow, got to the building, one door was pinned shut from the inside. Meanwhile, in another unit, a woman who had paid Igor to sublet told him she had established residency and wasn't leaving.

The eviction took seven months, and Renkow said the whole episode cost him about $90,000. In May 2026, he was thinking about selling the building altogether.

If a bank had onboarded a customer that way, it would be a compliance scandal. But in rental housing, it barely made the news, and the only reason we know how it ended is that the suspect used his real face on the fake ID. Police eventually tracked him down, but not until January this year--four full months after the initial lease was signed.

Leasing is one of the least protected onboarding checkpoints in the financial system, and AI has found it.

A credit decision nobody deems as one

Think about what a lease actually is. A 12-month lease at $5,300 a month is roughly $63,600 in rent extended on trust, plus the keys to an asset worth far more. That's an unsecured credit decision by any reasonable definition, and yet, it's usually made by a leasing agent with a deadline, looking at PDFs.

The deadline is part of the problem. Chris Rankin, CEO of screening company Rent Butter, told Bisnow that tighter competition and ever-larger portfolios are pushing property managers to fill units faster, making it hard to look closely at every application.

In a lender's world, speed and scrutiny are traded off deliberately, whereas in leasing, speed usually wins by default.

Banks have spent years hardening this exact moment. In November 2024, in fact, the U.S. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) issued an alert warning financial institutions that criminals were using generative AI to fake identity documents and get past verification controls.

Most financial institutions responded with the tools they already had. Think customer identification programs, liveness checks, suspicious activity reports, and a regulator watching. When one bank flags a fake identity, that signal goes somewhere; a landlord who spots a forged pay stub usually just rejects the applicant, who is free to try the building down the street.

Leasing does have a federal rulebook, but it points in a different direction. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the FTC treats tenant screening companies as consumer reporting agencies, with a duty to keep their reports accurate. This protects applicants from being wrongly denied because of bad data, which is important but doesn't tell a landlord how to catch an applicant whose data is fake.

That part is left to each operator's budget and judgment. Yet, a leasing office has an inbox and a vacancy target.

The fakes got cheap

Most people underestimate how easy this has become. MRI Real Estate Software, for example, bought 200 AI-generated fake IDs, some for as little as $5, and tested them against standard verification tools, finding optical character recognition readers, the industry default, caught only 24%.

Recently, a Checkr survey of 1,400 landlords across 14 U.S. cities concluded that, in San Francisco alone, 85% of them are worried about application fraud. One in three had discovered identity theft in their buildings, and 70% had discovered or suspected application fraud that ended in an eviction.

Most respondents actually found out only after the tenant had moved in. At the worst possible time to learn anything.

Industry-wide, a National Multifamily Housing Council survey found that respondents wrote off an average of nearly $4.2 million in bad debt over 12 months, and about a quarter of it was tied to nonpayment by tenants who got in with fraudulent applications.

Fraud also runs the other way. The FBI's 2025 Internet Crime Report logged 12,368 real estate fraud complaints and $275 million in losses, a category that includes fake listings aimed at renters.

Where losses land

When a fraudulent tenant gets in, the cost doesn't stay with one landlord, but shows up as bad debt, legal fees, damaged units, and months of lost rent. Then, it spreads.

Owners are already squeezed on insurance. Property insurance costs for securitized multifamily properties rose 58% over five years, according to New York-based analytics firm Trepp, making it their fastest-growing major expense.

A tenant who lied their way in is also unlikely to carry real coverage, so when something goes wrong, the damage and liability tend to fall on the owner's policy. That feeds loss history, renewals, and eventually the rent everyone else in the building pays.

Deposit alternatives and liability programs have to price in those losses, too, meaning honest renters end up subsidizing those dishonest ones.

But fintech has already worked out that you can't win an arms race over what a PDF looks like. Lenders moved to verifying at the source, with direct payroll connections, bank data, and continuous signals instead of one-time snapshots.

Leasing should do the same.

The good news is that a lot of source-verified data already moves through the leasing workflow, but it just isn't treated as risk data. Does a renter's insurance policy actually bind at lease signing? Is the "third-party policy" someone uploaded real, and does it stay active? Did the deposit payment clear through a traceable instrument?

A fair objection

Consumer advocates would push back on the story as told so far, and they have a record to point to. Much of the fraud data, including some of the figures above, comes from landlord trade groups and screening vendors, who have a commercial interest in the problem looking big.

They also have evidence that more screening doesn't automatically mean better screening. The National Consumer Law Center's Digital Denials report, for example, found that tenant screening reports often carry inaccurate eviction and criminal records, that landlords frequently rely on a single automated score, and that the harm falls disproportionately on Black and Latino renters.

Regulators have acted on this before. In 2023, the CFPB and FTC asked a federal court to order TransUnion to pay $11 million to consumers plus a $4 million penalty over its tenant screening practices. The CFPB has also noted that there is no proof screening reports actually predict how someone will behave as a tenant.

Then, there's the cost. The FTC is now examining rental fees across the whole lease, from application to move-out, while NCLC separately argued that some proptech products, like security deposit alternatives, end up making renting more expensive. If every new fraud check becomes another fee on applicants, honest renters pay for a problem they didn't create.

That's a fair point, and it shapes what a good answer should look like. Verifying at the source and reusing signals that already exist in the lease lifecycle should make leasing cheaper and fairer for the honest majority, not more expensive.

Banks learned long ago that onboarding is where fraud is cheapest to stop. Rental housing is learning the same lesson one eviction at a time, and landlords far and wide are paying for it.

Parametric Insurance Is Key After Earthquakes

Parametric insurance delivers rapid earthquake funding to hospitals within hours, enabling critical care continuity when traditional claims processes would delay recovery.

Insurance

Unlike hurricanes, floods, or other weather-related disasters, earthquakes arrive without warning. There is no time to stage resources, activate emergency plans days in advance, or issue evacuation orders. The impact is instantaneous, and so is the need for action. And in the aftermath of a major earthquake, the first few days and weeks can determine the trajectory of an entire community's recovery. 

Roads may be impassable, power and communications disrupted, and homes and businesses damaged or destroyed. At the same time, hospitals face an immediate surge in demand for care, often while managing their own operational challenges. While physical assets can be, over time, repaired or rebuilt, the human consequences of catastrophe are irreversible. Access to emergency medical care, surgical services, and critical care can directly affect patient outcomes in the hours and days following a seismic event. Ensuring healthcare facilities remain operational, or can restore services quickly, is therefore a critical component of community resilience.

This is where parametric insurance is changing the conversation.

Parametric natural catastrophe products are designed to provide rapid liquidity following an event, based on the reported ground shaking intensity at or near an insured's location. Because payout structures are agreed in advance, claims settlement does not depend on traditional loss adjustment processes. Instead, funds can be disbursed within hours to days, supporting a faster and more predictable financial response.

For hospital operators, the value is immediate and tangible. Rapid access to capital can help fund emergency response measures, secure temporary facilities and equipment, support staffing needs, accelerate repairs, and maintain continuity of critical services. When lives are on the line, speed of funding becomes more than a financial advantage; it becomes an operational necessity. This approach is already being put into practice. Hospital systems in Missouri and Tennessee have implemented parametric earthquake protection to strengthen their resilience against seismic risk. While the New Madrid Seismic Zone is often overshadowed by California in discussions about U.S. earthquake exposure, history tells a different story.

The 1811–1812 New Madrid earthquakes remain among the most powerful seismic events recorded in North America. A similar event today would affect a much larger population and a far more connected economy. Swiss Re research estimated that a recurrence could generate more than $300 billion in economic losses, a figure that would likely be significantly higher today given increased development and asset concentration.

Recognizing this exposure, these healthcare organizations worked with brokers and risk carriers experienced in parametric solutions to design coverage tailored to their operational needs. The structures are calibrated to deliver meaningful payouts following significant ground shaking, ensuring that financial resources are available when they are needed most. This enables hospitals to accelerate recovery efforts, maintain essential services, and continue serving as anchors of support for their communities during times of crisis.

As natural catastrophe risks continue to challenge organizations worldwide, resilience is increasingly defined not only by physical preparedness but also by financial readiness. Parametric insurance represents a new generation of risk transfer, one that prioritizes speed, certainty, and operational continuity.


Megan Linkin

Profile picture for user MeganLinkin

Megan Linkin

Dr. Megan Linkin heads the Parametric Nat Cat team in the Americas for Swiss Re Corporate Solutions.

Prior to re-joining Swiss Re in 2012, she worked as a weather derivative underwriter and catastrophe bond analyst at Allianz Risk Transfer. Between 2008 and 2011, she was an atmospheric perils specialist for the Swiss Re Catastrophe Perils team.

She has given invited presentations to the state of New Jersey, the New York Academy of Science, Rutgers University, and the University of Maryland. She has also testified before Congress about the impacts of climate change on the insurance industry. Her manuscripts have been published in Climatic Change, the Journal of Climate and Weatherwise magazine. Dr. Linkin was named one of Reactions Rising Stars of the insurance industry in 2014 and was named the Underwriter of the Year in 2025 by Reuters' Parametric Insurer.

She received her Ph.D. and masters of science in atmospheric and oceanic science from the University of Maryland and graduated magna cum laude from Rutgers University with a bachelor of science in meteorology and a minor in mathematics. She received her Certified Consulting Meteorologist Seal from the American Meteorological Society in February 2013. She is an active member of the American Meteorological Society and the American Geophysical Union

The 2027 Chief Claims Officer

Chief claims officers must transform their departments into AI-native ground-truth engines or risk becoming the bottleneck in enterprise transformation.

Insurance

For decades, the mandate of the chief claims cfficer was relatively clear: build a strong organization to investigate claims, control costs, manage litigation, negotiate settlements, and deliver fair outcomes.

That mandate is no longer sufficient.

The 2027 chief claims officer has a much bigger job: build the insurer's ground-truth engine—an AI-native operation that produces superior outcomes, industrializes negotiation excellence, and converts what claims learns into intelligence for the entire enterprise.

This is not simply about using AI to make legacy claims processes more efficient. AI is turning insurance into an information business—and the most important ground truth in that business is generated in claims. Claims reveal what actually happened to the risks the insurer underwrote, what drove the loss, and what ultimately determined its economic outcome.

To compete in an AI world, insurers will need to capture that ground truth, make it machine-readable, and use it to improve underwriting, pricing, reserving, and portfolio management.

That puts claims—and the chief claims officer—on the front line of this unprecedented transformation.

A new competitive environment

Claims officers in traditional claims organizations face urgent and pressing competition from two sources at once. On one side is an increasingly industrialized plaintiff bar. On the other side is a new generation of AI-native insurers, poised to move forward.

On the first side, consider Morgan & Morgan. The personal-injury giant says it has invested roughly $300 million in technology and AI and plans at least $1 billion more over the next decade. Its proprietary MX2 platform supports medical-record extraction, case research, document generation, demand letters, and trial preparation, while Injury.com digitally acquires and qualifies potential claims.

Private equity is adding fuel, investing in personal-injury platforms to scale technology, analytics, marketing and standardized operations.

The plaintiff bar is turning claim development and negotiation from individual craftsmanship into an industrial system.

On the second side, a new generation of AI-native insurers is being built without decades of legacy technology, workflows and organizational baggage.

Companies such as Corgi are attempting to build insurance businesses from inception around modern data architectures, AI agents and technology-speed iteration. McKinsey has warned that AI-native insurance businesses can increasingly build and refine products in weeks while incumbents remain calibrated to annual planning cycles and multi-year transformations. 

Legacy insurers are being squeezed from both directions: out-innovated by the plaintiff bar in the contest over outcomes and potentially out-architected by AI-native insurers in the contest over how insurance itself operates.

Claims sits directly in the middle. That changes the requirements of its leader.

1. Level the playing field with the plaintiff bar

The plaintiff bar has largely approached AI as a weapon for improving economic outcomes. Carriers have largely approached it as a tool for workflow efficiency.

AI-powered demand packages are working. Carriers are only beginning to experiment seriously with the corresponding AI-powered offer package. Meanwhile, sophisticated plaintiff organizations are accumulating data, developing proprietary AI and attracting enormous capital.

The plaintiff bar is both the threat and the proof point.

They are investing their own money—and increasing institutional capital—because better case development, persuasion, and negotiation improve their economics.

The CCO must build institutional capabilities that can match increasingly industrialized counterparties.

2. Institutionalize negotiation excellence

Most carriers have some excellent negotiators. That is no longer enough.

If negotiation materially affects indemnity outcomes, it cannot remain an individual skill distributed unevenly across thousands of claims professionals. The organization should know who its elite negotiators are, why they outperform and how those behaviors can be replicated.

Carriers that cannot identify, measure and reproduce negotiation excellence do not really possess a negotiation capability. They possess individual negotiators.

The CCO must turn individual excellence into measurable institutional capability.

3. Stop putting AI band-aids on pre-AI claims operations

Many carriers can produce an impressive list of AI-centric projects: summarize a file, extract information, draft correspondence, analyze a demand, route work, search notes, or give adjusters Copilot.

Those applications can create real value. But old process plus an AI tool means slightly better old process.

McKinsey has warned about layering new technology onto legacy insurance operating models. BCG similarly distinguishes between deploying AI into existing processes and reshaping workflows around AI.

The CCO must redesign the operating model, not merely automate the existing one.

4. Build machine-first claims

The traditional claim file was built primarily for humans. Documents, notes, emails, medical records, and litigation materials accumulate while experienced professionals gradually construct an understanding of what happened.

In an AI-native operation, every claim should progressively become a machine-readable representation of the claim—the people, events, evidence, injuries, allegations, relationships, negotiations and outcomes.

That structured claim becomes the substrate on which specialized AI agents can continuously reason. Instead of occasionally asking AI to summarize a file, machines continuously read, structure, monitor, compare, detect, and prepare.

The CCO must make claims machine-readable while elevating, not diminishing, human judgment and action.

5. Build and lead a hybrid workforce

The future claim officer will have two kinds of capacity at their disposal: human expertise and machine intelligence.

AI agents will increasingly read, structure, monitor, research, compare, detect, analyze and prepare. Humans will increasingly concentrate on judgment, investigation, strategy, creativity, empathy, supervision, accountability and negotiation.

That will make exceptional claims professionals more important, not less.

Imagine an elite negotiator supported by agents that continuously understand the evidence, medical history, venue, plaintiff counsel, negotiation history, and comparable outcomes.

The machine handles much of the cognitive preparation. The human concentrates on what exceptional humans do best: think, strategize, persuade, read the counterparty, exercise judgment, and negotiate.

The CCO must become the architect of human and machine capacity—designing how each works together to produce better outcomes.

6. Make every negotiation a learning event

A sophisticated plaintiff demand should eventually meet an equally sophisticated carrier response. But the bigger opportunity comes afterward.

Every demand, analysis, strategy, offer, response, counteroffer, and outcome must become institutional knowledge in the same way that the plaintiff bar is institutionalizing these events.

Which plaintiff firms consistently outperform? Which strategies work against them? Which facts change settlement value? Which negotiators outperform expectations? Where does the organization systematically overpay?

Every negotiation should make the next negotiation smarter.

The CCO must ensure every claim and negotiation makes the organization smarter.

7. Elevate claims into the insurer's ground-truth engine

This is where the transformation extends beyond claims.

Underwriting begins with hypotheses about risk. Pricing quantifies them. Reserving updates them. Claims discovers what was actually true.

Claims learns what caused the loss, how injuries developed, what evidence mattered, how attorneys behaved, which defenses and negotiation strategies worked, and what the risk ultimately cost.

Yet much of that knowledge remains trapped in PDFs, notes, litigation files and the heads of experienced claims professionals.

Claims should continuously produce structured intelligence that flows into underwriting, pricing, reserving, risk, reinsurance and portfolio management.

The claim is no longer simply something to resolve and close. It is one of the insurer's richest proprietary information assets. The CCO must turn claims knowledge into enterprise intelligence—making the claims organization the feedback loop that allows the entire enterprise to learn.

8. Don't let claims become the transformation bottleneck

This may be the requirement that matters most to the rest of the C-suite.

A legacy insurer can modernize distribution, underwriting, pricing and portfolio management. But if its richest source of ground truth remains trapped inside a document-centric, human-first claims operation moving through multi-year transformation cycles, the rest of the enterprise eventually hits a wall.

AI-native competitors do not have to unwind decades of organizational architecture before redesigning how humans, machines and data work together. Incumbents do. That makes speed itself a competitive capability.

The modern CCO must protect the integrity of a massive, consequential operation while simultaneously making it capable of continuous change.

The plaintiff bar is moving at technology speed. AI-native competitors are being built for technology speed. Claims cannot continue moving at insurance speed.

The CCO must ensure claims leads rather than constrains the insurer's AI transformation.

The mandate has changed

None of these requirements eliminates the traditional responsibilities of the CCO. Claims still must be handled fairly; customers, regulatory obligations, litigation, reserves and operational discipline still matter.

But those responsibilities are increasingly table stakes.

Sophisticated plaintiff organizations are industrializing the pursuit of settlement dollars while AI-native insurers are being architected as technology-speed information businesses. Between them sits a claims organization that, at many incumbents, was designed for another era.

That creates both a threat and an extraordinary opportunity.

Carriers that generate that ground truth better, negotiate from it more effectively, make it machine-readable and distribute it throughout the enterprise will possess something more valuable than a more efficient claims department. They will possess a continuously learning insurance enterprise.

As chief claims officers enter 2027, the question is no longer whether their departments will use more AI. It is whether they can transform their departments into a competitive advantage rather than the bottleneck preventing the enterprise from changing with it.


John Burge

Profile picture for user JohnBurge

John Burge

John Burge is an engineer/attorney-turned-entrepreneur and operating executive at SigmaSight.

For the last 25 years he has led technology startups and turnarounds in the medical, insurance and litigation verticals, including managing a $400 million portfolio of medical malpractice runoff. Prior to becoming an entrepreneur, he was a product liability litigator and served in engineering roles with Upjohn and Eastman Kodak.