The Math of Healthcare Reform

The American Health Care Act fails to address what should be a critical goal of any reform: making healthcare affordable.

sixthings
The House Leadership’s plan for repealing and replacing the Affordable Care Act is now public for all the world to describe, dissect and debate. For articles on what it does, please check out my Flipboard magazine. To call the legislation dead on arrival is unfair. However, the proposal is looking under the weather. See also: What Trump Wants to Do on ACA   As I’ve posted previously, what Speaker Paul Ryan and the Republican leadership put forward is highly unlikely to be what emerges from Congress … assuming healthcare reform does emerge from Congress. Which may be a good thing. Because the American Health Care Act fails to address in any meaningful way what should be a critical goal of any healthcare reform proposal: making health care affordable. Washington is fixated on how Americans get health care coverage. Should there be government exchanges? Should premiums be subsidized? Should there be restrictions on how insurers set premiums for coverage? And so on. All of these are vital issues. But they’re playing around the edges of public policy when the real solution is at the core. This isn’t just opinion. It’s math. Consider: The Affordable Care Act requires carriers to spend the vast majority of every premium dollar they collect for medical care. In the individual and small group markets, 80% of premiums must go to cover medical care, or carriers must refund enough premium to reach that level. For larger employers, the medical expense target is 85% of premium. The remaining premium dollars are what carriers can use for paying claims, customer service, negotiating discounts with medical providers, advertising, legal expenses, staffing, HR departments, distribution costs, profit (or retained earnings for non-profits) and any other administrative costs. (Incidentally, I don’t see any reference in the new proposal to these provisions of the ACA, which, I assume, means they stay in place. If I’m wrong, please let me know in the comments section.) If lawmakers want to make health insurance coverage affordable, they’re going to have to make medical care affordable, because that’s where the money is. Zero out insurers' operational expense, and overall premiums would go down less than 20%. That’s a sizable amount. However, in three or four years we’re back where we are today thanks to medical inflation. And there’s no way to eliminate all administrative costs. Someone has to process the claims or answer consumers' questions. And those people expect to get paid. And someone has to pay for their phone, desk and computers. And someone has to support their equipment. And so on. Medical care represents 80% to 85% of health insurance premiums. Reduce this side of the ledger by 20%, and premiums fall 17% — roughly the same as eliminating 100% of insurers' operational costs. See also: Letter to Congress on Replacing ACA   If President Trump and Congress are serious about reducing the cost of health insurance, they need to figure out how to reduce the cost of medical care. There’s plenty of ideas out there (a topic for a future post). And, to be fair, they’ve mentioned a few. But there’s a political reality that explains why most of the rhetoric around Pennsylvania Avenue concerns the cost of coverage: No one has lost an election by attacking health insurance companies. They’re one of the safest pinatas in American politics. On the other hand, doctors and hospitals are politically dangerous to take on. Voters actually like them. Regulating health insurance so consumers get a fair deal is important. Lowering the cost of medical care is critical. It will also reduce insurance premiums. It’s just harder. Perhaps that’s why the Republican proposal is called the American Health Care Act. It would be wrong to use the word “affordable.” This article first appeared at the Alan Katz blog.

Alan Katz

Profile picture for user AlanKatz

Alan Katz

Alan Katz speaks and writes nationally on healthcare reform, technology, sales and business planning. He is author of the award-winning Alan Katz Blog and of <em>Trailblazed: Proven Paths to Sales Success</em>.

MORE FROM THIS AUTHOR

Read More