Reports of high-profile data breaches have been hard to miss over the past year. Most recently, it was a breach involving 56 million customers’ personal and credit card information at Home Depot
This is just the latest volley in a wave of sophisticated electronic thefts including Target
, Neiman Marcus
, P.F. Chang’s
. Much like in the other attacks, the suspected culprit in the Home Depot data breach
is a type of malware called a RAM scraper
that effectively steals card data while it’s briefly unencrypted at the point of sale (POS) to authorize a transaction. Reports of this type of attack have become increasingly common
in the months since the Target breach.
Whether the cause is a RAM scraper or an “older” threat like a physical skimmer placed directly on a POS machine
used to swipe a credit or debit card, a phishing attack storing customers’ card information insecurely
, the result is the same: Credit card data for millions of people winds up in the hands of criminals eager to sell it for profit. How does that process unfold? And how can you – or people you know – get sucked into it?
The Basic Process:
The journey from initial credit card data theft to fraudulent use of that data to steal goods from other retailers involves multiple layers of transactions. The actual thief taking the card numbers from the victim business’ POS or database doesn’t use it him or herself.
First, a hacker – or a team of them – steals the credit card data electronically. Most of these schemes begin in Russia or other parts of Eastern Europe, and much of what you might call the “carding trade” is centered there.
Next, brokers (also referred to as “re-sellers”) buy the stolen card numbers and related information in bulk and trade them in online carding forums
. A hacker may also sell the card data directly to keep more of the profits, though that’s riskier and more time-consuming than using a broker. These exchanges are found on the dark net (aka the dark web). That’s a part of the Internet you won’t find through Google, where all manner of illegal and unsavory things can take place
. Online prices vary depending on:
- How much additional data is available (CVV codes from the backs of cards and associated Zip codes make stolen cards more valuable),
- The card owner’s geographic location (a fake card used in the vicinity of the legitimate card holder is less likely to raise suspicion), and
- How recently the cards began appearing in the carding forums (which relates to the likelihood of card cancellation).
Prices for the individual cards have come down significantly
in the past few years because of the sheer amount of records available, though brokers can still do quite well from bulk sales of card data. Despite being on the dark web, many of the brokers conduct themselves like regular online businesses and will provide replacements or the equivalent of store credit if cards purchased from them don’t work.
The people who buy the card data from the brokers are called “carders.” Once the carders have the stolen card data, there are at least two distinct variations on the scam:
1) Physical, in-store purchases using fake credit cards.
2) Stolen card numbers used to charge pre-paid credit cards that are, in turn, used to purchase store-specific gift cards (which are less suspicious than general gift cards). Purchases are made online.
Variant 1 (“Mystery Shopper”):
This variation starts with carders printing up the fake credit cards for use in stores. Once they have the stolen card data, the equipment needed to make the fake cards isn’t that expensive. The carder then usually works with one or more recruiters to find people to use the fake cards (though a carder may do the recruiting himself). The enticement to get people to use the fake cards will generally be in the form of email spam and ads in Craigslist or similar sites offering easy money to be a “mystery shopper” or “secret shopper” as part of a “marketing study” or some other semi-plausible justification.
Not surprisingly, the items purchased tend to have high resale value. After the physical purchases are made, the “mystery shopper” can either send items to the recruiter/carder (generally via a secure drop site like a vacant office) or directly to someone who has “purchased” an item via an auction site in response to a posting from the recruiter/carder. If sent straight to the carder, she then auctions the items directly on eBay, Craigslist or an underground forum on the dark web.
The people who actually make the purchases with the fake cards may have no clue what they’re involved in (though sometimes they’re active participants in the scheme
or simply low-level criminals looking to use the cards for themselves). They are effectively the “drug mules” of the credit card scam, taking the most risk and getting paid the least.
You’ve probably seen one step retailers take to try and stop in-person card fraud. On a counterfeit credit card, the numbers on the magnetic strip and the front of the card generally don’t match -- it’s too expensive to create individual fakes. Some retailers have their personnel type in the last four digits on the physical card into the register after the card is swiped. If the numbers don’t match, the card is rejected as a fake.
Variant 2 (“Re-shipping”):
Rather than making physical cards, in this variation carders use the stolen card data to purchase pre-paid credit cards that are then used to buy store-specific gift cards (Amazon, Best Buy, etc.). As with the “mystery shopper” scheme, recruiters typically use ads and spam emails to entice people, though this time it’s people (especially in the U.S.) seeing “work from home
” promises. Sometimes, the recruiters will employ a more personalized approach, even going so far as to start a fake “relationship” with the intended target
. Then -- wait, there’s more -- the gift cards are used to purchase items online, and those items are shipped to the people responding to the ads, spam or “relationship” overtures. That’s where the “work from home” angle comes in.
The people initially receiving the packages directly from an online retailer are called “re-shippers.” People in the U.S. are used because U.S.-based addresses raise fewer red flags with the retailers. Like the “mystery shoppers,” the re-shippers are the drug mules here (and they are sometimes referred to as “money mules” or “shipping mules”). And, as with the “mystery shopper” scheme, re-shippers can either send items to the recruiter/carder or directly to someone who has “purchased” the item through an auction site.
While this may sound a little convoluted, the shell game-like nature of using one card to buy another and then another makes it more difficult for stores to catch onto this scheme before the purchase has already been made and shipped out. After that, it’s generally too late.