Global Trend Map No. 14: Regulation

Some 15% of the workforce is dedicated to governance, risk management and regulatory compliance--posing a huge opportunity for efficiency.

Following on from last week's post on investment management, today we tackle that omnipresent question for carriers old and new: regulation. Regulation affects absolutely every part of the insurance business, from how customer data is held and used to how insurers reinsure themselves and invest the premiums they gather. The time and money cost of complying with regulation is often significant, with recent estimates suggesting that 10% to 15% of the total workforce in financial organizations is currently dedicated to governance, risk management and regulatory compliance. The opportunity for greater efficiency here is so large that a whole new tech-powered industry – regtech – has sprung up around it. And, with demand for regulatory, compliance and governance software expected to reach a massive $120 billion by 2020, this is a space to watch. The following stats and perspectives are taken from our Global Trend Map; a full breakdown of our survey respondents, and details of our methodology, are included as part of the full report, which you can download for free at any time. See also: New Regulations for Disability Claims   Assessing the Impact of Regulation Regulation is a serious issue not just for (re)insurers but for the insurance ecosystem more generally. Out of all our survey respondents (unfiltered), 20% indicated that regulation had impeded progress "a lot." As we see from our our burden chart below, the impact is evenly spread across different ecosystem players. Here, 24% of brokers and agents state that regulation has impeded progress "a lot" within their organization, along with 17% of technology partners and 22% of insurers. The trend is the same when we use a weighted score (one point for "a little," two points for "somewhat" and three points for "a lot"), giving us an overall "burden score" of:
  • 186 for brokers/agents
  • 159 for technology partners
  • 175 for insurers
While regulation is a concern for insurance companies across the whole globe, it manifests itself differently in different regions. Our stats suggest that regulatory burden is above trend in Europe and below trend in Asia-Pacific (in terms of respondents answering that regulation is impeding progress "a lot"). Regulatory compliance certainly remains a daily issue in APAC but may, for structural reasons, be easier to deal with there on a big picture level. In Asia-Pacific, industry participants have the advantage of dealing, in the main, with large national markets (bigger than any U.S. state, for instance) but without the complexities of an overarching regional regulator (like we find in Europe with the E.U. and Solvency II). That said, carriers wishing to be active across the region still have a multitude of different regimes to comply with. Additionally, we asked survey respondents to indicate, via an open-text response, which regulations were currently the greatest cause for concern. There were too many responses to list everything, but some that stood out were Solvency II and the Insurance Distribution Directive (IDD) from respondents in Europe, and the DOL fiduciary rule from respondents in North America.
"Currently the focus is on protecting personally identifiable information, personal health information and personal credit information. Regulations in the future may evolve, requiring companies to ensure that they are using information in a fair and just fashion. For example, much can be inferred from the data from an individual’s smartphone, but it may not be fair and just to act on those inferences." — Cindy Forbes, EVP and chief analytics officer, Manulife Financial
Regulatory Burden: A Growing Challenge There is a marked trend toward rising regulatory burden, and we found this to be consistent across our different ecosystem players and regions. 89% of insurers and reinsurers believed regulation was posing a greater challenge to their organizations than during the previous 12 months. "Increased regulation" was one of the external challenges we explored in our industry challenges section, coming in sixth place out of 12 (based on all respondents). Drilling down into different carrier departments reveals that its impact is not evenly distributed across the business: "Increased regulation" was among the top three external challenges for carrier staff working in actuarial, analytics, capital management (where it took the top slot), investment, risk, senior leadership, strategy and treasury. The overall balance of these departments suggests the greatest burden from increased regulation within (re)insurers is falling on the investment and risk-modeling side of the business. Europe has certainly been a case in point over the past couple of years, with Solvency II subjecting carriers to more rigorous capital requirements. See also: Aggressive Regulation on Data Breaches   Regulation’s growing prominence in the eyes of high-echelon staff (senior leadership) indicates just how seriously it is viewed within the ecosystem. This, along with the other measures we have presented in this section, creates a perfect storm for the rise of regtech over the coming months and years.

Alexander Cherry

Profile picture for user AlexanderCherry

Alexander Cherry

Alexander Cherry leads the research behind Insurance Nexus’ new business ventures, encompassing summits, surveys and industry reports. He is particularly focused on new markets and topics and strives to render market information into a digestible format that bridges the gap between quantitative and qualitative.Alexander Cherry is Head of Content at Buzzmove, a UK-based Insurtech on a mission to take the hassle and inconvenience out of moving home and contents insurance. Before entering the Insurtech sector, Cherry was head of research at Insurance Nexus, supporting a portfolio of insurance events in Europe, North America and East Asia through in-depth industry analysis, trend reports and podcasts.


Read More